Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you need to go hungry on a diet?

340 replies

username30473 · 02/01/2022 12:47

I didn't want to use the word diet it was just for the title. The last couple of years my diet has been appalling to say the least. I have always been a size 10 but now a size 12 touching 14. From the way I have eaten I actually think I could be a lot larger.
Anyway I am now trying to change my diet back to what it used to be and lose weight.

I actually started on Boxing Day so I am a week in and I am hungry all the time. I am not massively restricting myself either. Yesterday I have had yogurt/fruit for breakfast, beans and scrambled eggs on toast for lunch, fruit for afternoon snack and steak and chips for dinner with a couple of Jaffa cakes for dessert. I just think I am so use to eating so much now I just have to get use to be hungry until my body gets use to less food again.

Do others find this to be the case?

OP posts:
Nospringchix · 02/01/2022 19:17

@SilverHairedCat

No, absolutely not.

Going hungry is pointless, it's not sustainable and is just starving yourself.

Fill up on better foods - raise the protein levels, add lots more veg to that diet, keep bread to one meal a day and you'll not be hungry at all.

Absolutely spot on. More fibre, from non starchy veg. Couple of pieces of fruit. Plenty of protein, this will reduce levels of the hunger hormone, grehlin.
Malibuismysecrethome · 02/01/2022 19:05

Drink more water. It really does stop hunger.

EmmaH2022 · 02/01/2022 18:57

@orangesandlemons3

I think yes, you do need to be feeling a little hungry in order to lose weight. Not starving, but a bit 'I could eat another bag of crisps' kind of way.

But the feeling never goes - it's not true that if you lose weight, you 'get used to eating less'. I lost 3 stone down to a size 6-8 but I still have the same appetite I always had - i am just better at resisting and make a point to be more active now. But if I let myself go, I could easily eat as much as I did when I was 3 stone heavier.

So do you feel hungry a lot of the time?
orangesandlemons3 · 02/01/2022 18:44

I think yes, you do need to be feeling a little hungry in order to lose weight. Not starving, but a bit 'I could eat another bag of crisps' kind of way.

But the feeling never goes - it's not true that if you lose weight, you 'get used to eating less'. I lost 3 stone down to a size 6-8 but I still have the same appetite I always had - i am just better at resisting and make a point to be more active now. But if I let myself go, I could easily eat as much as I did when I was 3 stone heavier.

Bunnyfuller · 02/01/2022 18:43

When you get used to over eating your tummy gets used to the bigger amount and it now needs time to adjust. Definitely look at where you can swap out some processed carbs, drink lots of water because our brain often tells us we are hungry when we actually need fluid.

Try to get active in some way, and you will get used to eating less. One thing I do is make myself stop eating the minute I start feeling full - regardless of how yummy it is! A couple of Jaffa cakes is hardly gluttonous, fgs to the poster judging! You’ll do it op 😊

IamnotwhouthinkIam · 02/01/2022 18:36

The thing is any "diet" will usually work to lose weight if you stick to it - whether it's 16:8, lower carb, low fat, Paleo, Weight Watchers, Slimming World, Cambridge style shakes/soups. The issue is keeping it off years later and if you are constantly thinking about eating during a time when you aren't "allowed" or craving foods that are "forbidden" on the diet, then that is less likely to happen imo. Most people can usually be determined for a few months or even a year if we really want something, but doing it for life can be harder, especially if it is a dramatic change of lifestyle.

When I was younger I would hear about/see the same returners at slimming groups because the lifestyle changes were too dramatic or awkward to keep up for years and I personally didn't find nutritionists and personal trainers especially helpful (I was referred to all of these on the NHS as well as trying various ones privately because I was so overweight).

So I eventually cut out the groups and "experts" and decided on no special diets/special times to eat - and just slowly reduced the high sugar foods, white carbs, processed food and replaced with mostly lower sugar, more wholegrains, lean protein and more veg and fruit. BUT no food is banned or are there specific times to eat and I still have a "treat" or two daily as well as a takeaway or a higher calorie/less healthy restaurant meal weekly if I want one. This makes things like evenings out, parties, weddings and even holidays much easier as I'm not eating very differently from everyone not on a "diet".

It did take me nearly 10 years to slowly lose almost half my body weight using this method - but I've kept it off for over 3 years now, and even now I'm pregnant I'm trying to keep it up and only put on what's necessary.

I really hope @username30473 finds what works best for them as I did Flowers

superplumb · 02/01/2022 18:31

You're prob hungry because you trained yourself to eat more previously so now when you ate physically eating less your body is moaning. It gets easier and guyr tummy shrinks and you'll find it hard time at the same amount without feeling sick. I find coffee and sparkling water takes the edge off

SkeletonSkins · 02/01/2022 18:02

@me4real

Eating sweet things is fine, but best after a meal or paired with protein/fat. I love the glucose goddess on insta - she shows how just changing the order we eat things can impact how our bodies respond to what we eat.

@SkeletonSkins That doesn't sound evidence-based to me. It's effectively a variation on 'food combining' which has been completely debunked.

I'm a qualified personal trainer with a specialism in obesity management, so I do know a bit about it.

Hm that’s really interesting as she is very evidence informed but I’m interested to hear if it’s not actually correct. These are the studies she refers to -

· Alpana P Shukla et al., "Food order has a significant impact on postprandial glucose and insulin levels." Diabetes care 38, no. 7 (2015): e98-e99, care.diabetesjournals.org/content/38/7/e98.

· Kimiko Nishino et al., "Consuming carbohydrates after meat or vegetables lowers postprandial excursions of glucose and insulin in nondiabetic subjects," Journal of nutritional science and vitaminology 64, no. 5 (2018): 316-320, www.researchgate.net/publication/328640463_Consuming_Carbohydrates_after_Meat_or_Vegetables_Lowers_Postprandial_Excursions_of_Glucose_and_Insulin_in_Nondiabetic_Subjects.

· Alpana P Shukla et al., "Food order has a significant impact on postprandial glucose and insulin levels," Diabetes care 38, no. 7 (2015): e98-e99, care.diabetesjournals.org/content/38/7/e98.

· Domenico Tricò et al., "Manipulating the sequence of food ingestion improves glycemic control in type 2 diabetic patients under free-living conditions," Nutrition & diabetes 6, no. 8 (2016): e226-e226, www.nature.com/articles/nutd201633/.

· Alpana P Shukla et al., "Effect of food order on ghrelin suppression," Diabetes Care 41, no. 5 (2018): e76-e77, care.diabetesjournals.org/content/41/5/e76.

EmmaH2022 · 02/01/2022 17:42

@SofiaMichElf

Definitely agree with those saying reduce carb intake.

Carbs added to most meals are almost a complete waste of time in that if you ate the same meal without the carbs, you'd be no more hungry a few hours later than with the carbs, so the carb calories are a waste.

Scrambled eggs on toast? Why not lose the toast and have some spinach (dead easy using frozen) and maybe a bit of cheese?

Calories about the same but you'll definitely be less hungry 3 hours later, despite feeling to not have eaten as much.

I tried this this week

Had a three egg omelette and salad for lunch instead of two poached eggs on toast

I was hungry within 2 hours. With the toast, I would not have been hungry for about four to five hours.

Backofthenet20 · 02/01/2022 17:41

When reading the comments it’s pretty surprising that very few people are talking about getting wholesome nutritious food. Sure eating less you might lose weight, but continue to eat processed food which is lacking in nutrients then you are likely to end up with ill health later in life with heart disease, cancer, type 2 diabetes and dementia. All of these conditions have a diet related component. Eat simple, cook yourself, eat the rainbow & monitor how many calories you eat to live a longer healthier life.

StuntNun · 02/01/2022 17:25

Nope. I followed a low carb diet (the Mumsnet Bootcamp) and one of the rules is to eat when you're hungry and to eat to satiety. I lost 30lb in five months.

Hospedia · 02/01/2022 17:25

Bet you wish you hadn't asked now, OP Grin

Really though, make small changes, eat what you want within your calorie allowance, and aim for as normal an eating plan as possible so that you're eating the foods you enjoy. Work around your current routine and lifestyle to do what works for you, what fits into the time you have, and what is most convenient.

Making radical changes, suddenly cutting out the foods you enjoy, considering them to be forbidden, trying to sccomodate the time to fry up eggs and veg first thing if this isn't part of your usual morning routine, and so on might work for other people and their lifestyle but if they're not currently part of yours then you're just going to get frazzled and it's not going to be sustainable long term.

Wannalivewithcommonpeople · 02/01/2022 17:22

@SallyWD Were you able to lose weight with 16/8? I’ve been doing it for a few months and no change, which is annoying as I find it easy to do.

me4real · 02/01/2022 17:22

Agree. There’s nothing wrong with a little hunger to be ready for our meal.

@Grilledaubergines Yep, I don't think it should be hours (plural) though. I can be looking at the clock for about an hour before a meal, but IDK if I'm really hungry.

I have my tea at 5pm BTW. That's just how I was brought up so it's natural to me, but I know most people eat later.

me4real · 02/01/2022 17:18

Eating sweet things is fine, but best after a meal or paired with protein/fat. I love the glucose goddess on insta - she shows how just changing the order we eat things can impact how our bodies respond to what we eat.

@SkeletonSkins That doesn't sound evidence-based to me. It's effectively a variation on 'food combining' which has been completely debunked.

I'm a qualified personal trainer with a specialism in obesity management, so I do know a bit about it.

Grilledaubergines · 02/01/2022 17:17

@SkeletonSkins

I think some hunger is normal right? I’m quite hungry now but I won’t eat again before my tea ar about 7pm. I think there’s this idea that hunger = bad and needs to be avoided at all costs.
Agree. There’s nothing wrong with a little hunger to be ready for our meal. Too hungry though, leads to excessive snacking. It takes a while to get a balance. I know my worst time of the day is getting home from work before I’ve started on dinner. I now always have a piece of fruit or a plain biscuit with a cup of tea about 5.00pm at work, and that helps me to get to dinner time around 6.30/7.00pm. Also, plenty of water to be drunk.
me4real · 02/01/2022 17:16

We're so conditioned with "snacks" these days that we've forgotten that actually the world won't end if we're hungry for an hour or two

@Sparklfairy I don't think we should have to feel hungry, it's unnecessary. The world won't end if we're hungry, but it's not a pleasant sensation and arguably, even on a diet, can be avoided to some extent.

Grilledaubergines · 02/01/2022 17:12

@Blossomtoes

That’s a diet? What on earth do you eat normally? Chips, toast, Jaffa Cakes all need to go.
That’s such a bad attitude to have re food. All those foods are acceptable on a diet. It’s how they’re cooked and the quantities which are an issue. A couple of Jaffa cakes with a well balanced daily menu is harmless. It’s deprivation of foods deemed to be “naughty” which leads to diet failure.
SkeletonSkins · 02/01/2022 17:09

Also for what it’s worth, I’d much rather be a bit hungry sometimes and eat carbs, than go low carb and never feel hungry. It’s just not sustainable for me.

Eating sweet things is fine, but best after a meal or paired with protein/fat. I love the glucose goddess on insta - she shows how just changing the order we eat things can impact how our bodies respond to what we eat.

If you want to cut carbs, fine, go for it, but don’t make out it’s the only way to lose weight.

SkeletonSkins · 02/01/2022 16:55

I think some hunger is normal right? I’m quite hungry now but I won’t eat again before my tea ar about 7pm. I think there’s this idea that hunger = bad and needs to be avoided at all costs.

DrSbaitso · 02/01/2022 16:54

@Lemons1571

I’ve also lost half of my body weight in the last 15 months. Size 20/22 to a size 8. I could only do it by strict meal replacement shakes, and cutting out 100% “naughty snacks” and treats.

I find it easier to have no sugary foods than “a little bit”, as a little bit leaves me craving more sugar and it deteriorates into 4 times the amount of sugar I should have.

I was hungry when I was being strict, but it’s surprising how quickly you get used to it and don’t feel so hungry. You’ve got to really want it though. You’ve got to want it more than you want the sugary snacks.

Is this sustainable for the rest of your life?
Kanaloa · 02/01/2022 16:53

@CaffeineAndCrochet

Don’t know if this is helpful but rather than ‘prepping yourself for hunger and discomfort’ I would try and reframe your attitude to hunger. If you’re going into it thinking oh this will be rubbish I’ll be so hungry and miserable I think you’re putting a negative attitude to if from the get go.

I try to reframe it like waiting for the new episode of a favourite programme eg ‘oh x is out on Thursday I’ll enjoy that’ so I would think ‘ooh I’m hungry I’ll have x for tea I’ll really enjoy it.’

Lemons1571 · 02/01/2022 16:37

I’ve also lost half of my body weight in the last 15 months. Size 20/22 to a size 8. I could only do it by strict meal replacement shakes, and cutting out 100% “naughty snacks” and treats.

I find it easier to have no sugary foods than “a little bit”, as a little bit leaves me craving more sugar and it deteriorates into 4 times the amount of sugar I should have.

I was hungry when I was being strict, but it’s surprising how quickly you get used to it and don’t feel so hungry. You’ve got to really want it though. You’ve got to want it more than you want the sugary snacks.

IamnotwhouthinkIam · 02/01/2022 16:22

Yes and No, OP. As someone who has lost about half their body weight through changing their eating habits, I can say there are things you can do to help with the hunger - having snacks like vegetables/lower sugar fruit or high protein ones like natural yogurt or lean meat.

BUT if you are anything like me it will often be carbs you are craving for snacks instead and it can be hard to force yourself to have the healthier alternatives. So yes, in which case you may have to be slightly hungry between your (hopefully balanced! veg/carb/protein) meals until your stomach "shrinks" - ie. your body gets used to slightly less calories.

You are doing the right thing btw - in my experience if you have significant weight to lose/ or want to keep it off permanently, the only way is to do it slowly while still allowing yourself "treats" so that you don't risk bingeing and can keep the "diet" up long term.

A portion of oven chips and a couple of jaffa cakes afterwards are fine as long as you are only having them once a day as part of a balanced meal of veg and lean protein (so your blood sugar doesn't get too raised from them). Equally there is nothing wrong with wholemeal toast (or 50/50 if you are trying to make the change from white bread) if you are having it with protein food like scrambled egg and beans.

Good luck!

Antsgomarching · 02/01/2022 16:17

Try to aim for a good amount of protein in each meal, say aim for 25-30g per meal, it fills you up. I’ve starting to try to do this again, struggled to lose weight after DD little time to plan or cook tbh. But it helps you feel not so hungry. No off to try to take my own advice