Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men who refuse to marry the mothers of their children

408 replies

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 19:21

You see that so often on here. I don’t mean couples where both parties are happy to marry, but ones where the man refuses despite their partner desperately wanting it, or else strings them along indefinitely.

Is there any reason at all, other than that he doesn’t want to have any duty to provide her with financial security for if they break up? So not only is he already thinking about potentially leaving, he’s happy to fuck over the person he ostensibly currently loves if they do break up.

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it. I suppose the ones being strung along have just been lied to, but having children is actually the bigger commitment in many ways. You’re joined for life. It seems so nasty to be prepared to do that, but not offer your partner the security and commitment they want.

OP posts:
FallonCarringtonWannabe · 06/01/2022 10:21

I have been banging on about this forever but I think this ought to be taught in school.
It is.

VikingOnTheFridge · 06/01/2022 08:11

The MN variant is 'having a baby with someone is a bigger commitment than marriage'. It's really not...

thepeopleversuswork · 06/01/2022 07:59

@MimiDaisy11

It's still shockingly common for people to believe in common law marriage.

I have been banging on about this forever but I think this ought to be taught in school.

MimiDaisy11 · 06/01/2022 02:45

@ComtesseDeSpair
I’m curious what percentage of the country think common law marriage is a thing. It seems to be a common misunderstanding. I remember doing a story for a writing group about a woman who had lived with partner for a while and he threw her out. People in the group said it was unrealistic as she’d be entitled to assets etc as they’d lived together for a while. No one spoke against this point. Even when I went away to research it some still seemed unconvinced.

Cameleongirl · 06/01/2022 02:00

I was talking to a colleague earlier today and she told me that her daughter (whom I've met a couple of times) is engaged and getting married later this year. She's mid-20's, he's a year or so older and they've been dating for about three years.

I'm assuming that getting married is something important to both of them so they're getting on with it. There's no point hanging around waiting if you're not on the same page about marriage/not getting married.

Iamthewombat · 05/01/2022 21:19

@Newyearnewme2022

I didn’t want to marry my exH, he pressured me into it. Not all women want to get married.
For the love of god. Does this have to be explained every single time?

The thread is about women who desperately want to be married, but the man refuses. Try reading the OP.

VikingOnTheFridge · 05/01/2022 21:17

@Porcupineintherough

I think even the most deluded woman knows whether she's married or not. So at the point she decides to start or continue a pregnancy she knows that she is making herself vulnerable. It's a choice and perhaps if we didnt focus girls so much on the romantic side of life and more on the hard financial realities, it would happen less often. Especially if we changed the law to make both parents properly financially responsible for their children.
Ehhh, you're conflating women knowing if they're married with women knowing about the impact of a marriage contract. Emphatically not the same thing. There is a lot of misunderstanding on this issue.
Newyearnewme2022 · 05/01/2022 17:31

I didn’t want to marry my exH, he pressured me into it. Not all women want to get married.

ComtesseDeSpair · 05/01/2022 17:17

@Porcupineintherough

I think even the most deluded woman knows whether she's married or not. So at the point she decides to start or continue a pregnancy she knows that she is making herself vulnerable. It's a choice and perhaps if we didnt focus girls so much on the romantic side of life and more on the hard financial realities, it would happen less often. Especially if we changed the law to make both parents properly financially responsible for their children.
What’s been an eye opener for me about being on MN is the sheer breadth of views and beliefs it’s allowed me to realise are out there amongst women I’d never come into contact with in my day to day life.

MN has taught me that there are women who believe that common law marriage exists and if you’ve lived together for five years it’s the same as being married; that there are women who get themselves pregnant “accidentally on purpose” because they think it will make the latest boyfriend stick around; that there are women who believe a baby is a bigger commitment for a man than marriage; that there are women who think a mother has an automatic legal right to stay in the family home until her children are 18.

In short, whatever you think you know about how you or the women you know might make decisions and the thought processes they might go through when doing it, probably doesn’t apply to a huge number of other women out there who make decisions based on things they don’t realise aren’t true, or just make poor decisions without really thinking about it at all.

Yes, I totally agree that we need better mechanisms to make both parents accountable for the children they produce. But we also need to get women to understand the impact of their choices and accept that they have agency and must use it.

ChampagneLassie · 05/01/2022 17:16

I think in advancing equality as women we've inadvertently ended up a bit screwed over. With sex and co-habitation before marriage becoming the norm, pregnancy and children outside marriage are an inevitability and many of us find ourselves in the position of wanting children and prioritising that over hoping to get married.

Porcupineintherough · 05/01/2022 16:59

I think even the most deluded woman knows whether she's married or not. So at the point she decides to start or continue a pregnancy she knows that she is making herself vulnerable. It's a choice and perhaps if we didnt focus girls so much on the romantic side of life and more on the hard financial realities, it would happen less often. Especially if we changed the law to make both parents properly financially responsible for their children.

KatharinaRosalie · 05/01/2022 16:55

How do you know? Some are

Well OK I guess some might be. Have not read a single post even on MN where the man has actually admitted they don't want to get married because of this. It's always 'just a paper' and 'yes sure when the time is right'

VikingOnTheFridge · 05/01/2022 16:37

There wouldn't have been any comparison vivain because this isn't a shared child. The situations are totally different.

vivainsomnia · 05/01/2022 16:35

Regardless of whether any of this is correct or not, the situation we discuss here is not like the one described by thepeopleversuswork. This is the difference. There is no comparison between a relationship where the parties are both the parents of the child/ren and one where they are not
But they would have been in that situation at some point. A point where either she was told he wouldn't marry her but she decided to have kids anyway. Or he said he would marry at some point after the kids, and she decided to go ahead and have the kids knowing he could change his mind.

Those men are not honest about it though, are they?
How do you know? Some are, some are not just like some women are honest about accidents and some pretend to be in the pill, are not, and hope that after the surprise child, her partner will ask for marriage. There is not one scenario fits all.

I’d go further than that: I think women need to be ruthless in protecting their assets precisely because historically they haven’t had any
Now that's a good one. Maybe we can start with 'men should especially be the ones to be chosen to become sahp because historically they gave never been'. Ridicous!

thepeopleversuswork · 05/01/2022 15:25

@ComtesseDeSpair

I’d go further than that: I think women need to be ruthless in protecting their assets precisely because historically they haven’t had any.

The vast majority of the world’s wealth has always been owned by men and in large part that’s been possible because they have been able to rely on free domestic labour from women. Why on earth shouldn’t women protect such meagre assets as they have been able to acquire?

ComtesseDeSpair · 05/01/2022 14:29

@KatharinaRosalie

Why is it ok for women to want to protect their assets, and actually called wise, yet men are so negatively criticized for the same view?

Those men are not honest about it though, are they? If they would say that darling, I won't marry you because I don't want to share my assets, then the woman could make her choices accordingly. I don't really see it happening though, it's all talk about being practically married and committed and it's just a piece of paper and doesn't matter.

This. I think it’s absolutely fine for people of either sex to want to protect their assets as long as everyone is clear what it means. I’m very open with DP about why I’m a bit nervous of marrying him: I own a house outright and have a great pension, and whilst I’d love to think he and I will be together forever, because I love him, I have to keep in the back of mind that there’s a chance that will not be the case. And in return DP accepts that, whilst he might reassure me that he’d never want to go after my assets if we divorced, somebody’s reassurance can’t always be trusted.

How many of these men who won’t marry the mothers of their children do you think are being that honest with them? How many women would agree to have children with a man if he was saying “I don’t know if I want to marry you because we might divorce and then I’d have to give you half the house”? I’m going to wager very very few - what they are doing is dressing it up as the “I love you babe, I’ll be yours forever, I’d always do right by you, the we don’t need a piece of paper for that” nonsense, which is duplicitous.

thepeopleversuswork · 05/01/2022 13:46

@vivainsomnia

Why is it ok for women to want to protect their assets, and actually called wise, yet men are so negatively criticized for the same view?

Because typically child-rearing and the way it is set up benefits men's earning power much more than women because of the childcare and domestic labour which overwhelmingly falls to women, whether working or not.

Women often either stop work or work less when they have children and do the bulk of domestic labour. Even if they continue to work at full pelt they very often still do most of the domestic labour. In nearly all scenarios marriage allows men to turbo charge their ability to earn money while women's earning power suffers.

You can't talk about equality in a vacuum here. Marriage is very rarely an equal set-up. It's insurance to protect the lower-earning partner in a domestic relationship, which in the vast majority of cases is the woman, but even if this isn't the case it almost always leads to the woman doing a disproportionate amount of domestic labour. It's not meant to be an opportunity for a man with a high-earning partner to hedge his bets on her income while he does even less domestic work.

It's perfectly reasonable for women who have been structurally disadvantaged by childbearing for millennia to want to claw back some financial power by avoiding marriage if it suits their needs.

KatharinaRosalie · 05/01/2022 13:40

Why is it ok for women to want to protect their assets, and actually called wise, yet men are so negatively criticized for the same view?

Those men are not honest about it though, are they? If they would say that darling, I won't marry you because I don't want to share my assets, then the woman could make her choices accordingly. I don't really see it happening though, it's all talk about being practically married and committed and it's just a piece of paper and doesn't matter.

VikingOnTheFridge · 05/01/2022 13:38

@vivainsomnia

with the woman taking the brunt of the domestic load and earning less as a result - there really do have to be compelling reasons for the man not to marry if the woman wants it It's much more commonly the other way around, that because the mum has less earning power that the decision is made that she'd take on the most of the domestic load not working or working pt.

Otherwise, this would mean working is never an option for single parents and it clearly is.

How often do we have the scenario of the mum, having a descent earning power gives it up against her will to become a sahm because it's what her oh wants for the family? Very rarely because that would be abuse.

It's much more common that the mum wants to be a sahm or work PT and their part we go along with it because that's what she wants and it makes sense financially because her earning power at that time is low.

The agreement usually becomes an issue when the father expects them to go back to work ft or increase their hours, and mum doesn't want to because the status quo suits her or she does but dad still expects her to do most of the domestic work. All this should be agreed upfront.

Regardless of whether any of this is correct or not, the situation we discuss here is not like the one described by thepeopleversuswork. This is the difference. There is no comparison between a relationship where the parties are both the parents of the child/ren and one where they are not.
vivainsomnia · 05/01/2022 13:35

Well, usually when a man is being criticised for this, there's a woman who's had his child/ren, with the associated risk to career and finances, and she's almost always doing a disproportionate share of the child and home labour too
That's not the case, men are being criticized the moment they say they don't want to marry but would be keen on kids as it's been shown cleat on this thread.

The whole 'I'm a women of great income potential but I have no choice but to sacrifice it because I'm choosing to have xhildren' is playing martyr. Many many mothers manage both, including single mums.

Having children is in no way automatic professional doom for the woman, thank God for that!

vivainsomnia · 05/01/2022 13:30

with the woman taking the brunt of the domestic load and earning less as a result - there really do have to be compelling reasons for the man not to marry if the woman wants it
It's much more commonly the other way around, that because the mum has less earning power that the decision is made that she'd take on the most of the domestic load not working or working pt.

Otherwise, this would mean working is never an option for single parents and it clearly is.

How often do we have the scenario of the mum, having a descent earning power gives it up against her will to become a sahm because it's what her oh wants for the family? Very rarely because that would be abuse.

It's much more common that the mum wants to be a sahm or work PT and their part we go along with it because that's what she wants and it makes sense financially because her earning power at that time is low.

The agreement usually becomes an issue when the father expects them to go back to work ft or increase their hours, and mum doesn't want to because the status quo suits her or she does but dad still expects her to do most of the domestic work. All this should be agreed upfront.

HappyDays40 · 05/01/2022 13:29

So many different situations to comment but I am not sure why anyone should feel pressured or compelled to marry anyone else just because of children and property. If that was a woman not wanting to get married and everyone was expecting her to get married even though she didn't want to we would all have something to say. There re other aways of protecting ourselves than marriage.

VikingOnTheFridge · 05/01/2022 13:23

Well, usually when a man is being criticised for this, there's a woman who's had his child/ren, with the associated risk to career and finances, and she's almost always doing a disproportionate share of the child and home labour too. Whereas there's no mention of there even being any shared children in the post you quote.

DrSbaitso · 05/01/2022 13:21

I understand that, @thepeopleversuswork. It's precisely because marriage is a commitment that it's not always the best thing to do. I was careful to point out that there are lots of times when it isn't a good idea, and compromising an existing child's inheritance is a classic one. If I became single, I'd never marry again for that reason.

I'm just saying that among the demographic where this is most likely to be an issue - younger couples who plan to have kids or already have them, with the woman taking the brunt of the domestic load and earning less as a result - there really do have to be compelling reasons for the man not to marry if the woman wants it. Because otherwise she's being left wide open while he retains the ability to bolt without protecting her. And I don't think it's helpful to push the idea to those women, in those situations, that this isn't a very strong indicator that he isn't all in and doesn't love you enough. If he'd rather be single than marry you. If he'd rather not financially commit to protect your non-monetary contribution that benefits him.

But it's why I dislike this idea that you can be JUST AS COMMITTED without marriage, because emotional commitment. That's what these women get sold, but emotional commitment won't protect you if it all goes wrong. Things are fine until they aren't. The piece of paper, as a PP said, is the protection for when things go wrong. We all hope they won't, but sometimes they do.

The fact that it isn't always a wise commitment doesn't mean it isn't a commitment. And there are times, many times, when it matters.

vivainsomnia · 05/01/2022 13:12

I am in a committed relationship without being married. Being married would leave me and my children financially vulnerable. There's no need for a legal commitment
Here you go! Perfect acceptable statement when it's made by a woman. Now get the men to say it and they are selfish bastard who only care about them, don't care about the protection of their partner and are clearly not committed.

Why is it ok for women to want to protect their assets, and actually called wise, yet men are so negatively criticized for the same view?

Noone should go ahead and have children before make it clear what the intention, not the wish they have as a family. I would have lived to stay at home when my kids were little but it wasn't what we'd agreed, would have put a lot of pressure in my oh and ultimately would have left me vulnerable so I went back to work ft asap.

Making generalities on genders ang roles is utterly pointless. The only thing that matters is that both are on the same wavelengths.

It's ok for a woman to wait to be married to have kids if indeed thats what her partner wants too. If marriage doesn't come forward, go separate ways before children. It's also ok for a man to say he would like kids but not marry. If that's not an option for his partner, they too can both go their own ways.

No one is right or wrong.

Swipe left for the next trending thread