Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men who refuse to marry the mothers of their children

408 replies

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 19:21

You see that so often on here. I don’t mean couples where both parties are happy to marry, but ones where the man refuses despite their partner desperately wanting it, or else strings them along indefinitely.

Is there any reason at all, other than that he doesn’t want to have any duty to provide her with financial security for if they break up? So not only is he already thinking about potentially leaving, he’s happy to fuck over the person he ostensibly currently loves if they do break up.

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it. I suppose the ones being strung along have just been lied to, but having children is actually the bigger commitment in many ways. You’re joined for life. It seems so nasty to be prepared to do that, but not offer your partner the security and commitment they want.

OP posts:
Onlyrainbows · 03/01/2022 07:26

My now husband was never really bothered about getting married. I can't remember exactly the words he used but they were hurtful. His ex-wife got engaged before we did and that also made "the pain" worse. My DH didn't actually have any reason to not get married, in reality the one benefited in the long term out of it was him. One evening during lockdown I had a mini breakdown about it and told him I wasn't comfortable about being unmarried. So we then set the date, bit couldn't agree on the type of wedding and that went on for months... One day everything changed and he was actually happy and even thrilled about getting married. We got married and that's been one of the happiest days of our lives (small registry office wedding in the end). When I ask him why did he act the way he did he's very apologetic about it and just tells me that getting married has only made our lives better in every possible way. I think men in general don't see the point of getting married

NdujaWannaDance · 03/01/2022 07:16

If marriage is very, very important to you you need to insist on it before you have children. That's your leverage. If you've already given the other side exactly what they want without any conditions attached, then you have nothing to negotiate with.

MoreAloneTime · 03/01/2022 07:12

I think one of the problems with this is with women not having all the time in the world to have babies.

Say you're 35, you don't want to have kids before being married but you've been with your partner for 10 years and he doesn't believe in it. The prospect of the current dating scene makes you shudder (that's a whole other thread) and you know you may not have enough time to conceive by the time you've found someone else if you do at all.

I can see how a lot of these situations could make you feel passive and like you have to just make the best of what you have

TrishM80 · 03/01/2022 07:12

@RedCandyApple

Imo most men don’t want to get married, it’s mainly women despite MN harping on about how it benefits men more than women (getting married) most men don’t actually want to, mainly women.
Absolutely. For an institution that supposedly benefits men more than women, it's women who push for marriage more than men. How many times do we hear a couple is going on holiday somewhere, usually abroad, the woman's girlfriends will be getting her all hyped up about "ooh, he's going to pop the question on this trip, I know it!".

Then if the fella doesn't propose, the woman is devastated and he's in the doghouse for the next 6 months until he's almost guilted into proposing!

Rainbowqueeen · 03/01/2022 07:06

@sjxoxo. Agree completely.

In every aspect of life men are let off the hook. They are considered heroes for doing the school run.

And it’s a woman’s fault if she gets in the situation where she is unmarried and pregnant. There is nothing to stop men saying “yes our relationship has failed but I want the best for my kids so I will acknowledge all your unpaid work (which often they have encouraged as it has left them able to continue their careers unimpeded) so I will go above and beyond the minimum to ensure that their lifestyles change as little as possible. I will give you part of my pension. I will make sure you are housed adequately. I will take on my fair share of child rearing”.
But can anyone name an instance of that happening.

We need to hold men accountable for their unwillingness to do the right thing by their children and by their ex-partners.

sjxoxo · 03/01/2022 06:43

@Rainbowqueeen yes I think you are right -and why would they want to support the idea of marriage when for the last 50 years it has been presented as largely a negative thing for a man to do? This negative portrayal of marriage for men has run alongside the narrative for women being ‘independent, as sexually liberal as she likes, career minded, becoming a mother without the need for a man, having it all’… all have been peddled as positive changes for us women. Now in some cases of course they are. Domestic violence and abuse is lower today than it was in the 40s and we have more freedoms of course. But isn’t it ironic that this positive freedom for women means men are able to take less responsibility for their children and families? I’m not saying the patriarchy have had a meeting and decided they want out of family responsibilities so they can keep their pensions & play golf when they want; but it makes me very uneasy. What’s the solution.. yes to support women so when men do abandon their kids, women aren’t trapped in money & time poverty; but where are the efforts to encourage men to take responsibility for their families?? Is the only thing CMS??? Yet on this very thread, numerous people have mentioned free childcare, better maternity rights, better legal rights- all to encourage and support women. Nothing to encourage men to take responsibility? Xo

sharkyandme · 03/01/2022 06:33

I wouldn't settle for it.

