Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Temporarily moving for Primary admissions

135 replies

Humdingledom · 03/01/2022 05:20

So I know lots of people do this but can’t help but think it’s really fucking cheeky

We are lucky enough to live in the catchment of the most oversubscribed school in the city. The family of DCs friend at school left their house they own and rented very close to the school so their DC got a guaranteed place at the primary school, and now DC has been there a term they are moving back to the house the own in a different area. There are easily 5 primary schools between here and where they live, with some
of them also “Outstanding” but ours does have a certain reputation.

I know other families temporarily moved in with the grandparents to be closer in the catchment and have now moved back outside the area or are planning to.

Like I said I know lots do it but it’s very annoying when friends that actually live on the catchment border missed out for places at the school when they had the option of two schools.

Let’s be clear I’m definitely not being snobby, I think it’s actually really rude of people who have luxury of moving temporarily when there’s people closer who maybe can’t afford to do that missing out!

OP posts:
littlemisslozza · 05/01/2022 07:29

It would be considered fraud in my rural Midlands county and it's made very clear in the admissions information that it is. Having said that, my SIL is in London and they regularly had families renting in their street for one year to get into the primary school, then moving away and driving in every morning. More difficult to manage when there's a larger proportion of people renting perhaps? What I thought was particularly wrong was that the siblings of these children who no longer lived near the school, had higher priority over the local children without a sibling there already. That wouldn't happen here, but my SIL was certain that was the case. Why would they move away if they weren't pretty much guaranteed a place for the younger ones? She must be right.

massiveblob · 05/01/2022 07:25

@ConstanceL if you didn't move local to school then it's only your child who will miss out on the huge benefits of going to local school. This really kicks in at juniors and then when they all move to high

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 05/01/2022 07:12

A family did this to get into the school my kid goes to; and it is talked about a fair amount by other mums, and not in a positive way. So the min you invite someone for a play date they’ll know.

Toocooltoboogie · 05/01/2022 06:39

Op has said themselves that they don't know the exact details of the moves. It's just school gossip and so what? The people that say report because it's unfair to those that live closer are just feeding into the unfair system. The school will do nothing as these people were in their rights to apply according to the rules. The fact they may move further down the line will not result in the kids being chucked out. Circumstances change and people move house when their kids are in primary- it's not against the law to and noone is ever asked to leave a school.

Florin · 05/01/2022 06:27

When our ds went to primary we decided on private due to some developmental delays so wanted smaller classes and extra help for him and a friend was so appalled that we paid for private as she felt private schools were wrong that she cut the relationship. However it was absolutely fine for her same age child to get into the best local state primary which they got into as they rented their house out for a year and they then rented a house a stone throw from the school for a year. After the year was up she moved back to their old house. I do understand the feelings about private school and quite frankly it isn’t fair but it was the best decision for our ds and we gave up a lot for it but at least we were honest about it. Ex friend was a teacher too.

newname12345 · 05/01/2022 06:13

@ConstanceL But you did play the system, though in a slightly different/longer game to others.

RedHelenB · 05/01/2022 05:54

No primary school is worth that. I feel sorry for the child, because their social life outside of school will suffer as they'll miss out not being local.

ConstanceL · 04/01/2022 23:42

@LakieLady

When a family member sold their last house, they had buyers in a bidding war because it was close to an excellent state grammar. They ended up getting £200k over the asking price.

That £200k would have paid for an excellent independent school for several years, so it seemed bonkers to me.

Did they have lots of children so the £200k wouldn't have gone far in school fees?

Primary school admissions can be an emotive subject. We stayed in our too small flat a couple of years longer than we wanted to get DC1 into the best state primary in the area, we then moved about a mile away a month after term started. Another mum made a few 'lighthearted' digs about how we had played the system as we knew we would be moving when we got the school place, but I can't see how we did play the system as we lived at our previous address for over 10 years and were still living there when the first term started. I did actually check with school admissions what their policy was with people moving once term started and they had no problem with it.

As policies change from LA to LA though perhaps the people the OP is referring to haven't broken any admission rules, but I know our local one says in their policy that rented property addresses when the parents own a house elsewhere won't be accepted.

StiffyByng · 04/01/2022 22:58

@LakieLady

When a family member sold their last house, they had buyers in a bidding war because it was close to an excellent state grammar. They ended up getting £200k over the asking price.

