Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Temporarily moving for Primary admissions

135 replies

Humdingledom · 03/01/2022 05:20

So I know lots of people do this but can’t help but think it’s really fucking cheeky

We are lucky enough to live in the catchment of the most oversubscribed school in the city. The family of DCs friend at school left their house they own and rented very close to the school so their DC got a guaranteed place at the primary school, and now DC has been there a term they are moving back to the house the own in a different area. There are easily 5 primary schools between here and where they live, with some
of them also “Outstanding” but ours does have a certain reputation.

I know other families temporarily moved in with the grandparents to be closer in the catchment and have now moved back outside the area or are planning to.

Like I said I know lots do it but it’s very annoying when friends that actually live on the catchment border missed out for places at the school when they had the option of two schools.

Let’s be clear I’m definitely not being snobby, I think it’s actually really rude of people who have luxury of moving temporarily when there’s people closer who maybe can’t afford to do that missing out!

OP posts:
BertieQueen · 04/01/2022 16:11

When my son was starting school a few years back we applied for the local school which was at the bottom of our road and we could see from our windows. The school is outstanding and very well known in the area - many parents lied about where they lived and rented out different properties to get their kids in. We didn’t get a place Angry we was sent to another outstanding school but further away. We had to drive past the school we wanted to get to the school we had been allocated, sitting in traffic with the other parents who had lied passing us on the other side of the road coming from the area they really lived in.

Many people who also had the same happen to them appealed and reported the ones who had moved to secure their place but nothing was ever done about it.

ElftonWednesday · 04/01/2022 16:03

Some people own several homes, or develop properties and move on regularly. I wonder how they work it out?

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 04/01/2022 07:28

@HiJenny35

Quite simply, you are wrong

BuanoKubiamVej · 04/01/2022 07:25

@HiJenny35 that's not true. The exact wording will be different in each LEA but the Haringey protocol mentions this scenario specifically: "A family rents a property, or lives with relatives temporarily, and uses this address
in order to gain a school place, whilst retaining ownership of an alternative property. In cases such as this, the property which is still owned by the family would normally be considered as the appropriate address to assess admission from, even if this property is not currently being occupied by the family."

In most LEAs a further-away property that is owned by the parents of the child must have been sold and contracts exchanged for that further away address not to be used. Being on the market for sale or rented out on a standard shorthold tenancy is insufficient because it would be too easy to revert back there once the school place was secured.

HiJenny35 · 04/01/2022 00:28

There's nothing to report, the place will not be removed from them because they haven't broken the rules, they made the property in the catchment their main residence for the alloted allocation period and moved after the place was offered. The checks in place check council tax etc this would have been in place as they were living there. Annoying yes, morally wrong yes, against the rules no so there's nothing you can do, as for reporting to the school, (unless it's one of the academy groups that run their own intake which are very few most use the council services) they have nothing to do with place allocation and cannot do anything, you would need to report to the borough but like I say they've not crossed any official lines.

JimmyGrimble · 04/01/2022 00:26

Disgusting behaviour. People like this are willing to go to any lengths to game the system to get a little bit more privilege for their children. They are directly stealing a place from another child.

Soberiscoolnow · 03/01/2022 23:46

@KrakowDawn

O get where you are coming from but generally there is a mixture of people in many areas if they only have state schools

Ours is a nice village where we get this a lot. We saved and saved and saved to finally be able to move to a desirable are with good schools and did it honestly. We live on the border of two catchment areas with two good schools - one school is two miles away but we fall on the catchment line. The other is ten miles away but in the other catchment area. DC had to go to the school more far away because of people doing exactly what the lady on the OP has done. We are lucky they are both nice schools and it’s worked out so it’s not so much of an issue but for people who have limited transport for example and would rely on the closest school surely you can see how it’s not fair

If they have enough money to pay a mortgage and rent in an expensive area they why can they not move? If they have the sort of money to do this then the place they actually live can’t be so bad either? Or get over themselves and choose another good school. One that’s closer to where they actually live.

PrincessNutella · 03/01/2022 23:32

Yes, it is fraudulent.

KrakowDawn · 03/01/2022 23:30

Where DD was born, it was actually cheaper to send her to fee-paying primary than it was for us to move into catchment for our closest primary school.

KrakowDawn · 03/01/2022 23:28

@Soberiscoolnow

‘I’ve got money so I can play the system, disregard the rules, and fuck everyone else’
Just like the people who can afford housing in catchment for outstanding schools then?
BuanoKubiamVej · 03/01/2022 23:18

YABU for being pissed off about it if you aren't reporting it. Choosing not to report it is collaborating in the deception and fraud so you're being hypocritical to moan about it. If it's wrong then it needs reporting. If you are choosing not to report then you are accepting that it's ok.

KimmyKimdoo · 03/01/2022 23:16

@FortySeven Why is it awful that someone wanted their child to go to an outstanding state school? Surely we’d all choose that if we could? I can’t see the issue.

mumda · 03/01/2022 23:12

Side effect: All the parents in cars picking kids up because they live too far away to walk?

Rubyupbeat · 03/01/2022 23:11

I would have done the same if mine had gone to a state primary.

FortySeven · 03/01/2022 22:41

It’s awful. One of the mums at school is always bleating about how she’d never dream of sending her kids to a fee-paying school because private education is immoral, yet she openly admits to moving into her BTL flat in the posh part of town for a year to get her son into the “outstanding” secondary Hmm

Kinneddar · 03/01/2022 22:36

The village I stay in has one of the top performing state schools in the country. People have actually rented in the village purely to have an address within the catchment area. They haven't lived there just paid the rent & registered for council tax

Absolute madness

HikingforScenery · 03/01/2022 22:32

@Soberiscoolnow

we all want the best for our children

Yes but at the expense of others? If it’s really about affordability - lots of people who are just “average” couldn’t afford to rent a house and pay an existing mortgage too, two council tax bills and all the other costs. But they might live on the edge of the catchment, still missing out of the school is very oversubscribed.

If the other school was shit I’d get it but from the sounds of it there’s a lot of good alternatives

If it’s oversubscribed, every child who is admitted is done so “at the expense of someone else”?
Mrsfrumble · 03/01/2022 21:17

Where I live you need to provide proof of 12 months rental.

Do you know what happens to people who have moved for legitimate / unavoidable reasons in the past 12 months? It seems very unfair that their children should be placed at the bottom of the admissions pile, especially as renters often have little control over if and when they have to move. I wonder if it might count as a form of discrimination?

Thank goodness that wasn’t the case in our borough when we were applying for DD’s reception place; we’d have been screwed as we’d only arrived in the country 4 months previously!

Soberiscoolnow · 03/01/2022 21:16

we all want the best for our children

Yes but at the expense of others? If it’s really about affordability - lots of people who are just “average” couldn’t afford to rent a house and pay an existing mortgage too, two council tax bills and all the other costs. But they might live on the edge of the catchment, still missing out of the school is very oversubscribed.

If the other school was shit I’d get it but from the sounds of it there’s a lot of good alternatives

HikingforScenery · 03/01/2022 21:04

I can’t be bothered with this tbh. Everyone in a city will be paying council tax, income tax, etc etc and yet some schools are way better than others.
Until there is better ( or actual) equality in the education system, this will continue to happen.
Who wants to move/ rent for the sake of it.

Yes, your parents were privileged enough to be able to buy a house just before you had to attend this school.
Maybe these parents can’t afford to do that.
It’s not something I would do but I don’t blame them at all. We all want the best for our children.

Meh 😑

Soberiscoolnow · 03/01/2022 20:21

‘I’ve got money so I can play the system, disregard the rules, and fuck everyone else’

funinthesun19 · 03/01/2022 17:37

This stuff really annoys me.
Out of interest, what actually happens when parents are reported for this and it’s all proved correct that they fraudulently got their child a school place? Do they get fined/ does their child lose their place? Bad for the child, but then another child living close by could be going to that school instead.

Soontobe60 · 03/01/2022 16:50

@Humdingledom

I’m not reporting anyone but it is common knowledge among the parents so maybe someone else will.
Well stop moaning about it then! They’ve committed fraud. Some other families who genuinely live in the catchment but not near enough may have missed out on a place, and have to spend a fortune getting their child to a school much further away.
ufucoffee · 03/01/2022 16:48

@Highfivemum

I based my previous answer on experience. I suppose each LA will act differently. When my old work colleague reported to LA about this happening they said as the people had lived at that address ( temp 3 months rental) they had not acted illegal and they could do nothing.
Where I live you need to provide proof of 12 months rental.
vivainsomnia · 03/01/2022 14:40

All children should have equal access to good schools
So who gets the places in the poor schools?

Sadly, it's not even the case of very bad Vs very good schools in many cases, as in OP its wanting access to the outstanding school when they are good schools in their catchment areas.

And worse is that their judgment is often based on OFSTED reports only.

This results in dreadful unecessary traffic as parents travel across the town and cities to take the kids in the out of catchment schools. The same who often will tell you proudly how they help the environment by recycling and chastised those who don't!

It's entitlement culture and my kids is more deserving then any other and the assumption their kids will become the next CEO because they attended they outstanding school rather than the good one like the suckers neighbour. Pathetic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread