Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men who refuse to marry the mothers of their children

408 replies

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 19:21

You see that so often on here. I don’t mean couples where both parties are happy to marry, but ones where the man refuses despite their partner desperately wanting it, or else strings them along indefinitely.

Is there any reason at all, other than that he doesn’t want to have any duty to provide her with financial security for if they break up? So not only is he already thinking about potentially leaving, he’s happy to fuck over the person he ostensibly currently loves if they do break up.

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it. I suppose the ones being strung along have just been lied to, but having children is actually the bigger commitment in many ways. You’re joined for life. It seems so nasty to be prepared to do that, but not offer your partner the security and commitment they want.

OP posts:
thepeopleversuswork · 05/01/2022 13:07

@DrSbaitso

I don't disagree with you on your position about marriage being the ultimate commitment. I agree that women should be ruthlessly honest with themselves about why he will not marry them.

And I love this:

The truth will set you free, but first it will piss you off.

But I'm not sure about this:

It's not an insult to happily unmarried couples to point this out, or to note that for couples in this position, a lack of love often IS the reason he won't do it.

I think this misses some subtleties, particularly with blended families:

I'm in a situation with someone who emotionally I would be happy to marry but I never will. And the reason I won't ever marry him is because it would introduce a level of financial risk for my daughter (who is not his daughter) which I'm not prepared to countenance: essentially it would jeopardise her inheritance.

It's not as straightforward as saying if I really loved him enough I'd be prepared to marry him -- marrying him would have consequences for my daughter. I don't think I have the right to put my emotional wellbeing ahead of my daughter's security.

There are certainly a lot of men who won't get married because they are scared of being weighed down or who are looking over their shoulder all the time for someone better. But there are plenty of older couples where one or both partner has children from a previous relationship whose financial health would be negatively impacted by their parent marrying. There are plenty of men in my situation or similar ones, who may deeply love a partner but who ultimately feel their children's security comes first.

ComtesseDeSpair · 05/01/2022 13:00

@TedMullins

I think what people object to is the suggestion that unmarried relationships are less emotionally committed than married people. A poster up thread said they don’t take relationships seriously if people aren’t married which is ridiculous.

Of course marriage makes a difference in the legal position it puts you in, and it is an extra commitment that binds you not just by words but by law and by finances. I don’t dispute that at all. But to suggest an unmarried relationship isn’t serious is a judgement you can’t possibly pass without knowing the people in the relationship. Perhaps they’re unmarried because one of them is a selfish miser who wants to hide their money from their partner and one of them is being screwed over, or perhaps they’ve made a joint decision not to marry. I don’t think you can make an overall value judgement on someone’s relationship on their marital status without knowing individual details.

I think couples can say they’re committed, and genuinely think it and mean it - just as I said to my best friend forever at 15 that we were like sisters and would be best friends forever, and goddamn: I genuinely thought it and meant it. But saying and believing that you are committed to each other isn’t actually a commitment. It doesn’t require or compel anything of you. You can love each other deeply, just as much married or unmarried; but love still isn’t a commitment.

If you accepted a job offer and the employer then said “we’re really committed to you, we think you’re great, we’re not going to give you a contract because we think that the professional relationship between us should speak for itself, we trust you and you trust us, that’s how a good professional relationship should be”, what would you assume? You wouldn’t assume that this was an employer who valued trust and was serious about you; you’d assume this was an employer who didn’t want to make a legal commitment to you.

You might agree to their terms and you could potentially rub along happily for years - but you’d (hopefully) sleep with one eye open and make contingency plans for the day they cut you loose. Which is perfect. And it’s the same thing financially insecure and dependent women should do when they have babies with a man who hasn’t given them a contract.

DrSbaitso · 05/01/2022 12:21

It's true that marriage doesn't guarantee fidelity or emotional commitment (whatever that is), but nor does not being married.

But if you have a man reaping all the "benefits" of marriage, which usually means children and a woman doing most of the childcare and housework, without protecting her legally when it would be in her best interests and what she wants, then he's unlikely to be very "emotionally committed" either. After all, he's leaving the back door open to run without obligation if he wants to.

It isn't helpful to try to obfuscate this with talk about emotional commitment that can't be legalised. You can be madly in love forever with anyone and have excellent reasons for not marrying. But if you are at a life stage, and in a life setup, whereby marriage would give you security and recognise your non-monetary contribution - and wouldn't, say, compromise the inheritance of earlier children - then it IS telling when a man won't do it. Emotional commitment costs him nothing and won't protect you, but it's the line often fed to these women and it fucks them over.

It's not an insult to happily unmarried couples to point this out, or to note that for couples in this position, a lack of love often IS the reason he won't do it.

The truth will set you free, but first it will piss you off.

TedMullins · 05/01/2022 11:38

I think what people object to is the suggestion that unmarried relationships are less emotionally committed than married people. A poster up thread said they don’t take relationships seriously if people aren’t married which is ridiculous.

Of course marriage makes a difference in the legal position it puts you in, and it is an extra commitment that binds you not just by words but by law and by finances. I don’t dispute that at all. But to suggest an unmarried relationship isn’t serious is a judgement you can’t possibly pass without knowing the people in the relationship. Perhaps they’re unmarried because one of them is a selfish miser who wants to hide their money from their partner and one of them is being screwed over, or perhaps they’ve made a joint decision not to marry. I don’t think you can make an overall value judgement on someone’s relationship on their marital status without knowing individual details.

LittleRoundRobin · 05/01/2022 10:20

Another excellent post @DrSbaitso ^

DrSbaitso · 05/01/2022 10:06

I agree that certain posters are taking your posts very personally, and that suggests to me that they aren't happy with their choice in life, not deep down, not really.

Possibly, possibly not. I don't know.

But it's very frustrating when someone tries to downplay or eliminate the reality of the commitment that is marriage, because it plays right into the silly narrative that marriage doesn't make a difference. And it does, demonstrably and objectively. That's why you need to take it seriously when deciding whether or not to do it, and your life choices based on whether or not it's being done.

And this idea that it doesn't make a difference is exactly what's fucking so many women over. It's not about that poster's personal relationship, it's not about her. It's about a cultural and societal understanding of what marriage is. It's not always a good commitment. Not everyone should do it.

But it's self-serving, defensive nonsense to insist that you can be JUST AS COMMITTED without it. You can't. That's the point of it. In many cases, it's precisely why you shouldn't do it and that's fine.

But it is a commitment, creating obligations that don't exist without it. And so it is very significant if a man who is at a particular life stage with someone, with certain plans or existing situations, won't make that commitment.

Crazykatie · 05/01/2022 09:38

Very varied opinions on this thread, if you are unmarried you need to look after your own interests very closely because that “piece of paper” gives you and the children a lot of rights.

If children are involved the best option is marriage, it simplifies everything, if you’re older and children aren’t an issue it’s about security, so make sure you protect your finances, because when the relationship ends you’re on your own.

LittleRoundRobin · 05/01/2022 09:35

@DrSbaitso

Well look, AlDanvers, OK. Marriage isn't an extra commitment if you don't include legal commitments as part of the discussion. That's got to be the most pointless line of reasoning I've ever seen on here, but if it makes you happy. And there are only six colours in the rainbow if you don't include red.

Don't marry if you don't want to. It's not a requirement. In some cases it's better not to.

But don't try to fool people, especially young women who are likely to give up some degree of financial power, that it isn't important or significant as a commitment when you don't specifically exclude it.
A man who thinks a woman is good enough for sex, companionship and bearing his children but not good enough for a legal commitment to protect her financially is, more likely than not, showing that he doesn't love her. Or maybe he does, but if he wants to leave the way open for an easy exit no matter the cost to her, it's not the kind of love I'd value.

It is an extra commitment, and it's a degree of protection against those men you mention, who would like to sod off and prioritise themselves when they want. The whole point of marriage is that you cannot prioritise only yourself above all.at no cost.

It's a commitment, and that's exactly why some people won't do it.

100 million per cent this. ESPECIALLY the last line/sentence.

