Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men shouldn't be named as women in newspapers if they have committed sexual offences?

385 replies

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 02/01/2022 14:59

Just that really - I'm seeing more and more newspaper reports where women are being implicated in weird sexual crimes and the you see the picture and it's obviously a man.

Now I totally get that if someone is transitioning it's polite to call them by their preferred name etc - but AIBU to think that some of these criminals are just taking the piss?

Here are some recent examples - and there are loads more.

www.northwichguardian.co.uk/news/19802592.northwich-woman-jailed-cocaine-fuelled-sex-dog/

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10339797/amp/Thumb-sucking-paedophile-claims-identify-five-year-old-girl-comes-court-dressed-ELF.html

How can anyone think this is ok? And will these "women" end up in women's prisons out of politeness?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
WorriedMumsDontSleep · 04/01/2022 16:10

I've seen the 'rape the other girl' mentality before, but never so coldly and lacking in empathy before.

Idontgiveaf324 · 04/01/2022 16:01

@DrSbaitso

I genuinely don't care whether someone like that is locked up in a male prison or a female one, the important thing is that they are taken away from society. Any future crimes they commit whilst in prison are not OK, but at least they will be committed on fellow prisoners rather than the general public. Prisons are not nice places, they're not meant to be nice places, the fear of getting locked up with a transgender rapist for 23 hours a day serves as a good deterrent not to be sent to prison in the first place. I don't want them to abuse a female prisoner, I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.

This is enough to dismiss any opinion you have on this matter. I can't believe you could read this back and not see what is so disturbing about it.

Agree that this is disturbing. Have a think about the sorts of reasons why women get sent to prison (as well as some of the issues they face including addiction and poverty) and also have a think about why you are so keen to centre the rights of a male rapist in order to deter women from crime.
Changingtheweather · 04/01/2022 15:53

So the women of Berlin, mass raped by Russian soldiers at the close of WW 2 probably deserved it because in all probability a significant proportion had at some point supported Hitler’s regime and hence made “better” victims
Okay then.

Artichokeleaves · 04/01/2022 15:52

Isn't it odd how no one in support of this agenda ever seems able to demonstrate empathy, compassion or basic regard for human rights in people they dislike or politically disagree with?

I may not like a person. I may wholly and entirely disagree with them and everything they choose to stand for. I may be truly revolted by their behaviour. I am still not going to accept a society in which they are abused, ill treated or subordinated. That seems to be the main difference between my perspective as someone 'not kind' and those who feel they're on the 'right side of history'.

That isn't a history I will be co operating with happening. It would be like a world run by bloody toddlers.

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 15:33

I genuinely don't care whether someone like that is locked up in a male prison or a female one, the important thing is that they are taken away from society. Any future crimes they commit whilst in prison are not OK, but at least they will be committed on fellow prisoners rather than the general public. Prisons are not nice places, they're not meant to be nice places, the fear of getting locked up with a transgender rapist for 23 hours a day serves as a good deterrent not to be sent to prison in the first place. I don't want them to abuse a female prisoner, I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.

This is enough to dismiss any opinion you have on this matter. I can't believe you could read this back and not see what is so disturbing about it.

YouSetTheTone · 04/01/2022 15:30

@MorningStarling

I honestly can't get too worked up about whether a rapist believes they are male or female. Clearly I'm in the minority but to me the term #notourcrimes applies because I'm one of the people who has never committed rape or sexual assault, not because I'm female.

There was a thread a few weeks ago about the Northwich dog abuser. I said then what I'll say now, I genuinely don't care whether someone like that is locked up in a male prison or a female one, the important thing is that they are taken away from society. Any future crimes they commit whilst in prison are not OK, but at least they will be committed on fellow prisoners rather than the general public. Prisons are not nice places, they're not meant to be nice places, the fear of getting locked up with a transgender rapist for 23 hours a day serves as a good deterrent not to be sent to prison in the first place. I don't want them to abuse a female prisoner, I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.

To me it doesn't matter whether crime statistics are skewed by so-called "female" rapists. What matters is that rapes aren't committed, and if they do that the offender is locked up. Suggesting it is harmful that a transgender rapist has their crime recorded as a female one implies that the victim is less of a victim because their attacker was "only" a woman. I'd suggest many rape victims are traumatised by the crime itself, which prison their attacker ends up in and which list the crime is recorded on is only a minor concern.

Society has evolved and now believes that someone can become a member of the gender they were not born as. Whether you think that's right or wrong, that's where we are. There were similar arguments when rights for homosexuals were being promoted decades ago - they were identified and treated differently in prison because they were deemed at greater risk of attacking others. If we believe a person has the right to choose their sexuality, now their gender, we must allow them that right without limitation. We can't say "well you can live as a woman except when it comes to playing sport or going to prison" - either a man can transition to become a woman, or they can't.

Either a man can transition to become a woman or they can’t

A man can never change sex to become a woman. It is physically impossible. A man can be a transgender person who ‘identifies as a woman’ but this does not mean he is a woman and has access to women’s single sex spaces. No.

And how is it that you have so little empathy for women in prison? That in your view they should serve their sentence plus additional punishment by being locked up with men and raped/ assaulted?
I think it was on this thread that someone posted an image with statistics around women prisoners - many of them have been in care homes, many of them are from disadvantaged backgrounds, many of them have been previous victims of assault, many of them are NOT in prison for violent crimes.
They do not deserve to serve their prison sentence in fear of male prisoners alongside them. I’m disturbed that you would think this.

Finally - don’t you understand statistics? If male crimes are being wrongly recorded as female crimes then women lose justification for the single sex spaces that protect them from being victims of crime.

98% of sexual assaults are committed by men and 2% by women becomes:

60% of sexual assaults are committed by men and 40% by ‘women’*. Those crimes are still being committed by men but they’re now hidden by the figures.
So the need to have separate single sex spaces to keep women safe can be argued against as there’s no longer a figure that says 98% of sexual assaults are committed by men.

There would be lots of other consequences to wrongly recording the sex of the perpetrator.

*the figures here are made up to illustrate the point. Whatever the new figure of crimes by men recorded as by women would be it would obscure the truth.

Nemorth · 04/01/2022 15:29

@MorningStarling so prisoners aren't "normal"?

What are they then?

Women get sent to prison for crimes such a non payment of the TV licence fee...

Do they really deserve to get raped because of that?

I think perhaps you are not a normal person. You have no understanding or empathy.

If you have children I hope they are male. As you seem to have no empathy for females.

Poal · 04/01/2022 15:25

I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.
Lovely Hmm

Saltovinegar · 04/01/2022 15:22

You are an absolute scumbag MorningStarling, that's a truly awful post.

LaChanticleer · 04/01/2022 15:21

Any future crimes they commit whilst in prison are not OK, but at least they will be committed on fellow prisoners rather than the general public.

So this is an example of society’s “evolved opinion”?

Do you know anything about why most women are imprisoned, @MorningStarling ? They are mostly there for offences such as benefits fraud or non-payment of television licences, or as a consequence of a chaotic childhood, leading to problems of addiction or being vulnerable to being prostituted, or they’re there because they’ve been victims of domestic violence, or basically because they’re poor.

If you read any professional/scholarly criminology, you might learn something about the very different kinds of crimes for which female offenders are committed to imprisonment.

But mostly, I’m just Shock at your lack of compassion. Evolved opinion, obvs.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 04/01/2022 15:19

Maybe @MorningStarling inhabits a Stephen King book.

OP posts:
Abhannmor · 04/01/2022 15:14

@MorningStarling

I honestly can't get too worked up about whether a rapist believes they are male or female. Clearly I'm in the minority but to me the term #notourcrimes applies because I'm one of the people who has never committed rape or sexual assault, not because I'm female.

There was a thread a few weeks ago about the Northwich dog abuser. I said then what I'll say now, I genuinely don't care whether someone like that is locked up in a male prison or a female one, the important thing is that they are taken away from society. Any future crimes they commit whilst in prison are not OK, but at least they will be committed on fellow prisoners rather than the general public. Prisons are not nice places, they're not meant to be nice places, the fear of getting locked up with a transgender rapist for 23 hours a day serves as a good deterrent not to be sent to prison in the first place. I don't want them to abuse a female prisoner, I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.

To me it doesn't matter whether crime statistics are skewed by so-called "female" rapists. What matters is that rapes aren't committed, and if they do that the offender is locked up. Suggesting it is harmful that a transgender rapist has their crime recorded as a female one implies that the victim is less of a victim because their attacker was "only" a woman. I'd suggest many rape victims are traumatised by the crime itself, which prison their attacker ends up in and which list the crime is recorded on is only a minor concern.

Society has evolved and now believes that someone can become a member of the gender they were not born as. Whether you think that's right or wrong, that's where we are. There were similar arguments when rights for homosexuals were being promoted decades ago - they were identified and treated differently in prison because they were deemed at greater risk of attacking others. If we believe a person has the right to choose their sexuality, now their gender, we must allow them that right without limitation. We can't say "well you can live as a woman except when it comes to playing sport or going to prison" - either a man can transition to become a woman, or they can't.

You seem to inhabit a different moral universe to the rest of us. I'm trying my best to phrase this politely.
Abhannmor · 04/01/2022 15:11

YANBU . It is outrageous.

Ionlydomassiveones · 04/01/2022 15:06

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

eagerlywaitingfor · 04/01/2022 15:02

It's not unknown for the media to report other or previous names a person has been known by, so I see no reason why they can't in cases where the person has transitioned.

There is no difference between the reporting of (for instance) someone called Joe Bloggs, previously known as John Smith, and another person called Jane Bloggs, previously know as John Smith. Gender/sex is irrelevant.

So why the media can't/won't do that is anybody's guess.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 04/01/2022 15:02

@MorningStarling

I honestly can't get too worked up about whether a rapist believes they are male or female. Clearly I'm in the minority but to me the term #notourcrimes applies because I'm one of the people who has never committed rape or sexual assault, not because I'm female.

There was a thread a few weeks ago about the Northwich dog abuser. I said then what I'll say now, I genuinely don't care whether someone like that is locked up in a male prison or a female one, the important thing is that they are taken away from society. Any future crimes they commit whilst in prison are not OK, but at least they will be committed on fellow prisoners rather than the general public. Prisons are not nice places, they're not meant to be nice places, the fear of getting locked up with a transgender rapist for 23 hours a day serves as a good deterrent not to be sent to prison in the first place. I don't want them to abuse a female prisoner, I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.

To me it doesn't matter whether crime statistics are skewed by so-called "female" rapists. What matters is that rapes aren't committed, and if they do that the offender is locked up. Suggesting it is harmful that a transgender rapist has their crime recorded as a female one implies that the victim is less of a victim because their attacker was "only" a woman. I'd suggest many rape victims are traumatised by the crime itself, which prison their attacker ends up in and which list the crime is recorded on is only a minor concern.

Society has evolved and now believes that someone can become a member of the gender they were not born as. Whether you think that's right or wrong, that's where we are. There were similar arguments when rights for homosexuals were being promoted decades ago - they were identified and treated differently in prison because they were deemed at greater risk of attacking others. If we believe a person has the right to choose their sexuality, now their gender, we must allow them that right without limitation. We can't say "well you can live as a woman except when it comes to playing sport or going to prison" - either a man can transition to become a woman, or they can't.

Wow. So you don't care if women are raped in prison by men who are pretending to be transgender, it serves them right and being raped in prison is a deterrent?
OP posts:
MorningStarling · 04/01/2022 14:56

I honestly can't get too worked up about whether a rapist believes they are male or female. Clearly I'm in the minority but to me the term #notourcrimes applies because I'm one of the people who has never committed rape or sexual assault, not because I'm female.

There was a thread a few weeks ago about the Northwich dog abuser. I said then what I'll say now, I genuinely don't care whether someone like that is locked up in a male prison or a female one, the important thing is that they are taken away from society. Any future crimes they commit whilst in prison are not OK, but at least they will be committed on fellow prisoners rather than the general public. Prisons are not nice places, they're not meant to be nice places, the fear of getting locked up with a transgender rapist for 23 hours a day serves as a good deterrent not to be sent to prison in the first place. I don't want them to abuse a female prisoner, I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.

To me it doesn't matter whether crime statistics are skewed by so-called "female" rapists. What matters is that rapes aren't committed, and if they do that the offender is locked up. Suggesting it is harmful that a transgender rapist has their crime recorded as a female one implies that the victim is less of a victim because their attacker was "only" a woman. I'd suggest many rape victims are traumatised by the crime itself, which prison their attacker ends up in and which list the crime is recorded on is only a minor concern.

Society has evolved and now believes that someone can become a member of the gender they were not born as. Whether you think that's right or wrong, that's where we are. There were similar arguments when rights for homosexuals were being promoted decades ago - they were identified and treated differently in prison because they were deemed at greater risk of attacking others. If we believe a person has the right to choose their sexuality, now their gender, we must allow them that right without limitation. We can't say "well you can live as a woman except when it comes to playing sport or going to prison" - either a man can transition to become a woman, or they can't.

VelvetChairGirl · 04/01/2022 14:20

they shouldnt be called female words at all if they had done a crime or not, they are a subset of males not females.

stick to being called trans isnt that the definer? I would say maybe they should have their own fixed pronouns like instead of she, xer or zer but then we all confused enough already.

maybe all of em, all the gender ideologists should be one pronoun X or something simple to show they are not him or her, that way you get the NBs too and we arent all ordered to remember individual peoples individual pronouns, as if anyone is going to remember all that, personally it takes me about 3 months just to remember peoples names.

YouSetTheTone · 04/01/2022 12:32

@WandaWomblesaurus73

Something we will hear a lot more of now is "but women rape too" In whose interests is to obscure statistics on who is committing sexual based crimes more often?
It makes me so angry. The word woman should NEVER be redefined to include men. No aspect of that redefinition benefits women. NONE. Pretty much every aspect of that redefinition actively harms women.
FrancescaContini · 04/01/2022 11:44

@WandaWomblesaurus73

Something we will hear a lot more of now is "but women rape too" In whose interests is to obscure statistics on who is committing sexual based crimes more often?
It’s the absurd extension of the gaslighting that is TWAW.
WandaWomblesaurus73 · 04/01/2022 11:42

Something we will hear a lot more of now is "but women rape too"
In whose interests is to obscure statistics on who is committing sexual based crimes more often?

OP posts:
doadeer · 04/01/2022 10:22

If a penis is involved in sexual assault it's very strange to call the perpetrator a woman.

Lovelyricepudding · 04/01/2022 10:20

@Ionlydomassiveones

I think committing such a male crime should prohibit their claim to be trans as they are not in good faith ‘living as a woman’. I’ve never understood what ‘living as a woman’ means, but the one single thing you can’t do as a woman is rape another one with a penis.
I don't careally if they want to call themselves 'trans'. What no man, sex offender or not, should ever be able to do is call themselves a woman. Men are not women and never can be and the GRA should be repealed.
WandaWomblesaurus73 · 03/01/2022 20:49

@Thelnebriati

Naive people can be just as dangerous because they are so keen to be nice they can end up enabling predators.
That's the whole "Be Kind" command that has now turned into "Be Kind to rapists"
OP posts:
Ionlydomassiveones · 03/01/2022 16:45

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.