Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you think driving whilst disqualified should be automatic prison sentence?

41 replies

themiceareout · 02/01/2022 18:14

Do you think driving whilst disqualified should be an automatic prison sentence, a friends niece got banned for getting 6 points in the first 2 years of passing her test and carried on driving anyway and got caught. I think she definitely needs community service as a punishment but do you think a custodial sentence needs to be imposed or does it depend on why the person was banned in the first place?

Obviously it's up to the courts to decide what they think is the appropriate action to take.

And no this not about my DD incase you ask.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Graphista · 03/01/2022 01:41

No - but mainly as I'd prefer prison spaces be reserved for violent and sexual offenders and king pin level drug dealers - and I'd have them in for life! Actual life not a long sentence

A massive fine AND community service AND permanent driving ban (driving is a privilege not a right) is what I would like there to be and if the car is hers seize it and sell it and give the money to victims of such drivers and their families or charities that support them

I've also said before on here it should become an offence to make a vehicle available to a banned/disqualified driver.

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing given the WOEFUL sentencing given by judges to certain types of violent offenders I think mandatory sentencing for certain crimes at this point IS needed! Are you a judge/related to one?

I'm sick of seeing rapists, paedos and wife batterers set free or given pathetically minimal sentences for their crimes - but that's really a while other thread

It's one of the great scandals of our time

Totally agree

The trouble with judges having discretion is they tend to use it to protect naice, white people from well off backgrounds whilst the full force of the law falls on people from ethnic minorities and the less well off.

Also true

Stompythedinosaur · 03/01/2022 01:35

No, I think prison should be reserved for violent crimes.prison is very rarely rehabilitative.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 03/01/2022 00:55

some discretion has had to go because judges have allowed personal bias to interfere with their sentencing.

Judges are incredibly undervalued and underestimated. They aren’t worried about vote winning or party politics and so don’t have to make populist or popular decisions. They are the most independent arm of government.

Pirrip1 · 02/01/2022 22:31

No, it shouldn’t be automatic. It should be up to the Judge, taking into account all the circumstances.

Prison isn’t a deterrent because no-one ever thinks they’ll get caught. That’s why they do it. I’m also unclear what the point of prison in this case would be.

Georgeskitchen · 02/01/2022 22:22

Suspended sentence for first offence then after that jail

Alexandra2001 · 02/01/2022 22:10

@user1471505494 Nope our jails are full of people doing ridiculously short sentences & locked up for stupidly long hours, achieves nothing.

We do not do anything like enough rehab, education and parole is a joke.

Plus we have such low numbers of Police, the chances of being caught are tiny, so of course jail is no deterrent, no one gets caught.

Look at rape stats for a snapshot at all that is so wrong with our justice system

user1471505494 · 02/01/2022 21:47

@Alexandra2001

What good do you think sending her to prison will do?

It says to other "drivers" in the same position that driving whilst banned will lead to a far worse punishment.

Do not underestimate the power a deterrent sentence has.

Total rubbish. If prison sentences acted as a deterrent our prisons would be nearly empty instead of overflowing
Alexandra2001 · 02/01/2022 21:45

@SuPerDoPer

Prisons are absolutely full. Most prisoners reoffend within a couple of years. It doesn't work as a deterrent. If you want people to change their behaviours then you need to educate them and help them make better choices. All prison does in cases like this is to remove the barriers to further offending - so this girl should lose her job, her home and her kids should go into care (if she has any) just so we can see justice being done? Ridiculous.
...so the alternative is she does a CS, keeps her licence and next time kills a child.

the DD 12m ban certainly does work but cuts in traffic/community policing means the chances of being caught are minimal, so people take risks.

We are too soft/perverse, we send people to jail for failing pay a fine but glass someone in a pub and its "he was an abused child, show mercy!" and they get a suspended sentence.

Blanketpolicy · 02/01/2022 21:35

Depending on the circumstances of the driver there are more appropriate measures that can be used -

Confiscate car regardless of who owns it unless reported stolen
Dont allow them to register a new car in their name for x years
Significant community service
Fines
Curfew/tagging
Extended driving retest/education
Longer bans
Points on licence for longer

Porcupineintherough · 02/01/2022 21:26

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

No, not automatic. It’s important that judges have discretion. The move towards removing judges’ discretion by the legislature/ executive is not healthy for our democracy.

Guidelines are one thing, make sentencing automatic and you might as well have a robot in charge.

The trouble with judges having discretion is they tend to use it to protect naice, white people from well off backgrounds whilst the full force of the law falls on people from ethnic minorities and the less well off. Perhaps sentencing does have to be more rigid to be fairer?
PixieLaLa · 02/01/2022 21:21

@BigYellowHat unless your DS was in the car at the time with your ex I don’t understand why that would have been any of your business?

RestingPandaFace · 02/01/2022 21:17

Wouldn’t a better solution be to crush the car, even if it is notionally someone else’s?

Real world consequences, and would make family far less likely to turn a blind eye.

JaniceBattersby · 02/01/2022 21:07

I spend more than half of my working week in the mags courts. There are about 20 DQ drivers convicted every day in the court in which I work.

There are simply nowhere near enough prison spaces for all those people to be given custodial sentences. I see people convicted of death by careless driving walk free. There aren’t even enough prison spaces for those who kill people behind the wheel.

There are many, many serious offenders who burgle houses, seriously assault people and commit major fraud who never go to jail. I’d start with them tbh.

Rosebel · 02/01/2022 21:02

We often hear about prisons being overcrowded as it is. If she had been caught drink driving then maybe but not for any reason at all
I would rather prison was kept for serial offenders and those guilty of serious crime.

Shade17 · 02/01/2022 20:58

Do you think driving whilst disqualified should be an automatic prison sentence, a friends niece got banned for getting 6 points in the first 2 years of passing her test

She wasn’t disqualified or banned, getting 6 points in your first two years just bumps you down to a provisional. You can book and retake your test as soon as you like. She would’ve been driving unaccompanied on a provisional which I’m guessing would be “otherwise in accordance” and probably got her disqualified.

RoseRedRoseBlue · 02/01/2022 20:56

A repeat disqual driver should go to custody.

Hankunamatata · 02/01/2022 20:53

No. There are much better ways to handle it than a custodial sentence in an already broken and overcrowded prison system. The like of electronic tagging, behavioural management courses, community service etc

NetballHoop · 02/01/2022 20:52

@Skeumorph

Massive fine would be better. I mean real, painful £25k, to be deducted from earnings like FOREVER.
The trouble with massive fines is that it makes the person more likely to re-offend in order to pay off the fine.
sadpapercourtesan · 02/01/2022 20:49

@Bagamoyo1 and it's a shoddy, inadequate sticking-plaster solution that leads to nothing but more misery and recidivism.

A burglar will typically get the sort of shit-and-a-shave short sentence that comes with absolutely no attempt at rehabilitation, no support, no training, just bang-up and release. The burglar is now an ex-con with even less chance of gaining decent employment than he had before he went in. He's spent a few months bored out of his wits in the company of other criminals and been turfed back out onto the street - what do you think the outcome is likely to be?

We have to start thinking beyond banging people up for every offence. Prisons are only useful for housing those who cannot be around the general public.

DarkDarkNight · 02/01/2022 20:47

Not sure about automatic prison but definitely a large fine, community service and a much longer disqualification - long enough to affect someone’s lice and make them think twice - 3+ years. I see a lot of stories in local press where people are given more lenient sentences because they need their car for work, or will lose their job or have young children and it doesn’t hold much sway for me. People should think of that beforehand.

If they are caught driving while banned a second time it shows a total disregard for the law and should be an automatic prison sentence. I’m not sure what it would take to get through to someone like Katie Price who is a law unto herself.

SuPerDoPer · 02/01/2022 20:46

I think the general public have no idea what prison is really like. People don't get rehabilitated and it mostly just sets their life chances way back so they take bigger risks to try and claw their way back up again.

BigYellowHat · 02/01/2022 20:45

I think so many people drive when banned. I’ll never forget when DS was about 4, the ex was banned for the second time. Anyway, I arrived at his about 10 mins early and he wasn’t there. A few minutes passed and I saw his car with him driving and his girlfriend in the passenger seat. Originally they were doing about 20MPH but then he sped up when he saw me, did a 180, zoomed off at twice the speed around the corner and they came back with her driving. I confronted him and he denied he was driving with her backing him up even though both my mum and I saw him. There was nothing I could do without photographic evidence so I had to leave it.

SuPerDoPer · 02/01/2022 20:44

@Alexandra2001

What good do you think sending her to prison will do?

It says to other "drivers" in the same position that driving whilst banned will lead to a far worse punishment.

Do not underestimate the power a deterrent sentence has.

If prison was a deterrent nobody would drink drive or use their phone behind the wheel. But people do because they assume they won't get caught.
RoseRedRoseBlue · 02/01/2022 20:42

It should be Community Sentence first time, suspended sentence if it happens again and custody on the third time unless there are the most extenuating circs.

SuPerDoPer · 02/01/2022 20:41

Prisons are absolutely full. Most prisoners reoffend within a couple of years. It doesn't work as a deterrent. If you want people to change their behaviours then you need to educate them and help them make better choices. All prison does in cases like this is to remove the barriers to further offending - so this girl should lose her job, her home and her kids should go into care (if she has any) just so we can see justice being done? Ridiculous.

Swipe left for the next trending thread