Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not want to give DP’s son my car

184 replies

Cardilemma · 02/01/2022 20:49

For context;
Been with DP 6 years, we live together and have a joint account for joint finances we pay. Other bills we pay individually and keep what’s left after (much the same). We have one DC together and his DS is 18.

So to the point of the thread..
DP’s son is due to sit his driving test soon. I recently got a new car and still have the old one, it’s not worth much to sell but would give someone a good turn as a first car. DP and I have paid for our own cars separately but are insured to drive each other’s and often do. Technically separate in way of ownership and having paid for but very much used mutually. DP had expressed he would like to give his son the car.

I however don’t. I have a niece similar age who I’m very close to (my twin’s DD) and is also doing her driving lessons but not quite ready for test yet. She has always been a massive part of my life and has also been a huge part of my own DD life, from baby sitting a few hours here and there to taking her out to the park etc. She’s been brilliant with her.

DP’s son on the other hand I’ve never had much a relationship with, he stayed with his dad (and me when we moved in together) every weekend but they two would usually spend weekend out together and I worked shifts so wasn’t always home. We did do somethings together but it was clear he’d rather spend the time at football etc with his dad so I left them to it. He stopped staying regularly when he was about 16 and just started visiting as we only live a bus ride away. He’s never expressed any interested in our DD (which is fine, I get babies and toddlers aren’t usually teenage boy’s thing)

So my dilemma is, I worked hard to pay for that car and if I was to give my car away for free to anyone I would rather it be my DNiece.

AIBU for wanting to say no?

OP posts:
VividImaginationAgain · 02/01/2022 21:53

I agree with those saying sell it and give them something towards a car.

OakPine · 02/01/2022 21:49

Neither. What if you give one of them the car, and heaven forbid, they have an accident in it?
Then you will be worrying that it was your fault.
If you want to be generous, sell the car, give them some money as a present towards a car, once they have passed their tests.

lightisnotwhite · 02/01/2022 21:47

@HollowTalk

This is ridiculous - you don't share your cars and you don't share your spare money. Of course you can give your car to your niece and your partner shouldn't say a word about it. He can buy his son a car if he wants to, given you don't share all your money. He wants the glory of handing over the car without actually paying for it. Stand your ground on this one.
This.

It’s a faff buying a cheap second hand car especially now when there’s a short supply. You don’t share enough of your lives to justify giving it to DSSl

Eddielzzard · 02/01/2022 21:47

You could say something like 'when you brought up your DS's driving test the other day I didn't have a chance to tell you what I've been thinking about doing with my car...' and then tell him about your DN. But I would absolutely check with your sister first in case she's got a plan. You don't want to tell him 'No' if your Dsis doesn't want the car for her DD.

whynotwhatknot · 02/01/2022 21:47

just say you werea saving it for dn its your car not his

JurgensCakeBabyJesus · 02/01/2022 21:46

If the car isn't worth a huge amount and you wouldn't give your own child a car why give it to either of them? Sell it and split the money giving them both a little step up towards their first cars. Even if it's a few hundred pounds each it's a good start.

CreamFirstThenJamOnTop · 02/01/2022 21:46

Yanbu. Myou already had an idea of what you might do with it.

But I’d definitely discuss it with DN in case she already has a plan for her first car. She may not want/need yours. In which case maybe DP could buy yours for his son.

Incidentally, my first car was from my mums twin sister 😊

Obbydoo · 02/01/2022 21:45

Just sell it then problem solved as neither gets it. I would never hand on a car as if anything goes wrong with it (as presumably it will otherwise why have you bought a new one) you will feel guilty.

Sally872 · 02/01/2022 21:44

I can understand your partner thinking it would be good first car for his son as lying spare. When you mention you have plans for it and it is not spare he should not object to that either.

It is a little awkward though for niece to get your car at same time step son also needs one. I would perhaps sell to niece at a good price. Or sell to dh at going rate to gift/sell to son.

maddy68 · 02/01/2022 21:43

Eh???? Give him the bloody car. A step son should be treated the same way as your own child. A niece is way down the list

Nanny0gg · 02/01/2022 21:42

@FindingMeno

Surely its your sibling who is responsible for your neices car, if anyone. I would pass it on to your partners son if it's a ltr.
Why? She's closer to her niece and was never a parent to her partner's son.
Rainbowqueeen · 02/01/2022 21:42

I think your DP is being a bit presumptuous. He should have asked you if you had any plans for the car.

I would stick with your plan of giving it to your niece, subject to her parents approval. Or sell it - the value of second hand cars has risen considerably.

For me it’s a combination of irritation at your DP for just assuming he has control over what you do with your own possessions and women supporting other women - we get the short straw on so many things in life including lower salaries and it sounds like your niece deserves it

Floralnomad · 02/01/2022 21:41

YANBU , but you are wrong about them appreciating the car more if they’ve paid for it - that is totally dependent on the person in question . Our son was given his first car and really appreciated it . Just ask your twin if they want if for your niece .

JohnSmithDrive · 02/01/2022 21:38

These relationships always puzzle me on MN.

To me, you just say "oh, I'd planned to give it to DN", when he mentioned it and open a discussion. I wouldn't want to live with someone I couldn't have that conversation with.

HollowTalk · 02/01/2022 21:36

This is ridiculous - you don't share your cars and you don't share your spare money. Of course you can give your car to your niece and your partner shouldn't say a word about it. He can buy his son a car if he wants to, given you don't share all your money. He wants the glory of handing over the car without actually paying for it. Stand your ground on this one.

thirdfiddle · 02/01/2022 21:34

Running a car as a young person is hideously expensive. Are you sure either of them actually want one let alone this specific one? The cost of the car itself is the smallest part. Insurance is huge. Fuel. Maintenance - old cars often cost 100s a year as various components wear out. Running a car basically not sustainable till you're working FT.

Longdistance · 02/01/2022 21:34

It’s your car, it’s got nothing to do with your dp whatsoever who you give the car to. I hope he hasn’t mentioned it to his ds as it’s not his to give away.

FindingMeno · 02/01/2022 21:32

Surely its your sibling who is responsible for your neices car, if anyone.
I would pass it on to your partners son if it's a ltr.

Witchlight · 02/01/2022 21:31

What about selling it and splitting the proceeds to DN and DSS.

They then have to earn the other half of the car.

Or, tell DP he has to compensate you half the value of the car, if he wants to give it to his DS- you can then donate the half to DN

TakeMe2Insanity · 02/01/2022 21:31

You say the car isn’t worth much, I say go and look on one those sites like webuyanycar and you’ll be shocked at the value! We’ve just a sold a car which pre covid was worth £50, for £400! So definitely look at its current value.

You aren’t being unreasonable at all.

Iloveacurry · 02/01/2022 21:31

If you were to sell, how much would you get? If you don’t give it to your niece, your sister might have something planned herself, can you sell it to your DP for his son?

LuluBlakey1 · 02/01/2022 21:27

Sell it to your niece for less than it is worth eg worth £2000, sell it to her for £500- so she has to save up but you are still helping her. Definitely ask DSis first though.

Ourlady · 02/01/2022 21:27

Your car your choice!

Cardilemma · 02/01/2022 21:22

Have you asked your dtwin if she'd mind if you gave dn the car?
I'd actually be a bit annoyed if my sister gave my dd a car. It's something my kids will have to work towards not just be handed.

I hadn’t actually even thought of this. But I wholeheartedly agree and wouldn’t give my own child their first car for that reason. I do think it’s something that should be worked towards and then it’ll more likely be appreciated and looked after. Food for thought certainly.

OP posts:
BungleandGeorge · 02/01/2022 21:19

How much money is it worth? Maybe ask your partner for whatever you’d have got if you part exchanged? If you’re giving it away I think your child’s sibling should probably be first in the queue. It could also be sat there for months before your niece passed her test (and she may have other plans for a car)