Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To the people who believe men and women can never be friends, do you then believe that people who are bisexual shouldn’t have any friends at all?

106 replies

AlternativePerspective · 03/01/2022 12:20

Genuine question.

Time and time again on here we see posts from posters saying “men and women cannot be just friends, one or the other will always have feelings, they’ll end up having an affair, I wouldn’t allow my husband to have female friends,” etc etc.

So, based on that assumption, surely it then stands to reason that someone is bisexual should never have any friends, since they are attracted to both men and women?

Obviously men and women can be just friends. But if you believe they can’t, then surely you believe as above. And if not, why not?

Vote:

YABU: bisexual people shouldn’t have friends.

Yanbu: Both men and women can have friends of the opposite sex, just as people who are bisexual can be friends with either men or women without needing to sleep with them.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BoopTheFloof · 04/01/2022 13:14

I’m bi.

The main barrier I have found to men and women being friends is very different socialisation around sexual conduct. It’s not directly about attraction, it’s about what is and isn’t acceptable behaviour.

Nidan2Sandan · 04/01/2022 13:01

I'm always accused of being a "cool wife" on here. DH has a really close female friend, they went through training school together. He even shock horror went to visit her and stayed at her house! Apparently this means I should believe he was shagging her senseless and not just believing that my husband loves me and is loyal to me Hmm

FWIW, all but one of my friends are men. Mainly because I met them through my sport and that sport is male dominated. But then, I dont look at them as a walking penis, I look at them like a human being.

5128gap · 04/01/2022 12:26

Its not about the sex of the friend, is about whether they are potentially attractive to the other party or not. Most of the situations where this arises involve a partner whose 'best friend' is an attractive member of a gender they would be sexually interested in. People have no difficulty in believing friendship exist where the friend in question is unattractive; and people in same sex relationships can get just as concerned about same sex friendships involving an attractive friend.

SpankyPankhurst · 04/01/2022 12:19

Yes. They should put the "bi" in "Billy No Mates."

Whatwouldscullydo · 04/01/2022 12:14

I think some of the paranoia about male/female friendships on Mn must come from some of the deeply odd ideas about the nature of friendship in general expressed on here

I do find the restrictions/boundaries of friendships fascinating tbh.

I've spent 20 years of my employed life merely having to engage in pretty superficial relationships with people. I'm.sure anyone who's worked in a pub for instance knows that before they became buildings full of loud music and fancy drink offers , that your good old fashioned pub with regular customers, well u somehow became relationships advisors, shrinks, general life advisers etc ( look mate I work in a pub and I've never dated anyone more than 6 months Im clearly not the person to ask) my jobs since have been similar in that sense. I found myself Desperately missing the deep and meaningful trusting friendships I had back in my school/college days.

When I had kids etc I tried to build relationships based on commonalities with other mums but never really quite got there. Despite not really seeing why it would make a difference whether my friends were men or women I seemed to mostly befriend men. Not even intentionally I just kinda fell into it.

Years later I realise that many of them just seemed to want to put me in the position of knowing things about them that they should probably be talking to their wives about. Although there were/are a couple of friendships I still maintain , and certainly not at a level their significant others need to be worried about.

Ultimately however despite being that person for others I don't really have that tell eachother everything relationship with anyone now ( regardless of the sexuality of that person as that's something that's never really been a factor or problem.as why would it be?! ) not through choice but more through respect for the other person given that according to MN rules I've basically had an emotional affair with every man and woman I've ever been friends with)

As much as I understand life changes and priorities change and that can naturally just cause people to grow apart, it can be a bit annoying that people pull back/fully invest depending on whether or not they are single.

It can make you feel guilty for something you never did if that makes sense.

I guess what I'm saying is don't leave it to guess work. If u have told me the most personal things about yourself then u can tell me the truth about why you don't speak to me so much any more.

Ironically when speaking to or out with friends said friend got more "check ins" when it was a straight male than when it was a lesbian friend.

My ex was was also less " off" with me goimg out with women even if I stayed over ams even if they were gay. Than an evening out with a straight man even if they began seeing people ( who weren't me)

HairyFanjoBanjo · 04/01/2022 12:11

I wonder if it’s some straight men who are the problem in this scenario. Rather than all men and women (bi or straight) not being able to have platonic friendships.

Toxic masculinity for some straight men etc..

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 04/01/2022 12:04

I'm bi. The number of people I find attractive is staggeringly low and it doesn't seem to affect my ability to make friends. I am however on the fence about straight males as friends for me. In my experience it usually goes badly due to their behaviour, samples being "my wife doesn't understand me" and waking up with their hand in my pants (two different "friends"). Oddly enough (or not) my lesbian or fellow female bi friends have never pulled stunts like that. Now my male friends fall into two distinct camps, gay or married to my female friends.

hugr · 04/01/2022 11:54

[quote MiddleParking]@hugr I didn’t assume that, I considered it and then assumed you would recognise that that also fell outside the scope of the topic Confused again, the discussion is about the beliefs of people who don’t think that men can be friends with women. Not people who say, “I don’t believe men can be friends with anyone whose sexuality includes attraction to men.” My point is partly that no one is saying that because people whose worldview is inclusive of people who aren’t heterosexual are almost certainly not the people saying they don’t believe men and women can ever have platonic friendships.[/quote]
The OP asks do those who believe men and women can't be friends think bisexuals shouldn't have friends. You said that these people would be unlikely to have a bisexual partner so it's not relevant. I'm simply pointing out that a partner might have a bisexual friend of the same sex, which would complicate a situation for those who believe men and women can't be friends. Hope this is relevant enough to the OP for you.

ElectraBlue · 04/01/2022 11:47

I have 3 close male friends. 2 are platonic and the 3rd recently became a lover after 6 years of friendship (we were both single).

So yes men and women can be platonic friend and yes, some can develop feelings for each other.

Life is usually not black and white...

I see people as individuals and their gender and sexual orientation is irrelevant.

The assumption that because someone is bi they are going to want to sleep with every friend they make is staggeringly ignorant.

As for ''Many people people would not consider a relationship with a bisexual' this is assuming that people are as judgmental as you are...

Seriously some people need to relax a bit and stop walking around with so many prejudices...

Annaghgloor · 04/01/2022 11:45

And I select all my friends of both sexes for their lack of desire to talk about football, cars, babies or shopping. Grin

Annaghgloor · 04/01/2022 11:44

@Whataday198

I think the message I'm getting from a number of posters on here is that they wouldn't have anything to do with anyone who wasn't straight so it's not relevant who non straight people are friends with as they aren't real people.

MN posters wish to live in their own nice heterosexual world where men only are friends with other men, and talk about cars and football and women are only friends with other women and talk about babies and shopping and never the twain shall meet.

Not all of us (though I know where you’re getting the impression from). I’m straight, but have three lesbians and a bi woman among my close friends, and my closest male friend is bi.
Whataday198 · 04/01/2022 11:34

I think the message I'm getting from a number of posters on here is that they wouldn't have anything to do with anyone who wasn't straight so it's not relevant who non straight people are friends with as they aren't real people.

MN posters wish to live in their own nice heterosexual world where men only are friends with other men, and talk about cars and football and women are only friends with other women and talk about babies and shopping and never the twain shall meet.

gannett · 04/01/2022 11:21

*What a bizarre vision of best friendship. I’ve never discussed details of my sex life with any of my friends, male or female, and I don’t think that’s ‘normal’ at all, any more than I think that shopping is any more than a tiresome chore, whoever you do it with. It is, however, entirely normal for me to have a drink or dinner or see a film or play with a male friend, as it’s entirely normal for DH to see his longterm female friends solo. These are in many cases people we’ve had in our lives for 20 years or more.

I think some of the paranoia about male/female friendships on Mn must come from some of the deeply odd ideas about the nature of friendship in general expressed on here.*

Same. I talk about sex in general with both male and female friends but it'd feel as uncomfortable talking about my own sex life with another woman as with a man (and it'd feel like just as much a betrayal of my relationship with DP).

My friendships are pretty much all centred around mutual interests, none of which require participants to be men or women.

gannett · 04/01/2022 11:16

@Dottybackorcid

Try put a bull on a field full of cows and see what happens. Now put a cow in a field full of bulls. Basic biology 🤣.

Males are usually biologically programmed, just to reproduce and pass there genes on as much as possible. Where as females nurture.

A bisexual females will not have the same natural instincts as a bisexual male, so your argument falls over Grin

Bull...shit.

The "basic biology" types (who remind me so much of the "evo psych" lot on MRA forums) seem almost proud to declare themselves cows, not humans. Baffling.

Unsuremover · 04/01/2022 10:16

@Dottybackorcid

Try put a bull on a field full of cows and see what happens. Now put a cow in a field full of bulls. Basic biology 🤣.

Males are usually biologically programmed, just to reproduce and pass there genes on as much as possible. Where as females nurture.

A bisexual females will not have the same natural instincts as a bisexual male, so your argument falls over Grin

I like to think humans are more evolved than cattle in the field. I mean a bull will service a whole herd of females, not sure my husband has it in him to pop into my office and do the rounds. What are the instincts of a bisexual male btw? Would be extremely helpful to know that an entire subset of rhe species act in the same way.
Nathlash · 04/01/2022 09:55

@MorningStarling

The voting on this makes no sense, it's illogical.

Straight men can have straight male friends.
Straight women can have straight female friends.
Bisexual people can have bisexual friends.

In each case the person is able to have friends of the same sexual orientation. There's no double standards or doublethink necessary.

Are you on glue?
SwimmingIntoMotherhood · 04/01/2022 09:54

@MorningStarling

The voting on this makes no sense, it's illogical.

Straight men can have straight male friends.
Straight women can have straight female friends.
Bisexual people can have bisexual friends.

In each case the person is able to have friends of the same sexual orientation. There's no double standards or doublethink necessary.

Sexual orientation doesn't always prevent feelings though

Yes it would negate the affair element but the OP specially also mentions having feelings for someone else, being attracted to them - in which case their orientation doesn't always play a part in that.

MorningStarling · 04/01/2022 09:31

The voting on this makes no sense, it's illogical.

Straight men can have straight male friends.
Straight women can have straight female friends.
Bisexual people can have bisexual friends.

In each case the person is able to have friends of the same sexual orientation. There's no double standards or doublethink necessary.

TedMullins · 04/01/2022 09:26

@SportsMother

It is, however, entirely normal for me to have a drink or dinner or see a film or play with a male friend, as it’s entirely normal for DH to see his longterm female friends solo. These are in many cases people we’ve had in our lives for 20 years or more.

The Norm for you, but not common at all, if at the same frequency as with a same sex friend.

In your experience maybe but in mine, this is perfectly normal and common.
Labracadabradoodle · 04/01/2022 08:33

I have male friends and female friends. Some are single, some are not (I am also friends with their partners).
My sexuality has nothing to do with it, because they are just friends and we don't view each other in a sexual way... It really is that simple.

Snugglepumpkin · 04/01/2022 07:45

I can't vote for either of your choices because I actually believe it's not that men & women can't be friends, it that men are rarely able to be friends with women without wanting to take it further.

So I would feel as equally doubtful about the friendship motives of a bisexual man as I would about a heterosexual man.

It's not that I think every man is like that, but an awful lot of them do seem to be.

However, I wouldn't automatically think a bisexual woman (by which I mean biological woman) would possibly have ulterior motives.
I would believe they might just want to be friends in the exact same way a lesbian woman might want to just be friends.

I just don't think women are led as much by what's between their legs as men are.

Nathlash · 04/01/2022 07:38

@SportsMother

It is, however, entirely normal for me to have a drink or dinner or see a film or play with a male friend, as it’s entirely normal for DH to see his longterm female friends solo. These are in many cases people we’ve had in our lives for 20 years or more.

The Norm for you, but not common at all, if at the same frequency as with a same sex friend.

And yet Mn is full of posters saying they are desperately lonely and want friends — why disregard 50% of the human race?
SportsMother · 04/01/2022 07:04

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

malificent7 · 04/01/2022 06:57

This could be because of the fact that dp is my best friend , i don't want emotional closeness with anyone else but also i don't have many friends in general...i do miss them.

malificent7 · 04/01/2022 06:54

I think the nature of the friendship counts for a lot. I have male friends with who I am friendly with and have a laugh with if i see them out.
I don't have any male friends who i hang out with lots, go on coffee dates with, weekends away, cinema etc as seems to be the norm on here.