Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men shouldn't be named as women in newspapers if they have committed sexual offences?

385 replies

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 02/01/2022 14:59

Just that really - I'm seeing more and more newspaper reports where women are being implicated in weird sexual crimes and the you see the picture and it's obviously a man.

Now I totally get that if someone is transitioning it's polite to call them by their preferred name etc - but AIBU to think that some of these criminals are just taking the piss?

Here are some recent examples - and there are loads more.

www.northwichguardian.co.uk/news/19802592.northwich-woman-jailed-cocaine-fuelled-sex-dog/

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10339797/amp/Thumb-sucking-paedophile-claims-identify-five-year-old-girl-comes-court-dressed-ELF.html

How can anyone think this is ok? And will these "women" end up in women's prisons out of politeness?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Artichokeleaves · 03/01/2022 09:46

@YouSetTheTone

So women won’t be able to point to statistics that prove that the majority of sexual/ violent assaults are perpetrated by men - and therefore why sex spaces are needed to keep women safe- because men who are pretending to be women are having their crimes recorded as by women. And when they go to prison they get to go into the female estate where more women are at risk. Have I missed out any more boundaries around women that are being eroded by this? #NotOurCrimes
At every stage, ask yourself:

which identifiable group benefits?
which identifiable group loses?
Is there a consistent pattern here?
what is the key characteristic that identifies the winners and the losers? (clue: it is not being trans. TM are not permitted this movement between estates at all.)
what do we call it when one characteristic is consistently given higher priority, importance, legal rights and privilege over another?

Is this an acceptable thing in a modern society that is supposed to care about equality of human rights?

whachatalkinaboutwillis · 03/01/2022 09:45

Of course they should be named as men. It is absurd to suggest that anyone who rapes using their penis, that they were born with, is a trans person suffering dysphoria. It is grotesquely offensive to those with dysphoria who are trying to navigate their lives and will cause transphobia and lead to a bigoted opinion that many transpeople are perverts. Those trans persons with dysphoria need to stand up and fight these perverts who are using their trauma to justify rape and abuse.

YouSetTheTone · 03/01/2022 09:38

So women won’t be able to point to statistics that prove that the majority of sexual/ violent assaults are perpetrated by men - and therefore why sex spaces are needed to keep women safe- because men who are pretending to be women are having their crimes recorded as by women.
And when they go to prison they get to go into the female estate where more women are at risk.
Have I missed out any more boundaries around women that are being eroded by this?
#NotOurCrimes

BernardBlackMissesLangCleg · 03/01/2022 09:34

YANBU

Lookingoutside · 03/01/2022 09:32

DeepaBeesKit

‘Yanbu. It really fucks statistics too if these crimes get recorded as committed by women.’

The incel movement will soon point to said statistics and claim that women are raping men.

What then?

LondonWolf · 03/01/2022 09:17

There’s a definite change in perception of these issues. I’m sure I am not the only one who remembers the general acceptance that “TWAW!” and MNetters were bigoted/unkind etc if they queried these assertions, and that was right here on MN. I remember multiple “disgusted” posts and requests for this kind of transphobia and bigotry to be only discussed on the feminist boards so that decent, kindly people didn’t have to read it. Now here we are where those attempting to discuss two or three years ago, knew we’d be and there’s rarely a “oh just be kind!” post now. I do wonder sometimes if those who were so happy to give away women spaces and call “bigot!” are shocked by how far it’s come?

ParsleySageRosemary · 03/01/2022 09:07

And if that style guide was deliberately intended to annoy by way of contrast to the attitudes to women, particularly those reporting crimes against them, it’s succeeded very well.

ParsleySageRosemary · 03/01/2022 08:59

YADNBU. The number of blinkers middle class women supporters have over this issue annoy me. Women are at risk from men.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 03/01/2022 08:31

I think most women I know including myself are very supportive of trans people. However the boundary pushing to be point of abandoning all safeguarding measures put in place specifically because of predatory male violence and sexual assault, cannot be allowed to continue.

We cannot allow manipulative men to hitch themselves to a cause in order to enable their fetishes - which mostly manifest in pretending they are women. These men are certainly not safe to be near women and children in intimate settings.

With self ID ANY man can say he is a woman and we have no choice - we have to move over and allow him access to us, access to our daughters. The media have be told to "kill" stories if need be - see below from the The Trans Journalist Association - which is advising news writers to "kill" stories on trans criminals, censor detransitioners, and erase references to biological sex as a reality.

Their style guide is currently being utilized by multiple major media outlets.

transjournalists.org/style-guide/

"Don’t ask for or publish a person’s criminal history unless it’s completely relevant.
Be aware that trans people are disproportionately criminalized and policed. If the person you’re reporting on has a criminal record, reporting that information could have consequences for that person. For instance, it could make it harder for an individual to find work. Reporting on that criminal record also perpetuates stereotypes about trans people. If that history is not relevant to the story, you should not report it. If it is, you should consult with the individual about whether they are comfortable with that information being published. Before proceeding, discuss the potential negative impact publishing such information could have on them. You may need to find a different source or give the source anonymity if you cannot proceed with the story without publishing their criminal history. Publishing such information is rarely in the public interest. Consider killing a story if you have no alternatives."

OP posts:
Idontgiveaf324 · 03/01/2022 07:55

@sst1234

The mat ignorant are the women who defend this misogyny. Do they not see what they sleep walking into. How can any woman defend this? Would really like to hear a coherent argument for a women as to why she is happy to have her safety trampled on. It’s like a kamikaze mentality.
Internalised misogyny and extreme privilege. Most women I know who think this stuff is okay are middle class, often went to all girls or private schools and work in professions where their male colleagues are fairly well behaved. Lots of them also resent other women, especially older women. I’ve heard some of them say that they’d rather share spaces with their ‘trans sisters’ than ‘TERFs’. They close their eyes and ears to the prison thing - to them literally all transwomen are Hayley from Corrie.
UndertheCedartree · 03/01/2022 02:25

And most women in a psych hospital are victims of trauma - a lot of which is sexual or domestic violence.

UndertheCedartree · 03/01/2022 02:23

[quote BrightYellowDaffodil]should warrant more jail time too IMO

You mean the sort of jail time where they’ll claim to be a woman for an easier life/better access to victims, then revert back to their actual sex when they get out?

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/03d57d22-6b4c-11ec-bb37-1b2eed73c283?shareToken=b5d40b683a6857af319ab4e2d2968b8e[/quote]
Not quite the same but this happened when I was in a psych hospital. We had a bio male who identified as a woman on the women's wing (i.e where our bedrooms/shower rooms were - rest of ward was mixed) - however, when discharged he identified as a man again.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 03/01/2022 02:00

@WandaWomblesaurus73

Many of the women in prisons are victims of domestic abuse. As a survivor of both rape and domestic abuse myself - I would be horrified if I had to then share a cell with a man and call him a woman.

Horrified.

Yup
To think that men shouldn't be named as women in newspapers if they have committed sexual offences?
sst1234 · 03/01/2022 02:00

The mat ignorant are the women who defend this misogyny. Do they not see what they sleep walking into. How can any woman defend this? Would really like to hear a coherent argument for a women as to why she is happy to have her safety trampled on. It’s like a kamikaze mentality.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 03/01/2022 01:58

@Enough4me

The loud male Twitter group read our honest reflections and say mumsnetters are witchy dinosaur nuns (or whatever they pick to be offensive). They fear facing the truth and continually play the victim.
They hate women and hate them talking. Which is another reason for women to have safe spaces.
OP posts:
Enough4me · 03/01/2022 01:46

The loud male Twitter group read our honest reflections and say mumsnetters are witchy dinosaur nuns (or whatever they pick to be offensive). They fear facing the truth and continually play the victim.

user313213521 · 03/01/2022 01:45

They should do (as some reports do) include an '...formerly known as....', certainly in cases where the person has committed crimes under a former name.

This could not legally be used only against trans people by the courts. It would have to be applied to all defendants.

It would be easy to see cases where the case is unrelated to a name change, but they're still caught up in such rules, such as

  • a woman who has changed her name in a bid to evade an abusive ex who has been trying to find her, and is endangered by it
  • a married woman being referred to by her maiden name, even though no one has known her by that for 30 years
  • a trans person who is being tried for something totally unrelated to their trans status (false accounting, or possession with intent to supply, for instance) and is then outed to all and sundry for no good reason
And probably lots of other scenarios I can't think of at 1.45am.

The law of unintended consequences always applies.

Femisaurus · 03/01/2022 01:44

YANBU. #notourcrimes

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 03/01/2022 01:37

@Helleofabore

Nathlash

This is true too. Not you Wanda! But yes, some posters have started threads for screenshots.

I know you didn't mean me :)

I thought that first comment was odd and a bit snide too but then decided to ignore it. It's censorship in itself.

I posted because I am horrified by what I'm seeing in the news and I want to know if other women see this too.

This IS my reality, in 2022, I am asking a group of women if they think that men who are sexual predators can say they feel like they are women and these men can then be recorded as "women" and put in the same prison cells as actual women.
And that there is already evidence to show that men who do this have assaulted women. These mens crimes will also then be recorded as womens crimes.

This seems to be the norm now. It's normal enough for our mainstream newspapers and media outlets to report it as such. This suggests it's normal for this to happen and everyone is ok with it. Otherwise why is this prison and police policy? Why is it media policy to report it as such? Because obviously most people must be ok with it.

So am I being unreasonable to think that this is wrong? And am I being unreasonable to want to know what the fuck is going on or if I am the only one seeing this? So yes it's absolutely an AIBU. This is exactly where this thread belongs.

Also...

It's weird how men on Twitter like to monitor things that women say on Mumsnet.

Or maybe it's to be expected.

OP posts:
AlfonsoTheGoat · 03/01/2022 00:58

I agree.

Buttonitboris · 03/01/2022 00:47

I'm not kind and I think the elf bloke should also have been done for contempt of court

Enough4me · 03/01/2022 00:47

YANBU and are being completely reasonable. Men are male, however they chose to identify.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 03/01/2022 00:41

YANBU

DdraigGoch · 03/01/2022 00:39

@Helleofabore

Nathlash

This is true too. Not you Wanda! But yes, some posters have started threads for screenshots.

They can share all the screenshots they like around their Twitter echo chamber. They had already made their minds up anyway and the lurkers get to see how reasonable everyone here is.
Barbarantia · 03/01/2022 00:33

I can just picture my colleagues who have had very little exposure to this debate but who have had to participate in d&i training watching this unfold.
I imagine the first reaction is : not all are like that. Then heel digging - even more pronouns everywhere to show they are the true allies (or should I say good disciples? )

Fun times ahead.

Swipe left for the next trending thread