Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Men who refuse to marry the mothers of their children

408 replies

SparrowNest · 02/01/2022 19:21

You see that so often on here. I don’t mean couples where both parties are happy to marry, but ones where the man refuses despite their partner desperately wanting it, or else strings them along indefinitely.

Is there any reason at all, other than that he doesn’t want to have any duty to provide her with financial security for if they break up? So not only is he already thinking about potentially leaving, he’s happy to fuck over the person he ostensibly currently loves if they do break up.

My AIBU is that I don’t understand why women tolerate it. I suppose the ones being strung along have just been lied to, but having children is actually the bigger commitment in many ways. You’re joined for life. It seems so nasty to be prepared to do that, but not offer your partner the security and commitment they want.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VikingOnTheFridge · 09/01/2022 16:48

@CatsArePeople

Children involve no inherent commitment at all to the other parent.

Unless you use an anonymous sperm donor or conceive via one night stand with a total stranger, it's very likely that your child's father will be in your life to some degree.

Which is not at all the same thing as them having made a commitment to you, let alone one that's more significant than marriage. People insist on conflating the two.
G5000 · 09/01/2022 15:38

If they want to be. Many men will happily walk away, never see or think of their children, and there's nothing you can do about it. At least in case of dividing the marital property, there are legal options available.

CatsArePeople · 09/01/2022 15:06

Children involve no inherent commitment at all to the other parent.

Unless you use an anonymous sperm donor or conceive via one night stand with a total stranger, it's very likely that your child's father will be in your life to some degree.

Porcupineintherough · 07/01/2022 23:46

Men retain their earning power but women are generally the ones to retain the children. I know which was more important to me.

EightWheelGirl · 07/01/2022 20:43

For God's sake change the username, you're not fooling anyone. You can insult women's work and life experiences, but do you have to insult our intelligence too?

What's insulting is the insinuation that no woman could possibly disagree with you, ergo anybody that does is male. No true Scotsman.

Yes, men retain their earning power and are usually in a substantially better position if the marriage fails. But that's the risk you take if you accept the privilege of not working and being bankrolled by a man.

Read the below posts from the thread I mentioned above and honestly tell me if you can imagine a man posting them. Of course not all women are this privileged but then not all men are housework dodgers.

My DSis married a very high earner and has never worked a day in her life.

I dont work, I was able to be a sahm with my sons, both in 30s now. I lunch, dressmake, walk my dogs for miles, spend time with friends and family etc....
I also volunteer for a small homeless charity, something I am so passionate about, being literally close to home.
I feel totally fulfilled!

My DH works 80 hours a week for a signficant amount of money, which allows me to be a SAHM and indulge myself, allow me to do all of my volunteering and my hobbies.

I work just a few hours a week in a job I love doing, I don’t have to work for financial reasons. I’ve accidentally ended up with a really high earning DH. I enjoy having lots of time to myself, I have hobbies, an amazing spa membership and an extremely fortunate to have some really good friends whom I’m able to see nearly every week

AlexaShutUp · 07/01/2022 08:17

@vivainsomnia

If we actually lived in a world where men, on the whole, did their fair share of childcare and domestic work even when their partner works full time, and there was no pay gap, and no natural consequences of children that affect girls more, you might have a point And so the suction is marriage? How retrograde. How about teaching young girls to ensure that their boyfriend are active in domestic duties before moving in together, discuss and fully agree how these duties will be divided, as well as childcare shared and insist it is stuck to instead of giving up and demanding marriage?

Unless deep inside many women are happy to be the main provider of childcare and home duties rather than the provider of finances.

I agree. We should be encouraging girls to insist on the equal sharing of domestic duties and childcare responsibilities, not encouraging them to accept inequality on condition of marriage!
vivainsomnia · 07/01/2022 08:14

If we actually lived in a world where men, on the whole, did their fair share of childcare and domestic work even when their partner works full time, and there was no pay gap, and no natural consequences of children that affect girls more, you might have a point
And so the suction is marriage? How retrograde. How about teaching young girls to ensure that their boyfriend are active in domestic duties before moving in together, discuss and fully agree how these duties will be divided, as well as childcare shared and insist it is stuck to instead of giving up and demanding marriage?

Unless deep inside many women are happy to be the main provider of childcare and home duties rather than the provider of finances.

WhatNoRaisins · 07/01/2022 07:59

Am I right that another widely believed myth is that child maintenance is properly enforced?

VikingOnTheFridge · 07/01/2022 07:12

I'm saying children are more of a commitment for women than marriage

Ok, that's not really the point though. Children involve no inherent commitment at all to the other parent. It's a discussion about commitment in a partnership. It's because children are almost always such a big commitment for a woman that this matters.

thepeopleversuswork · 06/01/2022 23:19

@EightWheelGirl

Men and women have their own unique challenges but working part time once the kids are at school or grown up is a privilege not an oppression and the threads I've read on here support this

That's a subjective point of view and I am not even going to going there on the point that this is largely socially conditioned. But your view that working part time is a privilege isn't relevant.

The fact that many women downgrade their capacity to earn money during the time they are caring for children leaves them financially vulnerable. This is usually compounded by the fact they do the lion's share of domestic and child-related labour -- whether they work or not. That's what housework has to do with it.

The compound of these things is that men's earning power and assets generally significantly outstrip those of women over time while women typically work equally or harder than men (whether domestically or outside the home or in combination). If a partnership then breaks down and the woman doesn't have her own assets or the protection of marriage, she's up shit creek.

It's nothing to do with "victimhood" -- its just very obvious that there is not a level playing field and pretending that all women are secretly dying to give up work doesn't change that.

DrSbaitso · 06/01/2022 22:40

@EightWheelGirl

The recent advice on here was don't get married if you have significantly more assets than your husband. Surely this is just the reverse?

Oh girl, girl, you girl you. If we actually lived in a world where men, on the whole, did their fair share of childcare and domestic work even when their partner works full time, and there was no pay gap, and no natural consequences of children that affect girls more, you might have a point. On the whole, though, we don't. And I know you want that not to make a difference, being such a girl, but it does.

Of course, as a girl, you'll also be well aware of the implications of having children upon a girl.

What's housework got to do with men not wanting to risk their assets in the face of fairly challenging odds that the marriage will last?

I'm sceptical of common rhetoric around the pay gap tbh considering that it only kicks in around the age of motherhood, with women in both the UK/US having outearned men until the age of 35-40 for over 10 years now. The Economist even commissioned a study which found that childless women 'continued to be promoted more aggressively than their male counterparts'. The economist Kate Andrews mentions this in her debate about the pay gap with feminist Kate Smurthwaite which can be found on YT.

I don't buy all this victimhood nonsense tbh. Men and women have their own unique challenges but working part time once the kids are at school or grown up is a privilege not an oppression and the threads I've read on here support this - read the thread 'you're lucky if you don't have to work' and witness all the posters opining about how lucky they were to marry a high earner who loves his job and had allowed her to give up working and enjoy life. The suicide rate amongst middle aged men wouldn't be so high if they were living the dream surely. Working 45 years without more than a couple of weeks off consecutively doesn't sound very appealing to me at all.

Men as a group definitely hold the power by large, but the average man is pretty much just a workhorse supporting his family via a mundane job whilst his wife supports the family via mundane domestic shit.

I don't even know where to start with this, and I'm tired, and we all know who you are and what your agenda is, so I'll keep it brief.

It takes more than money to run a household, especially with kids. It's usually the woman doing the "invisible work" that leaves the way clear for the man to prioritise earning. Which means that that if the relationship fails, he's likely to be able to support himself better, and if the woman is protected, she gets a fair share of the assets she cleared the way for him to earn. I am, of course, working on the assumption that he was happy to have her raising his kids and cleaning his house while they were together. If he fought to reduce his work responsibilities so he could do this, you may have a point, but that's rare on a class level.

As for you not grasping the significance of the pay gap kicking in around the age of motherhood...Girl, indeed. At least you're not calling us "females" this time, I guess.

For God's sake change the username, you're not fooling anyone. You can insult women's work and life experiences, but do you have to insult our intelligence too?

ComtesseDeSpair · 06/01/2022 22:27

Well yes, of course they are, because it’s mainly women who stick around to raise them. Which is why it’s in a woman’s interest to do her best to ensure that she has the means to do so: either through marrying their father so he has legal and financial obligations to her; or if she doesn’t marry him, making sure she never puts herself in a vulnerable position by giving up her career, not insisting on being on the house deeds, and becoming financially dependent.

That’s what this thread is about.

EightWheelGirl · 06/01/2022 22:23

@ComtesseDeSpair

I dunno. Children are a bit more permanent than a spouse. Can't be reversed like a marriage.

Almost 50% of non-resident parents in the UK (95% of them men) pay no child maintenance at all or are in significant arrears. Data from Gingerbread indicates that around 40% of non-resident parents (still almost entirely men) never or rarely see their children.

Even if we accept that some of those men are the former partners of all those “crazy exs” we hear about who deny access and won’t give details for payment, that’s a hell of a lot of parents (fathers) who don’t seem to be treating their children as a permanent commitment, isn’t it?

And sure, marriage doesn’t prevent men being deadbeat dads, but it does often mean that a woman at least walks away on divorce with enough assets to be able to get by and raise those children when their father has no interest in them.

I'm saying children are more of a commitment for women than marriage is.
ComtesseDeSpair · 06/01/2022 22:20

I dunno. Children are a bit more permanent than a spouse. Can't be reversed like a marriage.

Almost 50% of non-resident parents in the UK (95% of them men) pay no child maintenance at all or are in significant arrears. Data from Gingerbread indicates that around 40% of non-resident parents (still almost entirely men) never or rarely see their children.

Even if we accept that some of those men are the former partners of all those “crazy exs” we hear about who deny access and won’t give details for payment, that’s a hell of a lot of parents (fathers) who don’t seem to be treating their children as a permanent commitment, isn’t it?

And sure, marriage doesn’t prevent men being deadbeat dads, but it does often mean that a woman at least walks away on divorce with enough assets to be able to get by and raise those children when their father has no interest in them.

EightWheelGirl · 06/01/2022 22:20

The recent advice on here was don't get married if you have significantly more assets than your husband. Surely this is just the reverse?

Oh girl, girl, you girl you. If we actually lived in a world where men, on the whole, did their fair share of childcare and domestic work even when their partner works full time, and there was no pay gap, and no natural consequences of children that affect girls more, you might have a point. On the whole, though, we don't. And I know you want that not to make a difference, being such a girl, but it does.

Of course, as a girl, you'll also be well aware of the implications of having children upon a girl.

What's housework got to do with men not wanting to risk their assets in the face of fairly challenging odds that the marriage will last?

I'm sceptical of common rhetoric around the pay gap tbh considering that it only kicks in around the age of motherhood, with women in both the UK/US having outearned men until the age of 35-40 for over 10 years now. The Economist even commissioned a study which found that childless women 'continued to be promoted more aggressively than their male counterparts'. The economist Kate Andrews mentions this in her debate about the pay gap with feminist Kate Smurthwaite which can be found on YT.

I don't buy all this victimhood nonsense tbh. Men and women have their own unique challenges but working part time once the kids are at school or grown up is a privilege not an oppression and the threads I've read on here support this - read the thread 'you're lucky if you don't have to work' and witness all the posters opining about how lucky they were to marry a high earner who loves his job and had allowed her to give up working and enjoy life. The suicide rate amongst middle aged men wouldn't be so high if they were living the dream surely. Working 45 years without more than a couple of weeks off consecutively doesn't sound very appealing to me at all.

Men as a group definitely hold the power by large, but the average man is pretty much just a workhorse supporting his family via a mundane job whilst his wife supports the family via mundane domestic shit.

G5000 · 06/01/2022 22:12

Nobody is saying marriages are for life.

Lolabray · 06/01/2022 21:58

I’m other way. I had the husband and kids, he cheated and then I left him and brought my kids up alone. Do you think this is why I got married to end up in divorce and as a single parent. Hardly settled and committed was that marriage! Marriage these days aren’t like they used to be for life. People have boundaries and expectations and like me not everyone will put up with BS. A ring on your finger does not mean happiness ..

VikingOnTheFridge · 06/01/2022 21:58

Children being permanent doesn't mean they involve making any commitment whatsoever to the other parent. They don't, that's a fact. We'd be doing better than we are if parenthood even meant an automatic commitment to the child.

The people disagreeing with me on this point are demonstrating the issue...

EightWheelGirl · 06/01/2022 21:50

@VikingOnTheFridge

The MN variant is 'having a baby with someone is a bigger commitment than marriage'. It's really not...
I dunno. Children are a bit more permanent than a spouse. Can't be reversed like a marriage.
DrSbaitso · 06/01/2022 21:35

@PinkButtercups

I'm not married. Doesn't really bother me tbh.

If we broke up 1000% DP would never leave me with nothing. Everything he'd do 50/50. I don't need it in writing nor do I feel that I am owed it.

If he's so happy to see you right, why isn't it in writing?
VikingOnTheFridge · 06/01/2022 21:22

[quote thepeopleversuswork]@LadyMonicaBaddingham

Yes this a la carte traditionalism. Basically it means cherry picking those parts of the relationship contract that suit the bloke (having kids with your name on, having a domestic helpmeet and sex on tap). Without any of the responsibilities.[/quote]
I think this is the sort of partner OP is talking about. Ones who want it both ways.

PinkButtercups · 06/01/2022 21:13

I'm not married. Doesn't really bother me tbh.

If we broke up 1000% DP would never leave me with nothing. Everything he'd do 50/50. I don't need it in writing nor do I feel that I am owed it.

Iamthewombat · 06/01/2022 20:49

It IS taught. Ffs. Yhe issue is that other adults frwqurnlt spout nonesnese to their chidlren and their children believenit.
X

Thanks for the kiss. I am translating this post as follows:

It IS taught. Ffs. The issue is that other adults frequently spout nonsense to their chidlren and their children believe it.
X

Make your mind up. You seem to be suggesting that you teach both PHSE and RE. Is the fallacy of ‘common law’ spouses debunked in schools, in PHSE lessons, or not?

First, you say that it is taught in school, in response to @thepeopleversuswork.

Then you complain that we can’t expect schools to teach life skills.

Then you say, “Why would common law marriage be on [the PHSE curriculum] when it isnt a thing? Do you honestly think schools have the time to teach about things that aren't a thing???”

Since common law marriage is emphatically not a thing, and most of the recent posters understand that very clearly, is it on the curriculum or not? Because it isn’t a thing, and you claim that schools are too busy to explain that common law marriage is a fallacy.

Then you say, “it is taught FFS”. Yes, it is everybody else’s fault for not understanding your clear and lucid argument, so you must swear at us.

Please don’t feel obliged to hijack the thread to complain about the hard lot of PHSE teachers. Start a new thread for that.

pollygartertidywife · 06/01/2022 20:13

My granny had a saying .. (not very pc I know but she would be 112 now if was still alive so her words are not contemporary but nonetheless the sentiment remains the same. ..

Why would a man buy the cow when he is already getting the calf and milk for free ?

Personally, I think a lot of women do not value themselves sufficiently.

Those with good self esteem have an expectation of being treated in a certain way. So - if the expectation is marriage, they would not settle for less. Would certainly not bring children into the relationship without this requirement being met. (Contrary to MN lore it is actually fairly rare to have accidental pregnancy these days - if you are using contraception as it should be used. )

However low self esteem makes women more vulnerable. Much more likely to accept what's offered. Rather than make demands about their needs. Therefore for whom marriage is a 'want' they will often have children first - mistakenly belief that their partner will marry them . This obviously does happen but it's rare.

My advice . If marriage is important to you. Do not have kids first. If he doesn't want marriage and you do.. move on a finds someone who has the same values.

thepeopleversuswork · 06/01/2022 20:01

@LadyMonicaBaddingham

Yes this a la carte traditionalism. Basically it means cherry picking those parts of the relationship contract that suit the bloke (having kids with your name on, having a domestic helpmeet and sex on tap). Without any of the responsibilities.