Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Temporarily moving for Primary admissions

135 replies

Humdingledom · 03/01/2022 05:20

So I know lots of people do this but can’t help but think it’s really fucking cheeky

We are lucky enough to live in the catchment of the most oversubscribed school in the city. The family of DCs friend at school left their house they own and rented very close to the school so their DC got a guaranteed place at the primary school, and now DC has been there a term they are moving back to the house the own in a different area. There are easily 5 primary schools between here and where they live, with some
of them also “Outstanding” but ours does have a certain reputation.

I know other families temporarily moved in with the grandparents to be closer in the catchment and have now moved back outside the area or are planning to.

Like I said I know lots do it but it’s very annoying when friends that actually live on the catchment border missed out for places at the school when they had the option of two schools.

Let’s be clear I’m definitely not being snobby, I think it’s actually really rude of people who have luxury of moving temporarily when there’s people closer who maybe can’t afford to do that missing out!

OP posts:
Muchtoomuchtodo · 03/01/2022 14:33

@Humdingledom please report them. I don’t know whether their dc will lose their place but it’ll send a strong message to others considering doing the same.

Highfivemum · 03/01/2022 14:25

I based my previous answer on experience.
I suppose each LA will act differently. When my old work colleague reported to LA about this happening they said as the people had lived at that address ( temp 3 months rental) they had not acted illegal and they could do nothing.

HeyFloof · 03/01/2022 13:56

Two kids in my DCs class got places they weren't entitled to. They were reported and investigated but ultimately could provide the proof of council tax bill being in their name even though it was common knowledge they don't live in that address. The council don't care if proof is provided. Two other children who live locally missed out because of them.

DadOnIce · 03/01/2022 13:29

Than those in non-grotty areas, that should read. Sorry, that doesn't make sense otherwise.

DadOnIce · 03/01/2022 13:27

Whenever there is a thread about moving to get into a decent school, the suggestion always comes up that parents should 'put their energies' instead into campaigning to improve the 'bad' school in their locality. This rather misses the point that they have no interest in doing this, and probably not much in the way of 'energies' either.

Mine are way past primary school age now, but I'm thinking of some of the poorer schools in our city and what it would take to get them up to the standard of those in the better areas, and at the end of the day, I can't think of any solution that would work, short of picking up the exact same school with the exact same teachers and resources and depositing it in a more leafy postcode.

Some schools do change and turn around long term, but this usually takes longer than the primary school life of one child (7 years), so parents would be investing their energies in improving the school for future children, not their own.

And actually, anyway, a lot of schools in more difficult areas can be better resourced and equipped and have more dedicated staff than those in grotty areas, and yet still under-perform.

Twinkleylight · 03/01/2022 13:22

@schooladmission

Hello - I have NC for this as my answer will probably out me for where I work.

I work in school admissions in a London borough with some very sought after very naice middle class schools that people lie and cheat to get in to so we are vigilant with address checks - the cost of renting a place for a year can be cheaper than paying for 3 kids to attend the private schools in our area.

If OP was to report this case to us, it would fall foul of our admissions rules - we state that where a family own a property and are living in a rented property, we will calculate the admissions from the owned property - unless the family have lived away from the owned property for 3 years or more (or have never lived in it because they are landlords). We have made a few exceptions when supported with supporting evidence as to why family have been placed in this position. We will not accept, bad housing market etc as a reason. People will not realise that that they are breaking our rules (because the didn't read the admission arrangements) and will admit that they intend to buy further from the school one they have secured a place for the oldest child.

In this case as the child has been attending for a full term, it is very unlikely that the place would be withdrawn as the child has settled - but we would remove sibling priority for any subsequent siblings - thereby almost guaranteeing that they will not be offered a place if they are applying from the address they have just moved back to.

@Highfivemum
OnceuponaRainbow18 · 03/01/2022 13:16

@Highfivemum

That is wrong, it’s fraudulent and can be investigated

Highfivemum · 03/01/2022 13:07

Nothing will be done if reported as they DID live in the area on application date. Council would not have the time or resources to peruse it. There job os for all children to get a school place. Which they have.
This thing is common. We all will know a parent who did this. Money does talk sadly.

Ionlydomassiveones · 03/01/2022 12:43

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

KimmyKimdoo · 03/01/2022 12:38

Every child equally deserves a good education. The current system is not good enough and I can’t really blame parents who try to make the best for the children. It’s the system of education that needs sorting. No schools should be left underperforming.

KimmyKimdoo · 03/01/2022 12:37

@Shelby2010 what sort of campaigning do you think would make any real difference to a crap local school? I mean, realistically speaking, it would take a LOT of money to improve some schools and that’s something that can’t be done by parents. How many parents can afford to pay for new teachers/ better training/ improved facilities?

schooladmission · 03/01/2022 12:35

Hello - I have NC for this as my answer will probably out me for where I work.

I work in school admissions in a London borough with some very sought after very naice middle class schools that people lie and cheat to get in to so we are vigilant with address checks - the cost of renting a place for a year can be cheaper than paying for 3 kids to attend the private schools in our area.

If OP was to report this case to us, it would fall foul of our admissions rules - we state that where a family own a property and are living in a rented property, we will calculate the admissions from the owned property - unless the family have lived away from the owned property for 3 years or more (or have never lived in it because they are landlords). We have made a few exceptions when supported with supporting evidence as to why family have been placed in this position. We will not accept, bad housing market etc as a reason. People will not realise that that they are breaking our rules (because the didn't read the admission arrangements) and will admit that they intend to buy further from the school one they have secured a place for the oldest child.

In this case as the child has been attending for a full term, it is very unlikely that the place would be withdrawn as the child has settled - but we would remove sibling priority for any subsequent siblings - thereby almost guaranteeing that they will not be offered a place if they are applying from the address they have just moved back to.

Shelby2010 · 03/01/2022 12:27

It would be better all round if the parents put that time, money and energy into campaigning for improvements to their local schools. However it is understandable that they want to put their kids first.

LethargicActress · 03/01/2022 12:11

@RoomOfRequirement

Until the government ensures every child has access to the same, high level of education I don't blame the parents one bit.

The educational disparities of people who live in, usually, lower income areas is an embarrassment and absolute travesty.

I agree with this. The situation with schools is a great example of where we should hate the game, not the players.

While what these parents have done is questionable, but they shouldn’t have found themselves in the position where their child won’t get as good an education because of where they live in the first place.

I know some people say it takes away a place from children who love closer, but why should the child who lives closer have an advantage anyway? All children should have equal access to good schools.

CovidCorvid · 03/01/2022 12:10

I couldn’t stay friends with someone who did this. Somewhere there’s a kid who’s missed out on a place due to these people.

Happened to us/dd, she didn’t get a place at the local outstanding school when normally we’re in catchment. Multiple people from the very posh town 15 miles up the road rent a crummy terrace near the school. Most didn’t even move there. They’d pay a years rent, pay council tax and some utility bills and that was enough. The headmaster even told a friend at an open evening to do this. 🤷‍♀️

CruCru · 03/01/2022 12:07

The thing about this is, isn't it really awkward when the parents come to the induction evening and get chatting to the other parents? Conversations along the lines of "Oh yes, we live on Next-door Avenue" "Oh wow! So we do we! We've never seen you before - what number do you live at?" There's no sensible answer to that.

I think a couple of the south London boroughs removed the sibling priority policy because of this.

dottiedodah · 03/01/2022 12:03

Reporting them seems rather harsh to me .The child will suffer immensely if moved to another School surely .I get what you mean about unfairness ,but so much in School Admissions is unfair! As PP upthread says ,Church Schools are always oversubscribed .Many people join that Church ,get DC baptised there .Get them in and their attendance fades away. Another high achieving Grammar School in our area, had pupils from 20 miles away taken in by their parents who shared the drive in!There was a case in School in the next town where parents had done this.If I remember correctly they were fined,but their children were allowed to stay at the School

KimmyKimdoo · 03/01/2022 11:51

But why should the places in the better school only benefit those who can afford the more expensive area? I don’t blame parents who do this.

llansannan22 · 03/01/2022 11:51

I think it is obtaining something by deception. I'm not sure what can be done about it. Any law with penalties worth having would never be enforced.

JammyRedRooo · 03/01/2022 11:48

I know a family that rented a tiny house in the catchment of an Outstanding local school then once the DC was admitted they bought in a cheaper area with a less good school. That was always the plan - they couldn't afford to buy anywhere suitable in area A but didnt want their kids to suffer schooling wise.

Unfortunately while a good education is such a postcode lottery people will do these things. I would leave it alone.

IglesiasPiggl · 03/01/2022 11:22

You need to check the rules for your council. I don't think you can get annoyed about people doing whatever it takes to get the best school places within the rules, but if they have actually broken them, then that's a different matter. It's usually quite hard to get away with common fraudulent applications, so perhaps what they did is permissable in your area?

TeachesOfPeaches · 03/01/2022 11:21

In my borough they don't check every single address and will only investigate if reported.

CSJobseeker · 03/01/2022 11:15

@Aroundtheworldin80moves

You can live half a mile in one direction from our local secondary and not get a place, but can from five miles in the other direction.

Which is actually a lot fairer than it sounds as the catchment takes in outlying villages, which aren't near any schools, but there's another school less than a mile away.

What on earth has that got to do with the OP?
CSJobseeker · 03/01/2022 11:14

@Chasingaftermidnight

It isn’t just cheeky - depending on exactly what they’ve done it’s potentially fraudulent and criminal.
I agree with this. And I'd report them - their child having a place means another child (who lives nearer) misses out as a direct consequence.
OnceuponaRainbow18 · 03/01/2022 11:14

It’s fraudulent and illegal. I would report and the place can be taken away

Swipe left for the next trending thread