Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect to be able to stay in the house?

66 replies

Mooey89 · 03/01/2022 08:52

I genuinely don’t know if I am being unreasonable.
STBXH and I split 6 months ago, due to his drinking, lying, and his u turn on wanting children.
I have a DS who is 8.
When we bought the house, I put down the deposit of 20k.
Since then with the house price increase the house has gone up considerably in value, but so has everywhere else. So even downsizing I would be doubling my mortgage for a small flat.

I asked DH to move out. He refused. He won’t even leave the marital bed. We don’t have a spare room.
He can’t afford to take over the mortgage. I can, but I wouldn’t be able to buy him out at this stage.
I really, really, don’t want DS to lose his home.

He’s now saying we need to sell and he will be living here until it’s sold.
I suggested he moved out, let me cover the mortgage, and in 2 years when I have been able to pay down some debt I will then be able to buy him out, but he says no.

I don’t know if I’m being wildly unrealistic? But I don’t want my son around an alcoholic anymore and I can’t carry on like this.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AskingforaBaskin · 03/01/2022 19:55

If DS is not his then he does not unfortunately have to take his housing into account. Nor will he be expected to :(

Also the court will not remove him from the home without good reason or unless he has suitable accommodation. They will not intentionally make him homeless.
I am sorry. It can not have been easy to be married to him and have to deal with this.

Jessie75 · 03/01/2022 13:48

@CowMarshland Did you mean the person that has caused the relationship to break up i.e. if somebody’s unfaithful they get out, if somebody is an alcoholic and the other person cannot possibly live with them they get out, that’s what’s caused the relationship breakdown not the person who initiates it on the grounds of the other persons behaviour ?

CharlotteRose90 · 03/01/2022 13:39

You need to sell and divide the house. You don’t get to keep the house yourself when he has money in it. Go see a solicitor and put it on the market. You should hopefully both get enough to move on.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 03/01/2022 13:35

It is a very good job CowMarshland that your view of who should move out upon dissolution of a marriage is only your opinion and not, in fact, the law. Were it the law, abused and vulnerable women all over the country, having found the strength to separate, would be habitually forced from their homes. Our system is far from perfect (as the experiences many on this site and even on this thread have attested to), but at least it is not so punitive as that.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 03/01/2022 13:08

@CowMarshland

For me I think the person who ended the relationship should be the one that lives out.

If house is in my name (say we got together and they lived in my home) and mortgage then paid by both then I’d expect to pay other person a reasonable sum for them to leave.
If joint mortgage I’d expect home to be sold or the other person bought out.

This idea has the potential to be so dangerous Shock

It means women who experience abuse and domestic violence will end up being even more terrified to leave because they'll end up homeless as well as on their own with their DC.

Exasperatedhousehunter · 03/01/2022 13:06

@CowMarshland

For me I think the person who ended the relationship should be the one that lives out.

If house is in my name (say we got together and they lived in my home) and mortgage then paid by both then I’d expect to pay other person a reasonable sum for them to leave.
If joint mortgage I’d expect home to be sold or the other person bought out.

That’s ridiculous. So you’d expect a woman who ended the relationship due to infidelity or abuse to leave the home just because she was the one to break it off? Thankfully there is no such rule.
CowMarshland · 03/01/2022 13:04

For me I think the person who ended the relationship should be the one that lives out.

If house is in my name (say we got together and they lived in my home) and mortgage then paid by both then I’d expect to pay other person a reasonable sum for them to leave.
If joint mortgage I’d expect home to be sold or the other person bought out.

Ohshittt · 03/01/2022 12:46

PP have given more practical advice but I just wanted to say I absolutely understand you don't want you and your son to lose your home but please just think what you will gain from it, freedom from a man making your life a misery, a fresh start in a home just for you and DS. I imagine this will be a rough ride but you can handle it and it will be worth it 💕.

llansannan22 · 03/01/2022 12:31

You are doing the right thing getting legal advice.

colourfulpuddles · 03/01/2022 12:28

Why do you think you get a right to stay in the house anymore than he does? The house should be sold.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 03/01/2022 12:26

I take the view (from what I have read; acknowledging that more information mighy impact my opinion) that the OP’s son fulfils the definition of “child of the family” as prescribed by the Matrimonial Causes Act.

GCAndProud · 03/01/2022 12:25

[quote timeisnotaline]@LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood this child is not ‘of the family’ though, it’s just the ops? The ex isn’t the dad so can’t be expected legally to adjust his split to support the child?[/quote]
It would be if the child has lived with the couple and been treated as a child of the family. Essentially if in his role as stepfather has assumed responsibility for the OP’s DS and treated him as a child of the family, DS would qualify. It wouldn’t cover if eg the DS actually lives with his other parent and just visits/stays over with OP and DH but would cover a situation where DS’s permanent home was with OP and DH. It’s a question of fact but I’d have thought it would apply here.

timeisnotaline · 03/01/2022 12:00

@LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood this child is not ‘of the family’ though, it’s just the ops? The ex isn’t the dad so can’t be expected legally to adjust his split to support the child?

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 03/01/2022 11:55

I am very sorry indeed Jessie75 that you have had such a difficult time and that things are currently no better for you.

Jessie75 · 03/01/2022 11:20

@LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood
Well of course they haven’t got better, things have got worse as could be expected under the circumstances. I’m honestly not snapping at you I’m really not and please don’t take it in that light but what I am saying is once lawyers get involved it’s like an electricity meter just constantly running both sides, digging in because you believe youve spent £5,000 coming this far so another £5,000 to finish things off and youre told a solicitor cant just put down their pen as you might want them to and just stop, professionally speaking the judge will be expecting the barrister to be there, all the time its your costs rising.

And somebody always loses and it’s not always who you expect it to be .

Gcandproud · 03/01/2022 11:05

[quote LakieLady]@GCAndProud, your £30k in fees is almost exactly what it cost my ex to get 47.5% of the equity in a home I'd owned solely for years before I met him!

The stupid thing was, I'd already offered him £72k and would have gone to £80k, but he turned it down flat, twice (once prior to proceedings, once at mediation). He ended up getting £97.5k, but it cost him the best part of £30k to get it, so was no better off overall.[/quote]
He sounds like a bit of an idiot. Unless the assets are in the millions or the other party is not offering anything that is remotely reasonable (eg if you’d offered him 5k or something), it’s not worth spending the money on a final hearing. In some cases, there is v little left once legal costs are accounted for.

2Gen · 03/01/2022 11:05

@Aprilx

You need to keep focusing on what is legal rather than what feels fair / moral etc. And no, if he doesn’t agree to go it would be very difficult to remove him from the marital home, him drinking, lying and doing a u turn on wanting children are not legal grounds to get him out.

I take it from your wording that your child is not his so you have not been together less than eight years? A “short” marriage will mean it is less likely that assets will be split 50:50. But yes as mentioned, you need legal advice to determine the best way to proceed. I suspect that selling the house is a real possibility.

About him deciding he doesn't want children, I wonder could you get an anullment on those grounds? I know for us Catholics, the openess to children is a prerequisite for a valid marriage so one party's refusal is grounds for an anullment in the eyes of the Church, but I'm not sure if it is in British Law. It might be an idea to find out? Again, I would echo other posters and urge you to seek legal advice which I see you have arranged.
StarryNightSparkles · 03/01/2022 11:02

Sorry op I have no advice on the mortgage except to seek legal advice. 6 months is a long time to still be living with someone that you have split up with especially sharing a bed. If I were you then I would buy a blow up bed for in the sitting room for him or you to sleep on, or could you sleep in your son's room. I would close all joint bank accounts or anything else linked to him and set up my own bank account etc. I would start living independently from him and not tell him any of my business.

I hope things get better for you and your son soon 💐

2Gen · 03/01/2022 10:57

Of course YANBU, not at all! You STBXH is the unreasonable one and alcoholics usually are VU and very selfish!
If I were you, I seek out legal advice from a solicitor. You could also ask Women's Aid I think?
I'm really sorry you and your child are being put through this OP! Please let us know how you get on?

LakieLady · 03/01/2022 10:50

@GCAndProud, your £30k in fees is almost exactly what it cost my ex to get 47.5% of the equity in a home I'd owned solely for years before I met him!

The stupid thing was, I'd already offered him £72k and would have gone to £80k, but he turned it down flat, twice (once prior to proceedings, once at mediation). He ended up getting £97.5k, but it cost him the best part of £30k to get it, so was no better off overall.

GCAndProud · 03/01/2022 10:38

OP, if you go to court and want a judge to determine the outcome (it has to go to a final hearing for this), an estimate of costs if you are legally represented would be around £30,000 plus VAT and that’s pretty conservative. Your DH would likely incur the same if he got representation. You can represent yourself of course but that won’t be a pleasant experience and it will probably take at least a year until you have a final order during which time he will still be living with you. So try to settle without court proceedings if possible and listen v carefully to any legal advice you obtain and don’t seek to push for something unrealistic. If your solicitor says that sale is likely, listen to that. Try to encourage your ex to get legal advice too, so that he isn’t being unrealistic either.
It’s very hard to give advice as to what will happen for definite so your solicitor will probably say that this is what might happen but that they don’t know for sure. This is because the judge has a discretion so you can never know for sure. The only way to find out for sure is to go to a final hearing but the expense and delay in that means that for most, it’s really not worth it.

Finally, beware of only using free appointments from firms as they are often short and don’t really give you much clarity on your position. Instead, ask if your local firms do a fixed fee initial consultation, which will be much more thorough and should also provide you with a follow-up advice letter setting out your options. You can then take stock and consider your options. Go to the consultation with as full details as possible of the following:
-value of family home - good to have 2 or 3 valuations for better accuracy

-yours and DH’s earnings
-savings
-debts
-pensions (ideally you’d get a CETV but this might take a while)
-outgoings
-an idea of what you’d need to rehouse, ie costs of homes in your area and an idea of how much the bank would allow you to borrow.

Having all of these will give the solicitor a much clearer picture from which to advise. Much better than going to the meeting and saying that you don’t really know what the assets are worth.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 03/01/2022 10:35

That sounds dreadful for you and the children Jessie75. I hope things are improved now.

I acknowledge that each case is very fact specific. In my 25 years of professional practice I have seen a whole range of outcomes. Very little is guaranteed. But I do think it is important that the OP knows that her proposal is worth exploration. It is the sort of arrangement I would be looking at with great attention were she a client of mine. It doesn’t sound to me that it is unrealistic (from the little I can glean from the post). And it is on all fours with the outcomes many of my clients have achieved. The important thing is that the OP gets a chance to explore her proposal in detail with her solicitor and that she is not bullied by her ex or misled by well meaning (but wrong) advice that her staying in the house is not even within the wide range of possibilities.

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/01/2022 10:25

You’ll feel much better when you get legal advice

They should also help you try and negotiate, eg would he agree to a deferred sale if you helped cover his rent in the meantime, or he got a bit more in 2 years.

If he takes the (reasonable) view he wants the money now, then also talk to an FA to see if you can find a way to buy him out.

AlDanvers · 03/01/2022 10:25

I think people often forget that a child doesn't need housing in the home they are in. So their housing needs can be met and the family be sold.

Its not one or the other.

Jessie75 · 03/01/2022 10:20

@LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood The judge is exact words were if you can afford to have paid the mortgage for the last five years on your own in this house you can afford to rent end of story that is the children’s housing needs met as far as the court is concerned.

Never mind that we were mid pandemic and there were no houses to rent, there were no removal companies available, storage places were booked to capacity.

Swipe left for the next trending thread