Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it is not appropriate to put Harry Potter on for a 4.5 year old??

164 replies

Athysuisse · 03/01/2022 12:56

I dropped my daughter off at her Grandma's (my MIL) yesterday afternoon as my husband and I have had very little time to be together one on one and she offered. We grabbed a bite to eat and went for a walk. Altogether gone about 4 hours.

We returned to get her and I asked what they had been up to. My MIL proudly told me they had watched the first Harry Potter together.

My daughter is 4.5 years old and up until now has only watched things like Peppa Pig, Cocomelon, Peter Rabbit, Frozen etc. I didn't say anything to her then, but told my OH soon as we got in the car that I felt that was too mature for her.

He accused me of just nitpicking. I asked my daughter if the film was ok and she said 'it was ok, but a bit scary.' Sure enough, last night she came into our bed and said she had a bad dream.

I told my OH I thought her bad dream was because of what she had watched. He told me I am being extreme and it is a harmless film. I still feel annoyed by it though! It doesn't feel totally innocent given its dark theme. I wouldn't mind if she was a few years older, but 4.5 seems a bit young for that stuff. AIBU?

OP posts:
MaryShelley1818 · 03/01/2022 15:07

My 4yr old DS is Harry Potter mad! (Turned 4 a few weeks ago). Some children are more emotionally mature, some are more sensitive, children all like different things.
He's been watching all the HP movies since he was 3, understands the plots, knows all the characters and which houses they're in, has some HP Lego, is booked for his second trip to the studios next summer. He also loves the Jurrasic World/Park movies and has a really impressive knowledge of dinosaurs - he doesn't want to watch cartoon dinosaurs as he loves the realistic ones.
I'm in no hurry for him to grow up but I also am keen to allow him to develop his genuine interests if I feel it's appropriate. He loves movies and magic, talks about HP being about friendship and courage. And loves learning about Dinosaurs and the different periods that they lived, volcanos, meteorites etc
He hasn't shown a moment of ever being scared as he understands movies are pretend and just finds them interesting.

In contrast he's scared of heights, hates trampolines and screamed on the Peter Pan ride at Disneyland Paris. So lots of things that would be classed as for his age.

Terminallysleepdeprived · 03/01/2022 15:05

My dd watched it at about 5 but she watched films like frozen and bambi at 2 which I think are similar in terms of horror rating for kids. She wasn't fazed by it at all but I do know friends of hers who now at 8 can't watch it as they find it too scary. She has watched all of them now and loves them but she has chosen to and not had it forced upon her.

The only thing that matters is how you feel about it. If your relationship with your mil is OK just explain you don't feel she's old enough

PotteringAlong · 03/01/2022 14:57

My parents tend to stick on documentaries narrated by David Attenborough!

I think you’re better off with your MiL showing Harry Potter to a 4 year old (my 4 year old has seen it because by 10 year old is potter mad so he’s been indoctrinated earlier!) than the animal kingdom ripping each other apart.

And no @RipWheeler. Your friends son does not have mental health issues so severe that he cannot live independently because he watched the matrix.

TheGarbageManCan · 03/01/2022 14:56

I wouldn’t be too impressed with MIL either TbH - we did watch it together when DD was 4.5, but we’d read the book twice (back to back because she was so taken with hermione 🤦🏼‍♀️😂) and she had the context of it, but still found it scary. We are doing one book a year as they get very dark (book 4 😭😭). I don’t think I’d have just put it on if she’d not had the book read to her!

HeyFloof · 03/01/2022 14:52

@RipWheeler

My children would have been frightened and had nightmares. The first movie is PG which means it’s for the 8+, some of the subsequent films are 12. I found the ratings were about right. Have to confess I cannot watch horror of any sort so we may well be a ‘sensitive’ family.

My best friend is a huge Matrix fan and watched the first two films at home on dvd with her then 4 year old. She said he loved them! I was pretty shocked as I find them scary as an adult. Unfortunately he has suffered with severe mental illness all his life and is living in an institution now. I’ve always wondered if the films he was watching contributed. Obviously I’ve never said anything as my friend has enough to worry about. This is a true story but I know some of you will roll your eyes.

This, genuinely, is one of the most ridiculous things I've ever read. Unless her then 4 yo was being actually plugged into the matrix a la Keanu Reeves, it is vanishingly unlikely it caused his mental health problems.
ArabellaScott · 03/01/2022 14:52

Agree, OP, far too scary. Though it probably depends a bit on the child.

girlmom21 · 03/01/2022 14:51

@MyDcAreMarvel

Are people confused with a U? PG’s are aimed at 8 plus.
No they're not. PG suggests parental supervision/discretion.
MyDcAreMarvel · 03/01/2022 14:49

Are people confused with a U? PG’s are aimed at 8 plus.

CallMeK · 03/01/2022 14:49

My daughter has watched most of the HP movies with me and her older brothers. She loves it! She just covers her eyes if it gets scary.

lottiegarbanzo · 03/01/2022 14:46

My DC at the same age found Frozen upsetting and the Lion King really distressing.

Some DC get much more emotionally involved in films, while others seem to view from them a distance and don't feel particularly involved or affected at all.

Hemingwayscatz · 03/01/2022 14:43

The first HP is the most mild of the lot I’d say and I can’t really see much issue with this. I don’t think my 3 year old DS would care for it much, it’s a bit long to grab his attention but doubt he’d be scared.

ThrobbingToothacheOfTheMind · 03/01/2022 14:43

and I just said “let’s go and play a game because this film is too scary for you” - dd didn’t hear anything beyond “game” so the rest of the sentence was for mil

🙄
She probably only got scared because you made it more of a big deal than you needed to and overreacted because of your need to be passive aggressive with MIL. Don’t pretend she didn’t hear the full sentence.

girlmom21 · 03/01/2022 14:42

@BurntToastAgain

People can be in a mad rush to get in first on 'milestones' and it sounds like that was what your MIL was doing.

Maybe she was just trying to do something nice with her granddaughter?

At this time of year Harry Potter is on ITV almost constantly (I don't know if it was yesterday but that's not relevant).

It'd be really easy to get halfway through 'watching' it in the background before even considering what's actually on the tv.

BurntToastAgain · 03/01/2022 14:41

People can be in a mad rush to get in first on 'milestones' and it sounds like that was what your MIL was doing.

Maybe she was just trying to do something nice with her granddaughter?

SamMil · 03/01/2022 14:41

My just turned 4 year old watches Harry Potter quite regularly (at her request!). We've only watched the first 4 films with her as I think the others are too dark. She is not particularly sensitive though and not prone to nightmares.

You know your own child and I don't think there's any harm in mentioning to your in laws that she was frightened, and to maybe stick with U rated films!

ZeroFuchsGiven · 03/01/2022 14:40

Wow, that’s one of the most tremendous leaps I’ve ever seen on mn. You think The Matrix ruined his mental health? That’s actually quite a shocking and ignorant thing to say

Yeah, I had zero words for that one Grin

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 03/01/2022 14:40

My DS(5) absolutely would not enjoy Harry Potter. He would find the idea of Harry not having parents too upsetting and basically everything from moment they get through the door to the third floor corridor would be too scary.
My friend's son (same age) loves the films and can sit and watch all of them with no fear at all.

I love HP so I'm going to let DS discover them when he's old enough...think I was 10ish?

lottiegarbanzo · 03/01/2022 14:39

She's far too young for it. It's a PG, not a U (though, as it happens, so is Frozen, for the scary, fighting bits).

Different children respond very differently to the same films. You really have to follow the child's lead and get to know what will worry them, what go over their heads, what they'll enjoy. There is no universally 'right' answer.

People can be in a mad rush to get in first on 'milestones' and it sounds like that was what your MIL was doing.

It may also be that she and her DCs are quite insensitive to film content, so she's used to being able to show scary films to young children, without ill effects. Whereas you and your dd are more sensitive.

Being sensitive is not a bad thing and it's not going to change. It is part of who you and/or your dd are.

ThrobbingToothacheOfTheMind · 03/01/2022 14:38

@RipWheeler

My children would have been frightened and had nightmares. The first movie is PG which means it’s for the 8+, some of the subsequent films are 12. I found the ratings were about right. Have to confess I cannot watch horror of any sort so we may well be a ‘sensitive’ family.

My best friend is a huge Matrix fan and watched the first two films at home on dvd with her then 4 year old. She said he loved them! I was pretty shocked as I find them scary as an adult. Unfortunately he has suffered with severe mental illness all his life and is living in an institution now. I’ve always wondered if the films he was watching contributed. Obviously I’ve never said anything as my friend has enough to worry about. This is a true story but I know some of you will roll your eyes.

Wow, that’s one of the most tremendous leaps I’ve ever seen on mn. You think The Matrix ruined his mental health? That’s actually quite a shocking and ignorant thing to say.
BurntToastAgain · 03/01/2022 14:37

I agree with the poster saying that intense content is forced on children too young these days. Tv and film were much gentler in previous years. I am not as old as I sound, promise grin

You have seen bambi?

ThrobbingToothacheOfTheMind · 03/01/2022 14:36

Tv and film were much gentler in previous years. I am not as old as I sound, promise

You’re wearing rose tinted glasses. Children’s films are much more sanitised these day than the past.

girlmom21 · 03/01/2022 14:34

My parents tend to stick on documentaries narrated by David Attenborough!

Ah the ones where you see animals hunting and killing each other? Wink

I think you're doing the right thing OP. Hopefully it's just a one off and your daughters ok tonight.

Athysuisse · 03/01/2022 14:33

If it had been my parents I would have probably said it right then and there. I held my tongue because she is my MIL.

My parents tend to stick on documentaries narrated by David Attenborough! My MIL and I do have a decent relationship so I don't have an issue with her specifically. I think it was more just that I know my daughter gets spooked by things quite easily so I thought 'Great, now we will have dreams of Voldemort..!' She suffered from night terrors for 18 months and then it moved onto regular nightmares. We are finally at a nightmare roughly every two weeks. I think I panicked that it would up the number of nightmares! She did have a bad dream last night but it could be coincidence. She seems fine today. I won't make a deal of it with my MIL, but will just note no HP next time!

OP posts:
WeNeedToTalkAboutBruno · 03/01/2022 14:31

My 4yo has also seen Harry Potter as 6yo is a big fan after we read 1-4 for bedtime stories (and she now wants to go to Hogwarts Grin). I assume PG is to decide whether it is suitable for your own child so would recommend letting MIL know it was too scary for your child. Different children find different things scary. Mine weren’t bothered a jot by HP, but eldest is no longer allowed to watch Scooby Doo as it makes her worry at bedtime. Younger is a bit braver in general! We’re not reading past book four yet with 6yo as it gets a bit dark and I know she’s not ready. I think I may have skipped over certain sentences in the Goblet of Fire too as didn’t think they were appropriate. Both know they can’t watch past the 3rd film either as they are rated 12.

FeelingdownXmas · 03/01/2022 14:29

I let my nephew watch it when he was 3🙈 in my defense I was 15 and didn't know any better. He's 20 now and seemed to have survived it unscathed.