Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men who refuse to marry the mothers of their children

408 replies

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 19:21

You see that so often on here. I don’t mean couples where both parties are happy to marry, but ones where the man refuses despite their partner desperately wanting it, or else strings them along indefinitely.

Is there any reason at all, other than that he doesn’t want to have any duty to provide her with financial security for if they break up? So not only is he already thinking about potentially leaving, he’s happy to fuck over the person he ostensibly currently loves if they do break up.

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it. I suppose the ones being strung along have just been lied to, but having children is actually the bigger commitment in many ways. You’re joined for life. It seems so nasty to be prepared to do that, but not offer your partner the security and commitment they want.

OP posts:
LadyMonicaBaddingham · 06/01/2022 19:47

What continues to surprise me is the number of children from unmarried couples who still have the father's surname "because he's traditional" yes, when he wants to be

thepeopleversuswork · 06/01/2022 19:47

@EightWheelGirl

The recent advice on here was don't get married if you have significantly more assets than your husband. Surely this is just the reverse?
No no no. This is such a misguided line of argument.

You're not comparing apples with apples. Childbearing and childrearing are often fatally damaging to women's financial wellbeing, which is exactly why you have marriage. Partly because of the physical demands of having young children but mainly because after children women default to the domestic labour and childcare, leaving men free to focus on making money. Even when women continue to work outside the home they tend to do the vast majority of domestic labour in the majority of cases.

There is no equivalent situation for men. Men's careers aren't affected by having children. In the vanishingly rare cases when men become FT carers its almost always precipitated by a career crisis or because they never earned much in the first place (through choice or otherwise). Find me a man who has given up a well-paid career he loves to take care of kids and I'll find you a flying pig.

In the rare situations when women do have assets of their own (against all odds) why on earth would they consider sharing those assets with an able bodied male who is perfectly capable of generating his own wealth unless its to support mutual children?

It's one thing for those assets to go into a family pot and to be shared equally between the members of the family, if there are children. But the idea that a bloke - who is highly unlikely to be doing an equal share of the domestic load -- should be entitled to take half of your hard-earned assets in a divorce just because you married him is not what marriage is for.

Marriage is to protect the financially weaker partner in the partnership (usually the woman). It's not meant to be yet another lever for men to pull to get money while they fail to contribute to the domestic load.

When men start doing half of the domestic work and childcare I would consider this a fair line of argument. But we are generations away from this goal.

DrSbaitso · 06/01/2022 19:31

@2bazookas

I thought forced marriage went out last century. For anyone.

Parents should support their children but I don't think anyone
should marry against their will.

It's not forced marriage to end a relationship because your partner won't give the commitment you're looking for.
2bazookas · 06/01/2022 19:28

I thought forced marriage went out last century. For anyone.

Parents should support their children but I don't think anyone
should marry against their will.

DrSbaitso · 06/01/2022 19:24

@UndertheCedartree

I did have a friend whose DP wouldn't marry her. They'd had a baby together through IVF so were clearly committed to each other. I really didn't understand it. She didn't want a big wedding or anything (even though they could have afforded it if they had wanted to). Eventually 2 more DC later they got married.
No, they were committed to having a child. And legally, he had no commitment to her until they married. Only to the children, and in practice he could have dodged that easily.

It is not a commitment to another person to have a child. And if these people really believed that children are the greater commitment, why would they not be prepared to make the lesser commitment too?

(Disclaimer for the times marriage isn't a good idea, blah blah.)

UndertheCedartree · 06/01/2022 19:19

I did have a friend whose DP wouldn't marry her. They'd had a baby together through IVF so were clearly committed to each other. I really didn't understand it. She didn't want a big wedding or anything (even though they could have afforded it if they had wanted to). Eventually 2 more DC later they got married.

VikingOnTheFridge · 06/01/2022 19:14

@Bluesarestillblue

The whole common law wife thing just irritates me. Some of my friends are highly educated and in responsible, Professional jobs and still believe it’s a thing.

But, I do think having kids with someone is more “tying” than getting married. You can get divorced without kids and the person is out of your life after a few years or whatever. But if you have kids, you’re likely to be tied
To them through your
Kids

Having a child with someone doesn't innately involve any commitment to that person at all. It's a commitment to the child, or it's meant to be. In practice we live in a society where even that is pretty optional for men.

Marriage, otoh, is a legal contract with another party, one that potentially gives them a pretty big claim on any assets you may have, that prevents you from engaging in it with anyone else while it's still valid, and which you can't opt out of without a legal process sometimes requiring the permission of the other party.

DrSbaitso · 06/01/2022 19:07

@EightWheelGirl

The recent advice on here was don't get married if you have significantly more assets than your husband. Surely this is just the reverse?
Oh girl, girl, you girl you. If we actually lived in a world where men, on the whole, did their fair share of childcare and domestic work even when their partner works full time, and there was no pay gap, and no natural consequences of children that affect girls more, you might have a point. On the whole, though, we don't. And I know you want that not to make a difference, being such a girl, but it does.

Of course, as a girl, you'll also be well aware of the implications of having children upon a girl.

channels the Beatles Ah, gi-i-irl... 🎶

Bluesarestillblue · 06/01/2022 18:58

The whole common law wife thing just irritates me. Some of my friends are highly educated and in responsible,
Professional jobs and still believe it’s a thing.

But, I do think having kids with someone is more “tying” than getting married. You can get divorced without kids and the person is out of your life after a few years or whatever. But if you have kids, you’re likely to be tied
To them through your
Kids

EightWheelGirl · 06/01/2022 17:54

The recent advice on here was don't get married if you have significantly more assets than your husband. Surely this is just the reverse?

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 06/01/2022 15:40

That wasn’t what I suggested. No need to get defensive. I suggested that PHSE lessons would be a good way to inform young women that a common fallacy likely to affect them and their futures was just that: a fallacy.

It IS taught. Ffs. Yhe issue is that other adults frwqurnlt spout nonesnese to their chidlren and their children believenit.
X

thepeopleversuswork · 06/01/2022 14:29

[quote FallonCarringtonWannabe]@thepeopleversuswork it is.

What type of school do you work in where it isnt?
What type of campaigning have you been doing?[/quote]
I'm not a teacher: not sure where you got the idea from that I am? It probably should be taught be parents but as a lot of parents seem to be under the impression that common law marriage is a thing that message clearly isn't getting through.

@ComtesseDeSpair also makes a really important point here about marriage which is that its both emotional and intensely private (and to some extent moral) but also with a legal dimension, which is an unusual and quite uneasy combination. A lot of people aren't comfortable thinking about their marriage ending, so they just don't think about it. Much like death.

I also think the way marriage is communicated about to young people (and young girls in particular) is often very unhelpful: Disneyfied nonsense. You only have to look at the amount of threads on here that go into thinking about bridesmaids, dresses, table settings etc, versus the amount of discussion around the legal mechanics of marriage to see how unbalanced this is.

There's still this vague, woolly feeling that marriage is something you do when you're in love and want kids and everything will turn out happily ever after once you've had a big party. And precious little discussion that marriage could be something which will make or break your financial health and which you really need to understand.

There's obviously something that's getting lost in translation and if parents aren't doing a good job of this then perhaps schools should.

VikingOnTheFridge · 06/01/2022 14:02

@Porcupineintherough

I'm not sure how much use a 1 off lesson in school would be if you come from a sphere where people constantly reinforce this belief in common law marriage and rights. I mean, there is a lot of information out there for anyone who cares to look or think about it.
There certainly is, but you'd have to realise you needed to look at it. We don't know what we don't know, iyswim. So the problem continues.
Iamthewombat · 06/01/2022 13:53

Do you honestly think schools have the time to teach about things that aren't a thing???

That wasn’t what I suggested. No need to get defensive. I suggested that PHSE lessons would be a good way to inform young women that a common fallacy likely to affect them and their futures was just that: a fallacy.

If 50% of people believed that the earth was flat, contrary to all evidence, would you say that schools shouldn’t challenge that fallacy, even though it is clearly nonsense?

ComtesseDeSpair · 06/01/2022 13:51

I think part of the problem with education and conversations and awareness raising about relationship security and marriage and legal rights is that they require people to think uncomfortable thoughts about their relationship failing and ending. Many people simply don’t want to entertain that, they’d prefer to believe that they’re in love and have a wonderful relationship and their OH would never ever hurt them.

On threads about prenups, for example, you’ll see many posters stating things like “I’d never have a prenup and if you would then your relationship is dead in the water because you’re already thinking about breaking up before you’ve even got married” or “if you have to have a prenup it means you don’t trust your partner, but I trust my OH completely.” Hell, on threads about cheating you’ll see posters confidently asserting “I know my OH would never cheat, he’s not that type of man, he despises cheaters, I totally trust him.” Many people simply don’t want to give headspace to the idea that their relationship is fallible, that their OH is just as capable of cheating or turning out to be bastard as anyone else’s, and that’s why they need some form of safety net in the form of a contract.

Marriage in our culture is a weird dichotomy, it tries to speak both of love and legality, which aren’t easy bedfellows. Many people want to believe that if you have the former, you simply don’t need the latter. Amor vincit omnia.

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 06/01/2022 13:47

@Iamthewombat

Well, surely the problem was that she DIDN’T know, and it would have been better for her to have picked up that knowledge at some point in her life?

I get what you are saying, schools can’t teach all life skills, but this would be an excellent candidate for the PHSE (? I might have the acronym wrong) syllabus, wouldn’t it?

Marriage is certainly on the curriculum. I teach it every year and have done for many, many years. Why would common law marriage be on it when it isnt a thing? Do you honestly think schools have the time to teach about things that aren't a thing???

Family life IS on the pshe curriculum. It is also on the RE gcse spec.

Porcupineintherough · 06/01/2022 13:41

I'm not sure how much use a 1 off lesson in school would be if you come from a sphere where people constantly reinforce this belief in common law marriage and rights. I mean, there is a lot of information out there for anyone who cares to look or think about it.

VikingOnTheFridge · 06/01/2022 13:38

It would be better coming from parents, but the problem there is that a lot of parents won't understand either. You can't accurately convey what you don't know.

And getting schools to do it doesn't seem to be the answer either.

DrSbaitso · 06/01/2022 13:37

Parents can't teach it if they don't know either.

I'd like to see a government awareness campaign. Not telling people what to do, but giving information so they can make an informed decision. Can't get over a PP getting worked up over the idea that marriage is nothing more or less than a legal contract...

I should contact my MP, I suppose, but he's a lazy useless dickhead who doesn't give a shit.

Iamthewombat · 06/01/2022 13:32

Well, surely the problem was that she DIDN’T know, and it would have been better for her to have picked up that knowledge at some point in her life?

I get what you are saying, schools can’t teach all life skills, but this would be an excellent candidate for the PHSE (? I might have the acronym wrong) syllabus, wouldn’t it?

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 06/01/2022 13:16

Also, why is the answer on here about ANYTHING always it should be taught in schools.

How much time do these people think there in in schools to to teach children everything they ever need to know? Most of this should be taught by parents.

Laws change and knowledge grows. What you might have been taught in the 80’s and 90’s is not necessary the current law / understanding. You cannot expect to know everything you will ever need to know from school. You are supposed to be continuing to learn throughout your life.

At some point adults have to take responsibility to educate themselves before they make decisions.

The pp’s friend who didnt believe common law husband wasnt a thing certainly didnt learn that at school.

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 06/01/2022 13:10

@thepeopleversuswork it is.

What type of school do you work in where it isnt?
What type of campaigning have you been doing?

thepeopleversuswork · 06/01/2022 12:53

@FallonCarringtonWannabe

I have been banging on about this forever but I think this ought to be taught in school. It is.
Is it?
WhatNoRaisins · 06/01/2022 12:48

It's almost as though people think anything can become real if enough people keep saying it

Iamthewombat · 06/01/2022 12:21

Is it taught in schools now? Excellent.

One of my otherwise smart friends was in a quandary a few years ago about asking her ex-boyfriend to move out by a certain date, even though he hadn’t found anywhere to live yet (they had literally split a couple of days previously, amicably) because “after two years he gets half the house because he’ll be my common law husband”.

We all tried to correct her, but she was having none of it. No, common law spouses were A THING! And this was an intelligent professional woman. Christ.

Swipe left for the next trending thread