Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To the people who believe men and women can never be friends, do you then believe that people who are bisexual shouldn’t have any friends at all?

106 replies

AlternativePerspective · 03/01/2022 12:20

Genuine question.

Time and time again on here we see posts from posters saying “men and women cannot be just friends, one or the other will always have feelings, they’ll end up having an affair, I wouldn’t allow my husband to have female friends,” etc etc.

So, based on that assumption, surely it then stands to reason that someone is bisexual should never have any friends, since they are attracted to both men and women?

Obviously men and women can be just friends. But if you believe they can’t, then surely you believe as above. And if not, why not?

Vote:

YABU: bisexual people shouldn’t have friends.

Yanbu: Both men and women can have friends of the opposite sex, just as people who are bisexual can be friends with either men or women without needing to sleep with them.

OP posts:
Nathlash · 04/01/2022 06:34

@TractorAndHeadphones

Yet another bunfight thread.

Two BFF's going out for drinks, shopping, telling each other intimate details of their sex lives normal. But would doing all that with a single , straight male best friend be acceptable?

Also a man with mostly male friends and who doesn't do 'coffee dates' suddenly having them with a woman, texting sharing mundane details etc obviously something fishy. A man with multiple female friends who meets up with them, not fishy.

It's not a question of 'friendship' in general but the intensity.
Also being bi is irrelevannt. If the other people are straight nothing's going to happen even if you fancy them so what's the issue?

What a bizarre vision of best friendship. I’ve never discussed details of my sex life with any of my friends, male or female, and I don’t think that’s ‘normal’ at all, any more than I think that shopping is any more than a tiresome chore, whoever you do it with. It is, however, entirely normal for me to have a drink or dinner or see a film or play with a male friend, as it’s entirely normal for DH to see his longterm female friends solo. These are in many cases people we’ve had in our lives for 20 years or more.

I think some of the paranoia about male/female friendships on Mn must come from some of the deeply odd ideas about the nature of friendship in general expressed on here.

MiddleParking · 04/01/2022 06:07

@hugr I didn’t assume that, I considered it and then assumed you would recognise that that also fell outside the scope of the topic Confused again, the discussion is about the beliefs of people who don’t think that men can be friends with women. Not people who say, “I don’t believe men can be friends with anyone whose sexuality includes attraction to men.” My point is partly that no one is saying that because people whose worldview is inclusive of people who aren’t heterosexual are almost certainly not the people saying they don’t believe men and women can ever have platonic friendships.

SportsMother · 04/01/2022 06:04

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Dottybackorcid · 04/01/2022 05:45

Try put a bull on a field full of cows and see what happens. Now put a cow in a field full of bulls. Basic biology 🤣.

Males are usually biologically programmed, just to reproduce and pass there genes on as much as possible. Where as females nurture.

A bisexual females will not have the same natural instincts as a bisexual male, so your argument falls over Grin

hugr · 04/01/2022 05:20

[quote MiddleParking]@hugr the discussion is about the beliefs of people who don’t think that men can be friends with women. Obviously, people whose straight male partners have female friends aren’t those people.[/quote]
Lol! What I was saying was if the partner had a bisexual male friend. Weird of you to presume I meant female.

OfCourseIDontMind · 03/01/2022 19:12

Sexuality seems a pretty dumb reason to reject friendship. Maybe the people who believe this have some loyalty or bigotry issues?
Good people are good people no matter their gender, background, beliefs or persuasions.
What's that psychology about the 10 people closest to you are your reflection?

SwimmingIntoMotherhood · 03/01/2022 18:11

Probably

Only because those who believe men and women can't be friends never come across as overly bright.

Whataday198 · 03/01/2022 18:01

@crazyjinglist

Sort of YANBU, but also sort of YABU in the way you've phrased the question. I'm not one of the people who thinks men and women can't be friends, but I think you may be misrepresenting the view of those who do. They generally think it's unlikely for men/women to be able to be friends with no attraction on either side. That's not really the same as saying they shouldn't be friends. Ditto with bisexual people.
So basically you think bisexual people are unlikely to be able to have genuine friends that they aren't secretly lusting over but accept they will anyway? Well, that's an... opinion. Certainly.
tarasmalatarocks · 03/01/2022 17:59

I do think men and women can be friends , I do think however women tend to be better at being /staying friends without any interest/attraction— if I’m honest I think both sexes often find ‘friendship’ with opposite sex harder if it’s someone who would be ‘their type/attractive/ right age/on tap etc.

thepeopleversuswork · 03/01/2022 17:59

I'd hazard a guess that quite a lot of the people who say things like "I'd never allow my husband to have a female friend" are the sorts of people who don't socialise (consciously) with non heterosexual people anyway.

They tend to be old-fashioned, narrow minded and not very imaginative people who think that everyone should be married in the early 20s and live happily ever after and wouldn't recognise anything as complex and nuanced as bisexuality.

BadgeronaMoped · 03/01/2022 17:56

In my experience its (generally) always the man in the friendship who makes it weird. I'm not saying men and women can't have platonic friendships, of course they can, it's just when a friendship crosses the line. By that I mean emotionally, for example if a person's DH/DP/DW is engaging in intense relationship-type discussion/chit-chat to the detriment of their existing relationship.

Butchyrestingface · 03/01/2022 17:50

If you were a heterosexual female or a gay man, what the impediment be to a bisexual female being friends with either?

Or a gay woman, with a bisexual male friend?

Not sure that even people with the rather dated view that men and women can't be friends would object to a number of different scenarios involving sexual preferences that mean at least one party would not be attracted to the other.

gwenneh · 03/01/2022 17:46

@SapphosRock

Great question. I'm a lesbian, should I have no female friends?
Correct. And should a woman approach you with friendly overtures, you need to make it explicitly clear that you're a lesbian and therefore cannot, under any circumstances, be friends with a woman as friendship and romantic love are inclusive, always, forever, totally entwined, and do not exist separately.

Maybe we can get you a sign printed or something? Might be easier.

SapphosRock · 03/01/2022 17:37

Great question. I'm a lesbian, should I have no female friends?

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 03/01/2022 17:04

It’s apparent here in the “nobody would date a bisexual person anyway” comments

Indeed.

I'd like to ask the poster who appears to believe that straight people can instinctually detect bisexuals at 100 paces and automatically conclude they are not attracted to them, why, throughout my life, the vast majority of the people I've dated, slept with, been hit on by, had short relationships with, and the one person I spent almost half my life in a monogamous relationship with, were all hetero and completely at ease with my bisexuality?

2022, and its evident from this thread alone that the world is still full of people who have some wild, clueless, and outright offensive ideas about what Bi people actually are. It would be sickening if it wasn't so fucking laughable at the same time.

TedMullins · 03/01/2022 16:22

@GirlOnPfizer

The attitudes towards bisexual people on this site are fucking awful.
Yeah it’s straight up biphobia. Calling them (well, us, as I am one) greedy, untrustworthy, more likely to get STIs. It is definitely worse towards men, apparently it’s “not masculine” to have attraction to/have been with a man. Then people start coming out with “you can’t force people to sleep with who they’re not attracted to, that’s rapey!” Nobody wants to force anyone, just admit that your lack of attraction comes in this case from ingrained prejudice. It’s apparent here in the “nobody would date a bisexual person anyway” comments, basically saying bisexual people don’t figure in their worldview.
crazyjinglist · 03/01/2022 16:18

Sort of YANBU, but also sort of YABU in the way you've phrased the question. I'm not one of the people who thinks men and women can't be friends, but I think you may be misrepresenting the view of those who do. They generally think it's unlikely for men/women to be able to be friends with no attraction on either side. That's not really the same as saying they shouldn't be friends. Ditto with bisexual people.

RobotValkyrie · 03/01/2022 16:13

I don't know what these people (the "men and women can't be friends" crowd) think, as am not one of them.

But it makes me wonder if they spend all their time leering at the opposite sex (and projecting their own lust on others)

Note: am saying "opposite sex" since these people seem to assume everyone's straight. No idea what their idea on friendships are when it come to gay or lesbian people... (do you they fantasise that gay people are constantly trying to get into their pants as well? Classic narcissistic trait...)

gwenneh · 03/01/2022 15:38

@Thatsplentyjack

Who says the "should never have friends", more just that it's likely that they will eventually sleep with or develop feelings for one of their friends. Or are you going to tell is that never happens?
Of course it happens. The question is for those people who believes this will ALWAYS happen, as if friendship is somehow just a prelude to these things and can't exist on its own. The language you use, that it's "likely", suggests that you view it that way.

Can't get my head around that view of friendship, frankly. Do you seriously only have friends that you wouldn't date?

gannett · 03/01/2022 15:38

@GirlOnPfizer

The attitudes towards bisexual people on this site are fucking awful.
Every so often there's a thread about male bisexuality and I read them slackjawed at the amount of posters who feel able to express actual repulsion and disgust at those men.
GirlOnPfizer · 03/01/2022 15:34

The attitudes towards bisexual people on this site are fucking awful.

gannett · 03/01/2022 15:33

@Fidgetty

Do people really believe that men and women can NEVER have platonic friendships though? I'm in the category that thinks it's quite rare that a male/female friendship is completely platonic and that one or the other will have at some stage found the other person attractive even if that attraction dissipated. I imagine I'm at the extreme end of this yet even I can still accept that there are some cases where things are completely platonic. I don't know anyone openly bisexual so that's never crossed my mind.
But finding other people attractive is irrelevant.

I've always been in mixed-sex (and mixed-sexuality) social groups and can't comprehend things like "girls nights in" or "lads nights out" or any of those cliched segregated socialising things. I could tell you right now which of my male friends are more and less attractive. I assume DP could do the same with his female friends. We have eyes.

What matters is whether we act on that. And it's so easy not to.

The reason I don't try to shag my good-looking male friends isn't because I don't think they're good-looking, it's because I have loyalty to DP, respect for them and their partners, and self-control over myself.

I wouldn't be surprised if some male friends have found me attractive over the years but if they've never given any indication I assume the same is true of them.

ItchySnoof · 03/01/2022 15:28

Shit sorry, to answer the question no. People can be friends with whoever they like, whatever their gender and people who disagree because "they might cheat" desperately need to check their insecurities before getting into relationships.

ItchySnoof · 03/01/2022 15:24

I'm Bisexual, and have been told RE this and similar things that it doesn't apply to me because "you don't really like girls, you are in a relationship with a man and have kids" (i'm female, for context).

In my experience this comes from both LGBTQ and the Hetero community. They both seem to love invalidating Bisexuals, especially those who have a preference for the opposite sex over the same sex (i've had two relationships with women which apparently just didn't count because my life partner is male).

Thatsplentyjack · 03/01/2022 15:23

Who says the "should never have friends", more just that it's likely that they will eventually sleep with or develop feelings for one of their friends. Or are you going to tell is that never happens?

Swipe left for the next trending thread