Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men who refuse to marry the mothers of their children

408 replies

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 19:21

You see that so often on here. I don’t mean couples where both parties are happy to marry, but ones where the man refuses despite their partner desperately wanting it, or else strings them along indefinitely.

Is there any reason at all, other than that he doesn’t want to have any duty to provide her with financial security for if they break up? So not only is he already thinking about potentially leaving, he’s happy to fuck over the person he ostensibly currently loves if they do break up.

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it. I suppose the ones being strung along have just been lied to, but having children is actually the bigger commitment in many ways. You’re joined for life. It seems so nasty to be prepared to do that, but not offer your partner the security and commitment they want.

OP posts:
Cameleongirl · 03/01/2022 17:28

Back in 1999, my then-boss, who was about 30, told me that she generally gave bf about a year to propose-if there was no sign of a proposal, she ditched them! She was in a senior position earning six figures and knew exactly what she wanted and knew her own value.

As it happens, she was dating her now-husband at the time and they married in the autumn of 2000. If he hadn’t proposed quickly, he’d have been given the boot.

LittleRoundRobin · 03/01/2022 17:09

@Briony123

Once you have children, it really isn't in the higher earner's interests to wed, in case of divorce. I am baffled by the women who want to get married but move in and/or have children and carry out all wifely duties without being married and yet are then distraught that the man has everything he wants so obviously has no need of a binding legal agreement.
This. ^ And as someone said further back, many men will not marry because they want to leave the door open in case they meet someone better/more suitable. Some women do have babies before their man marries them, because some women are desperate to have babies, and would rather have them without marriage than lose out on motherhood.

I know a woman right now - my friend's daughter aged 29, who has been with her DP for 10 years. He is 30. He flat out has NO intention of marrying her - ever. She said to her mum some 4 years ago (about 6 years after they met,) 'I have mentioned marriage many times over this past year, but he just keeps saying 'one day.....' That's all she ever gets from him. 'one day...' Even 6, 7, 8 years on, she was still getting 'one day...'

Now, they have a house together, (bought it in late 2019,) but the relationship is no further on than it was 10 years ago. Buying a house is not a commitment, it's an investment. So the relationship has not advanced, even remotely.

She has seen friends and colleagues and family members meet a man, get engaged, get married, and have a child, ALL in less time than she has been with this man.

She basically does her own thing now, and goes on trips away, and for nights out with her friends, and does hobbies, and pursues interests without him. He does his own thing too: golf, football, gym, pool, nights out at the pub with his mates 3 or 4 times a month etc... They rarely do anything together, and live completely separate lives. I don't even know why they're together to be honest...

She also says to her mum 'don't get thinking you're going to have a grandchild soon. Ain't gonna happen.' Yet 4 or 5 years ago, (aged 25-ish) she wanted marriage and babies very much. (Clearly trying to convince herself/over-egging the pudding etc...)

Her mum (my friend) said 'fine, I wouldn't want you having babies anyway til you're ready, and you're sure you're with the right man. I'd rather you never have them, than have them with the wrong man.' Her daughter was like Shock when her mum said this.

My friend said she doesn't want her daughter having a baby with this man now, and will actually be gutted if she does now. She doesn't even like him anymore. She liked him to start with, but has gone cool now, as he has clearly been stringing her daughter along for a decade now, and has NO intention of marrying her.

My friend doesn't like his family either, as she's convinced that his mum and dad have put him off marrying her daughter, because the family is wealthy, and my friend is quite poor. No assets, her and her DH on a low income, and they have a poor private pension. She said they were quite friendly at first, but cooled off a bit when they discovered that they lived in rented accommodation and were quite poor.

So my friend's convinced that her daughter's boyfriend's parents could be part of the reason he won't get married to her daughter.

Quite sad to witness really, as this young woman is wasting the best years of her life with a man who will never commit.

MalagaNights · 03/01/2022 15:50

We need to be saying loudly and clearly to young women if you want to be married then make it clear to partners you will not have children until married. Non negotaible.

We've sold young women a lie with the laissez faire it's fine to live together, have a baby and then get married attitude which seems to be prevailing, and it's leaving too many mothers very vulnerable and unhappy.

This is made even harder on young women as men are commiting later and later and the biological clock for women is ticking, which is why I think they have the babies before the men will commit.
Which I understand, becoming a mother is very important to most women.

Feminism has put young women in a bind where they are leaving motherhood late, cannot delay it any longer, alongside everyone living longer and men reaching maturity and readiness for commitment later.

Our biological clocks really work against the modern set up they are sold at the moment.

As an older women I'm having these converstaions as much as I can with younger women who want marriage and children: they need to take agency, use the negotiating power they have (men do want children) to place themselves in strong positions.

No children without marriage.
From 25 years onwards make your position on this clear and don't waste time if he's not on board with this.

Value yourself, what you have to offer a man, and if he doesn't value it move on.

If more women did this the dating 'marketplace' would shift, and women would hold more power within it.

AlDanvers · 03/01/2022 15:21

But the bottom line is that if you expect a woman to give up her job and thus her financial security to care for your children there's a quid pro quo.

The solution is to make it much easier for women to work and support their own children, taking the financial pressure off the man somewhat. But a lot of men are not comfortable with this because it requires a much greater input on their part into childcare and the maintenance of the home. They need to learn that they can't have it both ways.

But this doesn't address that in a lot (I would guess majority) it's the women that want to stay at home or reduce their hours.

Making it easier to work has made someone women feel they can't be at home.

But, yes, if the man is driving the idea of the woman staying home I do think the least he could do it marry her. And vice versa if the roles were reversed.

AlDanvers · 03/01/2022 15:16

@CinnamonJellyBeans

I can't believe some posters are still glibly insisting that you should insist on marriage before kids. Yes, it's the ideal scenario, but you are not taking into account that women have a small window of fertility.

Once you're firmly ensconced in a relationship and you're in your mid twenties, without an agreement to marry, but a mutual desire to have children, it's a hard choice:

Leave, find a man to marry and then have kids? Ideal solution but your eggs could get past their use-by date

Stay, have kids and hope for marriage? Puts you in financial jeopardy but at least you have a better chance of offspring.

I think you are missing alot.

So the woman really wants marriage and he doesn't, so have kids anyway? Don't worry that you have 2 different plans for your lives, think abut eventual resentment and/or compatibility.

But also, you say its a hard choice. It's is hard. Bit it's still a choice. If you would rather have kids with someone who doesn't share your vision of your future lives, than risk not having them at all.....then that's the choice you make.

vivainsomnia · 03/01/2022 14:57

But marriage is literally about security
It's always security for the higher earner. It just happens to be more often men. When it's women, they ARE advised not to marry just in case because they deserve to keep what they've worked hard to build.

But the bottom line is that if you expect a woman to give up her job and thus her financial security to care for your children there's a quid pro quo
My experience is that it's much more often women who want to give up their job especially when lower earning than their partners. At least after the kids start school. I had a number of male colleagues frustrated because their wife/partner only wanted to work minimum hours or not at all once the kids were in school despite them helping at home.

I think situations when the man is the main earner and the woman the low or no earner come in many different shapes and forms and not always the stereotype portrayed here of the wife unable to work because she has to look after the kids and her partner doesn't want to work because he doesn't want to do anything to do with the house and kids.

Cameleongirl · 03/01/2022 14:45

But marriage is literally about security: that's all its about.

It really isn't. Yes, it's a legal contract, but it's also a public declaration of your commitment to that person. Of course, you absolutely don't need to make that declaration to be committed, but it's important to some people.

The fight for gay marriage is a prime example, IMO. Yes, it was about having the same legal rights as a hetro married couple, but it was also about being able to publicly declare your relationship, without shame or stigma -and that's a very new thing in our society.

I apologize if I've got this wrong, but that's how I viewed it.

LuaDipa · 03/01/2022 14:27

@Porcupineintherough

I dont really think anyone should be forced to marry against their will, male or female.

That said I wouldnt have set up as a common law wife with anyone, and even less so as I wanted children. And that I think is the answer. If marriage is important to you dont settle for less in a relationship.

This.

Not marrying is a valid choice for either party. But it’s wrong to string someone along on a promise for years. I also can’t understand why people don’t make their wishes/plans for the future clear at the outset of a relationship, and most importantly refuse to settle for less, in case they scare someone off. Surely if you want different things there is no future anyway.

Marriage was important to me personally so I told dh that very early on and he proposed very early on. We married in our early twenties and only moved in together 4 months before the wedding. If I’d told him I wanted marriage and he’d run a mile, I would have known it was a non-starter and moved on to the next one. As it was, he said he knew I was the one and he wanted the same.

There is nothing wrong with asking for what you want and I find it terrifying that so many people, particularly women, have such low self esteem that they are afraid to express their wants and needs and end up in shitty situations that only benefit their partner.

MoreAloneTime · 03/01/2022 13:36

I do agree that whatever a woman chooses whether that's to have a baby unmarried or hold out for marriage knowing fertility declines with age it's always better for it to be an informed choice. It's not great how many people passively sleepwalk into giving up jobs or paying off mortgages for men that won't marry them.

Iamthewombat · 03/01/2022 13:09

And yes, I know that some women are higher earners than their partners. They are the minority, though, and we all know it.

How many threads do we see on here where a woman has compromised her career, or worse still given it up to care for children, and isn’t married although she would like to be? The man, in most of these cases, has given vague assurances of marriage ‘some time in the future’ but later becomes evasive and resorts to the “just a piece of paper” and “aren’t we fine as we are?” arguments.

In the very worst cases, the woman isn’t on the deeds to the house and is extremely vulnerable.

ComtesseDeSpair · 03/01/2022 13:07

Once you're firmly ensconced in a relationship and you're in your mid twenties, without an agreement to marry, but a mutual desire to have children, it's a hard choice:

I’m not sure there’s any way around this. Life isn’t fair, sometimes you can’t always have exactly what you want when you want it, and sometimes the choices are difficult. Difficult choices don’t excuse you from making good choices. If motherhood is your priority over marriage then surely part of being a good mother is ensuring you could provide the best family for your child even if your relationship doesn’t work out - not simply hoping that things will work out and doing quite frankly dumb stuff like giving up your career and, when things don’t work out, acting as though you never had any real choice in how you did things.

Iamthewombat · 03/01/2022 13:06

I can't believe some posters are still glibly insisting that you should insist on marriage before kids. Yes, it's the ideal scenario, but you are not taking into account that women have a small window of fertility.

Can’t you? If marriage is important to you, then it is perfectly reasonable to take the position that you won’t be having children until you are married.

The thing I find difficult to believe is that anybody would think, “ooh, biological clock, tick tock, I know, I’ll put myself into the power of a man who won’t marry me and has one foot out of the door then spend the next twenty years unhappily hoping for a proposal”.

G5000 · 03/01/2022 12:56

Stay, have kids and hope for marriage? Puts you in financial jeopardy but at least you have a better chance of offspring.

Well in mid-20s I'd go. Mid-30s, if everything else is fine, stay. But insist on having childcare and housework shared equally, make sure you do not give up your career and earning potential and don't add all the wifework to your workload. Oh and give the children your name, of course

CinnamonJellyBeans · 03/01/2022 12:55

Yes indeed @thepeopleversuswork

Do not reduce working hours, pension contributions or pay > 50% childcare. Do not take a less good job that offers child-friendly hours so you can do the pick ups, drop off and holiday care.

TrishM80 · 03/01/2022 12:53

[quote LuluBlakey1]@TrishM80 'Aw, what a beautiful romantic story.....!'

Not.[/quote]
That's kinda what I was getting at.....!

thepeopleversuswork · 03/01/2022 12:52

@CinnamonJellyBeans

If "offspring" is what you want above all else and your partner won't marry you then the choice is to leave and go it alone or stay but insist on continuing to work. In this scenario a woman should never stop work.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 03/01/2022 12:43

I can't believe some posters are still glibly insisting that you should insist on marriage before kids. Yes, it's the ideal scenario, but you are not taking into account that women have a small window of fertility.

Once you're firmly ensconced in a relationship and you're in your mid twenties, without an agreement to marry, but a mutual desire to have children, it's a hard choice:

Leave, find a man to marry and then have kids? Ideal solution but your eggs could get past their use-by date

Stay, have kids and hope for marriage? Puts you in financial jeopardy but at least you have a better chance of offspring.

DrSbaitso · 03/01/2022 12:35

@BillSmithson

I didn't want to get married. Personally I thought it was a lot of faf and money for one day. The planning consumed our lives at one point and we went into quite a bit of debt afterwards which really impacted the next few years of our lives. Was nothing to do with not wanting to provide my now-wife with security.
You didn't need to have a big expensive wedding if you didn't want one.
MimiDaisy11 · 03/01/2022 12:33

@BillSmithson

I didn't want to get married. Personally I thought it was a lot of faf and money for one day. The planning consumed our lives at one point and we went into quite a bit of debt afterwards which really impacted the next few years of our lives. Was nothing to do with not wanting to provide my now-wife with security.
You don't need all that to get married. I know people who went to the registry office wearing casual jeans and t-shirt and just had their parents there for witnesses.
thepeopleversuswork · 03/01/2022 12:03

@vivainsomnia

The problem with men is when their partner become so fixated about it, it inevitably raise the 1ueatiin whether they want marriage more for their own security and comfort than their love for him, and therefore lead them to question how committed they are and whether they might just go with half the assets he mainly or solely brought to then go for a man she truly loves.

If you start questioning the main incentive that leads your partner push for marriage, it's not surprising it ends up making them reticent.

But marriage is literally about security: that's all its about. I can understand men being apprehensive about being taken to the cleaners in a divorce. That's why so many of them don't want to do it.

But the bottom line is that if you expect a woman to give up her job and thus her financial security to care for your children there's a quid pro quo.

The solution is to make it much easier for women to work and support their own children, taking the financial pressure off the man somewhat. But a lot of men are not comfortable with this because it requires a much greater input on their part into childcare and the maintenance of the home. They need to learn that they can't have it both ways.

G5000 · 03/01/2022 11:46

Getting married and having a massive wedding with a huge loan are 2 totally different things.

BillSmithson · 03/01/2022 11:44

I didn't want to get married. Personally I thought it was a lot of faf and money for one day. The planning consumed our lives at one point and we went into quite a bit of debt afterwards which really impacted the next few years of our lives. Was nothing to do with not wanting to provide my now-wife with security.

vivainsomnia · 03/01/2022 11:07

The problem with men is when their partner become so fixated about it, it inevitably raise the 1ueatiin whether they want marriage more for their own security and comfort than their love for him, and therefore lead them to question how committed they are and whether they might just go with half the assets he mainly or solely brought to then go for a man she truly loves.

If you start questioning the main incentive that leads your partner push for marriage, it's not surprising it ends up making them reticent.

Iamthewombat · 03/01/2022 10:56

@georgarina

I have an uncle like this. My aunt has three children with him, they've been together for around 20 years, live together, and she once even bought herself a ring and a wedding dress. But he refused to propose. Just avoided it, even though she so desperately wanted it and once threatened to leave. I really have no idea why.
Do you really have no idea why he didn’t want to marry your aunt?

The answer is obvious. He doesn’t love her enough to want to marry her and thinks that somebody better will come along. Sorry to be blunt.

user1958493 · 03/01/2022 10:45

@Comtesse

The bigger issue is giving up work or reducing your hours when not married but have children. That just seems so unwise…..
Lol