Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is not appropriate to put Harry Potter on for a 4.5 year old??

164 replies

Athysuisse · 03/01/2022 12:56

I dropped my daughter off at her Grandma's (my MIL) yesterday afternoon as my husband and I have had very little time to be together one on one and she offered. We grabbed a bite to eat and went for a walk. Altogether gone about 4 hours.

We returned to get her and I asked what they had been up to. My MIL proudly told me they had watched the first Harry Potter together.

My daughter is 4.5 years old and up until now has only watched things like Peppa Pig, Cocomelon, Peter Rabbit, Frozen etc. I didn't say anything to her then, but told my OH soon as we got in the car that I felt that was too mature for her.

He accused me of just nitpicking. I asked my daughter if the film was ok and she said 'it was ok, but a bit scary.' Sure enough, last night she came into our bed and said she had a bad dream.

I told my OH I thought her bad dream was because of what she had watched. He told me I am being extreme and it is a harmless film. I still feel annoyed by it though! It doesn't feel totally innocent given its dark theme. I wouldn't mind if she was a few years older, but 4.5 seems a bit young for that stuff. AIBU?

OP posts:
hangrylady · 03/01/2022 14:29

I take no notice of film age ratings and decide on a case by case basis whether I deem films suitable for my own kids. It depends entirely on the child, some 4 year olds would be terrified and others wouldn't bay an eyelid. You know your child and how they are likely to react.

Seriouslymole · 03/01/2022 14:25

I would have been incensed that she'd been allowed to watch the film before reading the books, but they are a bit of a rite of passage in our household.

But yes, YANBU - way too old for a 4.5 year old. I would have felt the same as you.

godmum56 · 03/01/2022 14:25

I haven't voted, but how would you had felt if it had been your parents and not dh's? you may say "oh they never would" but would you have felt the same if they had?

Gumbomambo · 03/01/2022 14:24

I bit too young I would think. DS is 8 now and he watched the first one at six, we had to have the remote control on standby the three headed dog and Voldemort’s head in the back of professor quirrels head was scary as was the turning to dust. Difficult to explain the child abuse to a four year old too as to why Harry has no mum and dad and his aunts family lock him in a cupboard. It won’t have harmed her though, lots of reassurance about things and hopefully when she’s older you can read the books together and start your own magical journey.

mamatoTails · 03/01/2022 14:23

We watched all the HP films leading up to
Christmas, with our children 13, 10, 8 and the youngest who are 4.5.
The little ones obviously didn't understand a lot but they enjoyed watching them with us.
My children have all preferred watching films with a bit more action - Jaws, Jurassic Park, Kong, Pirates of the Caribbean, Narnia etc.

gogohm · 03/01/2022 14:22

By the way frozen isn't really aimed at 4 year olds either.

ZeroFuchsGiven · 03/01/2022 14:22

I think this thread demonstrates greatly why we are now living in a world where children and young people are increasingly suffering with anxiety, mental health issues etc.

Kids need to learn resilience, emotions are normal and healthy, fear, anxiousness, being upset. Kids need to learn that these emotions are just as natural as being happy, excited etc. Not ever letting them feel these emotions and protecting them from them is so damaging and doing them no favours whatsoever.

gogohm · 03/01/2022 14:21

I will go over her head, not overly appropriate but no harm either. I doubt she understood it

girlmom21 · 03/01/2022 14:20

I agree with the poster saying that intense content is forced on children too young these days. Tv and film were much gentler in previous years.

When? Because we've recently watched both Beauty and the Beast and Lion King (25-30 years old) and they're both pretty savage in different ways.

SpinsForGin · 03/01/2022 14:20

The first two are absolutely fine. They get a bit dark after that.

NeedAHoliday2021 · 03/01/2022 14:19

The first one isn’t scary - our dc all watched it fairly young, especially my youngest as the oldest was way beyond peppa pig so it was a compromise. However mil showed my eldest the final film, which is very scary and dark, when I’d explicitly said Dd was too young. Dh and I popped out leaving dd1 with mil and came back earlier than expected. I walked in and realised, dd came to hug me hello and I just said “let’s go and play a game because this film is too scary for you” - dd didn’t hear anything beyond “game” so the rest of the sentence was for mil. She’s so desperate to be dd1’s favourite grandma Angry but I’d not worry about the first one.

ringoutthebells · 03/01/2022 14:18

@AsYouWishButtercup

FGS some of you are so precious. Scaring children 😂 it’s a PG, I’m going to go against the grain and say a child being a bit scared of a couple of scenes in a PG film won’t only not kill them but may actually be good for them lest they grow up to be a tremendous big girls blouse who needs a night light and dolly to sleep at age 22
'Grow up as a big girls' blouse' wow do people still think/say things like this in this day and age Confused

Most films are a bit OTT for children up to age 4, they're too long for starters, young kids are not designed to sit still for 1.5 hours. they should be playing and running about. I would never just 'put on' a Harry Potter film for a young kid. If they were expressing an interest, we'd start reading the book together and see how things went. Ideally I think they should wait til about 7 at the earliest, thankfully it really hasn't taken off in dds school year yet (y1) so she's not interested. For what it's worth she would have been terrified at age 4 too! Probably would still find it pretty scary at 6 now too, but it's not an issue as I'll wait til she shows an interest.

I agree with the poster saying that intense content is forced on children too young these days. Tv and film were much gentler in previous years. I am not as old as I sound, promise Grin

I'd set a loose simple rule with the mil, only c beebies/frozen if you're comfortable with those. Tbh it is pretty lazy to put on a film when looking after 1 child for a few hours!

RipWheeler · 03/01/2022 14:18

My children would have been frightened and had nightmares. The first movie is PG which means it’s for the 8+, some of the subsequent films are 12. I found the ratings were about right. Have to confess I cannot watch horror of any sort so we may well be a ‘sensitive’ family.

My best friend is a huge Matrix fan and watched the first two films at home on dvd with her then 4 year old. She said he loved them! I was pretty shocked as I find them scary as an adult. Unfortunately he has suffered with severe mental illness all his life and is living in an institution now. I’ve always wondered if the films he was watching contributed. Obviously I’ve never said anything as my friend has enough to worry about. This is a true story but I know some of you will roll your eyes.

Livelovebehappy · 03/01/2022 14:15

The first one is absolutely fine for a child of 4. The later ones not so much. I think you’re being nit picky with someone who is clearly doing you a good turn to give you a break. If you start stressing and creating drama over stuff like this, then be prepared for your mil to turn round and tell you she won’t be taking care of your dd again, as you clearly don’t trust her judgement.

kiki22 · 03/01/2022 14:15

It's a PG it's fine. In my experience the adults scare the children by making a big deal about the scary bits. It's much better to teach kids how to manage fear than avoid it and movies can be a great way of showing children range of emotion and how to deal with it.

ThrobbingToothacheOfTheMind · 03/01/2022 14:14

@girlmom21

It’s not the human caterpillar.

You're mixing two films at extreme ends of the spectrum there Grin

Grin

Not the very hungry human caterpillar?! 🤢

Newyearnewme2022 · 03/01/2022 14:14

I think my youngest had watched a couple of Harry Potter films by the time he was 4, he has older siblings. You are being precious and please don’t avoid the subject of death, films like Frozen and The Lion King are great for a very gentle first discussion about death.

HariboBrenshnio · 03/01/2022 14:14

If it was HP one or two, I don't see a problem. My kids have literally grown up on them, their first viewing was probably age 2. I love them and they are PG.

My 6&8 year old have seen all the films now and my 6 year old says Voldemort is her favourite character. I'm not saying we should purposefully scare our kids but I'd much rather they were watching things as imaginative and creative as HP rather than YouTube or peppa pig.

100problems · 03/01/2022 14:13

I think you deciding to let this one go is the best tack.

Best thing I found was to supply grandparents with a pile of DVD they could watch with the kids.

Guess you'd need to write a list of stuff that can be streamed these days.

I think folk move onto more sophisticated themes a bit soon largely due to the number of times they've watched every single Peppa episode (even though I could watch George I've skating every day))

Newuser82 · 03/01/2022 14:11

@Jessicabrassica

DD didn't watch it until we'd read it. She was probably y1/2 (5 or6). She then read all of the others and was allowed to watch them after she'd read them. Only the first gave her nightmares. Voldemort was more scary than her imagination could create. We stopped at the first 4 until the kids were 8 then allowed them to read the final one at 10. They had to read them first!
Yes we made our son read them before he was allowed to watch them.
BeefSupreme · 03/01/2022 14:11

ask them to stick to Us in the future

Us? The clone horror film?

girlmom21 · 03/01/2022 14:10

It’s not the human caterpillar.

You're mixing two films at extreme ends of the spectrum there Grin

Arepeoplereallycoolaboutthis · 03/01/2022 14:09

I think it depends on the child. Mine would have been fine watching it at that age.

But that doesn't mean you are overreacting. You know your child.

MargaretThursday · 03/01/2022 14:08

Depends on the child.
DD1 loved Harry Potter 1 & 2 at that age.
DD2 found Finding Nemo too scary at older than that so definitely not Harry Potter.
Ds would have been fine, but wasn't interested in stories and spent his time watching documentaries about WWII/planes.

I was more like DD2 and had to be taken out of the cinema during Bedknobs and Broomsticks. I still don't generally watch much above a 12A, and often that only through my fingers.

Ozanj · 03/01/2022 14:08

Depends on the child. DS is 2 and loves the first HP movie - he can’t sit through all of it in one go but will watch it in 3 parts. His favourite bits are the beginning when & he already understands that Harry’s aunt and uncle are ‘naughty’ and hurting him so he was so happy when Hagrid took him away.