Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men shouldn't be named as women in newspapers if they have committed sexual offences?

385 replies

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 02/01/2022 14:59

Just that really - I'm seeing more and more newspaper reports where women are being implicated in weird sexual crimes and the you see the picture and it's obviously a man.

Now I totally get that if someone is transitioning it's polite to call them by their preferred name etc - but AIBU to think that some of these criminals are just taking the piss?

Here are some recent examples - and there are loads more.

www.northwichguardian.co.uk/news/19802592.northwich-woman-jailed-cocaine-fuelled-sex-dog/

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10339797/amp/Thumb-sucking-paedophile-claims-identify-five-year-old-girl-comes-court-dressed-ELF.html

How can anyone think this is ok? And will these "women" end up in women's prisons out of politeness?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Enough4me · 05/01/2022 22:58

@MorningStarling your argument is that rapists can go to women's prisons to carry on raping to punish female prisoners. That damages women who are likely to have experienced abuse, but how does this reduce rape?

Could it even increase rape if rapists find it easier to find prey in women's prisons than on the streets?

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 05/01/2022 19:31

@Beowulfa

I am heartened to see this thread has made it to 13 pages without being relegated to the Naughty Corner, and that so many posters are seeing the shitshow for what it is.

Surely in future years people will look back in bewilderment on a society that:

-locks up rapists in women's prisons
-forces women to pretend in court that their rapist was a woman
-allows experimental drugs to be used on children who don't conform to gender stereotypes
-makes girls who are uncomfortable about changing with males feel bad about their discomfort

I want to be able to say that I took an active part in rejecting this.

Exactly this. How many women here wish they could speak out about it freely? In other words, how many of us are there? I do not believe that as many women don't know about it all by now as did this time last year. The ratio in some of the newspapers is reversed too.
OP posts:
334bu · 05/01/2022 18:33

I have read many things on these boards with which I have strongly disagreed but MorningStarling's contribution is really beyond the pale. Cruel and unusual punishment indeed. ! Sickening!

starlilly88 · 05/01/2022 18:08

Drives me mad. You don't see women wanting to be men so they can compete in mens sports (they wouldn't win and there would be uproar from men), or women committing crimes and pretending to be trans so they can go to a mens prison. Or women wanting to go in mens changing rooms. It's all about men trying to get access to womens places and an easier life in prisons. Once again womens rights get trampled on and we can't do anything about it in case we get called transphobic.

2Gen · 05/01/2022 16:24

Of course YANBU! These "women" are just vile men, sex offenders hwo have jumped on the transgender band-wagon in rder to access their chosen victim group, women or children or both, more easily! It actually makes my blood boil that they're allowed to do so! That is a crime in itself!
I do hope though, that most people still have some sense and when they see the photo of the so-called "woman" sex offender, they'll realise it's a man and won't be fooled! The trouble is, will they have the courage to express themselves openly on the matter or will they be too frightened of being called names, just like the police and SS were in the cases of the underage girls made sex- slaves by Muslim gangs? If we don't speak out against it, it'll just keep being done and only get worse!

TurquoiseBaubles · 05/01/2022 16:04
Shock

I've heard of cruel and unusual punishment, but that takes the biscuit.

logsonlogsoff · 05/01/2022 16:00

‘ Prisons are not nice places, they're not meant to be nice places, the fear of getting locked up with a transgender rapist for 23 hours a day serves as a good deterrent not to be sent to prison in the first place. I don't want them to abuse a female prisoner, I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.’

Jesus Christ. You know why most women go to jail in the first place? You might get the rare violent criminal ( who still deserve to be safe in prison by the way) but mainly they come from abusive backgrounds, where drugs, poverty and DV has played a massive part in their lives. Prison is not a deterrent.
I don’t commit crimes because I had a living childhood, a decent education and opportunities not because I’m afraid of prison.

logsonlogsoff · 05/01/2022 15:56

It’s BS and these rapists should at least be called transwomen in reports.

Bosky · 05/01/2022 15:53

@MorningStarling

I honestly can't get too worked up about whether a rapist believes they are male or female. Clearly I'm in the minority but to me the term #notourcrimes applies because I'm one of the people who has never committed rape or sexual assault, not because I'm female.

There was a thread a few weeks ago about the Northwich dog abuser. I said then what I'll say now, I genuinely don't care whether someone like that is locked up in a male prison or a female one, the important thing is that they are taken away from society. Any future crimes they commit whilst in prison are not OK, but at least they will be committed on fellow prisoners rather than the general public. Prisons are not nice places, they're not meant to be nice places, the fear of getting locked up with a transgender rapist for 23 hours a day serves as a good deterrent not to be sent to prison in the first place. I don't want them to abuse a female prisoner, I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.

To me it doesn't matter whether crime statistics are skewed by so-called "female" rapists. What matters is that rapes aren't committed, and if they do that the offender is locked up. Suggesting it is harmful that a transgender rapist has their crime recorded as a female one implies that the victim is less of a victim because their attacker was "only" a woman. I'd suggest many rape victims are traumatised by the crime itself, which prison their attacker ends up in and which list the crime is recorded on is only a minor concern.

Society has evolved and now believes that someone can become a member of the gender they were not born as. Whether you think that's right or wrong, that's where we are. There were similar arguments when rights for homosexuals were being promoted decades ago - they were identified and treated differently in prison because they were deemed at greater risk of attacking others. If we believe a person has the right to choose their sexuality, now their gender, we must allow them that right without limitation. We can't say "well you can live as a woman except when it comes to playing sport or going to prison" - either a man can transition to become a woman, or they can't.

Prisons are not nice places, they're not meant to be nice places, the fear of getting locked up with a transgender rapist for 23 hours a day serves as a good deterrent not to be sent to prison in the first place. I don't want them to abuse a female prisoner, I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.

Grotesque as this argument is, ie. that a "good deterrent" to women committing crime would be the fear and risk of being raped in prison, it is worth noting that one of the arguments often made for imprisoning certain men with women is that those men are in fear of and at risk of being raped in a men's prison.

However, if it is reasonable to use the fear and risk of being raped as a "deterrent" to women (who are usually convicted of non-violent offences) it should surely be even more reasonable to use the fear and risk of being raped as a "deterrent" to men, who are much more often convicted of violent offences and sex crimes.

Since males with a variety of "trans identities" are much more likely to be in prison for crimes of violence and sex crimes than other males, the "deterrent" argument suggests that they should always be imprisoned in the Men's Estate.

The argument that they should be given a waiver if they have committed a non-violent crime does not hold because (according to MorningStarling's explanation) women who commit such crimes are undeserving of protection because they are not "normal people".

MorningStarling also points out that women can be violent towards each other in prison.

Logically, using MorningStarling's reasoning:

  1. All males should be imprisoned in the Men's Estate, where they can live in fear and at risk of rape as a "deterrent".
  1. This should be especially true for males who have committed violent crimes and sex crimes. Society surely wants to deter these crimes more than others plus there is the added bonus of "an eye for an eye".
  1. Women are much more likely to be convicted of non-violent crimes so the "deterrent" surely does not need to be as extreme and living in fear of and at risk of violence from other women should suffice?

However, MorningStarling in effect suggests that the current situation is justified because:

  • protecting women (mostly non-violent and already traumatised and abused) from unnecessary fear and the risk of violence should be given zero priority
  • protecting males (who present a greater threat of violence to women even if their crimes were non-violent) from unnecessary fear and the risk of violence should be given top priority, with the added bonus for sex-offenders that they have access to captive prey.

MorningStarling

  • why do you think it is only women who should be "deterred" from committing crime by the fear and threat of being raped in prison?
  • why do you think rapists should be rewarded by having potential victims incarcerated with them? Surely this would encourage rapists rather than deterring them?
Beowulfa · 05/01/2022 15:43

I am heartened to see this thread has made it to 13 pages without being relegated to the Naughty Corner, and that so many posters are seeing the shitshow for what it is.

Surely in future years people will look back in bewilderment on a society that:

-locks up rapists in women's prisons
-forces women to pretend in court that their rapist was a woman
-allows experimental drugs to be used on children who don't conform to gender stereotypes
-makes girls who are uncomfortable about changing with males feel bad about their discomfort

I want to be able to say that I took an active part in rejecting this.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 05/01/2022 14:37

A year ago this thread would most likely have been deleted.

The world is waking up to the the actual impact of allowing any male to self ID as a woman.

These are not our crimes.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 05/01/2022 11:13

@TameDucksAtChatsworth

The In order for your last sentence to happen it has to be accepted that no-one can change their legal gender.

That is the only way forward.

We can begin this uphill struggle by refusing to use chosen pronouns, refusing to buy from shops that allow men into women's changing rooms and boycotting any women events/prizes such as sporting events or The Booker Prize that allow men to enter.

We can also support JK Rowling and other brave souls who speak out.

I agree. Women need to actively speak now and put pressure on our MP/MSPs and not back down on this.

This is something that cannot be allowed to be relegated to the feminism section of Mumsnet and hidden from other women.

We are all needed in order to protect our daughters - we cannot protect women from men erasing them from life or from men brutally raping them if we cannot define what a man and a woman is.

Right now JKR and other women are putting their careers and their safety on the line for us.

"Be Kind" is doublespeak for "I am a man with a sexual fetish. Let me do what I want or you will be punished."

OP posts:
334bu · 05/01/2022 11:05

www.heraldscotland.com/politics/19823487.stuart-waiton-need-debate-trans-inmates/

Interesting article in the Herald which unfortunately is behind a paywall. However, it does end with the statement that sorting out the problem has to start with recognising that transwomen are not women.

With reference to crime figures, I read some time ago that the Inspector of Prisons in Canada had stated that of the male prisoners seeking transfer to female prisons, some 60% had been convicted of sex offences.

TameDucksAtChatsworth · 05/01/2022 10:55

It's true that it's laughable when people see a picture of a man under the headline, 'Woman Guilty of Sex Attack" and they will laugh-it would make a cat laugh.

But all that laughing and incredulous shaking of heads counts for nothing if it is allowed to go on. Many people won't even think of the implications for their daughters.

That is why we each have to act in our own small way.

WishingWell5 · 05/01/2022 10:33

I am just thinking aloud here (totally uneducated/ researched) but I wonder if there is always going to be an alarming percentage of men who identify as women as sex offenders/ rapists/ paedophiles. Placing an unusually high importance on gender and sexualised feelings relating to gender. The identity as a woman in particular relating to societal understandings as being meek, mild, submissive etc. But with a penis. Is this part of the allure? I find this all very very worrying. Terrifying in fact that they can call themselves 'women' and society is ok with this, because 'its how they feel'.
I am not saying ALL men who identify as a woman, just to clarify.

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 05/01/2022 10:11

YANBU at all.

beachyandswimmy · 05/01/2022 10:06

@MarshmallowFondant

Disagree.

Naming these people as women, and referring to them as "she" or "her", along with a picture of the perpetrator, will drive it home to people how the whole idea of self-identification is fundamentally flawed and puts women at serious risk.

What I'm thinking. It's a good thing the first thing you see is a picture of the woman in question.

Thelnebriati · 05/01/2022 10:04

I think this is the main reason I no longer go with 'live and let live', and think its time to repeal the GRA completely. They should have just legalised gay marriage instead of creating a legal fiction thats a safeguarding nightmare.

TameDucksAtChatsworth · 05/01/2022 10:01

The In order for your last sentence to happen it has to be accepted that no-one can change their legal gender.

That is the only way forward.

We can begin this uphill struggle by refusing to use chosen pronouns, refusing to buy from shops that allow men into women's changing rooms and boycotting any women events/prizes such as sporting events or The Booker Prize that allow men to enter.

We can also support JK Rowling and other brave souls who speak out.

Thelnebriati · 05/01/2022 09:49

@PollyPepper

This makes me so fucking angry.

What TRAS don't realise is that the legal definition of rape is with a penis. A woman therefore CANNOT RAPE. She can assault, digitally penetrate, etc, but rape is with a PENIS. So are we now going to have a sudden increase in women commiting rape? Which, as the law stands, is not possible?

Watch them try to tie themselves in knots explaining that one.

''reports of more women committing sexual crimes coincide with shifts in how crime statistics data are being collected.'' www.womenarehuman.com/are-women-really-committing-more-sex-offences-now/

I don't think men convicted of sexual or violent offences should be allowed to change their legal gender, and dont see how that could be a controversial opinion.

Emerald5hamrock · 05/01/2022 09:10

Society has gone crazy.
What a fucking mess.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 05/01/2022 08:32

@PollyPepper

This makes me so fucking angry.

What TRAS don't realise is that the legal definition of rape is with a penis. A woman therefore CANNOT RAPE. She can assault, digitally penetrate, etc, but rape is with a PENIS. So are we now going to have a sudden increase in women commiting rape? Which, as the law stands, is not possible?

Watch them try to tie themselves in knots explaining that one.

So we are being told several things:

"Women have penises. Therefore women can rape with penises."

"Why can't you accept women rape other people and that can sometimes happen with objects like dildos."

"Transwomen are more vulnerable than women in prison."

OP posts:
PollyPepper · 05/01/2022 08:28

This makes me so fucking angry.

What TRAS don't realise is that the legal definition of rape is with a penis. A woman therefore CANNOT RAPE. She can assault, digitally penetrate, etc, but rape is with a PENIS. So are we now going to have a sudden increase in women commiting rape? Which, as the law stands, is not possible?

Watch them try to tie themselves in knots explaining that one.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 05/01/2022 08:20

@Moolia

I'm afraid you'll find that lots of TRAs say that a penis isn't necessarily male genitalia. They say there is such a thing as a female penis. I kid you not.
This has been going on for ages - "female penis" is supposed to be something we are all accepting of "girl dick" is the term I've seen being used.

medium.com/@transphilosophr/what-is-girldick-9363515e0bfd

OP posts:
Enough4me · 05/01/2022 00:58

Sexual predators will lie to get access to girls and women, so a mix could happen. This is the key issue, any man could be a sexual predator and it doesn't matter which out of the 100s of genders criminals select, no male should be in female spaces.

Swipe left for the next trending thread