Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blair knighthood

383 replies

Mummyrowland · 03/01/2022 02:54

Nearly half a million people have signed a petition over his knighthood in 48 hours.

It should be removed and he shouldn't be awarded it.

After all what did he do that was good?

What about all the squaddies he sent to their deaths over the supposed wmds?

High ranking members of the armed forces are threatening resignation if his award isn't reconsider

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 08/01/2022 18:46

He has done what every PM since year dot has done and cashed in on being a former PM..... even TM charges a small fortune on the speech circuit.

Nope. Tony Blair is the only ex PM in modern history to have claimed every single possible financial expense allowable. Don't you remember the furore some years back - when it emerged that (unlike the others including Thatcher, Major, and Brown) Blair claimed expenses to attend the Remembrance Sunday service.

I'm no fan of Brown (he continued the war on the disabled and poor with further benefit cuts, raided he pensions, and sold off our gold at knock down prices) but he didn't choose to rake in millions through profiteering, and legal but immoral schemes.

I suspect that Brown was more incompetent than bad. Blair on the other hand isn't so much evil as very very greedy.

The man has no shame. Particularly when it comes to money. He's the opposite of Robin Hood.

haribofiend · 08/01/2022 18:42

Thing is the honours are not a popularity contest.

Elections are though and he won 3 of them.

He introduced minimum wage
Free nursery for 3 and 4 year olds
good friday agreement and restored government to n.Ireland
Devolution for Scotland and Wales
He invested in our public services like no other government had since.

Alexandra2001 · 08/01/2022 18:34

@Tealightsandd

Estimated fortune of £60 million - a large part made off of profiteering from the housing crisis, owner of 10 homes (he must be fuming that 12 Homes Sunak has overtaken him in that regard). Yet...

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/tony-blair-cherie-furlough-covid-b1989173.html

Tony and Cherie. The epitomy of greed.
(Does anyone else remember Cherie's appallingly ill mannered grab in Australia - when she was told to select something for free as a gift...?).

Abuse of furlough, and legal but immoral tax avoidance schemes (check out Pandora papers and the Blairs).

No wonder there's no money to fund FFP3s for HCP, HEPA filters in schools, paying a decent wage to care home staff, or unfreezing the pitiful Local Housing Allowance rate.

Don't be ridiculous! Sunak and many others in the Tory party have fortunes way above Blairs & have far more properties.

He has done what every PM since year dot has done and cashed in on being a former PM..... even TM charges a small fortune on the speech circuit.

His 60m wouldn't give carers and other health workers a 0.1% pay rise, let alone pay for 100s of 1000s of FFP3 masks or housing allowances.... but a wind fall tax on oil companies who have made record profits this year would :)

Tealightsandd · 08/01/2022 18:27

doubt Blair really wants to be a arcane title anyway.

Then why did he accept it? He wouldn't have been the first to (politely) turn it down. Some people have principles and integrity. Foreign concept for Blair.

He wants the title because it will help make him even more money - on his lucrative lecture tours, and advising figures with dubious human rights backgrounds.

A family member of mine has it right. Blair (and his wife) are laughing all the way to the bank.

Tealightsandd · 08/01/2022 18:21

Estimated fortune of £60 million - a large part made off of profiteering from the housing crisis, owner of 10 homes (he must be fuming that 12 Homes Sunak has overtaken him in that regard). Yet...

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/tony-blair-cherie-furlough-covid-b1989173.html

Tony and Cherie. The epitomy of greed.
(Does anyone else remember Cherie's appallingly ill mannered grab in Australia - when she was told to select something for free as a gift...?).

Abuse of furlough, and legal but immoral tax avoidance schemes (check out Pandora papers and the Blairs).

No wonder there's no money to fund FFP3s for HCP, HEPA filters in schools, paying a decent wage to care home staff, or unfreezing the pitiful Local Housing Allowance rate.

mynamesnotMa · 08/01/2022 13:21

Do list the values of Johnson for Us?

mynamesnotMa · 08/01/2022 13:02

Tom Bowers is nothing but a sensationalist journalist. He blamed all of our present leaders faults on his violent abusive father. Giving the oaf no credence as a leader. His books aren't exactly an empirical source of wisdom.

mynamesnotMa · 08/01/2022 12:54

What lies and greed?
Is that the best you can do.

NiceShrubbery · 08/01/2022 12:08

He was a Christian and had morals and values. Sadly he been vilified for his ethics

TB's personal values became plain for all to see after he left office. His lies and greed have sadly eclipsed any good he might have done while PM. Read Tom Bowers' book Broken Vows for a bit of insight (I'm not recommending that book as I don't like the author's style at all, but it raises a lot of interesting questions about TB's ethics).

He's a worldbeater in political chicanery so by all means give him a medal for that. But not for outstanding service to the nation. Do British people really want to be associated with - and reward - those kinds of values? Very sad, if so.

mynamesnotMa · 08/01/2022 11:39

He challenged the status quo and wasn't afraid to stick his neck out. He was passionate about making life better for everyone. He was a Christian and had morals and values. Sadly he been vilified for his ethics. Those that can't believe a human can operate on this level seek to infer everything was deliberate. He says it haunts him those aren't the words of a man who doesn't care.
Did Thatcher care did she give two hoots to all the steel workers miners and industrial workers she took their livelihood from and had them run over by police horses when they protested. They were given benefits to shut up and go away. Whilst their livelihoods were stripped from them.
She stripped social housing and encouraged spending and borrowing then interest rates shot up to 14% many lost their homes. Did she care did Baroness Thatcher care nope her cronies told the poor to get on their bike. She changed the value system made the greed is good a mantra. Yet when the bubble burst and over 3 million unemployed she wasn't able to offer any solutions as she'd stripped industries and our love of financial sector wasn't enough.
Compare a lack of employment rights maternity pay decent education...teachers were constantly on strike under Thatchers Britain. There were riots strikes people a real north south divide.
Blair United the country wanted to celebrate youth culture and social mobility. He practiced what he preached. People didn't like that they didn't trust an honest politician.

Look at the useless lying feckless fuckers we have now. We almost expect them to lying shysters. Today we were he fiddled his expenses. He is responsible for the deaths of many over his stalling to go into lock down . The NHS is on its knees because of them nor Covid-19. They laugh in our faces as they continued to flaunt lock down rules. He lied about the EU and we are only going to see prices continue to rise. What contingency plan has he got. He's incapable of that level of thought. Carry on with your pathetic signatures I doubt Blair really wants to be a arcane title anyway. Confused

mynamesnotMa · 08/01/2022 11:19

Your hatred of the man shows just powerful he was.
I recall a much fairer Britain. I remember a feeling of a party that was much more centred. Without a doubt Brown was the brains and had some fantastic policies to get Britain working and the low paid could feel better off working and not feel stigmatised. Do you know how hard it is to claim PIP if you are disabled how utterly cruel the process is. Now the benefits systems means you can't possibly save you aren't allowed to be anything other than poor.
As for education its on its knees this government under Gove has created a two tier system again. The social divide is widening once again all in favour of those that can send their kids to private school. You do realise that there is no such thing as the better educated you are the more intelligent you are. Bright students can no longer go to university. Why should that be just for the rich,?
Sure start centres were amazing brilliant places to support parents and babies. They were free and accessible. There is nothing now.
Northern Ireland a mess for years a war fuelled by Thatcher and her hatred of Ireland. He brought peace and listened to both sides.
The country was thriving the debt was low their was optimistic. Business thrived workers had rights.
How many wars have been fought under dubious means. Saddam was a murderous mad evil dictator who butchered his own. The Tories voted to go to war. All the papers at the time were shouting we had no choice.
Carry on with your hate you know the real reason you hate him is deep down he was a powerful force for change. This country is right wing sadly and looks to remain so.

Alexandra2001 · 07/01/2022 20:32

@madisonbridges

The Queen did not like TB. She never forgave him about how he spoke to her over Diana's death - even though he was probably right. She didn't like Cherie Blair either. Probably didn't appreciate her sharing her contraception mishaps at Balmoral. Ugh. Can't blame her. She delayed giving the knighthood as long as she could and as a result no one after could get one. She probably holds him equal disdain to the million that signed the petition.
Wow! a Mumsnetter who is a close confidant of the Queen, we are blessed
Alexandra2001 · 07/01/2022 20:31

[quote Tealightsandd]@Alexandra2001

Tony Blair: 'My job was to build on some Thatcher policies'

www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-politics-22073434

Like I say, Blair continued all of Thatcher's worst policies. He was quite open about this (credit to him for his rare honesty).[/quote]
I played that video, you have selectively quoted, so he didn't reverse privatisations or union "reforms" correct! but he then says with a wry smile "my job was to try and build on them"

He didn't "continue them" at all, he didn't introduce more union reform nor further industrial privatisations.

PFI is an odd one, increase public borrowing, rise taxes or lease contracts (PFI) but at least Labour were pragmatic, they used the private sector to reduce waiting lists until more staff and building in place, something the Tories will be forced to do, at huge cost too..

Blossomtoes · 07/01/2022 18:43

He’s about a million times better than the bladder of lard currently occupying No 10.

Chely · 07/01/2022 18:36

He's a wanker!

NiceShrubbery · 07/01/2022 18:35

Believe that, you'll believe anything.

More likely it's a reward for TB's expert advice on opaque offshore asset structures.

madisonbridges · 07/01/2022 18:28

The Queen did not like TB. She never forgave him about how he spoke to her over Diana's death - even though he was probably right. She didn't like Cherie Blair either. Probably didn't appreciate her sharing her contraception mishaps at Balmoral. Ugh. Can't blame her.
She delayed giving the knighthood as long as she could and as a result no one after could get one. She probably holds him equal disdain to the million that signed the petition.

Tealightsandd · 07/01/2022 17:46

Queen sticking two fingers up at public opinion while she still can. Who cares what the serfs think.

The poor Queen. Officially it's her decision but reality is different. The fact that she waited 14 years (when usually ex PMs get honoured fairly soon after leaving office) speaks volumes about her true feelings.

NiceShrubbery · 07/01/2022 17:17

Only another 50 million to go...

Even if the whole country signs the petition, as this particular award is apparently the monarch's personal decision, it can't be revoked, because of reasons.

Queen sticking two fingers up at public opinion while she still can. Who cares what the serfs think.

And shooting the ostrich and heron for the feathers on the cap will give Andrew a nice change from grouse.

Tealightsandd · 07/01/2022 16:32

Anyway, 1 million signatures 👏👏

Happy Friday! Smile

Tealightsandd · 07/01/2022 16:31

Now I'm aware that Owen Jones is himself a rather divisive figure on here - but remember we can completely disagree with someone on one issue, whilst totally agreeing with them on another different matter. Afterall, we are all individuals with wide and varied opinions, not clones. Here on Blair he is bang on.

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/jan/07/labour-tony-blair-prime-minister-grassroots

Tealightsandd · 07/01/2022 16:27

@Alexandra2001

Tony Blair: 'My job was to build on some Thatcher policies'

www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/uk-politics-22073434

Like I say, Blair continued all of Thatcher's worst policies. He was quite open about this (credit to him for his rare honesty).

madisonbridges · 07/01/2022 16:21

If you cannot accept the results of a long running public inquiry, then there is no arguing with you.
Read the Chilcott report. He's damning of Tony Blair and how he compiled the evidence that the security services was telling him was "unproven". Chilcott also said about the dossier, "Iraq's capabilities were presented with a certainty that was not justified." He said so much more. Don't just dismiss what I'm saying because you like Tony Blair.

This idea the USA needed the Brits to trawl the net to justify a war is laughable.
It's laughable that it actually happened. The UN had refused to sanction the invasion and so many countries did not want to get involved. The US wanted to persuade countries but, like the UK, had little actual evidence of WMD. They were happy to use any evidence they could find to encourage others to join the invasion to give it legitimacy. When Blair produced a dossier which included unreliable and fictitious intel, they didn't question it, rather they promoted it as it suited their purpose. Colin Powell quoted it.

This is all on the record. I'm not speculating. It's true that Chilcott did not say that Blair was a liar. But he did say that Blair believed there were WMDs but had weak evidence so he used language to firm that up to give more weight to his argument. You might not think that taking, as the secret services say, "unproven" intel and giving it as indisputable fact is a lie. You might not think that taking a thesis and firming up language from that and presenting it as factual intelligence is lying. It just so happens I do.

NiceShrubbery · 07/01/2022 10:44

Alexandra2001 Unpaid role my arse. Financial enrichment is his reason for breathing.

Alexandra2001 · 07/01/2022 10:14

@NiceShrubbery Blair took an unpaid role helping Rwanda rebuild long after the 1994 Genocide, which the Tory Govt (among others) allowed to happen.

Blairs advice to Kazakhstan President after shooting dead 15 protestors is completely wrong.

Yes honours system belongs in the 16th century.