Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Blair knighthood

383 replies

Mummyrowland · 03/01/2022 02:54

Nearly half a million people have signed a petition over his knighthood in 48 hours.

It should be removed and he shouldn't be awarded it.

After all what did he do that was good?

What about all the squaddies he sent to their deaths over the supposed wmds?

High ranking members of the armed forces are threatening resignation if his award isn't reconsider

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mynamesnotMa · 29/01/2022 11:15

Very bad things compare him to this useless lying oaf we have now. Who has the deaths of his own people on his hands. A government who are ruining education the health service. How many lies has there been under a Tory government. How many times are people so thick that they vote them in.
Sir Blair compared to the baboon we have

Tealightsandd · 16/01/2022 23:43

wouldn't, not would've

Tealightsandd · 16/01/2022 23:42

I don't blame him for everything. But he did many very bad things and they shouldn't be forgotten or dismissed.

That said, whilst I never miss an opportunity to mention Blair's crimes, I would've ever wish him dead, nor would I celebrate his passing. I think the behaviour of some people when Thatcher died was very distasteful. Prison, on the other hand. I'd be happy if that was his fate.

You wish he was in now? What do you have against the disabled?

Btw, the casual Othering of the vulnerable during this pandemic is the direct consequences of his toxic legacy.

madIam · 16/01/2022 22:43

Can't believe people are still wittering on about this after the revelations of this week. I mean apparently Gavin Williamson is set to get a knighthood, which is just... He (TB- not GW, who did fuck all other than pose with a whip) achieved a lot and, Tealight your determination to blame him for every single thing ever is frankly weird. I definitely agree that other people worked on the GFA as well as him, but saying Mo Mowlam did it on her own is just as daft as saying he did.

I wish to god he was in charge now. I've never felt so hopeless in my life and hope and optimism was one thing we had in spades when he was in charge.

Tealightsandd · 16/01/2022 22:32

I just gave two reasons why it could be argued that John Major merited one.

And Thatcher? Well yes she did some bad things - including one of the most terrible policies ever. The Right to Buy has caused huge suffering and misery. (Yet none of her successors, including Blair and Brown, ended it in England). However, she was the first ever UK female Prime Minister. Which was a huge achievement at a time.

The Queen herself has my respect. Yes she has (financial) privilege, but I think she has a genuine sense of duty to the country. Much more so than many in the Houses of Parliament.

I agree that Boris doesn't deserve one. None of our PMs from Blair onwards do.

I don't think we need to scrap the honours system. Reform it, maybe.

Give the honours to those who genuinely deserve one. That includes the likes of Chris Whitty and JVT. Also the 11 year old Tobias Weller.

Here's another deserving candidate imo

www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/news/people/asda-chesser-delivery-driver-ozzy-iqbal-hailed-a-hero-after-saving-customers-life-3524559

StoneofDestiny · 16/01/2022 22:21

What have the Royal Family done to have all the awards they give themselves?
What did John Major do to be knighted?
Why did Thatcher get to be a Baroness - that vile specimen of humanity that she was.
Boris Johnson will be knighted - yet a more odious person to occupy the role of PM is hard to imagine.

Scrap the whole honours system.

Tealightsandd · 16/01/2022 21:54

@Hearwego

** What good did John Major do? He has a knighthood.

I did wonder why Major was knighted. Such an average man- no idea what he did to earn a knighthood , but could say the same for many MPs.

Not his biggest fan. Still undecided about him tbh, but I suppose it could be argued that he was a good example of meritocracy. Working class background, lived in a council flat, and left school at 16. Yet made it to the role of Prime Minister. Perhaps inspiring for others.

Also he put in a lot of the groundwork for the GFA.

Hearwego · 16/01/2022 21:21

**
What good did John Major do? He has a knighthood.

I did wonder why Major was knighted. Such an average man- no idea what he did to earn a knighthood , but could say the same for many MPs.

Mummyrowland · 16/01/2022 00:48

Blair went to war on false evidence

Blair sent troops in ill protected quite insufficient ppe

Blair unskilled skilled jobs

Blair implemented tuition fees at uni

OP posts:
madisonbridges · 15/01/2022 19:42

Yeah Iraq didn’t go how he hoped, but Blair was trying to avoid the political isolation of USA who were definitely going to invade Itaq, and also deal with the chemical weapons Saddam claimed to have, as well as the humanitarian issue of how he routinely tortured his people

Saddam had been torturing his people for year. And yet Blair didn't step up to do anything about it, so crediting him for being a humanitarian when he'd done nothing about the situation for the previous 6 years in power is crediting him with humanitarian credentials he doesn't deserve. Plus the fact if he was doing it to oust Saddam for being a tyrant, why didn't he put that forward as part of his argument for war? Further, everyone knew there were no chemical weapons. Hans Blix had searched everywhere the security services had said there were weapons and there was nothing. The UN wouldn't sanction invasion because there was no evidence to say there were weapons. And because there was no evidence, Blair manufactured some and over represented other intel. Chilcot is damning about his actions over the dossier. We even know that when Straw and Hoon spoke up that claims were being exaggerated, they were told to zip it.

