Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men who refuse to marry the mothers of their children

408 replies

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 19:21

You see that so often on here. I don’t mean couples where both parties are happy to marry, but ones where the man refuses despite their partner desperately wanting it, or else strings them along indefinitely.

Is there any reason at all, other than that he doesn’t want to have any duty to provide her with financial security for if they break up? So not only is he already thinking about potentially leaving, he’s happy to fuck over the person he ostensibly currently loves if they do break up.

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it. I suppose the ones being strung along have just been lied to, but having children is actually the bigger commitment in many ways. You’re joined for life. It seems so nasty to be prepared to do that, but not offer your partner the security and commitment they want.

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 02/01/2022 20:54

My brother (now aged 71) has never married and never wanted children. He was never a high earner nor did he have 'assets' to protect. For him it was simply because he didn't want to surrender his freedom and the ability to make his decisions on his own. But he was always 100% honest about it with any woman he was involved with. He lived with a few women over the years and most of the relationships ended when the woman started pushing for marriage, either he ended it or she did.

I think the loss of freedom is what stops a lot of men and women from marrying. They might 'commit' and it may even last a lifetime, but they always want the 'open crack in the front door' that not being married gives. Marriage means that door is shut, not locked, but it's not as easy to get outside. I think that's the main reason people don't want to marry, much more than trying to protect assets or finances.

A580Hojas · 02/01/2022 20:53

I'm in my late 50s and so are most of my friends. In my close friendship circle (let's say I'm friends with 20 couples) I know 3 who are not married but have been with their partners for 20 or 30 years. They are all the lower earners and they all did the majority of childcare or organising of the childcare when their kids were little.

Dozer · 02/01/2022 20:53

Yes of course, mathanxiety a will can be changed. But if made in good faith it mitigates some of the financial risks with death, for the duration of the relationship.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 02/01/2022 20:52

To the women on here (smugly) telling us how they got married before children and asking why don't we all do the same: I'll bet all of you were actually asked by your husband to get married before you seriously wanted to have a baby with him.

A lot of couples move in together once they have been dating a while. Convention dictates that the women has to be passive about marriage and wait and wait some more to be asked while her eggs get older. The proposal appears to be the man committing himself to the woman, rather than a mutual decision.

However, having a baby together is usually a mutual decision, so it's deemed acceptable for the woman to broach the subject and persuade the man. It seems to me that it's easier to get his DNA than a proposal.

We need to change our daughters' mindset: You can discuss marriage and insist upon if if you are a woman. Do not wait for him like a book on a shelf. You are a valuable, smart and talented person. If he's not thrilled at the thought of having you forever, dump his ass. Do not idealise big proposals, expensive engagement rings or fancy weddings that let a man put off the proposal while he waits for the right time or saves the money.

BoredtoTiers · 02/01/2022 20:51

YABU if only because a couple should ideally (barring unplanned pregnancy) be on the same page regarding marriage before committing to children.

DH and I had a home, joint mortgage etc. before marriage BUT we were earning similar, had similar earning potential and both had sufficient to support a similar lifestyle if it all went tits up. Most importantly, though, we didn't have children.

I realise all relationships are different, but genuinely can't fathom how people end up having planned children with someone with whom they can't have an open & honest conversation about life plans.

LittleRoundRobin · 02/01/2022 20:50

@Blossom64265

I am perplexed by this as well. Obviously caveating the discussion to only include women who do believe in marriage, I don’t understand why so many women have decided to agree to take the huge risk of having children without getting married first. It’s not like women don’t have any power. They could simply decline to become mothers without marriage. I am sure someone will come along to point out that weddings are expensive, but expensive weddings are not required for a marriage to take place. If a couple wants to move on to other phases like buying a home and having children, they may just need to skip the big party.

It’s frustrating seeing these women acting like they are passive passengers to a life that is just happening to them. It feels like the feminist lessons we learned from the previous generations have been misunderstood and mistranslated by the generation coming up and they have re-combined the various messages into the worst possible setup for women.

100% this. Excellent post. ^
mug2018 · 02/01/2022 20:50

I have been married & now divorced & have no desire to remarry
My partner (m) frequently asks me to marry him & I frequently refuse: we are both financially stable and do not need a piece of paper to feel secure & committed in our relationship
It's seems to me, very odd that this post is aimed at men who refuse marriage, when it's equally a right for the woman to refuse .

Bluesarestillblue · 02/01/2022 20:48

I think a lot of men are still holding out for something better... and like stringing the woman along.

Early in our relationship I told DH that after a few years in a relationship I’d be looking to get married. And definitely before kids were on the way. I would move on if that wasn’t for the man I was with.

DH proposed after 3 years of dating. He said he wasn’t massively fussed about marriage, but he knew it was important to me, and he wanted to be with me for the rest of his life.

mathanxiety · 02/01/2022 20:48

That can be addressed through a will...

Wills can be changed.

Man leaves partner and children, takes up with someone else or even marries her, changes will.

First woman is screwed.

mathanxiety · 02/01/2022 20:46

With a big dollop of ignorance of the law.

Hankunamatata · 02/01/2022 20:46

Depends what is important to you. Marriage was important to me and dh. Discussed in early days where we both thought a relationship should head. Marriage was prioritised for us, we did it on the cheap. I wouldn't have stayed with dh if marriage hadn't been forthcoming within the year and he was of the same mind.

IamGusFring · 02/01/2022 20:45

@Crazykatie

I would say it’s almost always financial, whatever the stated reason is, a man with property or high income not wanting to have half of his wealth taken. ( or the perception of that). It’s very common in second partnerships, of course it can work both ways, if a woman has property or pensions, I’m sure it will become more common.”

“Ask for financial advice” oh yea, the only answer you will get is don’t get married.

If that is the answer you get then you need a better IFA .

Time and time again on here I read people saying that marriage means you wave goodbye to your finances . There are pre nups and post nups and despite not being legal as written in the law as yet they are in practice .

Dozer · 02/01/2022 20:45

That can be addressed through a will, RobotValkyrie.

My take on it is that fathers who don’t want to marry their partners want to retain maximum possible financial assets in the event of a break up, and decide how to use the money, eg how much maintenance to pay for DC above the minimum. Rather than a court requiring them to share it.

Don’t think it necessarily follows that those men are shit fathers. Unless, post break up, they act in certain ways, eg paying no or only low maintenance.

I don’t much like or respect men who encourage or allow the mother of their DC to do things that benefit the men and (arguably, in the short term) DC but damage her financial position, eg SAH.

AngelinaFibres · 02/01/2022 20:45

@TeenyQueen

I think the financial aspect of marriage is one thing, but we often forget that marriage bring both parties a lot of legal protections if someone dies or is seriously injured. It also gives you the right to use the same surname, which was actually very important to me, I would hate to have a different name than my children.

I would not have had children with DH unless we were married, if we'd had an unplanned pregnancy I would have expected to get married before the baby was born (I was never fussed about having a big wedding).

Some people say that marriage is just a piece of paper, but it's a pretty important piece of paper legally if something goes wrong.

It is the most important piece of paper you will ever have. When my husband decided to become my exhusband he turned into a person I no longer recognised. I have no doubt that if my children and I had not had the legal protection provided by the marriage certificate he would have simply disappeared into the sunset with the new and exciting 17 year old girlfriend and I would been left in a huge mess. As they say "Hope for the best, prepare for the worst". Having been through a divorce I can honestly say I wouldn't buy a secondhand car with someone I wasn't legally married to. I would certainly never buy a house,have children etc without it
mathanxiety · 02/01/2022 20:44

You're asking why women shoot themselves in the foot, or why women let men shot them in the foot.

The answer is low self esteem and toxic optimism.

BoodleBug51 · 02/01/2022 20:44

DH and I didn't marry until our eldest was 5 months.

When she was 3 months old, we decided to take out life insurance and write our wills and it was pretty horrifying to realise that if something happened to DH (I was a SAHM) I was pretty much screwed. We married quickly and quietly, then had a massive family party later that summer.

DH's sister never married her DP (he refused) and she got pretty shafted over when they split. He's got a lovely pension and was able to take early retirement at 50 while she's still working and trying to make her way back up the career ladder after a 10 year break raising their DC. She's very very bitter about it all.

thepeopleversuswork · 02/01/2022 20:43

Fundamentally most men don't want to get married unless they have to and I think a lot of women tolerate it because they are young and naive and "in love" and full of romantic ideas about creating a family with someone. Once they are pregnant by someone they think they are in love with its hard to play hardball over marriage and a lot of them tend not to want to push the point until its too late.

I think the post 1960s position on marriage created a toxic double whammy as well: the moral impetus on marriage fell away -- no-one cares any more about "living in sin" so everyone thought it was all fine to crack on with cohabiting and having babies, but a lot of women weren't told that marriage is primarily legal insurance for the non-working partner, as opposed to being something to do with romance or commitment or something you do to have a big party.

I think we need to be doing a better job of teaching our daughters what marriage really is and why and when its important: ie to protect you if you stay at home. So many young women still have warped and inaccurate perspectives on this.

Mouseonmychair · 02/01/2022 20:42

Men by and large aren't bothered about marriage in my experience and kids even less so especially when spelled out what equal parenting actually involves. Add into the mix that women often choose to take time out of their careers because "I carried it for 9 months" and go part time plus the risk of a man having to subsidize the wife in a divorce and half of all marriages will fail. I can see why marriage is a issue for them. Women can choose when to have children (they have the ultimate choice over continuing a pregnancy) they can make marriage and equally parenting a prerequisite for children but I would suspect the number of willing men would decrease rapidly.

XingMing · 02/01/2022 20:42

For me, marriage was purely about the security, public commitment and the legalities. I'd feel exactly the same about DH unmarried, after 30 years, but it means, at retirement age, legal entitlement to spousal pension benefits without quibbling, and better, more flexible options to leave everything we have mutually worked towards to our family. Of course, if you have nothing much to leave to your children and don't bother to make a will, then the most aggressive and acquisitive child will probably scoop the pot.

AlDanvers · 02/01/2022 20:41

Are we allowed to say that a man who refuses to marry the mother of his childrenis a shit father who does not even care about his own kids?

You are allowed to say it. But you are also saying women who have kids without getting married, are shit mothers

wombleflump · 02/01/2022 20:41

It’s not the 1950s. Most men are not waiting to provide you with a rose picket fenced cottage and provide for a wife to be a SAHM. Life is full of disappointments and messy relationships. How many people in the past were trapped in unhappy marriages.
People change. Maybe if you are a trophy wife type you can achieve this model of insisting someone marry you and support you having kids. Some of us just have to accept our own inadequacies and take the scraps😂

User342354252 · 02/01/2022 20:41

I don’t understand why so many women have decided to agree to take the huge risk of having children without getting married first.

Sadly I think many feel this is the actual step necessary to nudge the man into marriage and for some it works. Out of all our friends with babies, 50% were married beforehand, 30% hastily married during pregnancy and 20% remained unmarried after children, although a handful did end up married years later.

Surprisingly, many of the women tolerate it because they are equally if not wealthier than the man. So even though they know they're with a commitment-phobe, at least financial problems don't play a role even if the relationship ended.

For men it seems more like a matter of ease. Divorce is expensive and time-consuming whereas an unmarried split is as simple as packing a bag and leaving. Many are also not keen on the expenses that marriage entails, engagement ring, wedding, honeymoon etc. The loophole of having a small civil ceremony while pregnant seems to work well for men who primarily don't like the expense and faff of a huge wedding.

RobotValkyrie · 02/01/2022 20:36

Are we allowed to say that a man who refuses to marry the mother of his children is a shit father who does not even care about his own kids?

Parents are supposed to care about their kids. That does include "what would happen to my kids if I was to die?". Marrying the other parent ensures a straightforward inheritance process which reduces the risk of the kids and surviving parent falling on hard times. It also entitles the surviving parent to additional financial help: www.gov.uk/bereavement-support-payment

Unless a will has been set up and/or life insurance has been taken, a man who refuses to marry the mother of his own children essentially says "These kids mean nothing to me, I don't care what would happen to your lot if I was to die"

WonderfulYou · 02/01/2022 20:35

I’m not someone who ever wants to get married but I understand why a lot of women choose not to have sex before marriage - if someone says they want to be with you forever and have children with you and eventually get married, then why not do the marriage before the kids.

I know accidents happen but I don’t know why women who are desperate to get married don’t say we’re not having children until we get married.

MimiDaisy11 · 02/01/2022 20:32

I have noticed this pattern on here too OP. I have seen a few waiting for their partners to propose. I was in the situation of having a baby outside of marriage and it was me who proposed. I’m not sure we’d be getting married otherwise. So in some cases it’s not the men who are holding back on marriage but the women having outdated views. I think as well people avoid difficult conversations. Before our child was born we had a talk about securing our future and rewrote wills, took out life insurance etc. To some people this just makes them uncomfortable.