That £200k would have paid for an excellent independent school for several years, so it seemed bonkers to me.

But you don’t get the 200k of school fees back, whereas in all likelihood they’ll make a profit on the house when they sell.
GettingStuffed · 04/01/2022 20:43

When I went to school aeons ago if you were in the catchment area you went to that school, yes it meant houses near the school were more expensive it also meant that of you moved out of catchment the pupil had to move school to the one the new address was in the catchment area for.

However not all schools keep their Ofsted rating, things can change, the head or some of the better teachers leave , and a school with lower ratings may get an enthusiastic head or try to raise their ratings by engaging pupils to do better work.

It's a total crapshoot

LakieLady · 04/01/2022 20:33

When a family member sold their last house, they had buyers in a bidding war because it was close to an excellent state grammar. They ended up getting £200k over the asking price.

That £200k would have paid for an excellent independent school for several years, so it seemed bonkers to me.

A580Hojas · 04/01/2022 20:04

@MsMarch

I think that the situation where it would be considered fraud is if the family rent a place in catchment but don't actually live in it. ie they stay in their original home and take a 3 month hit or whatever on a short term rental. But that would make the rental not their primary residence, even if it is legally theirs, with council tax etc to prove it.
No, it is also considered fraud if the family actually live in that property but then move back to their other property out of catchment within a short time frame. By some local authorities/schools.
StiffyByng · 04/01/2022 19:58

Many years ago I owned a small one bed flat in what I found out was within admissions distance of a very sought after London primary. I knew this because someone put a note through my door (and all my neighbours) saying that if they would pay my council tax for a year and also a sum to be negotiated if they could use my address for a school application. This is probably one of the reasons why that borough is now one of those who does check up on addresses - if you own a large house and rent a small one close by, if you only have a six month rental contract, if you have a suspiciously-timed marital breakdown etc.

We’ve just moved into a rental house prior to buying in an area, and arrived just after the first cut off for 2022 secondary applications. Luckily the local authority form included a section for people imminently moving to the area, and had already told me in any case that an application up to 31 December with the explanation that we’d just moved would be accepted as on-time BUT the rental contract absolutely had to be for a minimum of 12 months and we couldn’t own a house anywhere nearby. This is a catchment area with lots of good schools, some of which are undersubscribed, so I think they offer more latitude than some others, but they still had pretty strict rules on residency.

MsMarch · 04/01/2022 19:43

I think that the situation where it would be considered fraud is if the family rent a place in catchment but don't actually live in it. ie they stay in their original home and take a 3 month hit or whatever on a short term rental. But that would make the rental not their primary residence, even if it is legally theirs, with council tax etc to prove it.

Triffid1 · 04/01/2022 19:40

[quote BuanoKubiamVej]@HiJenny35 that's not true. The exact wording will be different in each LEA but the Haringey protocol mentions this scenario specifically: "A family rents a property, or lives with relatives temporarily, and uses this address
in order to gain a school place, whilst retaining ownership of an alternative property. In cases such as this, the property which is still owned by the family would normally be considered as the appropriate address to assess admission from, even if this property is not currently being occupied by the family."

In most LEAs a further-away property that is owned by the parents of the child must have been sold and contracts exchanged for that further away address not to be used. Being on the market for sale or rented out on a standard shorthold tenancy is insufficient because it would be too easy to revert back there once the school place was secured.[/quote]
How is that even enforceable? I have a friend who rented out their house and they rented nearer to the school they wanted. If the council had said, "no no, you own this other house, so that's the house you have to consider your primary residence" that would have been complete bollocks. Heck, I know at least 3 families who own smaller properties in different areas (some close by, others further but still in the county) but who can't afford to upgrade to a bigger home so they rent out the smaller property and then rent a bigger property for themselves and their family. Will those people now not be considered for school places in the area they're renting. Rubbish.

if your primary residence is in catchment area, then that's the residence that counts for your school application.

BlingLoving · 04/01/2022 19:37

This might be morally ambiguous but it's not illegal. On the day of application you need to be living in the catchment area, with council tax records etc to prove it. It doesn't matter if you lived there for 5 minutes or 50 years. Similarly, once you are in to a school, you can live anywhere you like.

I understand why people find it a bit irritating but I honestly can't get worked up about it b because at the end of the day, at the time of application they did genuinely live in the catchment area. Sort of surprised it doesn't happen around here more although our local school catchment is getting very small so maybe it will start.

OnceuponaRainbow18 · 04/01/2022 19:32

@Borland

Yup, and then others may think twice before illegally claiming a school place for their kid

A580Hojas · 04/01/2022 19:27

"This is an actual child we are talking about who has been at the school a whole term, presumably settled in and made friends etc. Would you really want the child to be kicked out of school through no fault of their own. And yes another child may have got the place but presumably that other child has now settled in to their school. Besides if the council’s rules are it just has to be where you live at the time of application then the family have not committed fraud in any case."

This is so wet. If the child has only been at school for one term they are not going to be damaged by being moved. You can't use this as an excuse for awful, cynical, "me me me" cheating of the system!

A580Hojas · 04/01/2022 19:25

@RoomOfRequirement

Until the government ensures every child has access to the same, high level of education I don't blame the parents one bit.

The educational disparities of people who live in, usually, lower income areas is an embarrassment and absolute travesty.

Well this is very hypocritical of you. Where I live, most very good schools have catchments of social housing alongside million pound houses. Guess who are the ones cheating the system to get in? Of course it's parents just a few hundred metres too far away who swoop in to a rent a house at £3,000 per month for a year and then move out again.
downtonupton · 04/01/2022 19:17

The Admissions Code makes allowances for children who have already started attending and the place wont necessarily be taken away if they have been attending for more than a term but as mentioned up thread an application from a younger sibling may not qualify for sibling priority or similar limit on the sibling's chances of being offered (e.g. not treated as a catchment child if they are still in catchment etc).

It is a minefield and many different areas and schools deal with it all in different ways - some will investigate all accusations thoroughly and some just check council tax - none of us can say what will happen if P were to report it.

Some areas take into consideration how long you have lived in an address, whether you own elsewhere etc and if in doubt, will take the address the child has the longer association with (happened locally that parents 'split' and the new address right next to the fabulous primary school was not accepted as the child had the longer association with the family address - funnily enough the parents reconciled shortly after they discovered their plan wasn't going to work).

In my experience most admission arrangements will have unspecific wording such as 'on the balance of probability' where they will question why you moved from a nice 3 bed semi into a pokey 2 bed ex council flat next to a school. I know that some authorities have been forced to accept this sort of thing when the house has been sold and the new place is being rented but have accepted the address with the caveat that should the family move further away within a certain time-frame the address would be treated as an address of convenience and action taken (ie removing place or not giving sib priority).

OP should report it - if for no other reason than that the more cases that are investigated, the tighter the arrangements can be made to catch them.

it is unfair and it is tantamount to stealing something - I cant afford a house in the right area so I will lie to get what I want and someone else loses out because I have cheated. if it were benefits and someone forgot to mention that their boyfriend had moved in - half of Mumsnet would be up in arms about the benefit cheat - but when it comes to education apparently it is fair game and honesty doesn't apply.

I wish the system was different - but in all reality, whatever the system was, the wealthy would find a way to make it work for them.

Borland · 04/01/2022 18:50

@OnceuponaRainbow18

It’s fraudulent and illegal. I would report and the place can be taken away
This is an actual child we are talking about who has been at the school a whole term, presumably settled in and made friends etc. Would you really want the child to be kicked out of school through no fault of their own. And yes another child may have got the place but presumably that other child has now settled in to their school. Besides if the council’s rules are it just has to be where you live at the time of application then the family have not committed fraud in any case.
liveforsummer · 04/01/2022 18:19

Wouldn't matter what they did with the house as long as they changed their address with banks, Dr's etc to the new one.

Wotsitsits · 04/01/2022 18:17

YABU to moan about it if you're not going to report.

A close friend of mine sold her house, rented in catchment from July last year, and has now bought again outside of catchment. She will be moving in January. So not even a full year in catchment. I admire her commitment and pure fuck you energy, but I think a lot less of her now. Because she actually sold the other house I think she's within the rules unfortunately.

Cheeky fuckers the lot of them.

liveforsummer · 04/01/2022 18:12

Fwiw people do it for our school too. As long as they do a day at the school that's then for their place. The ones that outright lie often get caught and kicked out though. It was in a the news a while back naming and shaming some

liveforsummer · 04/01/2022 18:10

It's not really fraud if they did genuinely live there at the time. It would be fraud if they lied about living there. Morally questionable though yes. Bet your DD is pleased though?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread