Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you need to go hungry on a diet?

340 replies

username30473 · 02/01/2022 12:47

I didn't want to use the word diet it was just for the title. The last couple of years my diet has been appalling to say the least. I have always been a size 10 but now a size 12 touching 14. From the way I have eaten I actually think I could be a lot larger.
Anyway I am now trying to change my diet back to what it used to be and lose weight.

I actually started on Boxing Day so I am a week in and I am hungry all the time. I am not massively restricting myself either. Yesterday I have had yogurt/fruit for breakfast, beans and scrambled eggs on toast for lunch, fruit for afternoon snack and steak and chips for dinner with a couple of Jaffa cakes for dessert. I just think I am so use to eating so much now I just have to get use to be hungry until my body gets use to less food again.

Do others find this to be the case?

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 03/01/2022 10:17

Intermittent fasting works for me. I don’t eat until lunch. Early small lunch. Minimise snacks dinner on a smaller plate. No food after 8pm. Relax at weekends.

Lost 2 stone in 2019 and kept off by living as described. Size 14 to size 10 bmi 27 to bmi 22.

Curiousmouse · 03/01/2022 10:13

I have a friend who is a dietitian, and she is relatively young and very up to date, and she does not agree with low carving. By all means have one slice of toast instead of two, but very low carbing is false science. The liver does not like to metabolise fat and protein to make up for carbs.

I think the best way to lose weight and keep it off is to create a healthy diet that you can be enthusiastic about, which fits your lifestyle, and includes moderate occasional treats if you want them, and lots of fruit and vegetables.

Thepineapplemystery · 03/01/2022 10:09

@Rubyupbeat

I know if you make smoothies it intensifies the sugar? Is that right? So not good for dieting. But can I do the same to veg, ie...a soup or stew and it stay low cal as no sugar etc...so can eat largish portions?
You can't create sugar. Making fruit in to smoothies does make it easier to breakdown (as blending starts the process) it also starts to break down the fibre. Both of these things mean that you get hungry quicker. The additional issue with fruit smoothies is that is much more fruit than you'd eat in a sitting - handful of berries, banana, apple juice and slice of pineapple - would you eat that as a meal unblended? Also smoothies are mainly carbs, a little fibre and a few vitamins. Lack of protein and fat are an issue.

Smoothies can be great IF you add protein and reduce the sugar. For example handful of frozen berries, two large dollops of Greek yogurt (weighed if calorie counting), 15g nut butter, a handful of spinach, almond milk, 15g oats. It'll be much more filling than a fruit smoothie and I frequently have that for lunch and I'm full until dinner.

marmitegirl01 · 03/01/2022 10:02

Really interesting and helpful thread. Thank you

Spaceman1 · 03/01/2022 09:40

According to research 95% of us will put any weight we lose back on within five years. Only about 5% of people are able to lose weight permanently. However, it's still better for us to eat healthy food.

MushMonster · 03/01/2022 09:37

You are not hungry, it is your mind playing games with you.
I know it sound weird, but you have esten regularly, you have eaten well, so your body is not lacking of nutrients and you are not hungry. Not the hungry feeling of a person who has not eaten for 6 hours after hard labour.
It is a craving really, that is all. Try to drink instead, a couple of glasses of water. Or a hot drink, like a black tea. And wait for a few minutes. The feeling should disappear.
Or it will after a few days sticking to your food timetable.
I bet you you used to snack on sweet or calorie things quite regularly? And that craving is the "hungry feeling". After a few days, you will miss the taste of some of your favourite snacks, but the craving will go. Do not give up OP.

MargosKaftan · 03/01/2022 09:27

Please ignore the "if you aren't low carbing you aren't dieting and even if you lose weight, you'll have done it the morally wrong way" posters - they pop up on every diet thread, low carbing doesn't work for everyone, but they really can't deal with the idea other people lose weight differently.

Anyway, given your food list for the day was rather a lot, I assume you are used to over eating, so eating normally will leave you hungry for a while as your body readjusts to new normal gaps between meals. I found getting out helped, if I'm in the house, I feel the need to snack, regardless of how full my last meal left me. Hard to do when the weather is shit and we are all avoiding crowded indoor spaces though!

Aubree17 · 03/01/2022 09:05

Get yourself a fancy water bottle and set a daily water target.

I promise it will help.

Ikeabag · 03/01/2022 09:04

Oh and I try and get some protein because I weight train but I rarely hit it (usually my fats go over, not carbs, which I'm not surprised about) but it's not mattered in terms of weight loss. I'm not fastidious, I try and get a bit of fruit/veg and protein and that's it

Ikeabag · 03/01/2022 09:02

www.strongerbyscience.com/macrofactor/

This has been working for me. I depise dieting and am the kind of person who struggles with an all or nothing approach and ends up failing. It's gradual. It's fairly easy to log stuff. It's a well designed app. Regularly updated. Was recommended to me and I subscribed after the trial because I found it v easy to work with. Christmas I have eaten whatever but made sure I logged it, essentially I wasn't watching what I ate, but I'm back to following what it suggests now. No beating myself up. I find it takes the stress out of it.

Plumedenom · 03/01/2022 08:49

Also, you eat what works for you and enjoy it. You don't need to eat all this protein if you don't enjoy it. The main thing is to just eat less. Your diet sounds fine to me as long as it's less than it was before and you'll lose weight! People love to complicate it but it's that simple.

Plumedenom · 03/01/2022 08:47

A good half hour before a meal, we should start to feel hungry, and after a meal you should feel full but not stuffed. During the day, if you start to feel hungry you should eat a little snack like a few bits or an apple to get you to the next meal. But yes, the feeling of hunger should not be feared. It is normal human feeling and it won't hurt you. I also need to get back on the wagon this week.

Crayfishforyou · 03/01/2022 08:35

It takes me a week of dieting for the ‘I’m staaaaarving’ pangs to stop.
My body does adjust though and gets used to the new routine fairly quickly. I’m now 6lbs down and another stone to go.

Rubyupbeat · 03/01/2022 07:14

I know if you make smoothies it intensifies the sugar? Is that right? So not good for dieting.
But can I do the same to veg, ie...a soup or stew and it stay low cal as no sugar etc...so can eat largish portions?

PickAChew · 02/01/2022 23:51

Feeling hungry at first is normal but isn't going to be helped by eating jaffa cakes and other sugary stuff.

stevalnamechanger · 02/01/2022 23:34

@Blossomtoes

That’s a diet? What on earth do you eat normally? Chips, toast, Jaffa Cakes all need to go.
Not at all , you can lose weight in a calorie deficit of any kind
stevalnamechanger · 02/01/2022 23:34

More protein and good fats for breakfast and snacks will keep hunger at bay

Dixiechickonhols · 02/01/2022 23:29

Protein and lots of veg really works for me. So skyr & berries.scrambled eggs and mushrooms, salmon & stirfry. I’m a big fan of kvarg flavoured quark too.

SummersInHvar · 02/01/2022 23:14

Yes I’m always starving on a diet but exercise helps to drop it off quickly too

Thepineapplemystery · 02/01/2022 22:44

And hunger can definitely be mental/ psychological and no mount of food will change that!

Thepineapplemystery · 02/01/2022 22:43

I think there's different types of hunger.

Hunger from not being satisfied, and hunger from not being 'full'. I've found at times when I'm eating really large portions, I find a reduction in portion size leaves me feeling hungry but after a week or so I got used to the portions, which were perfectly adequate.

When I was hungry because I felt deprived or unsatisfied, I found that changed by changing what I was eating, not how much.

Ladywinesalot · 02/01/2022 21:43

You need to log your food on my fitness pal and eat lots of protein. Like 140g per day and less carbs

You’ll feel full.

Gensola · 02/01/2022 21:15

The only diet that’s ever worked for me was fast800 and I definitely felt hungry, but seeing the results every day kept me on it for 4 weeks, I lost almost a stone.
I’m about to try and lose the remaining stone but on a much more sensible diet which has been set up for me by a PT combined with exercise. Hoping not to feel too starving as this time of year is depressing enough as it is.

MadCattery · 02/01/2022 21:02

@deadlanguage

I haven’t RTFT so don’t know if it’s been mentioned but look up How Not to Diet by Dr Michael Greger. He’s got a couple of books and cookbooks and also a website (nutritionfacts.org) but it basically boils down to calorie density - eat lots of foods (ie fruit & veg) which low in calorie density. They are filling as high in fibre and water, low in calories so you basically can eat as much as you need to feel full, and obviously good sources of vitamins & minerals as well so it’s a win-win. He also has some specific recommendations based on various studies as well about things like specific foods which can help you lose weight (iirc cinnamon was one for example) and other lifestyle changes like timing your eating, weighing yourself daily etc.
The Volumetrics Diet was based on calorie density with amazing images, still have loads of them on Pinterest. Lots of fruit, veg and soups. Also, the GI (Glycemic Index) lists of foods helps a lot of people with insulin resistance. And the GI list is also good for low carbers. There is so much info out there, and a different diet for every day of the week. Only you know what works best for you.
Bagamoyo1 · 02/01/2022 20:49

@SilverHairedCat

No, absolutely not.

Going hungry is pointless, it's not sustainable and is just starving yourself.

Fill up on better foods - raise the protein levels, add lots more veg to that diet, keep bread to one meal a day and you'll not be hungry at all.

That’s true for maintenance, but if you’re trying to lose weight then you need to be in deficit, and that will almost certainly lead to a feeling of hunger, because you are eating less than you used to. It’s basic maths.
Swipe left for the next trending thread