Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not give a lift to a stranger?

190 replies

LondonQueen · 03/01/2022 19:01

Tonight I went to grab a few things from the shops with my DS as they didn't come on my usual online shop. As I was leaving the store, with DS holding my hand, a woman came up to me and asked for a lift to a street I hadn't heard of, which she assured me wasn't far and was near a local landmark (said landmark is about a 10 minutes drive from the shop)
I normally would have said yes but there was something off about this woman. I said No, sorry I have to go and pick up DD in the opposite direction. Despite this she followed me to my car! I politely but firmly said please step away from my car as you're scaring my DS. She walked away and asked again, I ignored her and got in the car and locked my doors. As I drove away, she walked up to another car with a young looking teenager walking towards it. WIBU to say no? Like I said I normally would give someone a lift so close but she made me feel uncomfortable, especially with DS with me. DH said he would have given her a lift as she was clearly in need or wouldn't ask! Please reassure me I did the right thing, or tell me I should stop being so paranoid.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LilyPAnderson · 17/01/2024 19:20

>>HE HAD A DASH CAM WHICH RECORDED THE WHOLE THING. He didn’t even think and stopped the car and rang police. She stayed!! And waited for them!! When they came she accused him of attempted rape and it was only when the police officer said do you have a camera? The man remembered. She tried to run away, she was charged and let off.<<

I don't think it's true, as the law is usually more harsh on women doing things like that while men who harm women are let off. If he has evidence there's no way she wouldn't be charged.

llanssannan · 13/01/2022 21:02

The woman may have been in need, be it practical or for a mental health issue. You were right to trust your instinct, but I think you should have called 101 to report it.

me109f · 13/01/2022 20:51

I go by gut instinct and weighing up the situation. If you feel it is not right you should not allow any stranger to come into your car.
I have given lifts before, but I want to know how far, and it needs to be convenient to me. There have been exceptions, I once gave an 18 year old girl a 40 mile lift in the wrong direction as she hailed me down in the middle of a freezing night in skimpy clothing. Her dad's expensive car was in the ditch and tangled with a fence in the middle of the countryside. He had lent it to her to go to a disco with her friends on her birthday and she pranged it but was unhurt. Bizarre but true. I must say she cannot have been driving insured. But I got her home and left immediately as I was very tired and had to get to work in a few hours.
Another lift was some sod I asked the way from, in London. The guy insisted he could show me the way if i gave him a lift; but I realised he was the worse for drink. I was really stupid, as he sat there quietly and then threw up all over my very nice car. I literally kicked him out into the gutter. It was winter and I had to scrub up the inside of my car. It was weeks before the car was close to OK inside; I had to do all my driving with the heater on full and the windows open.

Dontwanttolivewithmylover · 06/01/2022 14:31

No, never. You don't know what or who is waiting at the other end...do you?
Not in a million years. Funny that she was asking a mum on her own then to a young person. Why didn't she get a taxi. The shop would have rung one if she had no mobile. Let her get home the same way she got to the shop.

EightWheelGirl · 05/01/2022 23:20

[quote lhirault]@TragoCardboardCopper that happened to a friend of my dad's in the early 80s. A lovely guy, he used to pick up hitch hikers occasionally, his thinking being that at least they were safe with him giving them a lift. Picked up a girl who pulled the exact same stunt, demanded cash or she'd report him for rape. He called her bluff and reported the incident after she got out of the car. She didn't report him, but he never picked up a hitchhiker again. [/quote]
Why the hell don't the police ever charge these women, even when they have evidence? Rape allegations can tarnish a reputation forever even if unfounded.

lhirault · 05/01/2022 12:35

@TragoCardboardCopper that happened to a friend of my dad's in the early 80s. A lovely guy, he used to pick up hitch hikers occasionally, his thinking being that at least they were safe with him giving them a lift. Picked up a girl who pulled the exact same stunt, demanded cash or she'd report him for rape. He called her bluff and reported the incident after she got out of the car. She didn't report him, but he never picked up a hitchhiker again.

Mamanyt · 05/01/2022 00:54

You absolutely did the right thing. ALWAYS listen to your gut instincts on things like this. I do not know how available is is in the UK, but see if you can get the book, "The Gift of Fear," by Gavin de Becker. It talks in depth about how our "gut instincts" work, and how we put ourselves in danger by not paying attention to them.

Fernticket · 05/01/2022 00:10

Sunneysideup
Did your Uncle live in South Wales by any chance?

DdraigGoch · 04/01/2022 23:52

@tttigress

Can you report it? She sounds mental.
RTFT (or at least the OP's posts), she has reported it now.
tttigress · 04/01/2022 23:21

Can you report it? She sounds mental.

Kate0902900908 · 04/01/2022 23:18

Absolutely not. I know a poor man who once was asked to give a women a lift outside a supermarket. She said I’m being hurt and I need to go to a street around 10 mins away. He said yes. Half way there she said give me £100 or I will ring the police and tell them you tried to rape me.
HE HAD A DASH CAM WHICH RECORDED THE WHOLE THING. He didn’t even think and stopped the car and rang police. She stayed!! And waited for them!! When they came she accused him of attempted rape and it was only when the police officer said do you have a camera? The man remembered. She tried to run away, she was charged and let off. The poor man was traumatised by the whole thing I don’t think he will ever get over it. Can’t give details but he was a well known (locally) handy man. He never did that work again because he couldn’t go in strangers homes.

Nanny0gg · 04/01/2022 23:13

@NewYearCalavicci

That does sound very odd , did she give a reason as to why she needed a lift , ie in a rush , car broke down , let down by someone else ?

Are there no buses or local cabs ?
I hate to see people stuck so I would of possibly rang a cab for her and given a few quid towards it

Highly unlikely it was a genuine request for a lift
EightWheelGirl · 04/01/2022 23:04

Perhaps she needed help but you probs did the sensible thing.

55Jumbo · 04/01/2022 23:02

@riceuten

No, you were not, and the fact she followed you to the car probably said it. I am occasionally cheeky and try and blag a lift from people I don't know, but if they say no, then that's that.

A few years ago I was in a foreign country (whose language I speak reasonably well) and I was walking to the bus stop to catch the bus from the village to the nearest town, and bugger me, the bus was 10 minutes early and left me at the stop. As I stood there, a woman saw me and opened the door to her car and said "Hop in" in the local lingo - given it was an hour to the next bus and it was heaving down with rain, my normally guarded self said "Sod it" and she gave me a lift and refused payment. The irony was we spent 5 mins talking in the local dialect, and then she said "Are you English?" I said "Yes, are you?" - "No, Irish" and we both burst out laughing.

@riceuten that last bit of your story made me laugh Grin
Itsonlymeeee · 04/01/2022 22:52

I've been in the opposite position. I used to work in a nursing home & one day we had a workman (about 10 yrs older than me) in who was chatty & friendly to us all. As I was leaving at work at 2 he was also finished & asked if I wanted a lift back rather than catch the bus. Felt a bit awkward but said yes. He was very chatty & I had nothing to worry about but as soon as I got in the car I knew I shouldn't have as if it was one of my grown up daughters I would have had a fit at them! For that reason I never told my husband & girls or even my mates at work!

LouBan · 04/01/2022 22:40

You were absolutely right. Never ignore your gut feeling. I think the fact that she followed you and kept asking after you said no is suspicious. Did she give any explanation if how she got to the shops in the first place? 10 mins drive away is not an unwalkable distance. Personally, I would never give a stranger a lift.

riceuten · 04/01/2022 21:39

No, you were not, and the fact she followed you to the car probably said it. I am occasionally cheeky and try and blag a lift from people I don't know, but if they say no, then that's that.

A few years ago I was in a foreign country (whose language I speak reasonably well) and I was walking to the bus stop to catch the bus from the village to the nearest town, and bugger me, the bus was 10 minutes early and left me at the stop. As I stood there, a woman saw me and opened the door to her car and said "Hop in" in the local lingo - given it was an hour to the next bus and it was heaving down with rain, my normally guarded self said "Sod it" and she gave me a lift and refused payment. The irony was we spent 5 mins talking in the local dialect, and then she said "Are you English?" I said "Yes, are you?" - "No, Irish" and we both burst out laughing.

sweetbellyhigh · 04/01/2022 21:18

@EllieHJ

I gave a lift to a guy just before Xmas a couple of years ago. I was with my teenage son and he wanted to get to the AELTC. He had asked directions in the village and we were about to drive past it on our way home. He seemed very nice. We dropped him off and thought nothing of it. About 30 minutes later my youngest son had popped over to a neighbours and left the front door slightly open so he could pop back.

Two armed policemen pushed into the house shouting. They were shouting my husbands name because the car was registered in his name.

The guy had been seen being dropped off by me on camera and then left something outside the bloody place which they thought was a bomb. So they thought we were something to do with it. It was crazy! It turned out to be someone’s ashes that he’d left outside the tennis club.

All got sorted in the end but I nearly shit myself when we got raided!

Great story!!!

I unwittingly aided a young thief.

I was pulling out of my driveway and a boy of about 13 appeared at the window looking very distressed. I can't actually remember what he said but I let him get in and gave him a ride "home" which was two streets away. It was obvious he was lying. God the whole thing was weird. He also had only one shoe 👟

Turned out he was being chased by two men after being caught in someone's shed, one of the men was chasing with a hammer. 🤷‍♀️

TragoCardboardCopper · 04/01/2022 21:18

Her persistence makes me wonder if she was had been drinking or taking something that made her behave in a social boundary crossing way. It would have made me very uneasy too.

Your DH might want to consider that it's not just a physical threat he needs to be aware of. As PP have said, distraction theft is entirely possible, but an ex of mine had a more alarming experience. He picked up a female hitchhiker late one night, as he was worried for her safety. He started to drive her to her destination when she suddenly demanded he give her a chunk of cash. She said if he didn't she'd report that he had assaulted her, and ruin his life.

He thought much quicker than I would have and drove straight to a police station (back when they were manned 24hrs!) and told her he would walk in with her if she wanted to make a report. She told him to fuck off and did a runner

NYnewstart · 04/01/2022 21:14

@Sunnysideup78

You definitely did the right thing. I always remember a story that my uncle told me when I was younger about a colleague of his being approached by an ‘old woman’ in a carpark who didn’t have enough money to get the bus home. She took pity on her and helped her into the car, got in the other side and looked down to reverse to discover that the old lady had man’s hands! Quick thinking she said ‘could you just get out and see me back’ which they did and she quickly drove off! Afterwards she found the old lady’s handbag in the footwell and there was nothing but a big knife in there 😱 No idea if this story was true or just my uncle trying to instill some sense into me for when I was older. Needless to say, I’ve never given a stranger a lift or vice versa!
I’ve heard this story too. Think it may be an urban myth.
DaffyDaydream · 04/01/2022 21:03

I was quite alarmed reading this, especially as she persisted. You absolutely did the right thing.

qualitygirl · 04/01/2022 20:55

No I wouldn't but I would have offered to give her money for a taxi or helped her sort something

Wreath21 · 04/01/2022 20:54

@Sunnysideup78

You definitely did the right thing. I always remember a story that my uncle told me when I was younger about a colleague of his being approached by an ‘old woman’ in a carpark who didn’t have enough money to get the bus home. She took pity on her and helped her into the car, got in the other side and looked down to reverse to discover that the old lady had man’s hands! Quick thinking she said ‘could you just get out and see me back’ which they did and she quickly drove off! Afterwards she found the old lady’s handbag in the footwell and there was nothing but a big knife in there 😱 No idea if this story was true or just my uncle trying to instill some sense into me for when I was older. Needless to say, I’ve never given a stranger a lift or vice versa!
Untrue - one of the classic urban legends. However your uncle may well have believed it himself as well as telling it to you with the intention of warning you to be cautious (this is one of the main purposes of such stories though, unfortunately, a lot of urban legends also have a large dollop of misogyny and racism in them as well).
Wrenna · 04/01/2022 20:52

No way. I’ve never given a ride or received a ride from a stranger!

WagnersFourthSymphony · 04/01/2022 20:50

Oh, and the other thing is that most men don't have the same highly developed spidey senses that women do, especially when they become mothers.