Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blair knighthood

383 replies

Mummyrowland · 03/01/2022 02:54

Nearly half a million people have signed a petition over his knighthood in 48 hours.

It should be removed and he shouldn't be awarded it.

After all what did he do that was good?

What about all the squaddies he sent to their deaths over the supposed wmds?

High ranking members of the armed forces are threatening resignation if his award isn't reconsider

OP posts:
Anordinarymum · 03/01/2022 18:52

This reply has been deleted

Message removed as it quotes a post that's been withdrawn.

Anordinarymum · 03/01/2022 18:51

@PersonaNonGarter

Of course he should be knighted.

I never voted for him, but millions did and he was PM for a long time and acted on what he thought was right.

Despite thinking he was a tit when he was in office, I have felt genuinely sorry for him on occasion since. His party literally cannot see that without him they would have been out of power even longer. They are so weirdly ungrateful.

Agree
Blossomtoes · 03/01/2022 18:50

Blair made his own choice

Endorsed by a cross party majority Commons vote. It was a collective decision.

madisonbridges · 03/01/2022 18:50

@Alexandra2001
Obviously you feel strongly about this

I don't feel particularly strongly about Tony Blair or his knighthood actually. Nor do I think he should go to prison. But I do get cross at things being pushed away as minor or an error of judgement. And I will argue anyone who maintains that position.

And for the record, being PM, even a bad one, is incredibly tough. I don't have a problem with any PM getting a knighthood. If an actor can get one for being paid millions, why not a PM?

madisonbridges · 03/01/2022 18:44

[quote Alexandra2001]@madisonbridges Obviously you feel strongly about this but please remember the wars in Iraq (both of them) would haver happened anyway, George Bush Jnr was always going to invade, the UK just lent it a little legitimacy, the 100s of 1000s killed would have still died.

Blix was never going to find WMD's with Saddam still in charge and Saddam did have them, ask the Kurds?

Its all very well being wise after the event but had Saddam still had just a small amount of nerve gas and then used them on Israel or in Europe, the wests lack of action would have been heavily criticised.

Also, the inquiry found Blair did not lie.[/quote]
Bush is responsible for Bush's actions and is answerable to his own electorate. Blair made his own choice. As a British voter the inevitability of Bush invading Iraq is immaterial to me. There was so much evidence that Saddam had no weapons that would be of threat that Blair had to take a students thesis and plagiarise it as evidence in order to get parliament and the electorate to support him. That is an insult to me. But I could stomach an invasion of Iraq to get rid of Saddam if they had had a proper plan in place for after the war. But he couldn't even do that right. He entered illegally and then carried out a shambles of an operation. That reverberates today.

Blix didn't find WMD because there were none to find. It's incredible to me that you think there were still some there. If there had have been, do you not think they would have been found by now. The Kurds were gassed in 1988. If the Kurds know where there are more chemical weapons, why aren't they speaking up? The UN inspectors had been in Iraq since 1991. By 1995 they were pretty much sure everything had been destroyed.

Blair had a dossier put together that was a cut and paste job by staff in Campbells office, including a students thesis, to persuade mps to support a war. I could not give a rat's tutu whether a court thinks that's a lie or not. The fact is Blair apologised for it...after he won his vote and invaded.

And then he got himself appointed peace envoy to the middle east whilst taking millions from the UAE. Well, he might as well profit from the war he lent legitimacy to. No?

Blossomtoes · 03/01/2022 18:33

Nor can I @luckylavender. That’s why I wondered if there was a link. Like pp the decade of Blair’s premiership was the best politically of my life time. I too remember that absolute euphoria on the morning of 2 May 1997.

luckylavender · 03/01/2022 18:14

@Blossomtoes

But that series was made in the last couple of years. Of course he’d say that now, I’m pretty sure he didn’t at the time. And, even if he did, he should have resigned if Blair wouldn’t listen to him. I’m not buying it.
I can't find any evidence he said that. Not even in the Parliamentary enquiry.
ZenNudist · 03/01/2022 18:09

Margaret thatcher ruined this country and was made baroness. Cameron put the final nail in the coffin with brexit and he will get knighted. So will Johnson who is currently kicking the corpse of the UK down the road to make money for himself and his cronies.

Personally I liked Blair and I think he made the best decisions he could with the political situation and intelligence at hand at the time. I never thought there were any WMD either at the time and I thought 2nd Iraq war motivation was a combination of oil driven and Personal vendetta of GWB. There are a lot of leaders who send troups into battle or make decisions that kill. I think the honours are about the service and not the effect of that service. I don't like the honours system much TBH but don't think Blair's knighthood is the biggest problem we have.

jgw1 · 03/01/2022 18:07

This reply has been deleted

Message removed as it quotes a post that's been withdrawn.

SalveVagina · 03/01/2022 18:03

Trying to find the petition now so I can sign it.

Getyourjinglebellsinarow · 03/01/2022 17:58

He tricked us into an illegal war. He should be in prison

Alexandra2001 · 03/01/2022 17:56

@coffeerevelsrock I agree with all you have said, the years between 1997 and even through to 2010 and the GFC in 2008 were utopia compared to what the Tories have took us through since 2010.

