Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men who refuse to marry the mothers of their children

408 replies

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 19:21

You see that so often on here. I don’t mean couples where both parties are happy to marry, but ones where the man refuses despite their partner desperately wanting it, or else strings them along indefinitely.

Is there any reason at all, other than that he doesn’t want to have any duty to provide her with financial security for if they break up? So not only is he already thinking about potentially leaving, he’s happy to fuck over the person he ostensibly currently loves if they do break up.

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it. I suppose the ones being strung along have just been lied to, but having children is actually the bigger commitment in many ways. You’re joined for life. It seems so nasty to be prepared to do that, but not offer your partner the security and commitment they want.

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 04/01/2022 14:10

But you'd have to have been living under a rock not to have noticed that there are some men who expect this
I totally agree with SOME men, but this thread would like everyone to believe that those who are not are rare.

The PP said specifically her son shouldn't marry unless there is 100% commitment. I believe the same goes with kids. If a guy wants kids but insists on not marrying - bin him
I believe the same goes with kids too but you don't have to be married to be 100% committed to your children.

My dd wants kids, commitment but not marriage. Not all young women aspire for marriage.

G5000 · 04/01/2022 14:09

I also find it interesting that when mentioning household tasks on mn, DIY, repairs, gardening, etc...is never mentioned, despite being tasks more traditional taken on by men.

Oh I see it all the time. 'Well yes I do all the cooking cleaning laundry admin and childcare, but DH is really good, he changed a light bulb last year and once put an IKEA Malm together, so I can't complain really..'

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 14:02

@vivainsomnia

The way that often manifests itself of course is in men expecting family stuff (childcare/cooking/cleaning/life admin/school admin) to just magically get done by women Threads like this really show what cultural divides there are. The above is absolutely nothing I've experienced. All 4 of my grandparents work and even then, my grandfathers did housework and were much involved with their children. Same with my parents, and what I experienced with my ex and his parents, my current partner and his family, my friends, colleagues etc...

I also find it interesting that when mentioning household tasks on mn, DIY, repairs, gardening, etc...is never mentioned, despite being tasks more traditional taken on by men.

Plenty of women garden, including on here.

DIY etc is more of a "one off" with a visible, permanent result. Making dinner, cleaning the bathroom etc is "invisible work" that you often don't notice until it doesn't get done. It's domestic everyday drudgery.

My father would never lift a finger for said drudgery, but when he fitted a doorbell and some coving, we never stopped hearing about it.

CatsArePeople · 04/01/2022 13:59

Do you really believe a relationship isn't committed if there's no marriage?

The PP said specifically her son shouldn't marry unless there is 100% commitment. I believe the same goes with kids. If a guy wants kids but insists on not marrying - bin him.

thepeopleversuswork · 04/01/2022 13:37

@vivainsomnia

I'm not saying that this is what all the men in my life expect. And I wouldn't tolerate this.

But you'd have to have been living under a rock not to have noticed that there are some men who expect this.

ohdelay · 04/01/2022 13:36

@Crazykatie

How many men actually want children?, or do they just accept that the woman wants children, in a great many cases men don’t take much part in child care. Personally I don’t think most men are bothered much with children, they do what is needed to keep the woman happy, most of the time.
I agree and am yet to meet a man who decided he wanted a baby in his relationship to make it that bit better. Most see them as ruining it, less sex, less freedom, less money, less fun, less partner. A lot will bond with the child once it's here and older and interesting, but very few actively want them.
vivainsomnia · 04/01/2022 13:20

The way that often manifests itself of course is in men expecting family stuff (childcare/cooking/cleaning/life admin/school admin) to just magically get done by women
Threads like this really show what cultural divides there are. The above is absolutely nothing I've experienced. All 4 of my grandparents work and even then, my grandfathers did housework and were much involved with their children. Same with my parents, and what I experienced with my ex and his parents, my current partner and his family, my friends, colleagues etc...

I also find it interesting that when mentioning household tasks on mn, DIY, repairs, gardening, etc...is never mentioned, despite being tasks more traditional taken on by men.

Blossomtoes · 04/01/2022 13:09

@MalagaNights

We need to be saying loudly and clearly to young women if you want to be married then make it clear to partners you will not have children until married. Non negotaible.

We've sold young women a lie with the laissez faire it's fine to live together, have a baby and then get married attitude which seems to be prevailing, and it's leaving too many mothers very vulnerable and unhappy.

This is made even harder on young women as men are commiting later and later and the biological clock for women is ticking, which is why I think they have the babies before the men will commit.
Which I understand, becoming a mother is very important to most women.

Feminism has put young women in a bind where they are leaving motherhood late, cannot delay it any longer, alongside everyone living longer and men reaching maturity and readiness for commitment later.

Our biological clocks really work against the modern set up they are sold at the moment.

As an older women I'm having these converstaions as much as I can with younger women who want marriage and children: they need to take agency, use the negotiating power they have (men do want children) to place themselves in strong positions.

No children without marriage.
From 25 years onwards make your position on this clear and don't waste time if he's not on board with this.

Value yourself, what you have to offer a man, and if he doesn't value it move on.

If more women did this the dating 'marketplace' would shift, and women would hold more power within it.

Contrary to a previous opinion, I think you’ve nailed it @MalagaNights. I can see that it would make some people feel very uncomfortable though.
thepeopleversuswork · 04/01/2022 13:03

@DrSbaitso

Also, for all the ideas that women are incomplete without a man and defined by their relationships, I've found that men are really, really bad at being alone. Not many can do it. That's why they're content to coast in relationships. I also think it's one reason why there's always been an avalanche of porn of all grades, wherever the medium is. It's partly horniness, and depending on the context it could be misogynistic disrespect, but I truly think a lot of it is down to men simply craving female company and not doing well without it. For many men, their only real, complete confidante and emotional support is their female partner. They're just not good at being alone.
Totally agree with this. And I think its more than being "horny" or wanting female company or a confidante: I think most men have some deeply ingrained view that women create the basic structure of the family and thus of society too. They feel instinctively that you need women to keep things ticking over and stop the world going a bit Lord of the Flies.

The way that often manifests itself of course is in men expecting family stuff (childcare/cooking/cleaning/life admin/school admin) to just magically get done by women.

If channeled properly this can lead to deep and fulfilling relationships between men and women and a proper appreciation of what women bring to the table. If not it just leads to men coasting while women do all the dog work.

G5000 · 04/01/2022 13:01

There are a lot of people living hand to mouth for whom its almost impossible to plan financially.

Absolutely. But those people are not exclusively women. Young women are outperforming and out-earning young men nowadays. They should think carefully before deciding to throw in the towel and take a little part time job so they have time to also iron husband's socks.

AlDanvers · 04/01/2022 12:36

@CatsArePeople

This is exactly what I'm warning my son about.

So you want your son to go on impregnating women with zero comittment? Nice one.

Do you really believe a relationship isn't committed if there's no marriage?
DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 12:15

In the animal world passing on genes is the main driver for sex, humans are much more varied, probably pleasure, emotion and companionship are more important.

I agree, but I still maintain that most men want children even if they don't want to be primary caregivers or get married.

Crazykatie · 04/01/2022 12:09

@DrSbaitso

No, most men want children. They may not want to be primary caregivers, but they want their genes passed on.

Hence the phenomenon of the pusillanimous twat who coasts along with the woman he doesn't really love, claiming marriage is just a piece of paper and he doesn't want kids...and as soon as she ages out of her window and he actually realises that to stay with her really does mean no kids, he ditches her and finds a younger woman for marriage and children.

Men can seem more careless about it because they don't have the same window that women have, but most of them want children.

In the animal world passing on genes is the main driver for sex, humans are much more varied, probably pleasure, emotion and companionship are more important. In many species the male plays no part except impregnating the female
thepeopleversuswork · 04/01/2022 12:06

@LittleRoundRobin

This 100%.The ignorance and lack of awareness and narrow-mindedness, from a small bunch of posters on here is utterly breath-taking. So much privilege that they cannot see outside their own hugely over-privileged bubble.

There are some very privileged people on here and yes sometimes people have difficulty understanding that for women to be able to support themselves can be hard. There are a lot of people living hand to mouth for whom its almost impossible to plan financially.

But that doesn't mean we shouldn't aspire to it or teach our daughters to pursue it and it doesn't mean we should just give and and resign ourselves to being at the mercy of men. Your posts seem quite defeatist, as if anyone who is aspiring to financial independence is some Ivory Tower-inhabiting princess and not qualified to comment at all.

Financial independence doesn't need to mean having a trust fund or a huge salaried job in the City. It means having a job, even a poorly-paid job is better than nothing, some savings, a pension and some ability to support yourself if the worst should happen.

Every woman should have some means of supporting herself if the chips are down and every woman should teach their daughter this, rather than simply rushing to get married as early as possible. Marriage is a useful insurance policy but it should not be the sole financial gameplan for a woman.

I don't think you have to be super privileged to understand the importance of this.

vivainsomnia · 04/01/2022 11:27

So you want your son to go on impregnating women with zero comittment? Nice one
Haha, yes, that's exactly what I want HmmHmm

What I want is him to commit to a woman who is interested in him as awhile person before what he can give her in marriage.

That marriage should be about love and complete commitment, and a two way street, not about being pressured because one person feels vulnerable without it.

As for children, the main consideration is when he is ready to love and provide 50% of the care, including the not fun part of it.

BobMortimersPetOwl · 04/01/2022 11:10

Its absolutely fine for anybody to decide they don't want to marry, for whatever reason.

Everybody needs to take responsibility for themselves as an individual, so if that means not having children with somebody until you're married in order to have adequate protection then that's what you do.

CatsArePeople · 04/01/2022 11:03

This is exactly what I'm warning my son about.

So you want your son to go on impregnating women with zero comittment? Nice one.

LittleRoundRobin · 04/01/2022 11:02

@ComtesseDeSpair

Why would a woman having her own home, good salary, pension and savings prior to marriage and children be an exception rather than a rule?

@mathanxiety

You are overlooking the millions of people who live hand to mouth, rent their humble abodes, get paid by the hour, have no pensions apart from state entitlements, and they have zero in savings because everything is more expensive when you're poor.

If you are not aware of the reality of life for millions of other people then you live in a bubble.

This 100%.The ignorance and lack of awareness and narrow-mindedness, from a small bunch of posters on here is utterly breath-taking. So much privilege that they cannot see outside their own hugely over-privileged bubble.

I suppose they will come out with some shit like 'these poor folk shoulda worked harder and got a good education like me then.' That's one of the stock phrases from some yummy mummies and over privileged women on here.

The ignorance, lack of emotional intelligence, and sheer lack of compassion or understanding for anyone who is less fortunate than them makes me so angry that I rarely respond to their posts.

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 10:40

Also, for all the ideas that women are incomplete without a man and defined by their relationships, I've found that men are really, really bad at being alone. Not many can do it. That's why they're content to coast in relationships. I also think it's one reason why there's always been an avalanche of porn of all grades, wherever the medium is. It's partly horniness, and depending on the context it could be misogynistic disrespect, but I truly think a lot of it is down to men simply craving female company and not doing well without it. For many men, their only real, complete confidante and emotional support is their female partner. They're just not good at being alone.

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 10:34

No, most men want children. They may not want to be primary caregivers, but they want their genes passed on.

Hence the phenomenon of the pusillanimous twat who coasts along with the woman he doesn't really love, claiming marriage is just a piece of paper and he doesn't want kids...and as soon as she ages out of her window and he actually realises that to stay with her really does mean no kids, he ditches her and finds a younger woman for marriage and children.

Men can seem more careless about it because they don't have the same window that women have, but most of them want children.

Crazykatie · 04/01/2022 10:08

How many men actually want children?, or do they just accept that the woman wants children, in a great many cases men don’t take much part in child care.
Personally I don’t think most men are bothered much with children, they do what is needed to keep the woman happy, most of the time.

MorningStarling · 04/01/2022 09:54

Women have the sole power to decide whether to keep the child or have an abortion. I don't have much sympathy for women who end up in the plight the OP describes because they had the power to decide not to fall into this trap. I agree with the OP that it's hard to understand why any woman would make this mistake, given how much evidence there is of it happening time and time again, always with bad outcomes.

I don't like the argument that women are "tricked" or "manipulated" into thinking the man will stick with them forever if he can't be arsed to marry them. I think that's quite an offensive argument, misogynistic even, it suggests that women are inherently stupid and are easily controlled by the most pathetic of men.

flowerbubbles · 04/01/2022 09:39

I think if a woman wants to get married they should just get it done before having dc.
That way they know if a man wants this too or not before they're committed in other ways. It's easy to sell a house if you find out later down the line a man doesn't want to get married. A lot easier situation to move on from than having dc and I never know why women do this if they want to get married. Marriage should always be a choice not one someone is coerced or feels obliged to happen.

vivainsomnia · 04/01/2022 07:59

As an older women I'm having these converstaions as much as I can with younger women who want marriage and children: they need to take agency, use the negotiating power they have (men do want children) to place themselves in strong positions
You mean approach marriage and the relationship behind it like a business venture? And then if it fails, ditch it, get what you can from it and start another one?

This is exactly what I'm warning my son about. My dd has made it clear she will never marry. She is independent, on an excellent career path and don't need supporting. She will work and have kids.

I have told my ds that he should only marry if he is 100% certain he is fully committed and so is she, and they have already discussed at length their plans for the future, and they are totally in agreement. Ideally marry a woman who is independent, enjoy working and is prepared to approach the marriage in an equal footing where they both take on roles of financial provider and provider to the kids and home.

mathanxiety · 04/01/2022 00:15

@ComtesseDeSpair
I’d assume that most people partner with people similar to themselves, so can’t see why men and women in relationships would have such disparate backgrounds and jobs that the man would have everything and the woman nothing when they met.

You don't need disparate jobs or backgrounds to end up with a huge imbalance in power and potential. A man who works the checkout in a filling station still has more financial power and more options for future jobs than his female partner, if she, for example, takes time off her own part-time filling station job to take care of babies for a year or two or more.

Depending on how unequally domestic and caretaking roles are apportioned, or the availability of the hours she needs in order to make sharing the family load possible, her chance of getting a job afterwards and keeping at it may be ruined.

Why would a woman having her own home, good salary, pension and savings prior to marriage and children be an exception rather than a rule?

You are overlooking the millions of people who live hand to mouth, rent their humble abodes, get paid by the hour, have no pensions apart from state entitlements, and they have zero in savings because everything is more expensive when you're poor.

If you are not aware of the reality of life for millions of other people then you live in a bubble.

Swipe left for the next trending thread