Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men shouldn't be named as women in newspapers if they have committed sexual offences?

385 replies

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 02/01/2022 14:59

Just that really - I'm seeing more and more newspaper reports where women are being implicated in weird sexual crimes and the you see the picture and it's obviously a man.

Now I totally get that if someone is transitioning it's polite to call them by their preferred name etc - but AIBU to think that some of these criminals are just taking the piss?

Here are some recent examples - and there are loads more.

www.northwichguardian.co.uk/news/19802592.northwich-woman-jailed-cocaine-fuelled-sex-dog/

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10339797/amp/Thumb-sucking-paedophile-claims-identify-five-year-old-girl-comes-court-dressed-ELF.html

How can anyone think this is ok? And will these "women" end up in women's prisons out of politeness?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Pixies74 · 03/01/2022 16:41

@TeaAndStrumpets

As I said on another thread, one can see at a glance from a photo. The newspapers can publish a picture whereas they are not allowed to state the offender's true sex in the written report. The information is put out there. So partially sighted/blind people who rely on text to speech software are discriminated against and misled because they don't have that visual clue.
Gosh, that had never even occurred to me. Sad
Artichokeleaves · 03/01/2022 16:38

It is not a toxic debate to say that female people have the right not to lose their privacy, dignity, safety and basic human right to not be harassed and assaulted by any male person on the grounds that to do so makes the male person happier and validates his chosen gender identity. To insist that male people must have this access even when they have been convicted of serious sexual offenses against women? It's not toxic, it's fucking insane, inhuman and the scandal of this century.

When did the people leading this country get so confused about basic right and wrong?

LaChanticleer · 03/01/2022 16:17

I've read (but now can't find the reference) qualified forensic psychologists who say much what Prof. Treadwell writes about, and add that some men will use overly lax (or Stonewalled) misunderstandings of 'trans' to get into the female prison estate, as

  • access to women in close & intimate circumstances;
  • perceived easier conditions and more freedom
  • sense of power and control ('getting one over' authorities)

It's also instructive to look at what Frances cRook, long time leader of the Howard League for Penal Reform has said about male-bodied transgender prisoners in the female estate. (Sorry everyoe, it's the GUardian):
www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/sep/09/sexual-assaults-in-womens-prison-reignite-debate-over-transgender-inmates-karen-white

"Frances Crook, the chief executive of the Howard League for Penal Reform, said vulnerable women were being put at risk by a small number of violent men whose primary interest was harming women."

and

“It is a very toxic debate, but I think prisons have probably been influenced by some of the extreme conversations and have been bullied into making some decisions that have harmed women and put staff in an extremely difficult position,” she said.

GrandmasCat · 03/01/2022 16:16

@WandaWomblesaurus73
It isn't about trans people, it's about bad people who will exploit the law from self interest and work within a legal framework (that could protect women's spaces) to do as they want and get what they want.

I think this is the crux of the matter, as a society we need to learn to separate the concepts, being against self ID should not be perceived as being transgender phobic.

Defending women’s right to safe spaces, doesn’t need to be seen as being transphobic either as the fight is not against transgender women but against men, with no who are not really transgender, identifying freely as women.

Joining both concepts together as if they were the same is massively unfair both to women and real transgender people.

Thelnebriati · 03/01/2022 16:04

Naive people can be just as dangerous because they are so keen to be nice they can end up enabling predators.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 03/01/2022 16:02

This is from Professor of Criminology James Treadwell on Twitter - and every woman should read this and decide whether it's in our interests that predatory men are able to identify as whatever the hell they like.

@James_Treadwell
·
27 Dec 2021
"The idea that sex offenders are manipulative individuals who would exploit systems and laws could only be unreal to those who do not know how manipulative sexual offenders can be. All groom, seek to exploit and control. It's different, They have different plays, but all do it.

I sat across from sex offender who swore to me he wasn't working, he left my office to attend a children's charity disco his was supposed to be DJ at. A child rapist, "It is my right to practice my Bhuddist faith, and I should be allowed to travel to Thailand". (Hmm, no)

Some.academics say concerns over "supposed" threat of trans identities reveal lingering anti-trans sentiment. Do they? No. I know Trans people face massive abuse, I see that too. Both can be true. Yet still I am not sold in any way that Gender Self ID is as simple as some suggest

Bad law happens, bad legislation without consideration does have risk, and in this instance of Gender Self ID to me, the concern is also understandable. Of course some views may come from predudice. But not all. In my view if those who support Gender Self ID want to see change...

then there is a need to address concerns head on, and not simply claim they are not real, not empirically grounded or merely anecdotal. To me the issue here is the danger that Trans identity is used as cover for harmful individuals. That is in no one's interest.

Least of all Trans people. No community is made stronger internally or externally by association, real or implied with the most selfish, narcassistic, harmful and individuals, many of whom get off on causing pain to others around them. Who wants those people in their group?

My experiences are limited, but I have met and dealt with a lot more nasty, violent and dangerous preditory male sexual offenders than most people have. That is the group driving my concern. What I know of them as a group, there is NO rule or opportunity they will not exploit

It isn't about trans people, it's about bad people who will exploit the law from self interest and work within a legal framework (that could protect women's spaces) to do as they want and get what they want. You think that won't happen, you don't know how many sex offenders act."

OP posts:
simmonslulu · 03/01/2022 15:52

Yanbu identified as a male and placed in a male prison if convicted and sentenced to custody

VallarMorghulis · 03/01/2022 14:51

YANBU #NotOurCrimes

StrangeAddiction · 03/01/2022 14:41

YANBU

I saw an article of the "woman" you linked to a couple of weeks ago and it was like the newspaper was trying hard to convince everyone that it really was a woman by not mentioning once it was a trans woman when normally the would post something along the lines of "Sally, a trans woman/ a recently transitioned woman, Sally who was born a man but now identifies as a woman" etc. No one in the comments was convinced "she" was a biological woman though. I did wonder which prison they would go to.

Idontgiveaf324 · 03/01/2022 14:19

I read about one in Sweden where this guy dismembered a woman that he had been lying in wait for when she was out jogging and then joined in the search for her. Sick bastard. Then he claimed to be a woman and was transferred to a female prison where many inmates have their children living. Absolutely sickening that this is allowed. Oh and OF COURSE men will take advantage of it, especially sex offenders. If you had a choice between a male and a female prison and you didn’t have to even have a medical diagnosis, of course you’d take it.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 03/01/2022 14:12

How many men with convictions of sexual assault are being held in womens prisons across the UK? We need to know - I read something about figures being obscured.

4w.pub/male-serial-killer-housed-at-washington-womens-prison/

In America this is happening and it is the stuff of nightmares:

"Perry referred to his "male" and "female" identities in separate contexts, accusing his "male" side of having committed the crimes while his "female" identity was innocent of them."

This is a serial killer of prostitutes being held in a female prison.

Also now this: (someone posted the link earlier.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/03d57d22-6b4c-11ec-bb37-1b2eed73c283?shareToken=085064280774f9c874642abd0845af4f

OP posts:
ginghamstarfish · 03/01/2022 13:06

Clearly, for those of us living in reality, but you aren't supposed to say it or you're a bigot, transphobe, etc etc and risk abuse.

DrSbaitso · 03/01/2022 12:57

@ParsleySageRosemary

Can women sue a prison for example if they get raped by their trans cell mate?

How many women who’ve been in prison are going to be able to afford to sue anyone?

Well if it's a crime, the CPS will do it...no need for a private prosecution.

But be prepared to have to refer to the attacker as "she", or be deemed a hateful bigot and reduce your chances of a conviction even further.

ParsleySageRosemary · 03/01/2022 12:46

Can women sue a prison for example if they get raped by their trans cell mate?

How many women who’ve been in prison are going to be able to afford to sue anyone?

PrawnofthePatriarchy · 03/01/2022 12:39

YANBU.

These are #NotOurCrimes

Glad to see how many women are becoming aware of this issue.

Idontgiveaf324 · 03/01/2022 10:49

@RoseSays

It's insane, very sadly I think there will be have to be a few very high profile crimes and cases before the law makers feel any pressure to remove self-ID for safe spaces.

Can women sue a prison for example if they get raped by their trans cell mate?

Yes, sadly I think it will take one or more women in prison being killed for there to be any meaningful change. So far, policy makers across the world seem cool with the following:
  • Homeless women being raped in a shelter (Canada)
  • Competitive male swimmer claiming female identity and trouncing women’s record by 40 seconds (US)
  • Middle aged male claiming female identity and competing at the Olympics in weight lifting (NZ)
  • Women in prison being raped/assaulted by a man who also flashed his penis at them (UK)
  • Multiple court convictions in past few years worldwide of males IDing as female committing rape, sexual assault, bestiality, indecent exposure, possessing child abuse images, showing that claiming a female identity in no way affects a male pattern of offending (hardly any women are convicted of these offences and when they are, the circumstances are v different, eg they tend to be female teacher and male school pupil or abuse with a male partner who was dominant. Still reprehensible but very different factual pattern).
YouSetTheTone · 03/01/2022 10:31

Doesn’t the Geneva Convention say that men and women should be kept separate when imprisoned? Has the Geneva Convention been updated to now allow men who say they’re women to be imprisoned with women?

(I know the Geneva Convention isn’t applicable in the U.K. in peacetime but just wondering)

Artichokeleaves · 03/01/2022 10:28

@RoseSays

It's insane, very sadly I think there will be have to be a few very high profile crimes and cases before the law makers feel any pressure to remove self-ID for safe spaces.

Can women sue a prison for example if they get raped by their trans cell mate?

At the recent court case, this was in effect what the judge said to the woman who had brought the case.

In essence he said: it is not necessarily desireable or right but the MoJ cannot actually be stopped from doing it on grounds of it being illegal. It would require a woman who has actually been harmed to bring a case, with evidence. As usual until a woman has been harmed and can prove it to the nth degree, there is no hope of anyone giving a damn.

And since we know the rape prosecution rate, good luck with that.

RoseSays · 03/01/2022 10:14

It's insane, very sadly I think there will be have to be a few very high profile crimes and cases before the law makers feel any pressure to remove self-ID for safe spaces.

Can women sue a prison for example if they get raped by their trans cell mate?

MarshmallowFondant · 03/01/2022 10:08

What happens if they are changing their names - does it affect DBS checks? How can you keep track of offenders if you can't name them... or name what biological sex they are?

There is a special department at the DBS which handles "sensitive applications". The person concerned would be expected to complete a form with ALL their previous identities. This is what happens with all DBS checks anyway, you'd be expected to put your current name and previous names you had been known by.

But the "sensitive" route means that although the DBS will run the checks on all names/identities, these will not show on the certificate or be disclosed to the employer. So if you have Claire White applying for a position which requires a DBS, and Claire was previously Clive, then criminal records for Clive White will be checked but only the Claire name will appear on the certificate.

If that makes sense.

Tryagainplease · 03/01/2022 10:02

This makes me so fucking angry.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 03/01/2022 09:59

@Lookingoutside

DeepaBeesKit

‘Yanbu. It really fucks statistics too if these crimes get recorded as committed by women.’

The incel movement will soon point to said statistics and claim that women are raping men.

What then?

Oops sorry meant to quote you in this post not the last one - Yes exactly - obscure the details, say that women are rapists - lie about statistics.

How can anyone in their right mind think this is ok?

OP posts:
WandaWomblesaurus73 · 03/01/2022 09:56

@Lookingoutside

DeepaBeesKit

‘Yanbu. It really fucks statistics too if these crimes get recorded as committed by women.’

The incel movement will soon point to said statistics and claim that women are raping men.

What then?

Given that women are being raped and murdered by police and that reporting of rape is at a low, conviction rates are laughable - you would think that these criminals must think they are in heaven now they can identify as women, get treated like special cases and then get access to more vulnerable women who can't say anything!

Oh and once they are out of prisons they can have free access to women and childrens spaces again! It's a fucking free for all!

If women don't like it we can get our thinking corrected by the local constabulary! Or we can have our work cancelled. Or we can have rape and death threats. (Or all three!)

OP posts:
flowersinafield · 03/01/2022 09:54

YANBU I wish they'd at least say a trans woman

Idontgiveaf324 · 03/01/2022 09:50

Imo, a lot of people who are trans-rights activists try to pretend that it’s only a tiny minority of ultra-religious trad-wife types who don’t welcome penises into their spaces. See for instance that car-crash interview with Ellie-Mae O’Hagan where she kept saying ‘the majority of women agree with me’.

This thread and many others shows that this is bullshit. Most women are not happy for any bloke to claim a female identity and share intimate spaces with them. Many had little idea until recently that very few transwomen, even those with gender dysphoria, have their genitals removed. On tv, most transwomen are played by biological females, creating a public perception that transwomen are physically indistinguishable from women. The reality is very very different.

I know someone who has recently transitioned. He (because he is male) is 6’2” with a very stocky build, visibly male and no amount of hormones will change that. No woman would realistically see him as female. There is no ambiguity. More disturbing, this is a man who used to compete in a violent sport, has convictions for domestic abuse against former partners and has had his three children removed from him by the courts with an order that he is to have no contact with them (which is pretty rare and usually only where there is abuse or neglect). He is absolutely not safe around women on any level yet now expects to share spaces with them and has said on social media that he wants to kill JK Rowling and shit on her grave. There is nothing in the self-ID proposals that would protect women from someone like this.