Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that Around the World in 80 Days if a vanity project for David Tennant?

66 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 03/01/2022 02:40

As someone who loves the book, and Jules Verne is a very good writer (although I think he was certainly on something when he wrote Journey to the Centre of the Earth!) , this TV series is shockingly bad!

It bears no resemblance to the story at all apart from the 80 day long trip and the names of some of the characters! There was no balloon trip, Mrs Auoda doesnt exist, Fogg is all silly and excitable and nothing like the regimented knowledgable character in the book.....he gets sea sickness ffs when in the book it becomes clear that he is an accomplished seaman.

And DT is executive producer.....coincidence?

Feels a bit like Doctor Who goes back in time in terms of how he is playing the character. Tortured but funny.....loving but repressed......blah blah....

OP posts:
AngryApple · 03/01/2022 06:10

Well as a fan of the 80s cartoon, I’d say it definitely had a better theme tune. Also I believe there were frequent balloon rides?

Wasn’t Steve Coogan once Fogg too? I’m sure he was also in a balloon!

And we know Richard Branson definitely had balloons.

This thread is balloonist.

PicaK · 03/01/2022 06:10

To be fair I've been binge watching "The Great" and spent the first 20 minutes of that gibbering in horror at the depart from actual history. But then I relaxed into it.
So I took Phileas Fogg in my stride.
I like the wokeness. I like Bridgerton.

Prescottdanni123 · 03/01/2022 05:57

Sometimes it doesn't do any good to make comparisons between books and TV programmes. Its better to just accept them at face value and read/watch them for what they are.

I haven't read the book, but sometimes literature doesn't transfer directly to television very well. What makes an entertaining book doesn't necessarily make for an entertaining TV programme, and changes need to be made.

Tlollj · 03/01/2022 05:56

I’m really enjoying it. It’s nothing like the book. But I’m ok with that.

2oldfordrama · 03/01/2022 05:55

I prefer Willie Fogg. Less ego and far cuddlier.

Imayhaveerred · 03/01/2022 05:52

Ah, I was wondering if there had been a radical departure from the book!

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 03/01/2022 05:40

I've not read the book, or seen the TV series yet.

But anything with David Tennant in is a winner in my eyes Grin

PicaK · 03/01/2022 05:35

I only watched it because I was feeling ill and desperate. I thought it would be a faithful Victorian jingoistic version of the book.
It's amazing. I love it!!!
It's taken the book and spun into another realm. I'm hugely enjoying watching it (and the wobbly sets). It's a reimagination and that's no bad thing.

PyongyangKipperbang · 03/01/2022 03:55

And I do think that its all a bit "woke". Fix being a woman who is trying to do things her way, Passepartout being black and dealing with the KKK, lots of white middle class English men learning a life lesson......

Like S2 of Staged, its all a bit too try hard.

And yet if they had named it something else and said "Inspired by......" then it would have worked a lot better as it manages expectations.

OP posts:
PyongyangKipperbang · 03/01/2022 03:52

I think it was the David Niven film waay back that made the balloon thing iconic.

Its not a bad series per se.....but it is absolutely NOT the same story! It bears no resemblance whatsoever! They dont visit the same countries in the same way, the methods of transport are wrong, Fix was a policeman who thought Fogg was a bank robber, its just heartbreakingly wrong. When I say that only similarities are the title and the names of the characters.....I am not exaggerating!

OP posts:
TheHamburgler · 03/01/2022 03:40

Never mind, just googled and can see that yes, the hot air balloon ride was in the show.

It odd that it’s become so iconic, despite not being in the source material.

Monty27 · 03/01/2022 03:40

I've not read the book.
I feel the same about any of these self ego stroking docu whatevers.
I guess their agents are quite persuasive.

Kanaloa · 03/01/2022 03:32

@DedafalalalalalusBloom

Oh now see I haven't read the book or know anything about the story but really enjoyed it! By and large though, I've never enjoyed a film or series when I've read the book beforehand. I always want it to be exactly like it is in my head and even the smallest deviation annoys me. ( I'm looking at you, His Dark Materials).
I’m just the same as this! If I’ve read the book the programme will disappoint in one way or another!

I did enjoy His Dark Materials but I had to separate it from the books and try enjoy it as it’s own thing. Otherwise I’d be sitting muttering ‘well where are all the daemons? Well why isn’t he taller? What happened to x character?’

TheHamburgler · 03/01/2022 03:20

Sorry, do you mean that there was a balloon trip in the David Tenant adaptation (I haven’t seen it)?

DedafalalalalalusBloom · 03/01/2022 03:19

Oh now see I haven't read the book or know anything about the story but really enjoyed it!
By and large though, I've never enjoyed a film or series when I've read the book beforehand. I always want it to be exactly like it is in my head and even the smallest deviation annoys me. ( I'm looking at you, His Dark Materials).

PyongyangKipperbang · 03/01/2022 02:42

I should add that I like DT a lot, he was great in Staged (although the second series was rather tortured) amazing in Good Omens and Broadchurch. Nothing personal against him but it just sort of feels like he had a day dream about what he would like to do and then made it happen.

OP posts: