Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men who refuse to marry the mothers of their children

408 replies

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 19:21

You see that so often on here. I don’t mean couples where both parties are happy to marry, but ones where the man refuses despite their partner desperately wanting it, or else strings them along indefinitely.

Is there any reason at all, other than that he doesn’t want to have any duty to provide her with financial security for if they break up? So not only is he already thinking about potentially leaving, he’s happy to fuck over the person he ostensibly currently loves if they do break up.

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it. I suppose the ones being strung along have just been lied to, but having children is actually the bigger commitment in many ways. You’re joined for life. It seems so nasty to be prepared to do that, but not offer your partner the security and commitment they want.

OP posts:
Seren85 · 03/01/2022 23:17

I was very glad I was married when my husband died. Because it meant I was the person the police came to, I got to make all the funeral decisions. I've see so many young women who lost partners be utterly frozen out of everything, every decision, even with kids etc. We'd named each other as beneficiaries when we moved in together so it wasn't about the money but it certainly made the whole sadmin process easier with a wedding certificate. I married for love and nothing else at 29 but widowed at 34 meant it was also a very sensible decision. However, I will never remarry. My house, my money, my pension. I can see why people choose not too. I also very much love my 'Chapter 2' as is the usual term. But I won't lose the pension my LH wanted me to have for him.

MalagaNights · 03/01/2022 23:08

@mathanxiety I agree with most of what you've said. I'm using feminism in a very broad sense to refer to the modern circumstances of high education, career and late motherhood you describe, and the unresolved issues women are faced with as a consequence.

Although statistically it is likely to be younger less educated women who not getting married. And those who feel the lack of protection it brings even more.
I've seen this described as the result of 'luxury beliefs' they're told marriage is just a piece of paper if he loves you. Which educated women think in their 20s, but don't have kids and in their 30s realise marriage has all sorts of benefits.
So they get married later, at a higher rate, and younger less educated women are suffering the consequences of the romantic lies they were sold.

I do think women have been sold a lie and they need to wake up to the reality of fertility windows and the vulnerability inherent in pregnancy and child care roles.

Women need to make good informed decisions for themselves. And not pretend lack of legal commitment when you (for most women) become vulnerable, is not a problem.

@AlfonsoTheGoat 🤣🤣 how well argued.
You've convinced me I'm stupid 🤣🤣.

SammyScrounge · 03/01/2022 22:25

@StoneofDestiny

Women don't have to have children with men before they commit to marriage. Their choice, it's not inflicted upon them.
Trust is the problem. Women trust too much.
Notbluepeter · 03/01/2022 21:46

@CinnamonJellyBeans

To the women on here (smugly) telling us how they got married before children and asking why don't we all do the same: I'll bet all of you were actually asked by your husband to get married before you seriously wanted to have a baby with him.

A lot of couples move in together once they have been dating a while. Convention dictates that the women has to be passive about marriage and wait and wait some more to be asked while her eggs get older. The proposal appears to be the man committing himself to the woman, rather than a mutual decision.

However, having a baby together is usually a mutual decision, so it's deemed acceptable for the woman to broach the subject and persuade the man. It seems to me that it's easier to get his DNA than a proposal.

We need to change our daughters' mindset: You can discuss marriage and insist upon if if you are a woman. Do not wait for him like a book on a shelf. You are a valuable, smart and talented person. If he's not thrilled at the thought of having you forever, dump his ass. Do not idealise big proposals, expensive engagement rings or fancy weddings that let a man put off the proposal while he waits for the right time or saves the money.

@CinnamonJellyBeans Very well put. I proposed to my DH. But I am the only women to have done so out of my friend groups. We need a paradigm shift. That for some reason feminism has not brought about.
KineticSand · 03/01/2022 21:07

If I was to marry the father of my DC, I would be worse off if we divorced than if we stay as we are. We have a joint mortgage and each will get the house if the other dies first, and have named each other as pension beneficiaries. That's sensible and is a financial commitment to each other.

We split parental leave and we split child rearing and domestic work 50/50. We pay into the home coffers according to our income (mine is and always has been more).

The above I describe negates the advantages of marriage, because we are equals and each contributes according to our means and abilities. I think this is a better recipe for equality than insisting on marriage for all.

AlfonsoTheGoat · 03/01/2022 20:54

@MalagaNights

We need to be saying loudly and clearly to young women if you want to be married then make it clear to partners you will not have children until married. Non negotaible.

We've sold young women a lie with the laissez faire it's fine to live together, have a baby and then get married attitude which seems to be prevailing, and it's leaving too many mothers very vulnerable and unhappy.

This is made even harder on young women as men are commiting later and later and the biological clock for women is ticking, which is why I think they have the babies before the men will commit.
Which I understand, becoming a mother is very important to most women.

Feminism has put young women in a bind where they are leaving motherhood late, cannot delay it any longer, alongside everyone living longer and men reaching maturity and readiness for commitment later.

Our biological clocks really work against the modern set up they are sold at the moment.

As an older women I'm having these converstaions as much as I can with younger women who want marriage and children: they need to take agency, use the negotiating power they have (men do want children) to place themselves in strong positions.

No children without marriage.
From 25 years onwards make your position on this clear and don't waste time if he's not on board with this.

Value yourself, what you have to offer a man, and if he doesn't value it move on.

If more women did this the dating 'marketplace' would shift, and women would hold more power within it.

That post is full of mistruths, misperceptions and failures of logic and reasoning. It deserves some kind of stupidity prize.
FanGirlX · 03/01/2022 20:34

[quote LittleRoundRobin]@FanGirlX

And this is why I'm so happy I didn't marry ex DP, even though he is DD's father. DD and I get to keep my house, salary, savings and pension.

Bully for you.

However, Many women don't have the luxury of already having their own house, and a sturdy pension, along with 'savings,' and a good salary - and especially when they have children. You are the exception rather than the rule.[/quote]
Feminism in action there.

I planned for mine and DDs future, before I chose to have her. Why do you have an issue with that?

FanGirlX · 03/01/2022 20:32

@ComtesseDeSpair

I think I must live in the same "bubble" which is women who have worked during their 20s, bought a home, started savings and pensions, had children in their 30s and crucially, not given up work to be a SAHP.

ComtesseDeSpair · 03/01/2022 20:11

[quote mathanxiety]@ComtesseDeSpair, you live in a bubble.[/quote]
That genuinely surprises me. I’d assume that most people partner with people similar to themselves, so can’t see why men and women in relationships would have such disparate backgrounds and jobs that the man would have everything and the woman nothing when they met.

mathanxiety · 03/01/2022 19:59

@ComtesseDeSpair, you live in a bubble.

mathanxiety · 03/01/2022 19:59

Feminism has put young women in a bind where they are leaving motherhood late, cannot delay it any longer, alongside everyone living longer and men reaching maturity and readiness for commitment later.

@MalagaNights, I agree with most of what you said. The general gist of it is an exhortation for women to be made aware that they can set rules and should be encouraged to be willing to wield the power that they have.

I disagree that it's feminism that has created the world women must now navigate, though. The tendency to ignore the necessity for someone to take care of babies and children isn't something feminism is guilty of.

It's to a large extent capitalism and the fundamentally misogynistic mindset that underpins all of western culture that has got women into the almost impossible position they now find themselves in. If they have babies in their late teens they often have to forget about third level education. If they have babies in their 20s their careers flounder. Waiting until their 30s means making sure they have the right man and all their ducks in a row financially so that they can take a career break if they want to SAHM for a while, or a high enough salary to hire someone to do childcare and give them the flexibility to fulfill the often insane demands of their workplace. My DD1 is 31 and three out of four of her friends who recently got married have had prenups.

I know many women who started out as high-flying lawyers in leading firms who are now teachers. Ironically, I also know a few women who started out as secretaries or receptionists who are now earning more than the former lawyers because they eventually trained as dental hygienists or ultrasound techs.

The messages we give young women are often based on a myth that there can be such a thing as Happily Ever After - there is a narrative in which the heroine works hard in school, gets into the great university, progresses to the high status career, and all the factors working against her will be vanquished. Having It All is a fairy tale where good triumphs. The advice is not always practical or sensible, and it doesn't take biological reality or the nature of the system they live in into account.

ComtesseDeSpair · 03/01/2022 19:57

[quote LittleRoundRobin]@FanGirlX

And this is why I'm so happy I didn't marry ex DP, even though he is DD's father. DD and I get to keep my house, salary, savings and pension.

Bully for you.

However, Many women don't have the luxury of already having their own house, and a sturdy pension, along with 'savings,' and a good salary - and especially when they have children. You are the exception rather than the rule.[/quote]
Why would a woman having her own home, good salary, pension and savings prior to marriage and children be an exception rather than a rule? Maybe I live in a bubble, but all the women I know have or had these things. Yes, the gender pay gap exists; and yes, women are more likely than men to jack their careers in after they become parents, but there’s no organic reason nowadays why men and women of the same age should have vastly different financial circumstances when they arrive at the point of decking to have a family.

LittleRoundRobin · 03/01/2022 19:37

@FanGirlX

And this is why I'm so happy I didn't marry ex DP, even though he is DD's father. DD and I get to keep my house, salary, savings and pension.

Bully for you.

However, Many women don't have the luxury of already having their own house, and a sturdy pension, along with 'savings,' and a good salary - and especially when they have children. You are the exception rather than the rule.

DrSbaitso · 03/01/2022 19:33

[quote thepeopleversuswork]@DrSbaitso

Grin You literally couldn't make people like that up.[/quote]
The more I think about it, the more sure I am that somebody did!

It was done well, though, I grant you. The mentions of the Aga and wines were dripped in as they lost more ground (there was actually a thread at the same time about Agas being shite...no offence to anyone who has one or likes them), and the snooty "oh I am so above this conversation, it's just something to entertain me while I sip my Dom Perignon" was very convincing.

thepeopleversuswork · 03/01/2022 19:29

@DrSbaitso

Grin You literally couldn't make people like that up.

AlDanvers · 03/01/2022 19:28

But she wasn't the only one that had that train of thought. Yes she was ridiculous but by far nit the only one who thinks a woman should have a right to stay at home, regardless of what the OH feels about it

DrSbaitso · 03/01/2022 19:23

There was a thread here a while ago (last few months) where the op wanted to stay at home. Her OH didn't agree.

There were many posters that claim it was a biological need and of a man didn't want to give his wife that opportunity he was 'a failure as a man'.

I know. I argued with them. One of the ones who kept saying every man had an obligation to support a SAHM kept dropping mentions of her Aga and expensive wines. I thought at first she was just an idiot who didn't realise she was showing up how little she knew about money and real life. Then I thought she was just trying to make herself look rich as consolation for losing the argument. Then, after reiterating that all women should be at home for precious child time, she said her kids were boarders but she saw them loads, every two weeks. At that point I realised she was either a troll or criminally thick. Either way, she wasn't convincing anyone except one other loony.

I do believe she was on the wine, though.

thepeopleversuswork · 03/01/2022 19:13

@AlDanvers

I remember that thread. It was quite an eye-opener. One poster in particular insisting the DH was abusive because he wasn't prepared to finance his wife to stay at home forever.

Some women do think they have a right to be totally supported but I think more often than not its a toxic combination of the fact it suits the bloke in the short term to have someone at home doing the stuff he can't be bothered to do and the woman's unwillingness to rock the boat and point out that he needs to get involved on the home front if she is to be financially independent. It's cock up rather than conspiracy.

AlDanvers · 03/01/2022 18:47

@DrSbaitso

Being a SAHP is supposed to be a joint decision. I'd hope that if someone became one, the working parent would be on board with that and want to ensure they were protected.

If they're not, and the other one becomes a SAHP anyway - effectively making a unilateral life decision that ought to be made consensually between them both - that's a more serious issue.

There was a thread here a while ago (last few months) where the op wanted to stay at home. Her OH didn't agree.

There were many posters that claim it was a biological need and of a man didn't want to give his wife that opportunity he was 'a failure as a man'.

Its not that uncommon for women to believe they have a right to it.

My point isn't that 'oh women are awful' vut that often the decision to stay at home is driven by the women, not men. As the original comment quoted was saying.

DrSbaitso · 03/01/2022 18:41

Being a SAHP is supposed to be a joint decision. I'd hope that if someone became one, the working parent would be on board with that and want to ensure they were protected.

If they're not, and the other one becomes a SAHP anyway - effectively making a unilateral life decision that ought to be made consensually between them both - that's a more serious issue.

AlDanvers · 03/01/2022 18:35

[quote thepeopleversuswork]@AlDanvers

But this doesn't address that in a lot (I would guess majority) it's the women that want to stay at home or reduce their hours.

That may be true but its cultural and the rest of millennia of societal expectation. It's not in anyone's interest to remain at home with children beyond the point where children go to school. Why do you think so few men want to do it? They understand that it leaves them dangerously exposed.[/quote]
Yes. I know its a society issue and needs addressing.

That includes women. I agree it's not in anyone's interests to stay at home long term, unless independently wealthy.

However, I don't believe that men on the whole drive the need to have a sahp. Its driven by mainly women. So my point is that just because someone is a sahp, I don't think it's right to say the man must marry them.

FanGirlX · 03/01/2022 18:14

@Comedycook

Your op is fundamentally sexist as it seems to presume the man is always the one who is better off financially. I know plenty of couples who have got together and the woman has owned property while the man has been renting previously.
And this is why I'm so happy I didn't marry ex DP, even though he is DD's father. DD and I get to keep my house, salary, savings and pension.
DemBonesDemBones · 03/01/2022 18:01

There are lots of reasons people don't marry, but your comment about not understanding why women tolerate it struck me. Not everyone has an upbringing which makes them feel 'worthy' or 'good enough'. I am married now but for a long time I didn't even contemplate it because I didn't see the point. Everybody left. Parents, partners. Looking back, I didn't feel people like me ' deserved' to be married-I should be happy with my lot.
I've been happily married for almost 10 years now and I totally understand why it's a great idea. But I still understand those who don't.

AlfonsoTheGoat · 03/01/2022 17:56

They made a choice to have children without being married.

thepeopleversuswork · 03/01/2022 17:38

@AlDanvers

But this doesn't address that in a lot (I would guess majority) it's the women that want to stay at home or reduce their hours.

That may be true but its cultural and the rest of millennia of societal expectation. It's not in anyone's interest to remain at home with children beyond the point where children go to school. Why do you think so few men want to do it? They understand that it leaves them dangerously exposed.