Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Temporarily moving for Primary admissions

135 replies

Humdingledom · 03/01/2022 05:20

So I know lots of people do this but can’t help but think it’s really fucking cheeky

We are lucky enough to live in the catchment of the most oversubscribed school in the city. The family of DCs friend at school left their house they own and rented very close to the school so their DC got a guaranteed place at the primary school, and now DC has been there a term they are moving back to the house the own in a different area. There are easily 5 primary schools between here and where they live, with some
of them also “Outstanding” but ours does have a certain reputation.

I know other families temporarily moved in with the grandparents to be closer in the catchment and have now moved back outside the area or are planning to.

Like I said I know lots do it but it’s very annoying when friends that actually live on the catchment border missed out for places at the school when they had the option of two schools.

Let’s be clear I’m definitely not being snobby, I think it’s actually really rude of people who have luxury of moving temporarily when there’s people closer who maybe can’t afford to do that missing out!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ReluctantEarlyRiser · 05/01/2022 14:01

Also, around here, school plays a massive role in the local community withevents etc that take place. It's really lovely! Sad for families to miss out on that aspect by shipping the kids out 30 minutes away.

A580Hojas · 05/01/2022 13:26

@ElftonWednesday

No, it is also considered fraud if the family actually live in that property but then move back to their other property out of catchment within a short time frame. By some local authorities/schools

I find that utterly fucking ridiculous as a blanket rule.

Out of interest, why do you find it utterly fucking ridiculous?

Under what circumstances might a family let their house, move to a rented house closer to the school and apply for an get a place, but then give up the rental and move back to their original house soon afterwards. What legitimate reasons could there be for doing this? I can't think of any other than to cheat someone else's child out of a school place.

Stiffybyng · 05/01/2022 12:51

The schools round here have siblings as second priority after catchment, so if you’ve moved out of catchment, siblings have some priority but all catchment children get a place first. Looking at the admission stats, for the most popular schools, it can be a lottery whether all sibling applications get in or not, so it would definitely put people off playing these sort of games.

ElftonWednesday · 05/01/2022 10:50

No, it is also considered fraud if the family actually live in that property but then move back to their other property out of catchment within a short time frame. By some local authorities/schools

I find that utterly fucking ridiculous as a blanket rule.

ElftonWednesday · 05/01/2022 10:46

Picking a school purely on its OFSTED rating is ill judged

Particularly when it hasn't inspected in a long time. It really annoys me that a school doesn't get inspected for ages once it is outstanding. How do we know it still is? Things change in a year or two, let alone ten years!

VestaTilley · 05/01/2022 10:42

YANBU. It’s beyond cheeky - it’s fraudulent and it deprives poorer people of getting in to a good local school - it’s regressive and selfish.

I’d be dobbing them in to the Local Authority...

downtonupton · 05/01/2022 10:19

That happens quite often. A nice middle class coasts because the parents carry much of the weight. Their SATS are high, the kids come in already able to read the parents/nannies have done half the work already.

Oftsed come in and look at the quality of teaching etc and see that it is inadequate.

Happened to a school where i work and also to the local one everyone hangs around on the waiting list for. Transferring in Y3 or 4 because they're been waiting since reception. A friend was very disappointed. Teaching poor, relied on parent - then all the kids she wanted her daughter to network with left for private school to cram for the grammar tests .

Coookiee · 05/01/2022 09:49

It's such a risk on a number of levels, not to mention an expensive hassle moving and then moving back. And whilst I do agree it's unfair on those who permanently live within the catchment missing out on a local school place, I also think that schools can vary so much and parents all want the best for their child.

However, I have to laugh because in my town there are a small number of "outstanding" lower schools, the rest are all classed "good". Over the years I have known a number of parents who have temporarily moved to ensure their child gets into one particular "outstanding" school in my town (the one considered the most elite of the outstanding schools, mainly due to its catchment that doesn't include any council estates and includes the most expensive houses in the town). Without fail, these parents boast on Facebook when they get their kids into this school and freely brag about their kid going to the best school. Until recently, this school hadn't had a full OFSTED since 2007. It finally had an OFSTED in October and it has been downgraded to "inadequate". It's now the worst graded school in the town. Where as there are schools that were "requires improvement" a number of years ago which are now considered "good" and they continue to improve yet people turn their noses up at those school because they don't have the outstanding tag. I dread to think how many children the "outstanding" school has failed since 2007.

Picking a school purely on its OFSTED rating is ill judged. Picking a school purely on its OFSTED rating and then moving house to try and ensure a place in that school is utter madness.

downtonupton · 05/01/2022 09:20

Just like some people check schools before they move, some will delay moving out of an area to secure a school place - there is nothing wrong with that.

People who rent out their property and move in to a rental - even if they are living there are cheating.

People who deliberately temporally move to secure a school place are cheating.

Viviennemary · 05/01/2022 09:19

Either report them or stop moaning about it.

SueSaid · 05/01/2022 09:18

Last year we had posters calling others 'nazis' for reporting people in an actual pandemic where public health was at risk.

Here we have a load of busybodies telling the op to report parents for getting their kids into a school of their choice. So what?! Yes perhaps another dc may lose a place but that's a bit of stretch isn't it.

You have no idea what is going on behind closed doors. Relationships breaking down, people living in rented accommodation or temporarily with relatives until they can sort it out.

Keep your beak out.

