Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is not appropriate to put Harry Potter on for a 4.5 year old??

164 replies

Athysuisse · 03/01/2022 12:56

I dropped my daughter off at her Grandma's (my MIL) yesterday afternoon as my husband and I have had very little time to be together one on one and she offered. We grabbed a bite to eat and went for a walk. Altogether gone about 4 hours.

We returned to get her and I asked what they had been up to. My MIL proudly told me they had watched the first Harry Potter together.

My daughter is 4.5 years old and up until now has only watched things like Peppa Pig, Cocomelon, Peter Rabbit, Frozen etc. I didn't say anything to her then, but told my OH soon as we got in the car that I felt that was too mature for her.

He accused me of just nitpicking. I asked my daughter if the film was ok and she said 'it was ok, but a bit scary.' Sure enough, last night she came into our bed and said she had a bad dream.

I told my OH I thought her bad dream was because of what she had watched. He told me I am being extreme and it is a harmless film. I still feel annoyed by it though! It doesn't feel totally innocent given its dark theme. I wouldn't mind if she was a few years older, but 4.5 seems a bit young for that stuff. AIBU?

OP posts:
Lacedwithgrace · 03/01/2022 14:07

YANBU. But HP isn't allowed in our house anyway.

Odoreida · 03/01/2022 14:04

And re HP, it depends on the child. Worth saying to MIL that they had a nightmare (while thanking her for the time off for you which sounds v enjoyable).

NellieBertram · 03/01/2022 14:04

Dc1 can definitely only watch CBeebies and U movies with the very mildest peril.

Dc3 aged 4.5 has probably never seen a U but has seen all the Star Wars movies, Jurassic Park and the Meg Blush

Not unreasonable to put on a PG kids film for a 4yo, but also fine to ask them to stick to Us in the future.

Odoreida · 03/01/2022 14:03

@WrongWayApricot a school friend made his dad smash the video of Watership Down with a hammer so that the film wouldn't exist any more

BurntToastAgain · 03/01/2022 14:03

@endofthelinefinally

Your husband is ignorant. He needs to learn some basic things about child development and parenting. Generally I think the HP books were intended to be read according to the age of the character of Harry. The visuals in the films are pretty terrifying for a small child and get progressively more scary with each one. MIL is very irresponsible too.
I’m not sure that there’s a Harry Potter domain of development.

It’s a PG film. Aimed at families. It’s not the human caterpillar.

It might be worth asking yourself if you helped your daughter here OP. She got in the car and you started talking about how it was too mature for her, too scary etc. So she told you it was a bit scary. And then had a bad dream.

Even if it’s not what you’d have chosen to do with her, sometimes there’s value in jollying it all along with kids rather than focusing on the bits that might be scary etc.

Fink · 03/01/2022 14:03

I probably sound like a snob, but in our house you don't get to watch a film based on a book until you have either read the book or had it read to you. If she's too young to listen to the book as a bedtime story (which she obviously is), then she's too young to watch the film.

Also, at 4 she probably doesn't have the attention span to watch a whole film.

AsYouWishButtercup · 03/01/2022 14:03

@Athysuisse

Agree that most Disney films have death and that is quite hard for kids. My daughter does get sad by the scene in Frozen where the ship goes down so I forward past it!

She may be more sensitive, I was at that age. And to be fair, I still detest proper horror films. The horror film Mirrors gave me nightmares for weeks and I felt spooked every time I looked in a mirror! She might be like her mummy!

Honestly you’re not doing her favours by fast forwarding that bit. Just explain Anna and Elsa’s mummy and daddy died in an accident, it would happen in those days with ships sometimes but nothing to worry about it’s just a film
AsYouWishButtercup · 03/01/2022 14:01

@MissM2912

Children need to learn resilience. It is a children’s film. Wise up. She will get over it! Think of some of the crap we watched as children! 101 Dalmatians, Dumbo, Jim will fix it 🙈
Exactly! I really can’t subscribe to the idea that children should only ever extremely happy, never face the smallest bit of adversity and never have natural feelings of fear, anxiety etc. you aren’t just raising kids, your raising people who will be adults one day and I think some people have forgotten how important resilience is.
TwinkleTwinkleLittleStarFightr · 03/01/2022 13:58

You’re going to love it when they are school age and their teacher sticks a video on to keep then entertained when they do marking.

My DS1 was quite a sensitive soul, and we had several times when he was quite upset at having been made to watch movies that we felt were too old for him (and no escaping it in a classroom setting).

Athysuisse · 03/01/2022 13:57

Agree that most Disney films have death and that is quite hard for kids. My daughter does get sad by the scene in Frozen where the ship goes down so I forward past it!

She may be more sensitive, I was at that age. And to be fair, I still detest proper horror films. The horror film Mirrors gave me nightmares for weeks and I felt spooked every time I looked in a mirror! She might be like her mummy!

OP posts:
RosieRabbit17 · 03/01/2022 13:54

My eldest is also 4 and a half and loves Harry Potter! He's only watched the first 4 films as I think it's becomes a bit dark after that. We're currently reading the 2nd book too. I definitely don't think the first film is scary.

Frazzled2207 · 03/01/2022 13:53

It’s very long. I’m surprised a 4.5 yo would be engaged with it that long tbh. My 6yo sat through it relatively recently and liked it. Not sure he would have at 4.5 but don’t think it would have done him any harm

HPFA · 03/01/2022 13:52

Possibly the film is a bit old for a four year old but it's not exactly Driller Killer.

I wouldn't be that bothered about it.

MissM2912 · 03/01/2022 13:51

Exactly- loads of the Disney films are scary and upsetting.

CottonSock · 03/01/2022 13:51

I'd say something to make sure she doesn't show the second film next time. My 5yo found it very scary at the end.

MissM2912 · 03/01/2022 13:50

Children need to learn resilience. It is a children’s film. Wise up. She will get over it! Think of some of the crap we watched as children! 101 Dalmatians, Dumbo, Jim will fix it 🙈

ancientgran · 03/01/2022 13:50

I think Disney can be very scary. I was traumatised by Dumbo, the scene where his mother is locked in the tiny train carriage and they are separated is horrible and I never let my children watch it. I never saw Bambi as a child, I let mine watch it and the younger 2 were crying when the hunter kills the mother. I took a group of DDs friends to see Pocahontas as a birthday treat, one was adopted and had separation issues and was hysterical about John Smith leaving. I had to swear to her (lie in fact) that John Smith goes back and they lived happily ever after.

I don't think Disney was meant for me and mine.

Never had any issues with Harry Potter.

KMBM107 · 03/01/2022 13:49

My 5 year old has seen the first 3 films. She was probably about 4 and half when she watched the first one. She has a 8 year old sister who is potter mad. Even got her a costume and wand as her sister wanted one so thought she would like it to dress up. There are some scary parts so think it depends on the child. I’ve asked family members to not go beyond what we’ve seen as I’m currently reading book 4 with my 8 near 9 year old now. Maybe quick word with mil to say not 2 show anymore and would like to read the books together when older may allow to approach it more diplomatically?

Duckfeather · 03/01/2022 13:48

It does depend on the child but I would say that 4.5 seems a little young. As previous posters have said there are a lot of dark themes. My DD is 7 and we’ve recently been reading the books and she is now obsessed. However we’re only reading the first three and stopping there until she’s older. She’s only been allowed to watch the first two films and she coped pretty well but couldn’t watch the Basilisk at the end of the second. Cuddled up to me and we told her when the scary bit had finished.

The third film scared me in places so she’s definitely too young!

mistermagpie · 03/01/2022 13:48

My six year old wanted to watch it so I put it on, I also have a 4.5 year old and he watched the first half and was quite captivated by it but stopped watching because he though it was getting scary in the second half. I don't think I especially did anything wrong by putting it on, but my 4.5 year old is pretty good at stopping watching something he finds scary.

My 2 year old likes coco melon, peppa pig etc but they are all too young for my 4.5 year old really. But all kids are different and yes I think it's fair for you to be annoyed that Harry Potter was put on for your child.

FrownedUpon · 03/01/2022 13:45

It’s a PG. You’re being a bit dramatic.

Eleganz · 03/01/2022 13:43

Parental guidance means that really. You are entitled to your own opinion, but so is your OH in terms of what is suitable for your child in terms of PG films. Harry Potter is marketed hard at a very wide demographic and MIL can't really be blamed for thinking the story of a child wizard is a children's film. I accept that the later films are darker and more adult, but I presume this was Philosopher's Stone and so a PG.

As such, there is no wrong or right answer here and I suggest you just agree to disagree as it won't change the fact that your daughter has now watched it.

ACCx · 03/01/2022 13:43

IMO there's worse films your MIL could've chose than Harry Potter. I mean its not like she's been watching Saw 3.

Clearlynotmyname · 03/01/2022 13:43

Yanbu- the end is pretty scary for small children. I would have been annoyed. Bit different if you're choosing a film for your own children as you know what their limits are.

peachesarenom · 03/01/2022 13:41

I said YANBU but I think some people just think a kids film is just a kids film. I watched Paddington with my little one and he said it was scary! It was a bit I guess!