Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think single women in mid 30s onwards are often wrongly accused of being picky

117 replies

Starbrand · 03/01/2022 10:53

I find this often. When you start seeing someone and dont feel they are compatible (for valid reasons, outlook on life etc) you are encouraged (often by older women) to “give it more of a go” and “no ones perfect” when you arent asking for perfection, you just dont want to waste your time or the guys?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NearlyAHoarder · 05/01/2022 18:30

Im single now and have settled in to it,, but every mcRelationship i ever had, it always split up because of the same little warning i ignored at the beginnig. Always....

Little inner voice, shhsh "hey, it's just a series of really good dates, no connection".
Him - it's over.
__
Little voice 'he seems to drink every night, maybe im worrying about nothing though"
Him - "some thugs attacked me for NO reason". I know I said Id be there but Im hungover.

Little voice "he seems a bit insecure." "So are we all sometimes"
Him - blah blah blah how can you say that! How can you think that! I cant believe you x,y,z I should have known you'd turn out to be like all the others".

I could go on for pages.

I dont think there's ever no little voice warning me when i meet a man.

When im single, the little voice says "phew, finally"

GrandmasCat · 05/01/2022 15:46

True, that is not picky, it is filtering… at the end of the day we don’t welcome contact/invitations from random men on the street, OLD should be approached in the same way.

D0lphine · 05/01/2022 09:58

@GrandmasCat

I thought I did, but ok… My experience of OLD was, in general, very positive. I say was because I “downloaded” my partner from there many years ago and we are still happy together.

But going back to those times, I would say that I was probably picky or better said, a blocker (first uncalled for innuendo, bad vibe, or something that made me think they were not pleasant, I pressed the “block”button and forgot about it completely).

I managed to meet a lot of nice men, some were not what I was looking for, for some I was not what they were looking for, but in general they were all very nice, articulate, polite people and some of them became good friends (with no benefits, I must add, as I am a prude).

The worst experience that I had was a hyperactive university professor that made me feel as if I was having lunch with my poodle. There was also a businessman who unexpectedly turned into an arse on arrival and some lawyer who, without noticing, talked about his “ex” as his wife. But honestly, these were an absolute minority, probably about 5-10% of the people I met.

But again, I was not looking for mister perfectly handsome, with a huge salary or fantastic physique, because I am far from being that person myself. I just wanted a well rounded intelligent man, with good principles, a high level of culture, amazing level of conversation (that’s what I am picky at) and a good heart.

Agree I was a blocker when online dating.

Anything sexual- block
4 kids with 3 different women who are all "crazy" - block
Sexist about women - block

But I don't think that's being picky I think it's just filtering the options to get a decent human!

crazyjinglist · 05/01/2022 07:21

I've never done OLD, @GrandmasCat, but your approach sounds eminently sensible!

crazyjinglist · 05/01/2022 07:20

I think Joey Trivianni is the holder of the truth when it comes to dating: If you class yourself as an “8” you can date people ranging from 6 to 10, but if you are a “4” you should adjust your expectations and date some one ranging from 2 to 6. (All a joke obviously but with some element of truth).

But Joey Tribbiani is only referring to physical attractiveness isn't he? And while people can still be as picky as they like in that respect (regardless of their own attractiveness), I don't think that's what people are mostly talking about on here. The benefit of being picky is to not end up with a bad relationship, rather than not ending up with someone not quite good-looking enough!

RantyAunty · 04/01/2022 22:41

@crazyjinglist

Whatever one's own criteria for a partner, I don't see the point of criticising another woman for being too picky. She is presumably only as picky as she wants to be.

Accusations of pickiness presuppose that being in a relationship is the be-all and end-all and that we have to compromise in order to find a partner. But we don't have to. We can stay single. If a woman has decided that being single is better than being with 99.5% of the men available, then why is that any skin off anyone else's nose? Besides, she's probably right.

This!!

Men need to improve themselves.

GrandmasCat · 04/01/2022 22:41

I thought I did, but ok… My experience of OLD was, in general, very positive. I say was because I “downloaded” my partner from there many years ago and we are still happy together.

But going back to those times, I would say that I was probably picky or better said, a blocker (first uncalled for innuendo, bad vibe, or something that made me think they were not pleasant, I pressed the “block”button and forgot about it completely).

I managed to meet a lot of nice men, some were not what I was looking for, for some I was not what they were looking for, but in general they were all very nice, articulate, polite people and some of them became good friends (with no benefits, I must add, as I am a prude).

The worst experience that I had was a hyperactive university professor that made me feel as if I was having lunch with my poodle. There was also a businessman who unexpectedly turned into an arse on arrival and some lawyer who, without noticing, talked about his “ex” as his wife. But honestly, these were an absolute minority, probably about 5-10% of the people I met.

But again, I was not looking for mister perfectly handsome, with a huge salary or fantastic physique, because I am far from being that person myself. I just wanted a well rounded intelligent man, with good principles, a high level of culture, amazing level of conversation (that’s what I am picky at) and a good heart.

longwayoff · 04/01/2022 22:30

Picky is good, it's not an insult, you're choosing what you want. Why wouldnt you? You wouldn't settle for a pair of slippers if you wanted boots. Go for it.

1967buglet · 04/01/2022 22:25

Be picky. Took me a divorce and some soul searching to find the right one. My second marriage is happy, but I don’t wish the misery of the wrong un’ and a divorce on anybody.

Moonface123 · 04/01/2022 22:07

Being single can be wearing in the respect you feel you have to somehow justify it, at any age.
So much pressure to pair up, and if you are a strong independant woman/ widow like myself it can feel very patronising.
l personally would never think a single woman in her mid 30' s was picky, more likely astute. Younger women often do not have the life experiance to make the best choices, very naieve, l know l was.

thepeopleversuswork · 04/01/2022 21:21

“Picky” is code for miserable women saddled with appalling marriages who are privately desperately jealous of your freedom. Ignore it.

Starbrand · 04/01/2022 21:05

Thanks to all who have responded. Some really interesting views and opinions on here. @GrandmasCat you never did answer my question from yesterday regarding your most recent experience (if any) of internet dating. Waiting with baiting breath

OP posts:
GrandmasCat · 04/01/2022 18:19

I think being picky protects you from relationships you don't want.

And also from those you want, I am afraid. One thing is to be picky and another one to have unreasonable high expectations when compared with what the picky themselves can offer.

I think Joey Trivianni is the holder of the truth when it comes to dating: If you class yourself as an “8” you can date people ranging from 6 to 10, but if you are a “4” you should adjust your expectations and date some one ranging from 2 to 6. (All a joke obviously but with some element of truth).

CharSiu · 04/01/2022 17:00

An actual partnership with children and any financial mixing well everyone should be picky. I have found that some women who want children over everything else drop their standards when they get to mid thirties and behind., I didn’t especially want children and found having a partner a hinderance because you need to consider them in your plans. I feel very lucky that I managed to find anyone at all that I liked enough it as it was never going to be easy for me. I knew that and would have rather have remained single.

stayathomer · 04/01/2022 15:44

Some people are picky but then I'm considered overly relaxed and that irks some people as much eg I've learned not to drop into people's houses driving by, or not to assume different things. It doesn't really matter. I've had single friends tell me jokingly (but meaning it) 'I wouldn't put up with that!' about things that I find tiny in the grand scheme of things, and I'm sure by dh's friends' standards I'm not the catch of the year but it doesn't matter. We're happy together and complete each other (I know, it's ick but there we are!!!) If they want to be single fine, if they want specifications, fine too!!

crazyjinglist · 04/01/2022 14:07

Whatever one's own criteria for a partner, I don't see the point of criticising another woman for being too picky. She is presumably only as picky as she wants to be.

Accusations of pickiness presuppose that being in a relationship is the be-all and end-all and that we have to compromise in order to find a partner. But we don't have to. We can stay single. If a woman has decided that being single is better than being with 99.5% of the men available, then why is that any skin off anyone else's nose? Besides, she's probably right.

Movingsoon21 · 04/01/2022 12:25

I hate this comment! IMO women in general should be MORE picky than they currently are, so men realise they need to up their game if they want a life partner! Too many beautiful, kind, intelligent friends of mine have settled for cheaters/gamblers/ men who are just useless around the house and refuse to help with childcare. And none of the men are lookers either!

I think one issue is that in previous generations men could get away with being a bit crap as they tended to out-earn most women, so women were willing to settle to get access to the money needed for family life, whereas now women can earn a decent wage so don’t need crappy men any more and aren’t willing to put up with so much rubbish!

