Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that men shouldn't be named as women in newspapers if they have committed sexual offences?

385 replies

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 02/01/2022 14:59

Just that really - I'm seeing more and more newspaper reports where women are being implicated in weird sexual crimes and the you see the picture and it's obviously a man.

Now I totally get that if someone is transitioning it's polite to call them by their preferred name etc - but AIBU to think that some of these criminals are just taking the piss?

Here are some recent examples - and there are loads more.

www.northwichguardian.co.uk/news/19802592.northwich-woman-jailed-cocaine-fuelled-sex-dog/

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10339797/amp/Thumb-sucking-paedophile-claims-identify-five-year-old-girl-comes-court-dressed-ELF.html

How can anyone think this is ok? And will these "women" end up in women's prisons out of politeness?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
mrshoho · 17/04/2022 19:35

It is horrific.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 17/04/2022 19:00

@mrshoho

unherd.com/2021/07/how-the-trans-activists-fooled-ireland/

A very informative piece written by a transgender person highlighting the terrible consequences of the Gender Recognition Act in Ireland. An act that seemed to get passed in Ireland very quietly under the radar.

This is what Nicola Sturgeon wants for Scotland and what the Labour Party are pledging to bring in.

The author is Debbie Hayton and it's about the Denton Playbook as a pattern for Ireland.

www.rollonfriday.com/news-content/dentons-campaigns-kids-switch-gender-without-parental-approval

www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-document-that-reveals-the-remarkable-tactics-of-trans-lobbyists

grahamlinehan.substack.com/p/the-dentons-document?s=r

mrshoho · 17/04/2022 18:52

unherd.com/2021/07/how-the-trans-activists-fooled-ireland/

A very informative piece written by a transgender person highlighting the terrible consequences of the Gender Recognition Act in Ireland. An act that seemed to get passed in Ireland very quietly under the radar.

This is what Nicola Sturgeon wants for Scotland and what the Labour Party are pledging to bring in.

Bosky · 17/04/2022 17:40

PurgatoryOfPotholes - thank you for this information!

"This is a quote from Jackie Doyle-Price MP's speech during the International Women's Day Debate in Parliament, as recorded by Hansard"

I missed this at the time!

hansard.parliament.ukCommons/2022-03-10/debates/1C377E5F-9903-48CD-A036-1F1728D726B2/InternationalWomen%E2%80%99SDay#contribution-8C48CCA4-479B-4D2F-99CF-6A7C2E45E94C

Women experiencing mental health crises are placed in prison, without them having committed any offence, to keep them safe. Is it still acceptable to you that they face any risk of rape in there?

I have attached screenshots from the 2021 unannounced inspection of Low Newton Women's Prison in Co Durham.

I agree that no woman should be at risk of rape in prison, whether from guards or other prisoners.

However, it is an added outrage that:

  • women are being imprisoned in the UK when they have committed no crime at all and should be in a mental health facility for their own safety
  • they are gaslit that all the other prisoners are female
  • they are at risk of being raped!

Rape by male guards and male prisoners is a big problem in the USA and Canada and we really want to avoid sinking to those depths in the UK.

Just this week:

"Two Female Inmates Pregnant By Transgender Inmates In New Jersey Women’s Prison"

reduxx.info/two-female-inmates-pregnant-by-transgender-inmates-in-new-jersey-womens-prison/

There are some more horror stories here:

www.womenarehuman.com/tag/prison/

and here:

reduxx.info/?s=prison

and here:

4w.pub/tag/prison/

and specifically in the UK:

transcrimeuk.com/

"No Men in Women’s Prisons – protests in England 2022"

Excellent article with a lot of UK history and information:

lilymaynard.com/no-men-in-womens-prisons-protests-in-england-2022/

Please see this post for information about women's organisations that were involved with Global Prison Protests for International Women's Day 2022

#IWD Global Prison Protests - Keep Prisons Single Sex

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4499918--IWD-Global-Prison-Protests-Keep-Prisons-Single-Sex

To think that men shouldn't be named as women in newspapers if they have committed sexual offences?
To think that men shouldn't be named as women in newspapers if they have committed sexual offences?
To think that men shouldn't be named as women in newspapers if they have committed sexual offences?
OatSprout · 16/04/2022 23:09

YADNBU

mrshoho · 16/04/2022 23:00

YANBU. Stop this nonsense and protect women and children.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 16/04/2022 22:39

These days, it is progressive to declare people to either be fair game (tfs, prisoners, people-who-voted-differently-to-you-at-the-last-election, some form of -ist and so on) for violence, or to be the people who get to say whatever they like without repercussion.