Should also be remembered that the GFA ended a conflict that saw 722 british soldiers murdered by terrorist's in NI, compared to 179 deaths in the 2nd Iraq war.... quite likely that without TB, many more would have died, i really don't see the likes of Cameron or Johnson winning over the IRA.

sst1234 · 03/01/2022 17:51

@DottyDoge

YABU, he was PM for 10 years and won three elections.
Labour don’t win elections. Tories lose them.
Alexandra2001 · 03/01/2022 17:49

@madisonbridges Obviously you feel strongly about this but please remember the wars in Iraq (both of them) would haver happened anyway, George Bush Jnr was always going to invade, the UK just lent it a little legitimacy, the 100s of 1000s killed would have still died.

Blix was never going to find WMD's with Saddam still in charge and Saddam did have them, ask the Kurds?

Its all very well being wise after the event but had Saddam still had just a small amount of nerve gas and then used them on Israel or in Europe, the wests lack of action would have been heavily criticised.

Also, the inquiry found Blair did not lie.

madisonbridges · 03/01/2022 17:12

Sorry @Blossomtoes. We cross posted. You call GH a liar. I can't say whether he is or not. Maybe he just stuck to collective responsibility. But the things he said that were untrue, like the 45minutes, were in fact untrue. And I don't think it's hard to imagine Campbell putting the hard squeeze on.

madisonbridges · 03/01/2022 17:08

Did you watch that interview @Blossomtoes? It was very interesting, although large parts of the premiership were left out. I had quite admired TB in the past but I thought he didn't come across, well. Conversely GB, who I'd thought of as moody and truculent, I thought came across as quite thoughtful with quite good ambitions for equalling up. Just shows, we can't know people until we know them!

coffeerevelsrock · 03/01/2022 17:08

Great PM who is sorely missed when you look at the absolute shit-show we are living through now. The sense of optimism when Labour won in 1997 was amazing - I can't imagine ever feeling like that again when you look at how life is now, and I don't even mean Covid. Asterity, Brexit, corruption, Windrush - just an endless stream of awful things that cost us all financially and have stripped the country of its international status and moral core.

Iraq was a massive mistake but this idea that he 'started a war' as if everything was fine over there and he just went in is ridiculous. And the comparisons to the Falklands - as if that was some kind of honourable war are also ridiculous.

And I wouldn't get excited about the petition - between 2016-2019 there were so many petitions designed to prevent/slow down Brexit and they all got to a couple of million and look at where we are now. Those petitions are a pointless exercise in trying to create the impression we have a bit of control, when we really don't (aside from elections, obviously).

Blossomtoes · 03/01/2022 17:06

But that series was made in the last couple of years. Of course he’d say that now, I’m pretty sure he didn’t at the time. And, even if he did, he should have resigned if Blair wouldn’t listen to him. I’m not buying it.

madisonbridges · 03/01/2022 17:04

@Blossomtoes

Any links to Geoff Hoon saying that *@madisonbridges*? I can’t find any, although I can find him justifying the use of cluster bombs.
I can't quote it but he was on the the Blair/Brown TV interview, either episode 3 or 4. He thpught they should correct some untruths that were going around but Blair and Campbell told him no.
Blossomtoes · 03/01/2022 17:01

Any links to Geoff Hoon saying that @madisonbridges? I can’t find any, although I can find him justifying the use of cluster bombs.

madisonbridges · 03/01/2022 16:52

@Luredbyapomegranate
All people are complex. I'm sure I have more in common with views of a man born in 1953, so quite close to my own age, and a man born in 1874.
But it wasn't me who compared them, it was another poster who said that churchill had sent squaddies to their death. I was saying that Churchill was defending his country from an aggressor whilst Blair was an aggressor who went to war on information he knew, wasn't true. (According to Geoff Hoon, Defence secretary.)

Theoscargoesto · 03/01/2022 16:51

@PlanetNormal thanks for expressing the ambivalence that I feel so well.

I’d commend reading the Miles Goslett book about David Kelly, because the inquiry into his death was shocking. Whilst that is the effect on one family of the Blair government, in a global sense many families did benefit and there again is the ambivalence I feel.

For me the honours system is deeply flawed and this debate highlights some of the reasons for that belief.

Luredbyapomegranate · 03/01/2022 16:43

[quote madisonbridges]@Blossomtoes Of course all conflict results in loss of life. But surely there's a difference in attitude towards a PM starting a conflict and one defending British lives from an aggressor.[/quote]
Well, Churchill was largely concerned with defending the Empire. Those references are always nipped out of his famous speeches.

They are both complex men with complex legacies.

GameofPhones · 03/01/2022 16:42

To those arguing that any PM would have followed USA into war, Harold Wilson decided to keep us out of Viet Nam.

madisonbridges · 03/01/2022 16:21

@DirectionToPerfection

Anyone who can seriously portray Churchill as a saint in comparison to Blair really needs to educate themselves.

Churchill was a vile, racist, murderous bastard.

...who didn't start wars that lead to the death of hundreds of thousands of people and then took a role as peace envoy in the region and earned millions of pounds from it. Saint Tony.