Lots of people told me I was too picky in my twenties as I was the last single one of my friends. But the truth is I would have been better off staying single than settling for any of the men I dated. Very happy that I waited until I found someone who was right, even though it meant marrying when older. And if I hadn’t got married I’d still be better off than some of my poor friends who now feel trapped in crap marriages.

NearlyAHoarder · 03/01/2022 23:09

@givethatbabyaname

I’ve accused someone of pickiness. She is single, 35, desperate to marry and move to the suburbs and have kids and get a dog. BUT, her list of requirements is ridiculous: specific skin colour; specific earning capacity; never divorced and definitely no kids; boy band good looks; funny; kind and generous; prepared to live in her town so she doesn’t have to move far from her parents; a year or max two older than her. She’s never met anyone like this before.

Isn’t it fair to suggest she’s being picky? Note, there’s nothing about compatibility here. This kind of person would likely NOT want someone as picky as her, or someone with as inflated an ego as hers. There’s also very little recognition of what she has to offer herself.

I think “picky” is being polite in this case.

I don't think it matters. If she's picky she's picky. That means that so far it hasn't been worth it to get in to a relationship.

I think being picky protects you from relationships you don't want.

Also, as women get older and the pool gets smaller, women have to date down. If they go on line they can't date their eQual (looks, health, energy, confidence, awareness, solvency)

The only way to get a relationship that sticks is to date down. Not in to that.

NearlyAHoarder · 03/01/2022 23:04

Women can't win. If they settled for a man they'd be accused of using him etc.

givethatbabyaname · 03/01/2022 23:02

I’ve accused someone of pickiness. She is single, 35, desperate to marry and move to the suburbs and have kids and get a dog. BUT, her list of requirements is ridiculous: specific skin colour; specific earning capacity; never divorced and definitely no kids; boy band good looks; funny; kind and generous; prepared to live in her town so she doesn’t have to move far from her parents; a year or max two older than her. She’s never met anyone like this before.

Isn’t it fair to suggest she’s being picky? Note, there’s nothing about compatibility here. This kind of person would likely NOT want someone as picky as her, or someone with as inflated an ego as hers. There’s also very little recognition of what she has to offer herself.

I think “picky” is being polite in this case.

DrSbaitso · 03/01/2022 22:52

@crazyjinglist

I do think women can be too picky. And unrealistic. I have a friend like it...she's constantly dismissing men for being bald/a bit tubby/wearing a horrible jumper. She'll dump them after the first date saying there's no attraction. But then dates men ten years younger who treat her horribly.

She's not too picky then. She's not picky enough if she dates men who treat her horribly!

Quite!

She should obviously lay off the arseholes, but if there was any interest on her part, she wouldn't be put off by a bad jumper or a few extra pounds (unless he really is physically repulsive to her, in which case there really is no point carrying on).

Maybe more people should give second dates a go, but I can see why they might rather spend their time on a new person who hasn't already left them feeling ambivalent or turned off as a first impression.

crazyjinglist · 03/01/2022 22:49

yes...I suppose I mean a lot of women are picky about entirely the wrong things and not picky enough about the things that really matter!

I guess, but the thing is... you feel how you feel about those trivial things. I agree they are trivial. But if you're simply not attracted to someone because they're a bit tubby or bald... then you're not attracted to them.

crazyjinglist · 03/01/2022 22:46

However extreme or unrealistic your criteria, it's you that's going to have to live with the partner who doesn't tick those boxes. There is no point in being with somebody who will annoy you more than they'll enhance your life. Better to stay single than put up with someone with whom you're not completely compatible imo.

JudesBiggestFan · 03/01/2022 22:44

@crazyjinglist yes...I suppose I mean a lot of women are picky about entirely the wrong things and not picky enough about the things that really matter! If the list was...is he kind? Is he solvent? Does he want a committed relationship? then everyone should be picky over those things!

crazyjinglist · 03/01/2022 22:40

I do think women can be too picky. And unrealistic. I have a friend like it...she's constantly dismissing men for being bald/a bit tubby/wearing a horrible jumper. She'll dump them after the first date saying there's no attraction. But then dates men ten years younger who treat her horribly.

She's not too picky then. She's not picky enough if she dates men who treat her horribly!

Swipe left for the next trending thread