I agree that certain posters are taking your posts very personally, and that suggests to me that they aren't happy with their choice in life, not deep down, not really. People who are so fiercely defensive are usually that way because what has been said has hit a raw nerve. It's naive at best to suggest marriage is not the ultimate relationship commitment, and foolish and dangerous at worst.

I don't take it personally if anyone berates or dismisses or mocks marriage, (and plenty of single people and people in unmarried couples in real life have done that, especially when I was a lot younger.) I don't take it personally, because I don't give a shit what they think.

I don't need to care, because I know I have the upper hand.

Unsurprisingly, many couples I used to know (who stayed unmarried) split YEARS ago. The majority of ones who have stayed together are the ones who got married.

HeavyHeidi · 05/01/2022 09:27

In the end... which set of kids are entitled to the inheritance?

Not an expert but internet says both are, does not matter if the children were born outside of marriage.

In England and Wales, when someone dies intestate, leaving a spouse or civil partner and surviving children or other descendants:

the spouse or civil partner inherits the personal effects or chattels of the deceased, the first £270,000 of the estate and half of the remaining estate.
The children inherit the other half of the remaining estate.

Crazykatie · 05/01/2022 09:04

@CatsArePeople

Imagine this... a man and a woman have kids, don't marry, it's just a piece of paper they say. They split up later on, woman keeps the kids. Then a man goes on and meets the love of his life, marries her, has more kids.

In the end... which set of kids are entitled to the inheritance?

A different subject, and would depend entirely on the terms of the will, only a spouse is guaranteed provision.
ComtesseDeSpair · 05/01/2022 08:54

@CatsArePeople

Imagine this... a man and a woman have kids, don't marry, it's just a piece of paper they say. They split up later on, woman keeps the kids. Then a man goes on and meets the love of his life, marries her, has more kids.

In the end... which set of kids are entitled to the inheritance?

The married v not married aspect is a bit of a red herring here surely? He could have also been married to the first mother when their children were born but without a will (or being in a country where all children must receive some provision) after he and she divorced the outcome would be the same, in that his second wife would inherit and then presumably her children thereafter.

This is more an argument for ensuring you have a will if you have children, regardless of your current marital status or whether or not you were ever married to their other parent: also an important thing to drum into young people.

CatsArePeople · 05/01/2022 08:22

Imagine this... a man and a woman have kids, don't marry, it's just a piece of paper they say. They split up later on, woman keeps the kids. Then a man goes on and meets the love of his life, marries her, has more kids.

In the end... which set of kids are entitled to the inheritance?

SunshineCake1 · 04/01/2022 22:14

Too much spouting of marriage is just a bit of paper means some women have forgotten the actual legal protection that marriage gives them and it is a very valuable piece of paper.

Of course, some men have never forgotten how expensive this piece of paper can be hence the dragging their feet over marriage. Children are expecting since too but very easy to walk away from them..

AlDanvers · 04/01/2022 21:00

@KatharinaRosalie

Not all people want kids, so will have no need to take a career hit

This thread is specifically about men not marrying the mother of their children. A childless couple is in a very different position.

This oart of the xinverstation started because someone posted about that ifbsomeone doesn't want to marry they can't be committed. I simply disagree.

Threads develope and often go into other areas.

Stop taking this so personally. It's not a slight on your relationship. Nobody denies that you're in love and happy. But you're not helping vulnerable younger women by reinforcing this idea that marriage isn't an extra commitment. It is. That's literally the point of it. It's not an attack on you.

You think you opinion matters, far more than it does. I dont feel attacked. I simply stated that you don't have to be married to be committed.

You took exception to that and keep saying that I am encouraging women to not marry. No matter how many times you say it, doesn't make it true.

I believe that women, need to seriously look at what they want, the position they are in and make a decision from there. The information is all available to them.

And if the person they are with doesn't also want those things, they shouldn't be having children with them.

My daughter would laugh at the suggestion I would encourage women not to marry.

I simply believe that you can be unmarried and more committed to your relationship. And that commitment is not only legal or financial.

There's been quite a few threads lately fro. Women who married the first semi stable man who asked. Then regretted it very very quickly.

As I said. No one should sleep walk into not being married and vulnerable.
No one should sleep walk into marriage either, assuming it's the best thing for them and their circumstances.

Not sure why you find that so controversial

thepeopleversuswork · 04/01/2022 20:55

@MalagaNights I totally get this and you're right that in the majority of cases marriage is the best financial insurance policy for a woman who is planning to take any kind of career break. I guess I see this from the perspective of someone who is still shocked by how much better my life has turned out outside a marriage than it was inside it. But I appreciate this is not everyone's experience.

I stand by my comment that absolutely every woman unless her father is Jeff Bezos should have some means of self-support as the primary financial plan though.

MalagaNights · 04/01/2022 20:33

@thepeopleversuswork I do totally get that many marriages just don't work and that very often women are far better off out of them and raising the children alone. Honestly I do. I've been in the ltb camp on here many times.

Saying statistically marriage provides the best results isn't the same as saying it always does, or even that it probably will.

But I still think it's the best protection we have for women who are going to take a financial hit from having children. And that is most women.

Not just sahm. Even women who work often don't take promotions because they don't want that level of commitment to work.
I earn more than husband now but for a few years was totally reliant.

We can pretend all being equal women and men should totally share child care from post birth. But all things aren't equal and many women do prefer prioritising being with children over career advancement.

It's not a judgement on people who don't stay married, that's just real messy life, but it's hard to talk about what seems to work more of the time,without some feeling it's a judgement.

I wish we could.

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 20:15

You see unmarried relationships as less than.

No, you do, hence the pretzel logic, defensivenes and accusations.

I've said several times that marriage doesn't require love, that unmarried people can be completely in love and that marriage isn't the best option for everyone. If I became single, I wouldn't marry again because I'd want to protect my daughter's inheritance.

But marriage IS a legal commitment and it DOES create commitments that don't exist without it. That's precisely why some people don't want to do it, and why some people shouldn't - because in those cases, it would be a bad commitment. Like taking on a mortgage you can't afford. It's a commitment.

Stop taking this so personally. It's not a slight on your relationship. Nobody denies that you're in love and happy. But you're not helping vulnerable younger women by reinforcing this idea that marriage isn't an extra commitment. It is. That's literally the point of it. It's not an attack on you.

thepeopleversuswork · 04/01/2022 20:13

@MalagaNights

I don't disagree with the statement that if you want a committed relationship marriage is the best bet. And I certainly agree that women if they want to marry should do this before having children.

But I take issue with this part of what you wrote:

We want the truth to be something else, we want to pretend that biological realities barely impinge on women, or that women don't really need men to raise children, or that it's not better for children to have a stable home with 2 parents, or that despite all its flaws marriage isn't the best way we've figured out to do this.

Your post ignores the fact that for an awful lot of women parenting within a marriage is not the optimal option. As someone who has found single parenthood infinitely preferable on every possible metric, more rewarding, more emotionally fulfilling and even more remunerative, than parenting in a marriage I just know that it isn't always as black and white as you make it. And many homes are far more stable without a man in them. For some women in many contexts marriage is the best option, but you ignore the fact that large numbers of women thrive and raise children well often better outside of marriage than they do in it. And there has to be a strategy for those women.

I think your tactics work really well if your goal is to be a SAHM but you should never have marriage as the cornerstone of your financial life goal. It may be critical life insurance if you plan not to work and it may augment your life if you do. But having a way to support yourself is really the only cast iron protection. It works if you marry and it provides a safety net if you don't.

KatharinaRosalie · 04/01/2022 20:11

Not all people want kids, so will have no need to take a career hit

This thread is specifically about men not marrying the mother of their children. A childless couple is in a very different position.

AlDanvers · 04/01/2022 20:06

@DrSbaitso

Well look, AlDanvers, OK. Marriage isn't an extra commitment if you don't include legal commitments as part of the discussion. That's got to be the most pointless line of reasoning I've ever seen on here, but if it makes you happy. And there are only six colours in the rainbow if you don't include red.

Don't marry if you don't want to. It's not a requirement. In some cases it's better not to.