The culture of impunity still seems to have some exclusions, of course. I'm merely basing this on the special rules for one part of MN, the life bans from Twitter that seem to affect some groups more than others…

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 16/04/2022 22:11

@DomesticatedZombie

Well, to be honest even when someone has committed a crime and harmed others, we don't abandon them to the wolves because we are supposed to be a civilised society which means we lead by example, we don't seek retribution/revenge and we attempt to rehabilitate.

I thought, anyway.

I believe those are old-fashioned liberal values that we have 'matured' past. These days, it is progressive to declare people to either be fair game (t**fs, prisoners, people-who-voted-differently-to-you-at-the-last-election, some form of -ist and so on) for violence, or to be the people who get to say whatever they like without repercussion.
SucculentChalice · 16/04/2022 21:49

YANBU. It can only be a matter of time before yet another patronising article appears in a British newspaper lamenting in painful detail how much the rate of offences committed by women is increasing year on year, and wringing their hands as to what they can do to stop this dreadful trend amongst women.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 16/04/2022 21:48

It's always been too far, it was a shit show waiting to happen the minute the GRA was passed in 2004, several MP's and Lords highlighted exactly where this would lead and, of course, that was hand waved away with that will never happen now it fucking has and those that support this insidious agenda still make excuses and are dismissive of the impact it is having.

For anyone who isn't familiar with the high quality of the House of Lords' debates and the prescience of those who anticipated this would happen, there's a Twitter thread of quotations from Hansard:

twitter.com/HairyLeggdHarpy/status/1052160108489334785

That thread is available on various sites including web archive.

VestofAbsurdity · 16/04/2022 21:42

@itsgettingweird

It's going too far now.
It's always been too far, it was a shit show waiting to happen the minute the GRA was passed in 2004, several MP's and Lords highlighted exactly where this would lead and, of course, that was hand waved away with that will never happen now it fucking has and those that support this insidious agenda still make excuses and are dismissive of the impact it is having.

The bottom line is it is only women and girls who are impacted and let's face it women and girls just don't matter and never have.

YANBU Op.

DomesticatedZombie · 16/04/2022 21:07

Well, to be honest even when someone has committed a crime and harmed others, we don't abandon them to the wolves because we are supposed to be a civilised society which means we lead by example, we don't seek retribution/revenge and we attempt to rehabilitate.

I thought, anyway.

ElPolloLoco · 16/04/2022 19:26

@DomesticatedZombie

I hadn't seen Morningstarling's post before. How absolutely fucking callous and horrible. Prisoners still have rights, they don't get thrown in a pit and left to rot. Have you time travelled from Roman times, Starling?
Exactly. I do my utmost to keep to the rules and not break the law but I am aware how things can suddenly go drastically wrong in an otherwise ‘normal’ life.

A car accident where you are unfairly blamed for injuring someone (I have seen first hand how biased and manipulative the police can be on this) and sent to prison, a Post Office manager who gets wrongly convicted of fraud because of a dodgy IT system that the PO refused to investigate, a victim of domestic abuse whose partner runs up huge debt in their name and she can’t pay her tv licence and gets jailed.

These things happen to women and the experience of being ripped away from your children and home is bad enough but to be locked up with a male who delights in taunting you, exposing himself and threatening you (or worse) while you’re in there? That is inhuman.

OP YANBU - Stonewall have been very thorough with their capture of key organisations. IPSO and Ofcom, the print and tv regulators enforce rules around using female pronouns for males with a trans identity regardless of the visual evidence.

News presenters and journalists have been disciplined for attempting to accurately report crimes and their perpetrators. It must feel terrible to be forced to report lies and obscure the seriousness of sexual crimes against women and children.

We need to keep complaining to Ofcom and IPSO for this enforced suppression of the truth.

DomesticatedZombie · 16/04/2022 18:54

I hadn't seen Morningstarling's post before. How absolutely fucking callous and horrible. Prisoners still have rights, they don't get thrown in a pit and left to rot. Have you time travelled from Roman times, Starling?

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 16/04/2022 18:48

However, Her Majesty’s inspectorate of prisons visited three prisons last year and in total found 68 women who had been remanded in prison for their own protection
…
Women experiencing mental health crises are placed in prison, without them having committed any offence, to keep them safe. Is it still acceptable to you that they face any risk of rape in there?

I'm not the poster you're addressing but I'm horrified. I had no idea that women were being imprisoned/remanded for such reasons.

PurgatoryOfPotholes · 13/04/2022 04:06

@MorningStarling

I honestly can't get too worked up about whether a rapist believes they are male or female. Clearly I'm in the minority but to me the term #notourcrimes applies because I'm one of the people who has never committed rape or sexual assault, not because I'm female.

There was a thread a few weeks ago about the Northwich dog abuser. I said then what I'll say now, I genuinely don't care whether someone like that is locked up in a male prison or a female one, the important thing is that they are taken away from society. Any future crimes they commit whilst in prison are not OK, but at least they will be committed on fellow prisoners rather than the general public. Prisons are not nice places, they're not meant to be nice places, the fear of getting locked up with a transgender rapist for 23 hours a day serves as a good deterrent not to be sent to prison in the first place. I don't want them to abuse a female prisoner, I don't want them to abuse anyone - but if they do, better their victim be a prisoner than a normal person.

To me it doesn't matter whether crime statistics are skewed by so-called "female" rapists. What matters is that rapes aren't committed, and if they do that the offender is locked up. Suggesting it is harmful that a transgender rapist has their crime recorded as a female one implies that the victim is less of a victim because their attacker was "only" a woman. I'd suggest many rape victims are traumatised by the crime itself, which prison their attacker ends up in and which list the crime is recorded on is only a minor concern.

Society has evolved and now believes that someone can become a member of the gender they were not born as. Whether you think that's right or wrong, that's where we are. There were similar arguments when rights for homosexuals were being promoted decades ago - they were identified and treated differently in prison because they were deemed at greater risk of attacking others. If we believe a person has the right to choose their sexuality, now their gender, we must allow them that right without limitation. We can't say "well you can live as a woman except when it comes to playing sport or going to prison" - either a man can transition to become a woman, or they can't.

I am resurrecting this thread, because I have something else for @MorningStarling to think about.

This is a quote from Jackie Doyle-Price MP's speech during the International Women's Day Debate in Parliament, as recorded by Hansard.

excerpt

We know also that many women do not belong in prison in the first place. One issue I have been taking up with the Ministry of Justice is the extent to which women are remanded in prison for their own protection. We have a mental health policy that has been removing police cells and prisons as places of safety—recognising that they are not good environments for people who are mentally unwell—but we are still remanding women in prison for their own safety. I thought it would be only a small number of women, probably no more than a dozen a year. Having raised the issue with the Government, I could not get any data on it. However, Her Majesty’s inspectorate of prisons visited three prisons last year and in total found 68 women who had been remanded in prison for their own protection. They were not people who had committed an offence, and it was not a punishment. It is totally inappropriate for a country such as this to be remanding women in prison for that purpose, and that was in just three prisons. Across the whole system, we know that women being remanded for their own protection are a significant proportion of the prison establishment, and frankly that is not good enough. I am ashamed of it, and I call on the Government to do better.

My criticism is not with the Ministry of Justice. One of the issues is that the Ministry of Justice is sweeping up the failings of other organisations within the public sector. It is sweeping up the ability of local authorities to offer safe spaces for women to be sent to when they are at risk. Mental health services are sweeping up that failure by the Department of Health and Social Care, and I encourage the Ministry of Justice to be rather more robust in its dealings with other Departments and say, “You know what? These are not our problems, they are yours.” We should not be dealing with vulnerable people within our estate.

[Bold mine]
Continues hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2022-03-10/debates/1C377E5F-9903-48CD-A036-1F1728D726B2/InternationalWomen%E2%80%99SDay

Women experiencing mental health crises are placed in prison, without them having committed any offence, to keep them safe. Is it still acceptable to you that they face any risk of rape in there?

ExtraPlinky · 09/02/2022 14:37

m.youtube.com/watch?v=ylEjDyimYAs&feature=emb_title

This speech by a former inmate should be heard by every woman.

This is Rebekah Wershbale’s speechh^ which she delivered outside HMP Styal in which she herself served a sentence.

“Today’s demonstration, this protest, this outright OBJECTION to men in women’s prisons is a subject that resonates with me on a terrible, very personal level.
I’m a former inmate of HMP Styal. This occasion marks the first time I’ve returned to these grounds since I was shipped out in a sweat box 10 years ago. The conditions inside were as bleak then as they are now. Healthcare was not a priority, women were and are terribly unwell, with godawful diets and no good treatment plans. Mental health care is practically nonexistent. We’re talking about a forgotten population of the most achingly vulnerable women that society has left behind. Self-harm is endemic, the statistics say that the prevalence is 5 times higher than the rates in men’s prisons – in reality, this translates to the fact that the women I knew inside that didn’t self-harm were a clear minority.
Many of the inmates are mothers. They miss their babies. You can hear them crying every night after lights out. The fear, pain and despondency they feel is palpable.
There are women as well that feel safer here. They welcome institutionalisation, even under these dire circumstances because their lives have been fraught with and rent asunder by MALE VIOLENCE. From their fathers, friends, strangers, partners and husbands. We know the numbers. 60% – well over half – report experiencing domestic violence. 30% report sexual assault. There is no provision for therapy or meaningful recovery so they make the best of what they have, which up until recently was an exclusively female relatively safe space.
Taking all these tragic factors into account, it should be a scandal that these women – with literally NOTHING to shield them, are now being subjected to men, violent, manipulative, aggressive MEN in the tiny spaces they’re permitted. On top of all the existing grievous harms and insults to their wellbeing. On top of all their anxieties and helplessness, they now have to endure men in their estates. In their cells.
It’s hard to imagine their disquiet at this frankly unthinkable development. Hard to comprehend how they must feel at the prospect of being trapped, with no way out. Locked down by a benign and loving government that just wants to do right by ‘transgender prisoners’ and couldn’t give a shit about the comfort, dignity and PHYSICAL SAFETY of a group of traumatised and marginalised women. Women who’ve already had to survive violent hardships and who are rightly terrified of men are now also terrified to say how they’re being affected.
This is an OUTRAGE. This subject brought me as close to the forefront of campaigning as I could get because I know firsthand, from my own ‘lived experience’ that female prisoners are barely afforded a second consideration in society. We’re pariahs – judged, unemployable and scarred. The women in this prison have vanishingly few advocates, which is precisely why they were among the first to suffer the horrific consequences of the transgender experiment.
This situation is disgusting. Whether it’s a heinous oversight, a sadistic abuse of power or simply cowardice and unwillingness to challenge trans dogma in government, it is a complete travesty. Every last person responsible should feel shame at this abject dereliction of duty.
We’re here to be a voice for the voiceless women and should a resounding NO to this legislation. At all costs and by whatever means necessary, we need to KEEP PRISONS SINGLE SEX."

Enough4me · 11/01/2022 14:43

Prison may have been safer for them then the DV in their homes, but being locked up with a man upturns this completely.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 11/01/2022 01:02

www.newstatesman.com/comment/2022/01/female-prisoners-shouldnt-be-used-as-a-shield-for-trans-women-from-male-violence

"Often lost in this debate, however, is the focus on the women actually in those prisons. Eighty-two per cent of women are in prison for non-violent crime and with short sentences. Fifteen per cent of women are serving less than a year. A high proportion are working class, poor and/or BAME. They are often sentenced because of offences committed in order to feed and clothe themselves and their family, or because they committed offences to provide for the drug use of another.
Among them are many women who have been coerced, abused, prostituted and raped by men. Fifty-three per cent of women in prison have reported childhood sexual abuse, and 64 per cent of women in one study exhibited brain injuries consistent with having experienced domestic abuse (of which 96 per cent reported they had been victims of)."

OP posts:
Enough4me · 11/01/2022 00:09

He'll claim he was stressed and had MH issues as faces disadvantages as he's a TW. Women cannot claim that being actual women puts us in a vulnerable position, because only men are attuned to the victim role (women have to get on with being capable adults).

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 10/01/2022 21:41

www.echo-news.co.uk/news/19837391.colchester-sex-offender-21-sick-child-images/

And another one
#TheseAreNotOurCrimes

"The court was told some of the most serious images had “hallmarks of sadism” and involved the abuse of toddlers."

What the actual FUCK is this?

OP posts:
PrincessNutella · 10/01/2022 13:43

So unreasonable, OP! Who are you to get judgy when a lady gets into a roid rage?

Enough4me · 10/01/2022 13:43

"Be kind" to TW, don't say what your eyes see, what your ears hear, what you know to be true.

"Be kind" to the young TM, ignore the irreversible damage they do to escape from the problems being female encompasses.

Be kind, really means lie.

SomethingOnce · 10/01/2022 13:15

And this is where the uncritical ‘Be kind’ nonsense get us. The road to hell is paved with good intentions.

WandaWomblesaurus73 · 10/01/2022 12:41

@YouSetTheTone

That is repugnant. This sounds to me like: ‘I will exploit your status as a traumatised victim of sexual violence (by men) to break down your barriers further and allow men into your counselling spaces despite your wishes to have female only recovery support.’ I don’t know how Nicola Sturgeon can sleep at night, knowing this man is in charge of a rape crisis centre under her own eyes.
Nicola Sturgeon heckles people who talk about womens rights - we are clearly the wrong kind of women to expect her support.

susandalgety.substack.com/p/shame-on-you-nicola-sturgeon

OP posts: