Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men who refuse to marry the mothers of their children

408 replies

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 19:21

You see that so often on here. I don’t mean couples where both parties are happy to marry, but ones where the man refuses despite their partner desperately wanting it, or else strings them along indefinitely.

Is there any reason at all, other than that he doesn’t want to have any duty to provide her with financial security for if they break up? So not only is he already thinking about potentially leaving, he’s happy to fuck over the person he ostensibly currently loves if they do break up.

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it. I suppose the ones being strung along have just been lied to, but having children is actually the bigger commitment in many ways. You’re joined for life. It seems so nasty to be prepared to do that, but not offer your partner the security and commitment they want.

OP posts:
AlDanvers · 04/01/2022 19:27

@RosieGuacamosie

My point is, going back to the original comment I made in response to someones comment, you can be fully committed to someone without marriage.

Sorry but I don’t agree with this. Marriage is the ultimate relationship commitment, it’s essentially saying “I bet you half my stuff we’ll be together forever and I believe in this relationship enough to take that risk”.

People generally cite financial issues for not wanting to marry, which is absolutely their choice, but don’t pretend they’re “just as committed” when they quite plainly aren’t, as one of the partners isn’t willing (perhaps sensibly) to risk their finances.

Sorry but no. I don't feel the need to place a bet on my relationship.

And let's not forget those bets are lost 50% of the time. Its not even a sensible bet.

And, usually, both people aren't placing that bet. It's just one person placing the bet. The other stands to gain either way.

Again, marriage isn't the ultimate commitment. Evidence by the large amount of people who get married and don't actually work at the relationship.

RosieGuacamosie · 04/01/2022 19:23

My point is, going back to the original comment I made in response to someones comment, you can be fully committed to someone without marriage.

Sorry but I don’t agree with this. Marriage is the ultimate relationship commitment, it’s essentially saying “I bet you half my stuff we’ll be together forever and I believe in this relationship enough to take that risk”.

People generally cite financial issues for not wanting to marry, which is absolutely their choice, but don’t pretend they’re “just as committed” when they quite plainly aren’t, as one of the partners isn’t willing (perhaps sensibly) to risk their finances.

AlDanvers · 04/01/2022 18:47

I didn't say it didn't add an extra layer. It doesn't prove that it's more committed.

There different types of commitment.

Both can completely independent of eachother. People get married all the time without actually being committed or invested emotionally invested.

Mn is full of threads by married women where the man is not committed, emotionally, in the relationship. They aren't committed to making it work. They treat their wives poorly (not talking abuse levels though they are there too), they got married but have no interest in investing in their spouse. Many aren't that fussed about the kids either.

And unfortunately many men who 'really want kids' and are really good parents only are when in a relationship with the woman. Splitting often exposes this and the men slowly disappear and priotise themselves at all times.

My point is, going back to the original comment I made in response to someones comment, you can be fully committed to someone without marriage. Marriage may not be the best option.

Emotionally commitment and legal commitment are 2 separate things that can exist together or separately.

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 18:08

That marriage is a legal contract only? Nothing else?

Of course it is. You don't have to love someone to marry them and you don't invalidate a marriage by falling out of love. It is a legal contract.

I wouldn't advise marrying someone you don't love, and I'd hope one marries because they love, but as cold hard fact, yes, it is nothing but a legal contract. That's why it's so annoying when people say "oh, you can't contract love" as if marriage is a love contract. It isn't. And you don't need love to make it valid.

You can love someone without marrying them, and it may well be the wisest course of action. You may be very emotionally committed, although that's hard to define.

But it's nonsensical to say that legalising your relationship doesn't add an extra layer of commitment. Of course it does. That's precisely why some people won't do it. I'm not saying they're wrong not to, or less in love, but of course they're less committed.

AlDanvers · 04/01/2022 17:49

My exh wasn't committed because he kept fucking other women.

Not really someone who is committed to these relationships, is it.

And just to top it off, despite being a very equal parent. He is now nor in touch with any. Despite being the one pushing for kids. Turns out he didn't really want them. Was just expected of him (not by me).

LittleRoundRobin · 04/01/2022 17:48

@AlDanvers

Do you really believe a relationship isn't committed if there's no marriage?

A lot of people think like this.

The law doesn't take a relationship with a non-married couple as seriously as one with a married couple either.

I have known a number of cases over the years, where a couple have been together 15-20 years, sometimes 25 or more, and one of them dies, and they don't even get a sympathy card from most people, OR a single day off work.

Conversely, I have known a few couples who were only married 5 or 6 years, and together for just 8 or 9 years, and when their spouse died, they had huge collections at work, were given a week off, had bundles of cards and gifts, and had the utmost sympathy from everyone. The non-married people got shag all, even thought they were together 3 times longer...

As I say, like it or not, even in 2021, the vast VAST majority of people will not take a couples relationship very seriously if they are not married. Not even if they have children. They will be taken more seriously if they have children, but still not as seriously as couples who do. The couples with children who are married, get a lot more respect.

I am not saying it's right, but that is how it is. I have to say, I don't take a relationship very seriously if they're not married either. That's just how I feel.

That doesn't mean not getting married is any less committed.

@DrSbaitso

Of course it's less committed. Doesn't mean it's always wrong not to do it, but it's a level of commitment above not doing it. It's a legal commitment, a contract. It must mean something if people refuse to do it.

Exactly! If the people who are daft enough to believe 'it's only a piece of paper' then why NOT get married? After all, it's ONLY a piece of paper. Wink

I also call bullshit on 'men don't want children only women do.' In my social circle, the men have very much wanted children, as much as the woman for sure. Including my own DH. He was ecstatic when I said I was pregnant with our first, and even now, feels extremely proud and privileged and happy that he is a dad. My dad was the same; he absolutely adored me and my brother.

AlDanvers · 04/01/2022 17:46

@DrSbaitso

You can be committed to a person without being legally committed.

How?

And how does adding a legal commitment not make the relationship more committed than it was without it?

So you believe a relationship without marriage can nor be committed?

That marriage is a legal contract only? Nothing else?

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 17:37

You can be committed to a person without being legally committed.

How?

And how does adding a legal commitment not make the relationship more committed than it was without it?

AlDanvers · 04/01/2022 17:35

@DrSbaitso

That doesn't mean not getting married is any less committed.

Of course it's less committed. Doesn't mean it's always wrong not to do it, but it's a level of commitment above not doing it. It's a legal commitment, a contract. It must mean something if people refuse to do it.

That would be the case if relationships only rely on legal commitment. I am not talking in only a legal sense.

You can be committed to a person without being legally committed.

The coment I quoted suggested that marriage was the only way a relationship can be a committed one. That's not the case.

I am in a committed relationship without being married. Being married would leave me and my children financially vulnerable. There's no need for a legal commitment.

I sought legal and financial advice.

I have also been married and can assure you my dp is far committed than my husband of 15 years ever was.

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 17:31

@Crazykatie

“ For many men, their only real, complete confidante and emotional support is their female partner. They're just not good at being alone.”

I would say that for “some” men that is true, men are very often macho and do not confide in their partner, less likely to be emotionally dependant, more likely to hide a illness, or a work problem.

In my experience, it's true far more often than it isn't.
AcrossthePond55 · 04/01/2022 17:30

@CatsArePeople

We as women need to take care of ourselves. Or at least, be prepared to.

Yes, but don't let men off the hook that easily. Don't willingly have kids with dudes who are scared of "the paper".

I guess my feeling is that if I am self supporting, who cares if a man is 'scared of the paper'? The reason for the piece of paper is to ensure that a 'non-earner' (be it male or female) is not put at a financial disadvantage, that they have some legal protection if the other person (be it male or female) decides to up sticks and leave. Obviously, these days it's much more likely to be the female who is dependent, but the world keeps spinning and things keep changing. SAHF are rarer, but they are 'there'.

The protection for children isn't dependent on marriage, child support/maintenance is a child's right regardless of marital status. And if a person is going to be an absentee parent and not pay it, then the fact that the parents were married doesn't mean shit.

It's not letting men 'off the hook', it's putting oneself on an equal footing with them. You don't want to marry me? Who cares? I can take care of myself AND maintain separate finances and assets. In fact, it may actually be an incentive for a man to marry a woman if he knows she's willing and able to walk away at any time, especially if she's a good earner with assets of her own. It also may be a good incentive for a man to carry his share of the household duties if he knows that if he doesn't his partner (or wife) could decide he's just not worth the extra work.

If a woman has some driving need to be a 'Mrs' because she thinks it's some sort of status symbol, then I think she needs to realize she's not living in the '50s. There is no such thing as an 'old maid' anymore. A woman's 'worth' is no longer determined by whether or not some man wanted to marry her as it was in our mother's and grandmother's days!

I'm speaking as a woman in her 60s, who has been happily married for over 35 years. We married because we both wanted to and wanted to be married before children came along. And we both kept working after the children came. All marriages hit a 'rocky patch' at one time or another, and when we hit ours it was a secure feeling for me to know that the DC and I would have been just fine if DH and I hadn't been able to reach a 'meeting of the minds'. And I expect that fact might have been in the back of his mind, too! So we entered our 'rocky patch' as equals, not with one in fear of loss of financial security or the other with a feeling of 'power' because they held all the financial cards.

Crazykatie · 04/01/2022 17:25

“ For many men, their only real, complete confidante and emotional support is their female partner. They're just not good at being alone.”

I would say that for “some” men that is true, men are very often macho and do not confide in their partner, less likely to be emotionally dependant, more likely to hide a illness, or a work problem.

Iamthewombat · 04/01/2022 17:23

Oh dear. Did you read the OP, or any of the thread?

MissMaple82 · 04/01/2022 17:21

Firstly your assuming it's men thar don't want to get married??? Secondly, not everyone wants to marry amd that is OK. Get over yourself!

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 17:11

That doesn't mean not getting married is any less committed.

Of course it's less committed. Doesn't mean it's always wrong not to do it, but it's a level of commitment above not doing it. It's a legal commitment, a contract. It must mean something if people refuse to do it.

AlDanvers · 04/01/2022 17:07

@CatsArePeople

Do you really believe a relationship isn't committed if there's no marriage?

The PP said specifically her son shouldn't marry unless there is 100% commitment. I believe the same goes with kids. If a guy wants kids but insists on not marrying - bin him.

Why would anyone marry if there isn't 100% commitment?

That doesn't mean not getting married is any less committed.

It should never be a case of 'marriage is the only right way'. Wether its rare or not, some women would be screwed.

And people can be very committed without marriage.

CatsArePeople · 04/01/2022 16:49

We as women need to take care of ourselves. Or at least, be prepared to.

Yes, but don't let men off the hook that easily. Don't willingly have kids with dudes who are scared of "the paper".

AlexaShutUp · 04/01/2022 16:38

We as women need to take care of ourselves. Or at least, be prepared to.

I could not agree more!

AcrossthePond55 · 04/01/2022 16:36

What we need to teach young women is the value and the importance of being self-supporting. That even if your 'goal' is to be a SAHP, you still need to have some skill that would enable you to earn a living, be it as a supermarket checker or a brain surgeon. A woman may not want to work, but she should be able to if need arises.

When I was a girl my parents always impressed on me the need to get some sort of skill or qualification that would allow me to support myself, and if need be my family. My auntie (Mum's sister) also stressed this with her daughter. My mum was a housewife, but she was also a trained bookkeeper. Auntie was a housewife, but also a licensed teacher. Neither of them worked when we were little, but both had a skill that allowed them to re-enter the workplace once we were grown.

Both of them felt that 'you never know'. Not that their husbands would leave them, but that life can take drastic turns and you must be able to cope with them. It's not just that a woman will be left penniless by some total shit. It's also what may happen if their OH becomes disabled, loses their job, or dies. Getting a job at a living wage isn't easy these days, but without some type of skill it's impossible.

Both my cousin and I did get career skills. I kept working after the children arrived and DH and I retired in our 50s. My cousin stopped to be a SAHM but kept her license current. It's a good thing she did because her exH left her for OW. She re-entered the workplace after the divorce was finalized at a good wage. She retired at 60.

We as women need to take care of ourselves. Or at least, be prepared to.

LowlandLucky · 04/01/2022 16:33

MalagaNights You are right.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 04/01/2022 14:28

*We need to be saying loudly and clearly to young women if you want to be married then make it clear to partners you will not have children until married. Non negotaible.

We've sold young women a lie with the laissez faire it's fine to live together, have a baby andthenget married attitude which seems to be prevailing, and it's leaving too many mothers very vulnerable and unhappy.

This is made even harder on young women as men are commiting later and later and the biological clock for women is ticking, which is why I think they have the babies before the men will commit.
Which I understand, becoming a mother is very important to most women.

Feminism has put young women in a bind where they are leaving motherhood late, cannot delay it any longer, alongside everyone living longer and men reaching maturity and readiness for commitment later.

Our biological clocks really work against the modern set up they are sold at the moment.

As an older women I'm having these converstaions as much as I can with younger women who want marriage and children: they need to take agency, use the negotiating power they have (men do want children) to place themselves in strong positions.

No children without marriage.
From 25 years onwards make your position on this clear and don't waste time if he's not on board with this.

Value yourself, what you have to offer a man, and if he doesn't value it move on.

If more women did this the dating 'marketplace' would shift, and women would hold more power within it*

I say this as someone who despite reasonable intelligence fell hook, line and sinker for the "only a bit of paper" argument. I would go further and not live with a partner before they at least committed to an intention to marry and ideally a date. As stated above most men don't like living alone..

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 14:20

@vivainsomnia

Childcare, housework is daily and non-negotiable And most women who work ft share it with their oh.

Those who work ft and do it all are the ones who really need to have a talk with their oh.

The point is, there's a lot of them.

Far more than there are men working full time and doing it all at home.

vivainsomnia · 04/01/2022 14:14

Childcare, housework is daily and non-negotiable
And most women who work ft share it with their oh.

Those who work ft and do it all are the ones who really need to have a talk with their oh.

CatsArePeople · 04/01/2022 14:13

I also find it interesting that when mentioning household tasks on mn, DIY, repairs, gardening, etc...is never mentioned, despite being tasks more traditional taken on by men.

How often DYI repairs need to get done? Its a very occasional task, and actually few men are capable, usually you need to hire someone.
Childcare, housework is daily and non-negotiable.

vivainsomnia · 04/01/2022 14:12

DIY etc is more of a "one off" with a visible, permanent result. Making dinner, cleaning the bathroom etc is "invisible work" that you often don't notice until it doesn't get done. It's domestic everyday drudgery
It really depends on the house. My oh is always busy with some DIY and maintenance of the garden but he also cooks and cleans.

Swipe left for the next trending thread