ConstanceL · 05/01/2022 09:12

[quote newname12345]@ConstanceL I did not say you did anything wrong. But by your own admission you "stayed in our too small flat a couple of years longer than we wanted to get DC1 into the best state primary in the area". Then as soon as you did you moved.

I agree its a different scenario to people who move, but you were still playing the system.[/quote]
But 'playing the system' implies some kind of cheating or at least being underhand. Which I don't think we particularly were. Taking advantage of ones current position within the system through inertia isn't the same as playing it I don't think!

Anyway, as I mentioned in my first post, primary school admissions can be an emotive subject, and people have differing opinions on what is right and wrong. As far as I'm concerned if people have followed the LA's admissions rules at the time of application and of term starting, then there is no problem morally or legally. But it is not clear if this is the case in the scenario the OP describes.

newname12345 · 05/01/2022 09:01

@ConstanceL I did not say you did anything wrong. But by your own admission you "stayed in our too small flat a couple of years longer than we wanted to get DC1 into the best state primary in the area". Then as soon as you did you moved.

I agree its a different scenario to people who move, but you were still playing the system.

SituationCritical · 05/01/2022 08:51

We had someone do this in our village...she lives here but rented a house in a nearby village to ensure her child got a place and rented out her house in the village. Her child got the place and they attempted to move back. Their tenant refused to leave, they ended up in court and the house was absolutely trashed requiring thousands and thousands of pounds worth of repairs. The local primary is absolutely lovely so no idea why she was so adamant on choosing this other school but not sure I'd say it was worth it!!!

Figgygal · 05/01/2022 08:50

What is so great about a PRIMARY school that people would do this? Its madness

ConstanceL · 05/01/2022 08:50

[quote massiveblob]@ConstanceL if you didn't move local to school then it's only your child who will miss out on the huge benefits of going to local school. This really kicks in at juniors and then when they all move to high[/quote]
We are now 25 mins walk away from the school rather than 5! We have hardly moved out of the local area and are still in catchment for the secondary school. We are in London so catchments for primary schools are miniscule. So I don't think my DC are in danger of missing out on anything..

ConstanceL · 05/01/2022 08:46

[quote newname12345]@ConstanceL But you did play the system, though in a slightly different/longer game to others.[/quote]
How though? We lived in our flat for over 10 years and hadn't even exchanged on the new property when the school term started so we couldn't have applied from what would be our new address anyway. Hardly playing the system - are you saying people should never move house once their child starts school? This is a completely different scenario to people who move to get a school place, we just stayed where we were 🤷‍♀️

newname12345 · 05/01/2022 08:46

@massiveblob With large schools though you end up with kids who even go to the same school together living miles away from each other anyway. DS's high school's catchment area (within a medium size town) is maybe up to 2.5 miles, so could mean kids live up to 5 miles from each other - not so easy to hang round after school unless they stay at the school.

My point being is that a lot of their weekday hanging out after school is now virtual. Partially because of their shared interests in online gaming, partially that covid has enforced/encoraged this, and partially because none of them live that close to each other regardless of which school they go to.

massiveblob · 05/01/2022 07:59

@newname12345 there's an element of that if they all live relatively near then just go to different highs. But likely near enough to still do sports together or hang out. It does fizzle off normally. At my DC high they all hangout straight after school together so those living further away at different schools aren't there.
If DC go to a primary where all go to high A but they don't as they live miles away that's also different.
I've seen this. The child ends up having to go to high school knowing no one. Not the end of the world but harder for many

newname12345 · 05/01/2022 07:52

@massiveblob In the past friends not being that local was a problem as it was too easy to lose contact. Not sure if it is so much now. A couple of DS's best mates from primary went to totally different high school's back in September, not only has he not lost contact with them, his large friendship group is now extended across 3 high schools (ie he's friends with children he's not ever gone to school with).

ReluctantEarlyRiser · 05/01/2022 07:50

I haven't read the whole thread but I find this pretty abhorrent. Schools need a mix of children from different backgrounds and academic abilities else the 'less desirable' schools will never be able to improve.

IMO a primary school is a primary school. If you're the type of parent who invests time in your children, encourages them and supports their school then they will do just fine wherever they are.

Going to a catchment school also means you can walk there and your kid has friends in the immediate area that they can play with!

user1487194234 · 05/01/2022 07:37

We paid about 100k extra for our house to get into the catchment area of the school we wanted for the DC.So can't /won't judge anyone for wanting the best school they can get

massiveblob · 05/01/2022 07:33

@littlemisslozza in our LA it's automatic sibling priority regardless of where you live by then. One child in = all get in.
Our neighbouring LA 5 mins away isn't. They changed it. Siblings only get priority if still in the specific catchment. That stopped all this.
Move at your peril. Move miles away and siblings will not get a place

drpet49 · 05/01/2022 07:31

* YABU for being pissed off about it if you aren't reporting it. Choosing not to report it is collaborating in the deception and fraud so you're being hypocritical to moan about it. If it's wrong then it needs reporting. If you are choosing not to report then you are accepting that it's ok.*

^This

massiveblob · 05/01/2022 07:29

@Humdingledom if you think this and have details you should report it. So should others. Otherwise you are just part of the problem. It stopped at our school as previously parents reported those cheating the system. A few had places removed between nursery and reception start for using grandparents address or moving before the Jan deadline etc
Everyone not doing anything is complicit.
Also agree with others... it's about wealth in many cases. Money to move into catchment etc.
It's also then wealth feeding PTA funds etc, socially selective intakes etc

Swipe left for the next trending thread