Rainbowqueeen · 03/01/2022 06:29

Such a great point @sjxoxo.

I honestly think that the majority of men do t want to change. They are happy to take the extra work that women do outside the house, their labour inside the house and the ego boost and career enhancements that having a family gives them. But they are not prepared to put in additional work themselves. Which is truly depressing

G5000 · 03/01/2022 06:27

Everyone is different what works for some won't work for others

Fair enough. Except in the preceding paragraph you say that you would like to get married, but he doesn't. So it doesn't really 'work' for you, only for him.

PinniGig · 03/01/2022 05:33

I wasn't in any particular rush or push to marry at the time I did but my husband wanted us to tie the knot for legal reasons and to ensure financial security in the event anything happened to him.

He isn't the biological father of our daughter but we started seeing each other when she was only a few months old or so. No involvement or dealings whatsoever with the ex and my husband adored and has raised her as his own since before she could sit up straight.

I was working for family law solicitors and had her surnamed changed by deed poll already but husband was updating his will and insurance info so included a specific clause that in the event of his death, I was the sole beneficiary and in the event we died together, daughter was to inherit all his estate to be held in trust etc. It was on his mind that the house, his savings and insurance polices weren't necessarily going to come to us by default and with our daughter not his biological child, he had to straighten that out and get it sorted to feel more at ease and sleep easy.

I fell pregnant with our son about 18 months or so later and my husband was more keen for us to wrap it up and feel we were complete as a family by getting married. I didn't marry him out of obligation or because I knew he wanted to obviously – I wanted to marry him but I could have lived happily with us just as we are.

If I'd been that way inclined, it would have been an absolute doddle and a nice little earner for me to stick it out a couple of years, divorce him and take his house or a nice lump sum from its sale plus maintenance etc.

Couples can still have and arrange to work things so they are afforded the same legal rights without being married if they want. I think if either person in a relationship is less keen to marry than the other – it's probably not a good idea to get married at all.

sjxoxo · 03/01/2022 04:56

This is such an interesting thread.

The general consensus seems to be the way forward is to protect women by better societal rights, access to childcare, financial independence etc. These are all good, positive things of course & I am for them.

But there is something that bothers me with this modern, progressive approach- and it was touched on by @thepeopleversuswork in a slightly different context- where are the men in this?? Where is their responsibility? Yes ok let’s protect women, but that means what for the mens responsibility to society, to their families..? How can we encourage men to support family life - it seems to me (as a woman, currently pregnant as it happens, marrried) that I am doing a lot for my family.. I don’t want the sole responsibility of doing the baby making, the earning, and the child raising, on my own- even if I can & it’s not a total shitshow of a life due to societal rights; I don’t want that burden my whole life without the other person who is 50% responsible also carrying some load.

Depressingly this leads me to another rather existential question.. in that case if it’s all our responsibility because men have been written off as useless; who are we having kids for? Ourselves? For the kids? For future society? I don’t know the answer to that but I fear in future when we have a labour shortage & an aged population who need financial support from young, working demographics, in western capitalist society this question will be raised. Xo

SmellyOldPartridgeinaPearTree · 03/01/2022 03:57

Given the amount of shit marriages you read about on here I think any woman who doesn't want to legally tie herself to a man is wise.

CayrolBaaaskin · 03/01/2022 03:56

And i am shocked at the pps who speak about women doing «wifely duties» to men they aren’t married to and «why buy the cow when the milk is free» etc. Unless you are the lower earner, marriage won’t benefit you anyway - are we really still stuck on telling women to marry a rich man?

It’s sad that women still think like that. Let’s stop valuing women on who they married and start looking at their own achievements. Let’s tell our daughters to get great jobs and build their assets and change our child support system to one that is fit for purpose. That’s much better than telling them to marry well.

SunscreenCentral · 03/01/2022 03:54

@DesdemonaDryEyes

I can never understand why folk make such a big deal about proposals and weddings when they already share children and a house.
Oh please. Proposals and weddings are ridiculous and the older I get the more ridiculous they seem.

Social media is an utter plague now on bubonic levels.

The absolutely massive wedding industry and its associates (magazines/influencers/huge advertising) etc are lethal. Women are more plugged into it than men.

Oh Men are plugged into a whole world of other shit, don't get me wrong - gambling, drinking, football etc

Our lives are "inspired" all day long by advertising and sales and clicks and mens' lives are too.

Marriage is a contract. Nothing more, nothing less. Easy to get into, expensive to get out and we all know that.

CayrolBaaaskin · 03/01/2022 03:49

@RobotValkyrie - what nonsense that a «man who doesn’t marry the mother of his children says he doesn’t care about the dc on his death». He could make a will to leave his property to his partner or children and if he hasn’t made a will his children will inherit everything.

HoppingPavlova · 03/01/2022 03:32

I don’t think it’s unreasonable at all. If that’s important to someone, either man or woman, then check your partner is onboard and get married BEFORE having children. Then no need for anyone to cry hard done by after the fact. There’s a level of personal responsibility with all this that you are not acknowledging.

CayrolBaaaskin · 03/01/2022 03:24

@Rainbowqueeen - i agrée entirely that what’s really needed to improve womens lives is a child maintenance system that means the financial burden of children is shared. Not returning to the 50s where we shame women for being unmarried mothers.

CayrolBaaaskin · 03/01/2022 03:18

@SparrowNest - your post is sexist and outdated. Marriage doesn’t necessarily bring women financial security. A significant proportion of women are higher earners with more assets than their partners - they’re better off not being married. Many married women who give up their careers to have children end up impoverished on divorce.

We need more equal sharing of childcare and the costs of children between their parents. That way women can work on the same terms as men.

BFPDec21 · 03/01/2022 01:41

It's not really my business what those I know who aren't married do.

I just do hope they know the law and have wills etc., when it comes to inheritance and protecting their child/ren and their interests. A lot of people expect things automatically go to underage children when it's not the case. It can even be the expectation that you'd expect a next of kin to ensure your children are protected and family relationships don't always shape up how you'd expect. I think that goes both ways though and it's not necessarily the case that one party is unaware whilst the other is totally aware.

Rainbowqueeen · 03/01/2022 01:38

I think there’s been a lot of social change which has led to where we are now but the gaps in that social change are where women get screwed.

Now, having children without being married or living with a partner without being married has lost most of its social stigma.

Abandoning your children or doing the absolute bare minimum for men has not lost its social stigma.

And this is where women lose out. Children need a certain level of care and funds in order to thrive. And it’s women who, on the whole, provide this. So women miss out on opportunities to build their careers and fund their retirement in the way that men do. Until this changes, marriage is a way for women to even up the playing field. And even that generally doesn’t get them to where men are.

We could instantly improve many womens lives by addressing the flaws in CSA and in stigmatising men who don’t put in the hard yards in raising their children.

Deadringer · 03/01/2022 01:13

I am in my late 50s and i don't agree at all that waiting for a proposal was the convention when i was young. My dh and i talked about marriage and decided together when the time felt right, in hindsight we were probably a bit young at 23, but we were both earning and in a position to buy a house. All of my friends and family were the same (i have 7 sisters), they all decided to get married as a couple. One or two of them did the whole proposal thing, but after they had already agreed to marry. The romantic proposal thing is a modern concept imo, traditionally a man would determine when he was in a financially stable position and ready to marry and would propose, as he would be expected to provide for his wife and any children that came along, there was nothing romantic about it. Now that women can and do provide for themselves this romantic proposal nonsense has come about, though i can never quite figure out what is romantic about waiting around for a man to decide your future for you.

Iamthewombat · 03/01/2022 00:20

Oh yes, for sure. We (women) have to stop enabling them!

thepeopleversuswork · 03/01/2022 00:16

@Iamthewombat

I totally agree that if a woman wants marriage she should hold the line on this before cohabiting and having babies. I'm just not sure that its true that women have become more passive and weak. I don't think they have, I just think men have more freedom and are generally far less willing to get married these days. I think deep down the majority of men will avoid marriage if they think they can.

mathanxiety · 03/01/2022 00:13

They might 'commit' and it may even last a lifetime, but they always want the 'open crack in the front door' that not being married gives. Marriage means that door is shut, not locked, but it's not as easy to get outside. I think that's the main reason people don't want to marry, much more than trying to protect assets or finances.

It's pretty easy to divorce.

It's not pretty easy to take all of your money and assets with you if you get divorced.

Iamthewombat · 03/01/2022 00:08

I totally agree that sitting around waiting for a proposal is a terrible idea. But until fairly recently that was the convention. Within my lifetime (I'm early 50s) it was frowned upon for a woman to initiate marriage discussions.

The woman doesn’t have to propose. She just makes it clear that any moving in and having babies will only be happening with somebody she is married to.

Although in my view, if you are older than your mid twenties and you have been seeing somebody for more than two years and he hasn’t initiated a conversation about the future, you are on a hiding to nothing and should move on. The PP who said that men will commit to marriage when they think you are the best they can get is spot on.