Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men shouldn't be named as women in newspapers if they have committed sexual offences?

385 replies

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 02/01/2022 14:59

Just that really - I'm seeing more and more newspaper reports where women are being implicated in weird sexual crimes and the you see the picture and it's obviously a man.

Now I totally get that if someone is transitioning it's polite to call them by their preferred name etc - but AIBU to think that some of these criminals are just taking the piss?

Here are some recent examples - and there are loads more.

www.northwichguardian.co.uk/news/19802592.northwich-woman-jailed-cocaine-fuelled-sex-dog/

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10339797/amp/Thumb-sucking-paedophile-claims-identify-five-year-old-girl-comes-court-dressed-ELF.html

How can anyone think this is ok? And will these "women" end up in women's prisons out of politeness?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Moolia · 05/01/2022 00:54

Most likely a combination of 1 and 2. It isn't necessarily either/or.

TurquoiseBaubles · 05/01/2022 00:41

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4444977-USA-Almost-50-of-Trans-Inmates-in-Federal-Custody-for-Sex-Offences

Delphinium has just posted this on FWR. "According to the document, 48.47% of biological male inmates identifying as women are in federal custody for sex offences, compared to just 4.71% of biological females identifying as men, and 11.2% of the non-transgender male population of federal inmates in general."

So in the US either
(1) transwomen are more likely to be sexual offenders than men; or
(2) men who are sexual offenders are claiming to be trans.

By allowing criminals to self-identify and not keeping correct data in relation to sex (as well as trans identity), we will never know which, but one must be true.

Enough4me · 05/01/2022 00:40

What is the definition of transition if not for a change to have taken place...can a transwomen and transman actually exist?

Unless DNA can be exchanged, but there is no way for this to happen.

Moolia · 05/01/2022 00:37

I'm afraid you'll find that lots of TRAs say that a penis isn't necessarily male genitalia. They say there is such a thing as a female penis. I kid you not.

FortniteBoysMum · 04/01/2022 23:07

If these men claiming to be women use their penis during the sexual assault they are arrested for then they should be prosecuted as and referred to as a man. They were using male genitalia to commit the crime. If they truly believed they were women they would not be using their penis to commit these crimes. There for treat them like the scum they are and if these men still claim to be women then chop their dick off. Won't be able to rape another woman again. It's one thing being trans gender it's snother using it to get away with crime or to try minimising it. If they go to a female prison that's lots of potential victims.

Changingtheweather · 04/01/2022 23:03

“How can you tell that those offenders were transwomen and not just men pretending to be women?”

Mmmm, that’s where self identification is so useful.

YouSetTheTone · 04/01/2022 22:59

@ppeony

Out of interest, do many of you talk openly about how you feel about this, or do you fear being called a TERF etc?
I am more and more open about my opinions with each day that passes. I’m no longer frightened of being called a TERF when the alternative is worse - that women’s rights are torn to shreds. As it stands my whole family know (and agree), my good friends, some colleagues, the school my children attend and my MP. And you lot Wink
FriendshipsAreHardForMe · 04/01/2022 21:11

I nearly spat my tea out at the first mugshot 😬

100% wrong to be calling them women. They're vile, sorry excuses for humans and should definitely be referred to as male.

As for the paedophile who refers to himself as a 5yr old girl... Well, he should be shot.

scotvic · 04/01/2022 21:07

YANBU Absolutely not! These are men and should be recorded as being male sex regardless of their gender identity (and whether it not it is genuine or just a way to avoid male prison / get access to women). Their crimes should be recorded as male crimes otherwise statistics will
become corrupted and meaningless.

Moolia · 04/01/2022 21:03

"And I also want to understand how to tell genuine transwomen from men pretending to be transwomen."

If all you need to be a genuine transwoman is a feeling, however fleeting, there is absolutely no way of knowing who is "genuine" and who isn't. That's why opening up women's safe spaces to any man who says he "feels" like a woman is so dangerous.

WineAway · 04/01/2022 21:01

@PumpkinGin have you answered your own question

How do we tell who isa ‘genuine’ trans woman & who is a predatory male? Is there a test? Can we see into their womanly essence?

Gender is all about regressive stereotypes.

Aren’t there more than 80 genders now?

If a told you I was a unicorn would you respect my identity?

Moolia · 04/01/2022 21:01

There is no way of understanding statistics if men are recorded as women and women are recorded as men.

PumpkinGin · 04/01/2022 20:53

I respect what people say they are. We can all be respectful and civil to one another’s

But I don’t agree that anyone automatically should be able to get into women’s spaces by claiming they are a woman. They could be a male sexual predator.

I do think transwomen need to be kept safe too. Life can be hard for so many people. That is why I suggest a separate space for transwomen.

But I really want to understand these statistics better. I want to know what the offending rates are for women, transwomen, men and transmen. And I want to know for which crimes. It is really important to get the right information in order to be able to understand issues better. And I also want to understand how to tell genuine transwomen from men pretending to be transwomen.

Fidgetty · 04/01/2022 20:46

Well, I think that gender identity is very important as well and I want to be respectful of people identifying as a certain gender. Or as non binary

"Gender identity" is made up twaddle. Why on earth do you think it's very important? Sex is important as it's the basis of female subjugation - if you want to be respectful to women it's sex first and foremost.

TameDucksAtChatsworth · 04/01/2022 20:39

Be respectful towards your own sex first and foremost as it is always almost women that end up paying the price for gender identity.

PumpkinGin · 04/01/2022 20:37

There are only two sexes

Well, I think that gender identity is very important as well and I want to be respectful of people identifying as a certain gender. Or as non binary.

But I just don’t really understand these crime statistics. And I think there clearly is an argument for a separate space for transwomen and transmen. Everyone needs their privacy.

As for statistics, I have read quite a few articles about transwomen and sex crimes recently and it is very possible that this is just a skewed picture of reality. That is why it is so important to collect proper facts and proper data.

Necessary, that is all good with the statistics, but how can you tell that those offenders really were transwomen and not just men pretending to be transwomen?

TameDucksAtChatsworth · 04/01/2022 20:22

@PumpkinGin

Why can’t we just have four separate jail departments and statistics? One for women, one for men, one for transmen and one for transwomen?

Then we could keep everyone as safe as possible and also get some more statistics on what the crime rates are in each group. And which crimes each group tended to commit. Think that would be really useful data to have to continue this discussion.

@PumpkinGin

Sit down, have a gin and take a deep breath before digesting what I am about to write.

There are only two sexes: male and female. Waters don't need to be muddied and smoke screens generated.

Two sexes-that's it. It was ever so and, when this moment of twattery has passed, it will be ever thus again.

TameDucksAtChatsworth · 04/01/2022 20:19

It's a frigging disgrace.

This is where Transgender allying and preferred pronouns have led us.

Don't be a bleating ally if you are a woman and refuse to engage with preferred pronouns-they are one more cobble on the road to hell for women.

It is time to stop this shite. if you are born with a cock and one x chromosome then you are a man.

Yes, women in prison will be raped and assaulted because of this and any woman who thinks that is in any way acceptable is an unnatural monster.

DrSbaitso · 04/01/2022 20:18

Why can’t we just have four separate jail departments and statistics?

We don't need to. There are only two sexes, two sets of prisons are all we need.

Oh, and that wouldn't be good for validating a feminine identity as no different to actually inhabiting a female body.

NecessaryScene · 04/01/2022 20:13

Why can’t we just have four separate jail departments and statistics?

They usually seem very reluctant to let stats out.

A cynic would suggest it's because they would show no tendency whatsoever for trans inmates to have opposite-sex offending behaviour.

There was some recent freedom-of-information success in the US which managed to determine that 50% of MtF prisoners in federal prison were convicted of sex offenses, compared to 4% of FtM.

And the total number of FtM prisoners is far smaller than the number of MtF, so that's much more than a 10:1 difference. (50% of the FtM in federal prison are for drug offenses).

Personally, I would actually be open to some suggestion that there might be a subset of males that somehow has "lady brains" such that they behave like females. I'm not philosophically against the possibility. It could conceivably happen. But you need to have evidence.

But all the actual empirical evidence - like prison stats - shows that it doesn't. Or at least if it does, the people calling themselves "transwomen" don't have that characteristic. They're very, very male-behaving. They would have to commit about 50 times fewer sex offenses than they actually do to convince me they're somehow "female gendered".

WineAway · 04/01/2022 20:12

@PumpkinGin that’s never going to happen due to costs.

Do we have prisons for Non Binary people? Of people who sometimes identify as a woman ir sometimes ad a man like Eddie Izzard?

Why can’t the recording of crimes be done on the basis of sex. Why can’t people go to the prison according to their sex.

Sex is immutable, it is coded into every cell of a body.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 04/01/2022 19:58

Seems sensible to me, PumpkinGin!

PumpkinGin · 04/01/2022 19:46

Why can’t we just have four separate jail departments and statistics? One for women, one for men, one for transmen and one for transwomen?

Then we could keep everyone as safe as possible and also get some more statistics on what the crime rates are in each group. And which crimes each group tended to commit. Think that would be really useful data to have to continue this discussion.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 04/01/2022 19:28

When JK Rowling talked about predatory male rapists and sexual offenders using Self ID as a way in to womens spaces she was threatened with rape and death.

Neil Gaiman, Phillip Pullman stuck the knife in. Owen Jones and Jameela Jamil cheered it on.

Courage calls to Courage.

OP posts:
WandaWomblesaurus73 · 04/01/2022 19:21

@ppeony

Out of interest, do many of you talk openly about how you feel about this, or do you fear being called a TERF etc?
Every woman from every kind of background I know talks about it behind closed doors.
OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread