Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blair knighthood

383 replies

Mummyrowland · 03/01/2022 02:54

Nearly half a million people have signed a petition over his knighthood in 48 hours.

It should be removed and he shouldn't be awarded it.

After all what did he do that was good?

What about all the squaddies he sent to their deaths over the supposed wmds?

High ranking members of the armed forces are threatening resignation if his award isn't reconsider

OP posts:
NiceShrubbery · 07/01/2022 10:03

I don't think it's a Labour-Tory thing.

I think the knighting of any 20th century PM is going to get a similarly outraged response (unless you're the Speaker of the HoC who thinks they should all be knighted).

Apart from lying to the entire world about Iraq, Blair is odiously self-serving and is known to have advised and supported murderous foreign dictators since resigning (eg Rwanda, Kazakhstan). According to a normal person, that behaviour would be known as bringing the good old Realm into disrepute; apparently in the Queen's books, that kind of thing is just what her Knight Companions should be doing (who's that other KC involved with Kazakhstan... I think some relative of the monarch with a sweating problem if I recall correctly)

It just shows what a medieval farce the honours system is.

Why would they all want to dress up like prats in hats anyway?

Can't they just go on a day trip to Warwick Castle if that's their thing?

images.app.goo.gl/MVgkdZx3dkfLbSH39

mynamesnotMa · 07/01/2022 09:41

^ this in a nutshell what pp said ^

mynamesnotMa · 07/01/2022 09:40

You are utterly deluded.
It's pointless.

coffeerevelsrock · 07/01/2022 09:23

It doesn't matter about all that, Alexandra. It's clear that according to some posters on here, Tony Blair is essentially to blame for anything bad that happened before him because he didn't reverse it all. He's also to blame for anything bad that happened after him because he started it and/or didn't reverse all Thatcher's shit , as above.

Like you say, it's because he's Labour. The Tories hate him as a successful Labour leader and the left of the Labour party hate him because he wasn't pure enough. it's absolutely maddening.

Alexandra2001 · 07/01/2022 09:00

@Tealightsandd

Returning to Blair's war on the disabled.

Yes Thatcher did bad things too. Not least introducing the devastating right to buy. But Blair didn't reverse it. He took all her worse policies, continued them, and then went way further than she'd ever gone.

You obviously never lived through Thatchers Britain or you voted for her...... What she did to the UK was nothing short of criminal, she took away apprenticeships, destroyed manufacturing, sold off utilities to Tory mates, right to buy, removed almost all unionisation - handing power to business and look how they have rewarded themselves? destroyed mining communities, using the police as her private army.

Slashed spending on health, education, benefits and according to Whitehall documents, wanted to end the NHS (always a Tory aim) and universal education, squander n - sea oil by allowing private companies to take almost all the profit.

the only good thing she did was in her support for the EU's Single Market but even that has now been thrown away by the Tories.

But as always "..... but Labour"

Alexandra2001 · 07/01/2022 08:49

@madisonbridges

I care not one ounce what Chilcott thought. Campbells staff trawled the Internet and found a thesis which they then plagiarised and put in the dossier as fact. Blair and the Americans then presented that doctored thesis as reliable Intel. Chilcote can say that wasn't Blair lying but what else can it be? Maybe there's some legal nicety to describe what he did but where I come from, it's called a lie. I'm not terrified of Tony Blair. Why would I be? He's had his time and commands little respect amongst most people. I just feel that whether they agree with the war or not, people should acknowledge that Blair, Campbell and Powell were far from honest in their dealings in the run up to the war.
If you cannot accept the results of a long running public inquiry, then there is no arguing with you.

This idea the USA needed the Brits to trawl the 'net to justify a war is laughable.

jgw1 · 07/01/2022 07:39

@Huy456

He was a war hero in Kosovo.

People forget the context, Bosnia was still a recent memory.

Also while we're at it Afghanistan not really a roaring success but no one seems to be bothered about that.

Also he was an excellent domestic PM and they lifted aspirations and children out of poverty.

This is what is called a balanced post. Please do not post in this manner in future, but instead stick with having an ill informed rant.
Huy456 · 07/01/2022 06:24

He was a war hero in Kosovo.

People forget the context, Bosnia was still a recent memory.

Also while we're at it Afghanistan not really a roaring success but no one seems to be bothered about that.

Also he was an excellent domestic PM and they lifted aspirations and children out of poverty.

coffeerevelsrock · 07/01/2022 06:16

Yes Thatcher did bad things too. Not least introducing the devastating right to buy. But Blair didn't reverse it

It doesn't work like that though, does it? Politicians can't come along and reverse what has gone before and turn back the clock - the overton window and all that. Just like the Tories would never have set up the NHS or introduced the minimum wage but once these things are in place they can't whip them away.

I also lived through the Blair years and certainly didn't agree with everything he did, including re housing, but life was a damn sight better for most than it had been before and is now and I firmly believe that his overall intention was to make things better but he knew that to do that, Labour had to get elected. Maybe that was what influenced the change of name of the dwp, I don't know. After all, it was Thatcher who not only implemented certain policies but came out with the 'no such thing as society' line, which encapsulated a way of thinking that was dominant in the 80s.

Blair is hated by all but none more so than the left of the Labour party, so if they get their way we can look forward to at least another 5 years of the Tories after 2024.

Tealightsandd · 07/01/2022 00:20

Returning to Blair's war on the disabled.

Yes Thatcher did bad things too. Not least introducing the devastating right to buy. But Blair didn't reverse it. He took all her worse policies, continued them, and then went way further than she'd ever gone.

Tealightsandd · 07/01/2022 00:12

Blair and the Americans

I agree with your post but just this. It wasn't the Americans. It was Bush. He misled Americans just as Blair misled the British.

Good post though.

madisonbridges · 07/01/2022 00:05

I care not one ounce what Chilcott thought. Campbells staff trawled the Internet and found a thesis which they then plagiarised and put in the dossier as fact. Blair and the Americans then presented that doctored thesis as reliable Intel. Chilcote can say that wasn't Blair lying but what else can it be? Maybe there's some legal nicety to describe what he did but where I come from, it's called a lie.
I'm not terrified of Tony Blair. Why would I be? He's had his time and commands little respect amongst most people. I just feel that whether they agree with the war or not, people should acknowledge that Blair, Campbell and Powell were far from honest in their dealings in the run up to the war.

Tealightsandd · 06/01/2022 23:53

Nope. Changing public attitudes is on Blair.

I not only lived through the Blair years and witnessed it firsthand, it's also backed up by well researched studies. As referenced in the Independent article I linked.

Again. It was Blair that changed the name of the Department of Social Security to the disabled erasing Department of Work and Pensions.

mynamesnotMa · 06/01/2022 22:28

Think you need to review your narrative you seem to be swapping the names.

It's interesting how many are scared of Blair. He very nearly rebalanced society and made it fairer for all. Sadly many are terrified of this

mynamesnotMa · 06/01/2022 22:25

28jgw1

Tealightsandd

That Independent articles explains it very well. You mutter about IDS and Cameron and Osborne, and co.

The vitally important point is this. Thatcher manipulated and changed public attitudes. SHe made it appear socially acceptable to attack the vulnerable, including the disabled, an

jgw1 · 06/01/2022 20:28

@Tealightsandd

That Independent articles explains it very well. You mutter about IDS and Cameron and Osborne, and co.

The vitally important point is this. Blair manipulated and changed public attitudes. He made it appear socially acceptable to attack the vulnerable, including the disabled, and to view them as 'scroungers'. That is why his heirs - those who came after him (including Brown) - were able to get away with the further attacks on the vulnerable and disabled.

Blair intentionlly erased disability when he changed the government department name. Social Security is inclusive of disability and illness. Work and Pensions isn't.

Are you saying that because Blair changed our view of the disabled a bit it is fine for those who came after him - mostly Tories- are fine to destroy any quality of life the disabled might have had?
mynamesnotMa · 06/01/2022 20:16

01:08madisonbridges

mynamesnotMa

Are you that deluded you don't think what ever Tory was in power we'd have had the same.
Look at the Gulf war crow about that

We might have gone to war. But would any other leader, eg Brown, May, Major, have falsified Intel to do so?

No he didn't link to your source reference Chilcott

Tealightsandd · 06/01/2022 16:24

if you think that will benefit the disabled or anyone else vulnerable you are in for a nasty shock.

There are no illusions about the lot in power right now. True heirs to Blair. That doesn't mean the current alternative would do anything better.

In fact so far they've indicated they wouldn't. Starmer disappointed recently by giving Blair like disabled erasing speeches on "hardworking families". Aside from suggesting yet more misery for already hard pressed individuals on single incomes, this doesn't bode well for anyone too ill or disabled to work.

Let's just hope that Starmer rethinks his direction. He's done some good things including tackling Labour's serious racism problems. I thought he had potential. Perhaps there's still time for him to reassess. He really needs to distance himself from Blair if he wants to get anywhere though. Take a leaf out of Andy Burnham's book there (the distancing from Blair, not the stoking regional division cheap ploy).

Tealightsandd · 06/01/2022 16:13

That Independent articles explains it very well. You mutter about IDS and Cameron and Osborne, and co.

The vitally important point is this. Blair manipulated and changed public attitudes. He made it appear socially acceptable to attack the vulnerable, including the disabled, and to view them as 'scroungers'. That is why his heirs - those who came after him (including Brown) - were able to get away with the further attacks on the vulnerable and disabled.

Blair intentionlly erased disability when he changed the government department name. Social Security is inclusive of disability and illness. Work and Pensions isn't.

Tealightsandd · 06/01/2022 16:07

@coffeerevelsrock

Your SIL either wasn't around in 1997 (too young), wasn't disabled at the time, or is in a minority.

Several people I personally know suffered directly as a consequence of Blair's war on the disabled.

Disabled rights groups at the time fought hard to stop Blair's attack on them but sadly lost the battle.

It was widely reported at the time. Easy to find old articles (not just the Independent link above) if you don't believe me/remember.

Blair's heirs simply continued further down the road he set us on. He didn't just open the door. He took it right off its hinges.

Blair and Brown's part privatisation of the NHS and PFI has had long-term negative consequences.

Blair (and Brown's) policies were about extreme short-termism. The equivalent of a parent blowing the family's life savings on a flashy holiday....and then living in poverty for the rest of time.

Talking of poverty - and relevant to the NHS. Blair (and Brown's) major role in creating today's public health housing and homelessness emergency impacts on the NHS. Substandard and insecure housing directly affects health - physical and mental.

Aside from their attack on welfare - causing increasing numbers of landlords to reject low income tenants - Blair pushed the scheme that he got rich off. His family personally profiteered to the tune of millions out of buy to let. He heavily plugged it to any old Tom, Dick, and Harry (dodgy criminals included). This drastically reduced the pool of affordable homes for first time buyers who had to compete with investors snapping up (often multiple homes) and pushing house prices up.

In 1997, when Blair got in, it wasn't too late to repair the damage of right to buy. It was impossible to claim ignorance of the human misery and suffering it had led to. What did Blair do? End it? Oh no. He very enthusiastically continued it. Brown too (who went further in the attack on the low waged and too ill to work, by cutting housing benefits).

Blair significantly reduced the availability of affordable housing with his mass immigrantion policy. A policy that would have been fine - had he funded the additional infrastructure and housing necessary for millions of new arrivals. He didn't. Instead he took advantage of them to pursue a policy of enriching slum landlords and exploitative cheap labour employers.

Alexandra2001 · 06/01/2022 09:05

@Tealightsandd Regardless of what Blair did or didn't do, this idea that without his policies the Tories from 2010 wouldn't have slashed help for the poor / disabled and increased Tuition fees is for the fairies.

Look what they did with the NHS? Blair spent 4% of GDP on the NHS over his time in office, the Tories have spent 1.1% over the last 11 years.
Driven EU health staff from the UK, removed the bursary and destroyed the social care system.

We are all now paying for our voting choices.

coffeerevelsrock · 06/01/2022 06:29

Tealightsandd

That article doesn't explain or prove anything. It just gives a brief outline of someone's research/theory into the matter - it's not the definitive word on it. Fwiw, my ex-sil is severely disabled and gets massively pissed off with people banging on about Blair. The person she blames for the shit she has had to deal with from the government is IDS. What she wants is a Labour government and she feels people banging on about Blair are standing in the way of this and it does her head in. She has always said voting Lib Dems to teach Labour a lesson in 2010 (because of Iraq) is the biggest regret of her life.

Saying Starmer should speak against this knighthood is absolutely ridiculous. Blair led Labour to victory three times, the only Labour leader to have done so (and once after Iraq). To say he shouldn't get a knighthood would be like saying Labour didn't deserve those victories and they didn't benefit the country, and that would absolutely be the line the questioning would go down if Starmer said that in an interview. Labour need to be shouting more about the good things they did achieve when in power, not allowing this anti-Blair drivel to drive the 'debate' , because all that does is ensure the bloody Tories stay in for ever more, and if you think that will benefit the disabled or anyone else vulnerable you are in for a nasty shock.

Booklover3 · 06/01/2022 02:06

Signed it. There appears to be two on Change. I found the one with the highest signatories

Tealightsandd · 06/01/2022 01:50

As for Starmer, if you look back at my posts over previous months I was one his lone defenders. I had reasonable hopes for him - was willing to look past his history with Blair. Afterall we all make mistakes. I was deeply disappointed when he decided to defend the indefensible. Warmongering aside, it doesn't bode well for society's most vulnerable - the disabled. The unfortunate victims of Blair.

And again. It was Blair who changed the Department of Social Security to the (intentionally) disabled erasing Department of Work and Pensions.

Tealightsandd · 06/01/2022 01:41

All you ve done over your last few posts is blame Blair for things that the Tories did either before 1997 or during austerity.

@Alexandra2001
You must be confusing me with another poster.

Both sides of the political divide attacked the vulnerable. But, as explained in the Independent article I linked (reposted for your convenience) it was Blair who began the war on the disabled. His heirs, i.e. Brown, Cameron, May, Johnson, simply continued down the path he set us on.

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/british-people-stopped-believing-in-the-benefits-due-to-tony-blair-researchers-claim-9753824.html