The HoC did vote, that's true. But they voted on a lie. On evidence that Blair said was proven to be true, but MI6 said was unproven intel from sources that they couldn't say were reliable. Maybe they would have voted for war on the truth, but we'll never know because Blairs manipulations took that option away from anyone.

The fact that the war didn't go as Blair hoped is the most damning of all. Before the war. Blair was told that the country would fall into sectarian chaos and he did nothing to prepare for it. "Wholly inadequate" Chilcot said. His actions left a vacuum that created space for the turmoil that has taken place since. And Tony Blairs response? Taking a paid position as a middle east peace envoy where he was criticised on all sides both for inadequacy of his work and for taking millions from UAE as he furthered his financial interests in the region.

Yeah, he's a real hero. But hey, at least he didn't leave the USA isolated!

Tealightsandd · 15/01/2022 17:50

Still, you're right that his heirs have been bad 'uns too. Unfortunate part of his legacy.

Tealightsandd · 15/01/2022 17:48

therapy for disabled etc etc

Therapy... to cope with the devastating effects of his harsh benefit cuts, taxpayer funded private company 'assessments' and the manipulating of public attitudes into viewing them as a 'burden'. Wonderful!

Tealightsandd · 15/01/2022 17:46

Competent indeed. More than that in fact. Just a shame that it was war - including one waged on society's most vulnerable, the disabled, where he excelled.

The GFA? That was John Major and then Mo Mowlam. They did all the work... before Blair breezed in and stole the credit.

Thirtytimesround · 15/01/2022 17:12

Well, I think that Tony Blair was the last competent PM that Britain had. Gordon Brown grumped about doing nothing, David Cameron created Brexit (costing our economy billions and pissing off all our allies), Theresa May tried hard but achieved nothing because she got stabbed in the back by the lying drunk who followed her, and Boris is the worst PM in British history.

Yeah Iraq didn’t go how he hoped, but Blair was trying to avoid the political isolation of USA who were definitely going to invade Itaq, and also deal with the chemical weapons Saddam claimed to have, as well as the humanitarian issue of how he routinely tortured his people. And more importantly there was a House of Commons vote and the majority of MPs chose to wage war in Iraq, it was a democratic choice, not one man running around the Middle East on his own. You can’t blame Blair for Iraq.

Blair negotiated and achieved the Good Friday Agreement, which brought peace to N Ireland, he stood up for Kosovo against Serbian genocide, he made Britain fashionable and cool for a while (Britpop! Olympics! Etc), and was a heavyweight in the European Union. Not to mention things like Surestart centres, therapy for disabled etc etc.

I think he’s awesome and I despise this pathetic petition by the woke brigade looking for someone to hate.

Tealightsandd · 15/01/2022 15:52

Btw you shouldn't insult chimpanzees. I expect they'd do a better job than most of us humans Smile

Tealightsandd · 15/01/2022 15:51

Like I've said before, the crimes, negligence, and incompetence of others doesn't absolve Blair of his. And also as I said, what we have today is in large part due to the long-term consequence of his toxic legacy.

mynamesnotMa · 15/01/2022 15:45

You mentioned lost lives in war. When is not the Case? How many have died due to his arrogance about the seriousness of Covid-19.
So many old people those with compromised immune systems are down to him. He couldn't decide to lock down and ofcourse not as there he was with his chums boozing it up whilst we all obeyed his rules. He lied repeatedly. This chimp is the worst PM in living memory.

mynamesnotMa · 15/01/2022 15:36

Repeating earlier mis quotes is not answering my question.
I repeat many of us have given you many examples of the positives changes to Britain by Labour. Tell me what this government and their leader has done. What changes to our society economy education health care system have their Been?

Tealightsandd · 15/01/2022 15:11

@mynamesnotMa

Probably because you can't possibly compare the great things they did for our country to these lying arrogant dangerous buffoons.
Churchill and Atlee did great things for our country.

Sadly since then we've had the likes of lying arrogant and dangerous Blair (and other bad 'uns).

He certainly did 'great' things... 'great' crimes against humanity.

A 'great' warmonger. Both abroad, and against his own people - particularly some of society's most vulnerable, through his war on the disabled.

mynamesnotMa · 15/01/2022 12:29

I've repeatedly asked you to share their successes. Yes comparing is a very healthy and relevant part of decision making .
Don't keep quoting Daily Mail sound bites in your response.

mynamesnotMa · 15/01/2022 12:27

Probably because you can't possibly compare the great things they did for our country to these lying arrogant dangerous buffoons.

Mummyrowland · 10/01/2022 22:04

@mynamesnotMa

You can't answer can You?
Why?
OP posts:
mynamesnotMa · 10/01/2022 21:24

You can't answer can You?

Tealightsandd · 09/01/2022 23:49

@Mummyrowland

Blair sent in armed forces ill prepared and ill equipped

Not enough body armour not enough protection on vehicles people died as a result that's inexcusable

This.
Mummyrowland · 09/01/2022 23:48

Blair sent in armed forces ill prepared and ill equipped

Not enough body armour not enough protection on vehicles people died as a result that's inexcusable

OP posts: