Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men who refuse to marry the mothers of their children

408 replies

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 19:21

You see that so often on here. I don’t mean couples where both parties are happy to marry, but ones where the man refuses despite their partner desperately wanting it, or else strings them along indefinitely.

Is there any reason at all, other than that he doesn’t want to have any duty to provide her with financial security for if they break up? So not only is he already thinking about potentially leaving, he’s happy to fuck over the person he ostensibly currently loves if they do break up.

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it. I suppose the ones being strung along have just been lied to, but having children is actually the bigger commitment in many ways. You’re joined for life. It seems so nasty to be prepared to do that, but not offer your partner the security and commitment they want.

OP posts:
SenselessUbiquity · 02/01/2022 20:30

@DrSbaitso

Honestly, I find that generally speaking, men do want to marry if they love the woman. That's why the ultimatum sometimes works. They realise that they will lose her otherwise, and they don't want to, so they commit. And usually, in those cases, find that they like it.

When they won't commit, ie won't marry, it's generally because they don't love her, or don't love her enough. And it's deeply saddening how many of them will string a woman along until she's lost her chance for children, then get with another younger woman for marriage and a family. As horrible as it is, I don't think these guys, as arseholish as they are, do it maliciously and intentionally. They're just happy enough with the situation, never had to make a serious decision about it, and only once they realise that they've lost their chance of kids if they stay with this woman, are they prompted into what they really want, what they're prepared to change for. Much like when they get an ultimatum.

I know it's not ALWAYS the case that a man who won't marry just doesn't love his partner enough, but I think it's true more often than not, especially when the woman does want marriage. And that's not a fault of the woman. She hasn't failed just because this dude doesn't love her. But she should realise that she deserves to be loved properly.

The biological clock complicates everything, of course. I can understand why women accept a degree of shite if it looks to be their only chance of children. I sometimes wonder if menopause is actually nature's way of preventing men from evolving by almost forcing women to reproduce with shitheads, or have no kids at all.

I think much of this is bang-on.

Things might have changed now, but when I was in my 20s and early 30s, I think a lot of young women and men were living together on completely asymmetrical terms: the man was enjoying a nicer home and better companionship that he would have had alone or in some horrible blokey house share, and the woman thought they were on the path to marriage. Lots of those couples broke up around 30, 31, 32, 33 and the woman was broken hearted - effectively divorced; the man had always seen it as a "starter relationship" which is something that a woman who knows she wants children doesn't really quite have as much time for as a man.

Some of these couples had children and I think, weirdly, it is easier for men to allow themselves to be sort of eased into becoming a parent than getting married. They kid themselves it "just happened," even as they knew they didn't love or respect her all that much.

I had children without getting married but not because he wouldn't marry me; I didn't want to marry him, but I didn't really understand why, and I was getting too hold to have children soon, and he really wanted them, and we did. I realised later that my strange feelings about not wanting to marry him were to do with how he treated me and my deep sense that he never really had my back. Had I thought more clearly about it and understood that, I would not have had children with him - and probably not at all. I was glad I didn't marry him - he was the wrong man.

wombleflump · 02/01/2022 20:26

Why marry if your partner earns less, drinks, Is Irresponsible with money and secretly you detest them. Keep your own career and assets. Never rely on a man to provide for you!

I would never marry again unless they were super wealthy 😂

Blossom64265 · 02/01/2022 20:26

I am perplexed by this as well. Obviously caveating the discussion to only include women who do believe in marriage, I don’t understand why so many women have decided to agree to take the huge risk of having children without getting married first. It’s not like women don’t have any power. They could simply decline to become mothers without marriage. I am sure someone will come along to point out that weddings are expensive, but expensive weddings are not required for a marriage to take place. If a couple wants to move on to other phases like buying a home and having children, they may just need to skip the big party.

It’s frustrating seeing these women acting like they are passive passengers to a life that is just happening to them. It feels like the feminist lessons we learned from the previous generations have been misunderstood and mistranslated by the generation coming up and they have re-combined the various messages into the worst possible setup for women.

CCC2 · 02/01/2022 20:25

My partner of 13 years died suddenly. I had wanted to marry for years but he always had a reason not to. I am not a 'widow' so no widows pension and also left me and our 2 young kids in a financial mess.
I am so angry with him and also with myself. I should never have allowed myself to be in this position.

AlDanvers · 02/01/2022 20:25

@SparrowNestbut I wanted to be married to make a lifelong commitment to each other. Now I’m a SAHM, with a view to going back to work after a few years break, I’m glad for the security of it. Partly, just the emotional security of knowing my husband hasn’t deliberately avoided making a commitment to split assets because he’s thinking in terms of leaving.

in reality marriage is not a life long commitment. Which is a good thing. Its the intention to make a life long commitment. But marriage often fails.

You can make a life long commitment or the intention to be together for life and not be married.

If you believe the decision by men, to not marry, is only ever financially motivated....do you believe women who want to marry are also only financially motivated?

Its good you got married before. If its important then you should.

No one has the right to work part time be financially support by a man or impose marriage or expect on going financial support (other than for the kids) after the relationship ends. Even on divorce, spousal maintenence is extremely rare (in the UK) and usually only for a short time when it is used.

So if the man doesn't want to get married don't through your eggs on their basket.

Women in this position are choosing it. Even if they say 'yeah one day'. They are choosing to crack on regardless. We have to take responsibility for our own decisions.

LittleRoundRobin · 02/01/2022 20:25

I am torn here. On the one hand, I agree that it's shit that men won't marry the mothers of their children. Then again, my sympathy only stretches so far, because these women do choose to have a baby with their man before they're married. So I can't vote as I am totally on the fence.

FinallyHere · 02/01/2022 20:22

@Phrenologistsfinger

In my case (ttc) Capital Gains Tax, innit. You have a joint allowance when married. If you both own a place, you lose out. Not the case in all these situations ofc.
I'm not following this @Phrenologistsfinger

Are you saying that CGT allowance is shared between married couples in the UK? That's not been my experience.

On the contrary, assets can be transferred between married couples without incurring tax. Transferring assets is one way to take advantage of the CGT allowance for both partners to the marriage.

A few years ago, our company was bought out at a price significantly higher than the trading price for shares This mean a CGT due on the amount over the annual allowance. Anyone who was married, could transfer shares to their partner to take advantage of both allowances.

If things have changed, I'd be glad to know about it. I have googled just now and not found anything to suggest that things have changed.

ivykaty44 · 02/01/2022 20:21

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it

same reason they agree to have children with them if there wasn't going to be an equal contract?

Dozer · 02/01/2022 20:19

Agree that when people don’t want to marry it’s almost always because the person with more financial assets - or the prospect of gaining money over time, eg through career progression or inheritance - wouldn’t want to share the money with their partner in the event of divorce. Even with existing or future DC to consider.

In most cases, fathers’ economic position is at least equivalent to their position before becoming a father, whilst mothers’ is substantially worse. Few fathers are willing to work part time and hardly any to SAH.

As for why some women with fewer financial assets than their partner don’t insist on marriage before DC, perhaps inequality in dating and relationships means that we consider our options and opportunities and make trade offs and take risks, especially if our age or health means we have fertility concerns. For example, someone in her mid 30s in a long term relationship who wants DC might think that a substantial proportion of men prefer to date younger women and/or not to marry. So might take the chance to have DC, even without marriage.

AlDanvers, I disagree with you: one can be emotionally committed without marriage, have some shared financial assets etc. Buy financial commitment is much less outside marriage because assets are not shared post break up.

Bagamoyo1 · 02/01/2022 20:19

I think the only reason people don’t want to get married is because they think they might regret it. They might worry they’ll lose money, or meet someone they like more, or have to give up assets/lifestyle - basically that their life will change in a way they’re not 100% sure about. And they worry they won’t be able to go back to how things were before.
I say this as someone who has been proposed to several times and engaged once, but been unable to actually commit to getting married!

FinallyHere · 02/01/2022 20:18

why people accept that kind of treatment.

Many of the people posting about it on MN appear to have had such a strong drive to have children, that they prioritise children while they are in their fertile years.

Anything else is considered less important

Id guess that men do it because they can.

FallonCarringtonWannabe · 02/01/2022 20:17

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it
And there we go. No matter what men do, it is always that fault of women.

Viviennemary · 02/01/2022 20:16

If I was a man who had a good job, savings and maybe a house of my own I wouldn't want to get married either. And have somebody come after my pension. No thanks.

DrSbaitso · 02/01/2022 20:16

Honestly, I find that generally speaking, men do want to marry if they love the woman. That's why the ultimatum sometimes works. They realise that they will lose her otherwise, and they don't want to, so they commit. And usually, in those cases, find that they like it.

When they won't commit, ie won't marry, it's generally because they don't love her, or don't love her enough. And it's deeply saddening how many of them will string a woman along until she's lost her chance for children, then get with another younger woman for marriage and a family. As horrible as it is, I don't think these guys, as arseholish as they are, do it maliciously and intentionally. They're just happy enough with the situation, never had to make a serious decision about it, and only once they realise that they've lost their chance of kids if they stay with this woman, are they prompted into what they really want, what they're prepared to change for. Much like when they get an ultimatum.

I know it's not ALWAYS the case that a man who won't marry just doesn't love his partner enough, but I think it's true more often than not, especially when the woman does want marriage. And that's not a fault of the woman. She hasn't failed just because this dude doesn't love her. But she should realise that she deserves to be loved properly.

The biological clock complicates everything, of course. I can understand why women accept a degree of shite if it looks to be their only chance of children. I sometimes wonder if menopause is actually nature's way of preventing men from evolving by almost forcing women to reproduce with shitheads, or have no kids at all.

CatsArePeople · 02/01/2022 20:15

If it’s that important to a woman they shouldn’t have children until they are married.

Sometimes women get bad advice from the older generation. Like - Mr. Wrong won't marry ya? Get yourself knocked up and he will have to do "the right thing". Doesn't work this way anymore.

Regularsizedrudy · 02/01/2022 20:15

I think for the women it’s a sunk costs fallacy. They don’t want to start all over again. As for the men I think they don’t love these women, they just think they will do and usually in these situations you find out the woman is doing loads for the man in terms of household crap. So why would they give that up.

fallfallfall · 02/01/2022 20:14

marriage is far less common now than 40+ years ago as is religion which often is supportive of marriage.
when choosing a partner if marriage is important make sure it's important to him as well.
i suspect many young men did not grow up in families where the mother was married, or not a member of a religious community which supports marriage so they just don't "know" about it.
ideally the community you make your vows in, supports you in times of struggle and helps both partners understand each other's views.
now there is MN AIBU and a slew of "therapists" which know nothing about your unique family circumstances.

IncompleteSenten · 02/01/2022 20:14

I think too many women are ruled by their hearts not their heads.

I knew there was no way I was having children unless married because I am not romantic and I don't 100% trust anyone.

If marriage before children is important then that's the deal you make and you stick to it.

If it's not important then no problem. But if it's what you want then don't put that aside because of pretty words and promises of soon.

Phrenologistsfinger · 02/01/2022 20:11

In my case (ttc) Capital Gains Tax, innit. You have a joint allowance when married. If you both own a place, you lose out. Not the case in all these situations ofc.

Covidclaire · 02/01/2022 20:11

If it’s that important to a woman they shouldn’t have children until they are married.

Ivchangedmynameforthis · 02/01/2022 20:11

We were this couple. Id been married before, both of our parents had had failed marriages and now DH didn't ever want to get married. We had DC and whilst I was a bit sad about it it wasn't a huge deal until DH had a nasty accident and was minutes from death. He realised that not even just on a romantic level but on a practical level as responsible parents we should get married. No grand proposal or fancy wedding but we are happy.

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 20:10

@Crazykatie

I would say it’s almost always financial, whatever the stated reason is, a man with property or high income not wanting to have half of his wealth taken. ( or the perception of that). It’s very common in second partnerships, of course it can work both ways, if a woman has property or pensions, I’m sure it will become more common.”

“Ask for financial advice” oh yea, the only answer you will get is don’t get married.

Yes, this is my assumption. Whatever reason they might give, generally it’s actually (real or imagined) financial concerns that put them off.
OP posts:
SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 20:09

@AlDanvers

So they’re still thinking in terms of screwing the mother of their children over.

So women only want to marry to be entitled to be provided for?

I don't think that's true.

And if you haven't got married, not getting g anything isn't being screwed. You know you aren't married. You are an adult who can fund out all the information you need.

Its not a secret.

I wanted to be married to make a lifelong commitment to each other. Now I’m a SAHM, with a view to going back to work after a few years break, I’m glad for the security of it. Partly, just the emotional security of knowing my husband hasn’t deliberately avoided making a commitment to split assets because he’s thinking in terms of leaving.
OP posts:
CatsArePeople · 02/01/2022 20:09

there are many variables. property, finance, extended family. Narriage doesn't always mean security. It can be the opposite, let's say your partner has a lot of debt.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 02/01/2022 20:06

I don’t think it’s even as sinister as wanting to screw over their partner, I think most men don’t want to get married. Both men and women are being taught to be independent: women work, men cook and clean- why is marriage important to show commitment?