Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men shouldn't be named as women in newspapers if they have committed sexual offences?

385 replies

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 02/01/2022 14:59

Just that really - I'm seeing more and more newspaper reports where women are being implicated in weird sexual crimes and the you see the picture and it's obviously a man.

Now I totally get that if someone is transitioning it's polite to call them by their preferred name etc - but AIBU to think that some of these criminals are just taking the piss?

Here are some recent examples - and there are loads more.

www.northwichguardian.co.uk/news/19802592.northwich-woman-jailed-cocaine-fuelled-sex-dog/

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10339797/amp/Thumb-sucking-paedophile-claims-identify-five-year-old-girl-comes-court-dressed-ELF.html

How can anyone think this is ok? And will these "women" end up in women's prisons out of politeness?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Ereshkigalangcleg · 08/01/2022 09:52

Wow, no one ever saw that coming.

thegreenlight · 08/01/2022 09:20

A system open to abuse - prisoners identify as female to get into women’s prisons, then revert when they are out. www.thetimes.co.uk/article/trans-prisoners-switch-gender-again-once-freed-from-womens-units-qjjsd0nlx

WineAway · 08/01/2022 08:51

& even worse here in Ireland. The public were never consulted on self ID. It was pushed in under the radar.

334bu · 08/01/2022 08:42

At what point were the public consulted on men being put into women's prisons?

At no point, at least in Scotland, were the needs of female prisoners ever considered; no equality impact assessment ever considered their needs, no serving frontline staff were ever consulted and definitely no consultation with female prisoners themselves.

YouSetTheTone · 08/01/2022 07:33

@WandaWomblesaurus73

At what point were the public consulted on men being put into women's prisons?

Have Stonewall put policies in place in institutions without the public being consulted?

I nearly corrected my previous post as I realised afterwards that although different questions asked of society might have had different results -we’d never even been consulted anyway so it was a moot point.

None of this has been done in consultation with the public - and least of all with women’s groups, who have actively been shut out of discussions with Stonewall. #nodebate has a lot to answer for.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 08/01/2022 03:08

At what point were the public consulted on men being put into women's prisons?

Have Stonewall put policies in place in institutions without the public being consulted?

OP posts:
Verv · 07/01/2022 16:25

YANBU, males are not women, even if they are uncomfortable with being male, they are still not women and should not be recorded as such when indulging in what is essentially male crime against women.

Stonewall no longer represents same sex attracted people.
Hasnt for a while.

Lovelyricepudding · 07/01/2022 16:15

@WandaWomblesaurus73

Nancy Kelly of Stonewall was interviewed on Women's Hour. Absolutely shocking.

Also on another thread regarding medical language for women...

Also in the way they have pushed trans ideology on children...

Stonewall have a lot to answer for.

She was also interviewed by Qatari-owned Al Jazeera where she praised her hosts for their lack of questioning and condemned the UK as intolerant. I am sure Qatar''s rulers (and Al Jazeera owners) lapped this up... no mention of their laws on homosexuality or the 6500 people who died building the football world cup stadium...
WandaWomblesaurus73 · 07/01/2022 11:15

It's the one she did a few weeks ago.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 07/01/2022 11:00

@WandaWomblesaurus73

Nancy Kelly of Stonewall was interviewed on Women's Hour. Absolutely shocking.

Also on another thread regarding medical language for women...

Also in the way they have pushed trans ideology on children...

Stonewall have a lot to answer for.

What did she say this time? Something homophobic?
WandaWomblesaurus73 · 07/01/2022 10:55

Nancy Kelly of Stonewall was interviewed on Women's Hour.
Absolutely shocking.

Also on another thread regarding medical language for women...

Also in the way they have pushed trans ideology on children...

Stonewall have a lot to answer for.

OP posts:
YouSetTheTone · 07/01/2022 10:49

Could anyone take Stonewall to court for successfully lobbying for such damaging practical outcomes from a nebulous ideology?
The slogans alone - ‘TWAW’ and ‘acceptance without exception’ - are part of a movement that has seen women paying a significant cost - in prisons, in court cases, in sporting arenas etc. Then there was all the secret meetings with people in power, the aggressive ‘training’ of the police force, the judiciary, the schools, the hospitals, the sporting committees..
Would we be here if the questions asked of society had been ‘are transvestites allowed in women’s sport?’ Or ‘are transvestites allowed in women’s rape crisis centres?’

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 07/01/2022 08:53

Given that predatory men will look for opportunities that allow them access to children and vulnerable females - priests, scout leaders, teachers, hospital staff etc - why anyone would think they wouldn't use the transgender umbrella veil of protection to get access to both privilege and victims, is beyond me.

Transsexuals and Transvestites should never have been lumped in together. Most women think that "Transwomen" are effeminate gay men who just want to be feminine and who are both vulnerable and safe. Many of us have gay male friends who are safe and supportive. Some of us have known transsexual people who are absolutely lovely.

However working in theatre and nightclubs - I met straight men who were simply in it for the fetish of getting turned on by dressing as a caricature of women. Being a women is not a fetish.

It's also not and can never be an idea in a man's head of what being a woman is like. They have no idea. It's stereotypes. I will not submit to being put in the same category as men who fetishise women in order to get a hard on - having access to our spaces and our children.

What we are seeing amongst the trans ideological bandwagon now are predatory men using the cause to bully women into submission.

At what point does it stop? Who needs to be raped for it to stop? It's already happening in prisons. These women are the canaries in the coal mine.

OP posts:
334bu · 06/01/2022 21:08

Yes OnlyaFleshWound that post of MorningStarling is beneath contempt.

scotvic · 06/01/2022 20:59

Appallingly, rape and sexual abuse (almost always by men) of very vulnerable people (women and girls) is rife. It very often goes undetected and unpunished. A new report about care homes and long stay hospitals shows that disabled women are incredibly vulnerable, mainly because they can't 'fight back' or communicate (ie report) abuse and/or won't be taken seriously by the authorities. morningstaronline.co.uk/article/f/its-massive-scandal-just-waiting-break
Women in prisons are similarly 'hidden' and voiceless. NO males should ever be imprisoned with women, and especially not those who have already committed sexual offences. How they may choose to 'identify' gender-wise is immaterial, they should NEVER be with women in womens prisons. If they are at risk in men's prisons, then let there be a 'third space' for transwomen prisoners. Its not the job of women to protect men from other violent men, especially if they themselves end up at risk of violence.

Enough4me · 06/01/2022 19:49

Because she's a woman, a non-man. She should be kind and smile, laugh at male jokes as it's not sexist if it's called banter, know her place.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 06/01/2022 18:41

And it's essential to protect convicted rapists like Karen White from being raped by male prisoners by placing them in the women's estate. No-one seems to think the unpleasantness of prison should simply deter the males who claim transgender identities from committing rape in the first place.

White was in prison on remand for raping a woman in a locked psychiatric ward. He raped her so violently that she was left with permanent injuries that mean she can never have children. But he got placed in a women's prison for his human rights.

But a 19 year old girl should be expected to accept rape as part of the penalty for shoplifting?

Why?!

Enough4me · 06/01/2022 18:11

True, it's strange that human rights are rights if you're a man wanting access to women's bodies and declare yourself a woman, but not if your an imprisoned women.

OnlyAFleshWound · 06/01/2022 17:47

[quote Enough4me]@OnlyAFleshWound, I agree, none of us is exempt from the risk of being incorrectly judged and being arrested or placed in prison. I say this as a professional and a non-criminal so no actual experience, but we all know there are cases of misidentification, false allegations and similar. Plus add in cases where mental health has not been treated or coercion and abuse has led to retaliation or defence.

Prisons are punishment through lack of freedom, not punishment through torture.[/quote]
And even if someone has been correctly arrested and convicted and imprisoned, and has no mental health problems and didn't act in self-defence, they still don't deserve to be locked up with a rapist and raped. FGS.

Prisoners are people with human rights, not disposable animals as @MorningStarling suggests.

Enough4me · 06/01/2022 17:20

@OnlyAFleshWound, I agree, none of us is exempt from the risk of being incorrectly judged and being arrested or placed in prison. I say this as a professional and a non-criminal so no actual experience, but we all know there are cases of misidentification, false allegations and similar. Plus add in cases where mental health has not been treated or coercion and abuse has led to retaliation or defence.

Prisons are punishment through lack of freedom, not punishment through torture.

OnlyAFleshWound · 06/01/2022 11:01

@morningstarling

There was a thread a few weeks ago about the Northwich dog abuser. I said then what I'll say now, I genuinely don't care whether someone like that is locked up in a male prison or a female one, the important thing is that they are taken away from society. Any future crimes they commit whilst in prison are not OK, but at least they will be committed on fellow prisoners rather than the general public. Prisons are not nice places, they're not meant to be nice places, the fear of getting locked up with a transgender rapist for 23 hours a day serves as a good deterrent not to be sent to prison in the first place. I don't want them to abuse a female prisoner, I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.

Your post demonstrates that not being in prison does not make someone "a normal person" [sic]

It is probably the worst comment I have ever read in over 10 years on this site.

Feel physically sick after reading that. It is horrendous that a person who would think and say those things exists as part of our society.

DrSbaitso · 06/01/2022 10:01

@WorriedMumsDontSleep

From the article: At present applicants must be 18 years old, supply evidence of a medical diagnosis for gender dysphoria and swear an oath that they have been living in their “new” gender for two years.

Which is very different to the general publics' idea of trans. Generally assumed to be someone with gender dysphoria (diagnosis on patient evidence and no concrete evidence. Mostly based on stereotypes) who has had extensive surgery and removed their penis. Living in the new gender can be as simple as changing post to a gender neutral name.
Compare to something like claiming disability allowance based on a real need it's a walk in the park.

Yes. A key point is that it no longer means someone who feels they were "born in the wrong body" and should have been born the opposite sex to what they are. It now just means "feeling female" (how do you know what this is if you are not female?) and therefore womanhood becomes merely a feeling. And no different to actually inhabiting a female body. You can be 100% comfortable in your male body, but in the new understanding, you are literally a woman just by feeling it, and you should therefore have access to all female spaces even though you're actually very comfortable in a male body.
WorriedMumsDontSleep · 06/01/2022 09:44

From the article:
At present applicants must be 18 years old, supply evidence of a medical diagnosis for gender dysphoria and swear an oath that they have been living in their “new” gender for two years.

Which is very different to the general publics' idea of trans. Generally assumed to be someone with gender dysphoria (diagnosis on patient evidence and no concrete evidence. Mostly based on stereotypes) who has had extensive surgery and removed their penis. Living in the new gender can be as simple as changing post to a gender neutral name.
Compare to something like claiming disability allowance based on a real need it's a walk in the park.

catzwhiskas · 06/01/2022 09:19

Good article by Tory Mp in today’s Times
www.thetimes.co.uk/article/4229fe10-6db1-11ec-87c8-7ab22098d3fb?shareToken=ced91a35371048d54b0113ee7df4a62a

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 06/01/2022 08:20

It’s BS and these rapists should at least be called transwomen in reports

No, it's because of polite fiction we're in this mess. At least when transvestite was used the general public understood that the individual still had a penis.
Thanks to transwomen being used as an umbrella from everyone to fully op to bearded bloke with male name, the word has been used to knock down women's boundaries.
If I was a (post op) trans person I would want a word to distinguish people from me. Not because they have rights to the female space and estate, they don't; but because it causes confusion to lump different groups of people with very different ideas together.

We have lots of words for the different branches of Christian, at least four words for people that don't eat meat, even bame is criticised for being too general. What good comes from calling all and sundry transwomen? It just caused confusion at best and allows breach of boundaries at worst.

Swipe left for the next trending thread