Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect to be able to stay in the house?

66 replies

Mooey89 · 03/01/2022 08:52

I genuinely don’t know if I am being unreasonable.
STBXH and I split 6 months ago, due to his drinking, lying, and his u turn on wanting children.
I have a DS who is 8.
When we bought the house, I put down the deposit of 20k.
Since then with the house price increase the house has gone up considerably in value, but so has everywhere else. So even downsizing I would be doubling my mortgage for a small flat.

I asked DH to move out. He refused. He won’t even leave the marital bed. We don’t have a spare room.
He can’t afford to take over the mortgage. I can, but I wouldn’t be able to buy him out at this stage.
I really, really, don’t want DS to lose his home.

He’s now saying we need to sell and he will be living here until it’s sold.
I suggested he moved out, let me cover the mortgage, and in 2 years when I have been able to pay down some debt I will then be able to buy him out, but he says no.

I don’t know if I’m being wildly unrealistic? But I don’t want my son around an alcoholic anymore and I can’t carry on like this.

OP posts:
Jessie75 · 03/01/2022 10:18

@LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood
I have first hand experience of a court ordering a house sale, giving myself and a 17 year old and an 11 year old 14 days to vacate the house. And not only that the judge offering my ex legal advice on how to engage bailiffs if we didnt comply.
Theh were my ex husband’s children too btw.

Itsalmostanaccessory · 03/01/2022 10:07

He'll need his equity to move on. If you cant buy him out then you'll have to sell.

gogohm · 03/01/2022 10:07

A few factors will be taken into account if it goes to court including how long you were married, what assets you brought to the marriage each and current assets. A private agreement is always preferable, I think it's now compulsory to try mediation. Speak to a solicitor with experience in these circumstances

Gcandproud · 03/01/2022 10:06

@LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood

Please do not listen to people saying that the courts will not put your child’s security and comfort over the need for your ex to have a clean break. Putting the needs of your child first is exactly what the court will do. To do so is enshrined in law. Section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act stipulates that when considering the exercise of its discretion upon an application for a financial remedy, the first consideration is the welfare of any child of the family whilst still a minor.

That of course is not to say that your husband’s needs are not also considered. But they are not considered “first”.

If you have a plan to buy him out in a couple of years, supported by evidence and properly reasoned, then you have a decent chance of staying in the house. You will be able to discuss your proposal with your solicitor. Have a think about whether you can raise even a small lump sum sooner as part payment. And don’t assume it will be a 50/50 split. Depending on the circumstances (in particular your earning capacity v his earning capacity) the court has the power to vary the shares in which you own the house. 60/40 is quite common.

The bigger hurdle for you in my view is getting him to leave the family home in advance of concluding your financial remedy application. You can expect the process to take a year or longer if it goes to a final hearing and it’s hard to compel him to leave in advance of that.

The Courts can make occupation orders requiring a co-habitant to leave a home, but you have to have grounds for making such an application. Have a look at Occupation Orders and see if you think you have grounds. The court will not allow one party to use such an order as a device to gain advantage in the final money on divorce outcome. Judges are alert to this being used tactically and will only grant such orders if there are grounds for them.

I hope your solicitor gives you the advice you need swiftly. Good luck.

Yes, the child’s welfare is the first consideration. And I’d expect credit for the deposit in a short marriage (but might be quite little compared to increase in equity). BUT, from the facts it seems that OP’s earning capacity is actually higher than her DHs. She says she can afford the mortgage on her own whereas he can’t. So I can’t see an adjustment in favour of the OP on the basis of earning capacity - in fact the DH might try to argue the opposite. Very often, the family home needs to be sold and keeping someone from their share so that the other can stay in the home will only happen where there genuinely is no other viable option.

OP is the debt joint or sole? What was it taken out for?

AlDanvers · 03/01/2022 10:06

And how is op supposed to do that?

Remortgage? People do it all the time.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/01/2022 10:04

Legal advice, and then mediation and likely court. Expedite as much as possible.

The starting point is “the housing needs of the parties” (especially any children) followed by the other needs of the parties (especially children). I would think this would give you a good chance of retaining enough equity to stay in the house, as only you will have to care for your ds. If you can afford to buy out whatever smaller portion the courts give him.

I’m not a family lawyer though so I don’t know any of that for sure, just my experience and recalling adviCe I was given.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 03/01/2022 10:04

I don't blame him for not wanting to leave his home - if a woman was in his position she'd be advised to stay put too.

Definitely get legal advice but don't hold your breath that you'll be able to keep the house and force him out, especially if DS isn't a shared child.

Sirzy · 03/01/2022 10:02

Also if you do go down tne buy him out in two years method then make sure you check out occupational rent. Even if your paying the full mortgage you could end up liable to owe him money if the properly would get more rented out (likely if it has gone up in value) as your in theory renting half from him. Not saying it’s right but my partner got caught out by the occupational rent rules big time

knittingaddict · 03/01/2022 09:58

@DomPom47

Could you not take out equity in the house and give to him? Good luck 💐
And how is op supposed to do that?

Op, I think you are being a bit unrealistic. There is a definite move towards a clean break in divorce and usually one partner is bought out of the marital home or it's sold and the equity split.

The number of shared children and the length of the marriage has an impact on how assets are split. Sometimes the years living together can count towards the length of the relationship, but that very much depends on circumstances.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 03/01/2022 09:54

Please do not listen to people saying that the courts will not put your child’s security and comfort over the need for your ex to have a clean break. Putting the needs of your child first is exactly what the court will do. To do so is enshrined in law. Section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act stipulates that when considering the exercise of its discretion upon an application for a financial remedy, the first consideration is the welfare of any child of the family whilst still a minor.

That of course is not to say that your husband’s needs are not also considered. But they are not considered “first”.

If you have a plan to buy him out in a couple of years, supported by evidence and properly reasoned, then you have a decent chance of staying in the house. You will be able to discuss your proposal with your solicitor. Have a think about whether you can raise even a small lump sum sooner as part payment. And don’t assume it will be a 50/50 split. Depending on the circumstances (in particular your earning capacity v his earning capacity) the court has the power to vary the shares in which you own the house. 60/40 is quite common.

The bigger hurdle for you in my view is getting him to leave the family home in advance of concluding your financial remedy application. You can expect the process to take a year or longer if it goes to a final hearing and it’s hard to compel him to leave in advance of that.

The Courts can make occupation orders requiring a co-habitant to leave a home, but you have to have grounds for making such an application. Have a look at Occupation Orders and see if you think you have grounds. The court will not allow one party to use such an order as a device to gain advantage in the final money on divorce outcome. Judges are alert to this being used tactically and will only grant such orders if there are grounds for them.

I hope your solicitor gives you the advice you need swiftly. Good luck.

Letitsnoooow · 03/01/2022 09:48

I think you have to start getting your head round the idea of moving out and making a fresh start for you and your son and look at the advantages. I had to seriously downsize after divorce with two small children and it wasn’t the end of the world.

DomPom47 · 03/01/2022 09:45

Could you not take out equity in the house and give to him? Good luck 💐

Jellycatspyjamas · 03/01/2022 09:44

Where are you thinking he’ll go if he leaves? If he doesn’t have the money to find somewhere to rent, buy furniture etc he has little choice but to stay until he can get funds together to go. If it were you leaving what would you consider fair? What’s the rental market like where you are, are there suitable properties he could move to short term if he had the money?

Marriage protects both parties legally in the event of a split, it’s his house too and he has as much right to stay there as you do which means you need to negotiate. You taking over the mortgage is fine, except he’s entitled to half the equity in the house and will need this to start over so how are you going to pay that?

It would be great if they would just leave when we’re done with the marriage, but realistically, and reasonably, that’s unfair. You have my sympathy, I’m in a similar position and it’s very hard but you need to agree a plan with him to separate - you can’t just kick him out of his own home.

Can you think about how it might work for you both living together in the short to medium term? If he won’t leave the marital bedroom, can you sleep wherever you’re expecting him to sleep? Can you start to separate finances - eg a common pot for household expenses and a separate account for wages, child benefits etc so you each have control of your money outside of running the house?

CheshireKitten123 · 03/01/2022 09:43

@CloseYourEyesAndSee

Get legal advice
This is your best option. ^
SpongeBobJudgeyPants · 03/01/2022 09:42

In the meantime find a paper trail of the 20K deposit you put down. You may need it at some point.

Gcandproud · 03/01/2022 09:33

[quote Jessie75]@THisbackwithavengeance no it will not cost him thousands, the court will award his costs against her if she doesnt cooperate with the division of assets[/quote]
Costs order are rare in the family court and in nearly all cases each party pays their own costs. Especially so if the case settles rather than being determined by a judge at final hearing. Unless this house is now worth millions (I’m guessing you bought it for 200k as the deposit was 20k) or there are other huge assets, if they went to court, the majority of the equity would be swallowed by legal costs.

Gcandproud · 03/01/2022 09:30

The deposit will not be ring-fenced unless you had a prenup but short childless marriages mean you are more likely to get credit for higher contributions and therefore an unequal split of assets.

The first consideration in splitting assets will be the welfare of any child of the family which will likely include your DS if he has been treated as a child of the family, even though he is not your ex’s child. But if you can move now, albeit to a flat, your DS’s needs would be met so it doesn’t sound like a case where the children’s welfare will be determinative. Your DH is only going to be made to wait for his share if it is necessary (ie that you wouldn’t be able to get another place at the moment so the only option is staying put).

I don’t know what other assets there are but if the house is the main one and the bulk of the equity is from the increase in property prices over the past few years, I’d expect him to be entitled to half the increase during the marriage with you probably being credited for providing the deposit (on basis of fairly short marriage, no joint kids, similar earning capacity and ages etc). But you’d need specific legal advice on that because there are many factors at play.

Sirzy · 03/01/2022 09:27

You may have to sell but you may alsopp0 be entitled to a bigger share of the equity because you have a child to house.

It doesn’t sound like the child is his though so he will have very little bearing on the outcome.

Jessie75 · 03/01/2022 09:26

@THisbackwithavengeance no it will not cost him thousands, the court will award his costs against her if she doesnt cooperate with the division of assets

Mooey89 · 03/01/2022 09:24

Thank you everyone. I think I needed the reality check. Booking legal advice and valuations this week.
Deep breath

OP posts:
THisbackwithavengeance · 03/01/2022 09:23

Legal advice or mediation.

You may have to sell but you may alsopp0 be entitled to a bigger share of the equity because you have a child to house.

Or you can point out to him that if lawyers/court are involved it will cost him thousands and you will go after his pension. Be reasonable. He's entitled not to be homeless or in a shit bedsit just as you are. Sometimes you just have to let reason sink in and that can take time.

If you can stick it out for a while, he will probably find a new woman who will not be impressed by him still living at home with his wife and that will be a carrot rather than a stick to shift his arse.

Malibuismysecrethome · 03/01/2022 09:22

If the house has gone up significantly they so has the equity. Sorry but you need to sell and take your original deposit and your share.

Beautiful3 · 03/01/2022 09:21

I'd seek legal advice. I don't think you can make him leave, as you're both married and he's on the mortgage. I think personally, selling it and moving out might be better, to get rid of him.

Autumndays123 · 03/01/2022 09:20

Surely if you are married and bought the house whilst married then he is entitled to 50%? I'm sure if roles were reversed and it was he who put the deposit down MN would be telling you to demand your fair share. You have no right to force him to leave the home, so unless he goes of his own free will, you need to sell up and split the equity

Aprilx · 03/01/2022 09:20

@Aderyn21

I hope you had your deposit ring fenced. Presuming your child isn't his, and that being the case he has no incentive to let you remain in the house. If your child is his then you might be able to make him wait for a sale. Get legal advice asap and in the meantime get together all paperwork which shows who paid for what and all financial assets such as pensions.
I think you are underestimating the legal importance of marriage.

“Ring fencing” assets is really not a thing within marriage.