But don't try to fool people, especially young women who are likely to give up some degree of financial power, that it isn't important or significant as a commitment when you don't specifically exclude it. A man who thinks a woman is good enough for sex, companionship and bearing his children but not good enough for a legal commitment to protect her financially is, more likely than not, showing that he doesn't love her. Or maybe he does, but if he wants to leave the way open for an easy exit no matter the cost to her, it's not the kind of love I'd value.

It is an extra commitment, and it's a degree of protection against those men you mention, who would like to sod off and prioritise themselves when they want. The whole point of marriage is that you cannot prioritise only yourself above all.at no cost.

It's a commitment, and that's exactly why some people won't do it. And that's sometimes wise. But only because it's a commitment, and it's always foolish to make a bad commitment.

Where did I say women should go into anything that outa them at risk?

My point was simply that you can be committed and nor married.
Women can even be married and it be their own detriment.
Not all people want kids, so will have no need to take a career hit

And actually, just because a man wants to marry you, doesn't mean your aren't sleep walking into disaster.

You see unmarried relationships as less than. That's fine. I don't. I ruin that lots of different relationship set ups can be equally committed, successful and great partnerships.

There's no one way. We should normalise our children understanding this. But also, they need to understand the benefits and pitfalls of each one. They should assume they will be fine without marriage, but they also should not assume they will be fine with it.

MalagaNights · 04/01/2022 20:01

Marriage isn't a good bet, but statistically it's by far the best bet you can make if you want your relationship to last, if you want to be financially secure, and if you want your children to have an involved relationship with their father, and the best outcomes on nearly all measures.

We want the truth to be something else, we want to pretend that biological realities barely impinge on women, or that women don't really need men to raise children, or that it's not better for children to have a stable home with 2 parents, or that despite all its flaws marriage isn't the best way we've figured out to do this.

Despite all the evidence we're not supposed to say it.

I think we should be saying it.

To help young women, most of whom want children, many of whom will want to take career breaks or work part time to be with their children. And the many who won't.

I think it should be the next feminist revolution: renegotiation of modern marriage.

As a partnership with legal protection where people enter into an agreement about the roles they'll take. You can take any role, no more assumption the women will do the child care, but if they agree she will, she has legal protection as she's agreeing to a vulnerable position.

But this modern open negotiation needs to take place before you sign the deal.

Having a baby then trying to negotiate your role puts you in such a weak position.
And we see that over and over on here.

G5000 · 04/01/2022 19:55

I'm sure an unmarried partner can be just as committed as a married one, during the relationship. We don't need any 'pieces of paper' when things are good and when everybody does what they are supposed to do.
We need those papers when things are no longer going well and the working partner in a relationship decides that never mind what we discussed, I don't actually want to give you a fair share, if I don't have to.

LadyEloise1 · 04/01/2022 19:53

I agree with your original post @SparrowNest

HTH1 · 04/01/2022 19:31

Yes. Put simply, they are keeping their options open so they can leave with minimal consequences if someone they prefer comes along.

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 19:28

Well look, AlDanvers, OK. Marriage isn't an extra commitment if you don't include legal commitments as part of the discussion. That's got to be the most pointless line of reasoning I've ever seen on here, but if it makes you happy. And there are only six colours in the rainbow if you don't include red.

Don't marry if you don't want to. It's not a requirement. In some cases it's better not to.

But don't try to fool people, especially young women who are likely to give up some degree of financial power, that it isn't important or significant as a commitment when you don't specifically exclude it. A man who thinks a woman is good enough for sex, companionship and bearing his children but not good enough for a legal commitment to protect her financially is, more likely than not, showing that he doesn't love her. Or maybe he does, but if he wants to leave the way open for an easy exit no matter the cost to her, it's not the kind of love I'd value.

It is an extra commitment, and it's a degree of protection against those men you mention, who would like to sod off and prioritise themselves when they want. The whole point of marriage is that you cannot prioritise only yourself above all.at no cost.

It's a commitment, and that's exactly why some people won't do it. And that's sometimes wise. But only because it's a commitment, and it's always foolish to make a bad commitment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread