Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you need to go hungry on a diet?

340 replies

username30473 · 02/01/2022 12:47

I didn't want to use the word diet it was just for the title. The last couple of years my diet has been appalling to say the least. I have always been a size 10 but now a size 12 touching 14. From the way I have eaten I actually think I could be a lot larger.
Anyway I am now trying to change my diet back to what it used to be and lose weight.

I actually started on Boxing Day so I am a week in and I am hungry all the time. I am not massively restricting myself either. Yesterday I have had yogurt/fruit for breakfast, beans and scrambled eggs on toast for lunch, fruit for afternoon snack and steak and chips for dinner with a couple of Jaffa cakes for dessert. I just think I am so use to eating so much now I just have to get use to be hungry until my body gets use to less food again.

Do others find this to be the case?

OP posts:
TheFoundation · 04/01/2022 07:44

@EightWheelGirl

www.healthline.com/nutrition/foods-loaded-with-potassium#How-to-Peel-Potatoes

There's plenty of ways.

EightWheelGirl · 04/01/2022 07:38

I'd probs struggle to get enough potassium without potatoes. Last statistic I read was something like only 3% of the population get the RDA of potassium. Or maybe it was 5%.

TheFoundation · 04/01/2022 07:27

Really you need to cut out bread & potatoes completely

No, you really don't. Getting the cravings for these things (carbs/sugars) under control is the way forward, but cutting them out altogether isn't the only way, and it's probably the hardest. You could cut them out for a few days, then reintroduce. Your cravings will be altered in that short time. You could fast 24 hours once every few weeks. You could fast daily (16/8) or weekly (5:2 or 5:1)

All of these methods will help your body to understand what fat is for (energy when there's no food), and to access it when it needs to.

Cutting stuff out completely is unnecessary, difficult, and ultimately, unsustainable for most people.

TheFoundation · 04/01/2022 07:21

All the protein in the world won’t replace grazing on crisps and biscuits all day

What does this mean, @Scottishnewbie2022?

If you eat your daily calorie requirement in protein (not suggesting anybody should, but for the sake of the argument) then you would neither need nor want the crisps and biscuits.

Can you explain what you meant?

Tzimi · 04/01/2022 07:19

@WishIwasElsa

Why in earth does toast have to go?
Bread is high in starchy carbohydrates. Really you need to cut out bread & potatoes completely.
Tzimi · 04/01/2022 07:15

@ceepeeree

You have a lot of carbs in your diet. You might feel more full if you increase the ratio of fat and protein and drop the refined carbs especially- they really don't keep you full.
Not only that, but carbs raise your insulin levels, but then they drop causing you to crave more sugar.
Tzimi · 04/01/2022 07:13

Give the low carbohydrate diet a try. Basically, cut out all sugar, and restrict your carb intake to 20g a day. This will also get rid of your hunger pangs, as you won't have insulin spikes due to eating sugar. You just have to get used to a high protein, high fat, low carbohydrate diet. And take plenty of exercise every day.

EightWheelGirl · 04/01/2022 07:03

@QueBarbaridad

To me the important difference is between the really nasty sugar crash hunger after having bran flakes for breakfast and normal mealtime hunger. It’s possible to cut out the former but not the latter.
Indeed. The carb crash can be avoided but not hunger full stop.

If your 'normal' daily intake is 4000 cals then I think you're going to be hungry on 1200 no matter the ratio of protein, lean veg, etc.

QueBarbaridad · 04/01/2022 06:59

To me the important difference is between the really nasty sugar crash hunger after having bran flakes for breakfast and normal mealtime hunger. It’s possible to cut out the former but not the latter.

beingsunny · 04/01/2022 05:55

I started seeing a nutritionist in October, after gaining 30kg in 3 years. I've lost 13 so far, it's basically come down to portion size and eating lots of steamed veg with my meal instead of chips/rice/pasta.

I'm rarely hungry and sometimes only eat 1/2 meals a day with no snacks.

I do drink 2/3 litres of water a day and if I am getting hungry I will have a tea with half a sugar which keeps me going till my next meal.

Nothing is off the table, but all in moderation, so one or two chocolates from the tin rather than two handfuls like I used to.

EightWheelGirl · 04/01/2022 05:32

[quote SilverHairedCat]@EightWheelGirl I don't know buy it. We don't have trough a packet of biscuits after dinner because we're hungry, we do it because we fancy it. Not eating them wouldnt leave us with hunger pangs.

I'm very overweight, but even I can tell the difference between hunger pangs and wanting to eat unnecessarily. I fail, however, because I have no willpower.

I'm back on Slimming World (I know MN hates it, but I don't eat the yoghurts, try to cheat on portions by eating entire 5kg bags of potatoes made into chips etc) and with three decent meals a day, I can honestly say that I NEVER feel hungry. Never.

Proper portions, lots of veg, lots of lean protein, plenty of fruit, lots of water and so on - it is a fact that these things fill you up.[/quote]
I think we're talking about two different things. IME it's possible to adapt to a new lower intake and not feel hungry as your maintenance calories start to decrease. At this point eating lots of protein and veg etc can leave you pretty full.

However, if somebody is used to eating twice the calories they need, they'll usually struggle to just stop and eat healthily without a period where they feel hungry most of the time.

Joystir59 · 04/01/2022 04:14

@Gwenhwyfar
Joystir59
I also echo what others have said about carbs- I've naturally found that I really don't want them when I'm slim, I want protein and vitamin rich food, I am lucky in that I genuinely love fruit and veg and make sure I have lots of them in the house.

But fruit and veg are carbs aren't they?
By carbs I mean processed carbs such as bread rice pasta.
I don't eat potatoes much either.
Apples and oranges are naturally sweet low calorie treats and I don't limit how much fruit I munch apart from bananas which are more substantial. I also munch on carrots as a snack. A handful (like five or six) nuts are a snack. A teaspoon of olive oil on a salad.

Mamanyt · 04/01/2022 00:44

There are a couple of things at play here, and one of them is that most people have stretched their stomachs out. The human stomach evolved for a "grazing" type eating habit. Small amounts, several times a day. Your unstretched stomach is about the size of the space between your two hands held together, slightly cupped. That's a TINY amount of food. As I said, with our modern eating patterns, we have streatched them out, and those of us who tend to overeat REALLY have stretched them out! The good news is, when you begin to restrict your intake, or to go to more, much smaller meals, your stomach will rebound to a great extent.

The second thing is that most of us no longer recognize the difference between "not hungry" and "full." One reason for this is that it takes a full 20 minutes for the "enough" signal to reach the brain. That means that if we eat quickly, we are overfilled before our brains know that we have had enough. Slow down your eating, and you will feel fuller on less food.

Mirimu · 04/01/2022 00:32

[quote Maskedsingerispants]@Mirimu Can you give an example of daily diet please or more info about it?
Also, by no oils do you mean no olive oil?[/quote]
I responded but first time posting on mums net so may have responded incorrectly sorry. Reply is somewhere!

Cavementality · 04/01/2022 00:32

Take part in veganuary. There is lots of help and support when you sign up and you won't go hungry!

Mirimu · 04/01/2022 00:18

Yep. On whole food plant based oil is avoided excluded. But I eat moderate amounts of nuts and seeds, including butters made from them (although if weight loss is goal rather than health you would go easy on them) and lots of avocados.
I might eat a big porridge for brekkie with dates banana hemp seeds and Brazil nuts. I might have a veg saute (water broth saute) with tofu with lots of chilli and spices on brown rice/brown rice noodles for lunch and maybe baked veg potato with salad and home made cashew cream ( cashew cream in moderate amounts) and avocado and salad etc. There are lots of whole food plant based fb groups and recipe books for ideas

Jewel52 · 03/01/2022 23:50

Think you may be consuming too many calories to lose weight because you’re trying to avoid going on an actual diet. I’ve done this in the past and then become frustrated that i’m Hungry with no benefit and just given up. Other posters have recommended diets that’ve worked for them so might be worth doing some research, choosing one and setting a date to start. Still hanging on to my own lockdown lard so know it’s never easy Sad

threatmatrix · 03/01/2022 23:47

When you put on weight you have stretched your stomach. It now needs to shrink back to what it was do after a while you won’t feel that hunger. That’s why things like weight watchers don’t work forever as you can eat big platefuls still do not shrinking your stomach. I’m struggling with this at the moment but to get back into a ten ( I’m exactly the same as you) will be worth it.

Bunnyfuller · 03/01/2022 23:29

For those saying the OPs daily diary was a lot of food - can you provide an example of what you would consider a normal amount?

I see the trigger at the word ‘chips’ but it all depends on amount and how they’re cooked surely?

I do notice that slim people seem to eat bugger all and exercise loads (at least if they’re older than 25!). My mum has always never strayed over a size 14 (is tall) but when I look at her portion sizes. I do agree we’ve got used to bigger portions (no, thanks, USA) and our bodies expect to be completely stuffed after a meal. As I said upthread, I’m trying to listen more closely as respond as soon as ‘full’ hits, rather than continuing with ‘oh but it’s delicious!’
I’m embarrassed to say I apparently qualify for 12w free slimming world in my county, so I’m going to take advantage

Emberino · 03/01/2022 23:08

Being on a “diet” always makes me eat more and feel hungrier. Perhaps changing what you eat and the way you eat in a way that is more interesting would help. Instead of streak and chips lose the chips and have some interesting veg or salad instead. Protein seems to keep me going and stop me feeling hungry … eggs are great at keeping hunger pangs away, cut out processed carbs. Stir fry’s with no rice but huge mound of veg with the protein are filling as well. Trick for me seems to be giving the stomach something to work on and fill it without taking in excess calories and cabs, and crucially not being on a “diet”.

Mynameisnew · 03/01/2022 22:25

@DoctorSnortles

I lost three stone last year. I was sometimes bloody ravenous. I drank a lot of cups of tea, when ready to chew my own leg off, which seemed to help.
@DoctorSnortles your comment resonated with me and made me smile, thank you :-)
Jollypots · 03/01/2022 22:20

This seems to be a lot of food. Did you have vegetables with your steak and chips?

AnGofsMum · 03/01/2022 22:02

I follow the 16/8 plan and also Slimming World when I want to lose weight. Not everybody likes SW but it works for me and the premise is that you are never hungry. Most foods are ‘free’ so you can eat as much as you like - these include rice, pasta, potatoes. Other foods are eaten in moderation.

Maskedsingerispants · 03/01/2022 21:57

@Mirimu Can you give an example of daily diet please or more info about it?
Also, by no oils do you mean no olive oil?

Teenagehorrorbag · 03/01/2022 21:48

@me4real

You can still eat the same volume of food- most people end up doing so.

So the trick is to eat mainly low energy density/high volume foods containing lots of water (some of which have some protein and fibre too.) This makes a plan and habits you can follow for life. Which is what people need or they'll just gain it all back.

It always amazes me how much food some people do eat. Some of the family pubs we eat in serve the most enormous amounts of food,

@Teenagehorrorbag I think they think people will think it's good value if they get a lot for their money. And not feeling like you've had enough food after a meal can be pretty lame.

I agree with all these points. I'm not suggesting that we should all eat teeny portions! Just that the big plate meal we ate was HUGE - and DH can eat for England. So it must be far too much food for a smaller or less active person. It's the same in fish and chip shops - the portions have grown so massive over the years, it makes me wonder if people's expectations have also crept up to an unhealthy extent?

But of course - if it's a big amount of healthy veg, for example - then great! But chips and fried food - maybe not so much.....

Swipe left for the next trending thread