Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think you need to go hungry on a diet?

340 replies

username30473 · 02/01/2022 12:47

I didn't want to use the word diet it was just for the title. The last couple of years my diet has been appalling to say the least. I have always been a size 10 but now a size 12 touching 14. From the way I have eaten I actually think I could be a lot larger.
Anyway I am now trying to change my diet back to what it used to be and lose weight.

I actually started on Boxing Day so I am a week in and I am hungry all the time. I am not massively restricting myself either. Yesterday I have had yogurt/fruit for breakfast, beans and scrambled eggs on toast for lunch, fruit for afternoon snack and steak and chips for dinner with a couple of Jaffa cakes for dessert. I just think I am so use to eating so much now I just have to get use to be hungry until my body gets use to less food again.

Do others find this to be the case?

OP posts:
Lavender24 · 02/01/2022 13:34

@Blossomtoes

That’s a diet? What on earth do you eat normally? Chips, toast, Jaffa Cakes all need to go.
That's what I was thinking.

I stay at the low end of normal weight and if hungry in the evening I snack on things like seeds, nuts, dried prunes, figs.

I don't agree that you need to be hungry or that it's all about calorie deficit. Not all calories are equal.

WishIwasElsa · 02/01/2022 13:32

Why in earth does toast have to go?

BeLessMe · 02/01/2022 13:30

My Fitness Pal.

It will help you make better choices with your food so that you feel fuller for longer and don’t feel like you are starving yourself.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 02/01/2022 13:29

You don’t need to starve yourself but generally, as a society, we’re used to being full all the time. Snacking being the worst culprit.

Being a bit hungry is perfectly normal, then eating enough food at mealtimes to stop that feeling (not keeping eating until you’re full though, as it takes time for the brain to register satiety). Portion size is key, too.

Scottishnewbie2022 · 02/01/2022 13:29

I know personally I don’t often feel hungry ever … I just feel bored and want to eat rather than needing to eat. Once your body is used to that it is hard to stop that way of life.

DrSbaitso · 02/01/2022 13:28

No, you don't have to go hungry.

You do have to learn to live with a little dissatisfaction, and not always having what you want, or as much as you want. But it gets easier the longer you do it.

bigdecisionstomake · 02/01/2022 13:28

I have realised two things recently.

Firstly, eating sugar and refined carbs makes you feel hungry within a couple of hours. For example, if I have a protein/fat heavy breakfast like eggs scrabbled in butter I get through to lunch without feeling hungry. If I have the same eggs scrambled in butter, but then have some chocolate mid morning I'm ravenous by lunchtime.

Secondly, it is perfectly normal, as PP pointed out, to be starting to feel hungry in the hour or so before your next meal. It is not normal to never feel hungry at all.

These two realisations have really helped me get my diet back on track. I've tried really hard to cut back on as much sugar/refined carbs as I can and also learned to appreciate the slight feeling of hunger knowing my next meal is imminent.

merryhouse · 02/01/2022 13:28
  • Should always feel a bit hungry by the time you eat
  • Being hungry and feeling hungry aren't necessarily the same thing
  • Fizzy water (I add PLJ) helps

Also I'd have had carrots and peas with the steak and chips, but that's moving on from calorie-reducing to more general healthy eating - perhaps once you've reached your target weight you could simply add vegetables to the level you've got used to.

PupInAPram · 02/01/2022 13:26

Having been overweight most of my life, I have discovered that running a slight calorie deficit is what has worked for me. Maintenance is aiming for calorie balance over a week now. I always used to feel starving on unsuccessful diets but now at a healthy bmi for 2+ years I don't. Taking action if I drift up more than 3 pounds is also important to me. I could not lose 5 stone again!

P0gM0Th0in · 02/01/2022 13:25

I found doing keto for a while shrunk my stomach (as in the organ). I’m not as strict any more but I definitely can’t pack away as much food as I used to; there’s just no room!

Blossomtoes · 02/01/2022 13:24

Everything in moderation. This "advice" is recipe for failure.

It’s a recipe for losing weight. I successfully lost 20 kg on low carb and have kept it off for more than ten years. And I was never hungry.

DarkCorner · 02/01/2022 13:24

I did lowish carbing recently (sort of lapsed over christmas!) and found my body needed around a week to reset itself and get used to not eating loads of carbs. After that I was barely ever hungry. I'd see if your body gets used to the new reality!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 02/01/2022 13:23

This is why I can’t face dieting tbh. I really hate the feeling of hunger.

When I was young I was very slim but didn’t need much food to jot feel hungry. I’m a 14 now which I don’t like but I also hate hunger Blush

user1471481356 · 02/01/2022 13:22

Yep, this is how it works. You’re hungry for a week or so and then your body starts to get used to it with just the odd hungry day now and then. Try to increase your protein. So swap out your chips for loads of veg and use those calories for protein spread more through the day.

BlwyddynNewydd2022 · 02/01/2022 13:22

Water is your friend here. Most feelings of "hunger" are actually feelings of dehydration it's just the brain can only give one signal.

If you feel hungry drink a pint of water and see if the feeling goes away after ten minutes, If it doesn't you are actually hungry but good news you'll eat less because you now have a pint of water sloshing about inside you 🤣

You should be feeling hungry but not attaching to the point you'll binge. We should all feel hunger at some points in the day.

Hospedia · 02/01/2022 13:22

Also don't go lower than around 1200 a day as you need this just to keep your body running, as a PP has said - you don't need much of a deficit to lose.

JohnSmithDrive · 02/01/2022 13:21

I think you need to distract yourself from what you think is hunger, but is actually boredom and acknowledge the fact that you are supposed to be hungry in the run up to a meal.

Dieting actually makes this harder because you're thinking about food all the time.

MrsG010814 · 02/01/2022 13:21

If you haven't already I would run your info through a TDEE calculator to work out roughly how many calories you need each day and how much to reduce to put you in a deficit. Increasing protein in your meals and snacks also helps keep you feeling fuller for longer. You don't have to be hungry all of the time, I find that I can maximise my calories by eating the right combo of foods. Make sure your drinking plenty water too.

Hospedia · 02/01/2022 13:20

400-500 calories a day

That should say 400-500 deficit rather than 400-500 calories. Don't have 400-500 calories a day, it won't end well.

Lacedwithgrace · 02/01/2022 13:20

You don't have to eat a lot of calories to stop feeling hungry. I'd rather eat a bowl of lettuce or low cal veg to keep the hunger away than nothing. If you're hungry to the point of light-headedness, shakes, etc then you're not getting enough calories

DoctorSnortles · 02/01/2022 13:19

I lost three stone last year. I was sometimes bloody ravenous. I drank a lot of cups of tea, when ready to chew my own leg off, which seemed to help.

Hospedia · 02/01/2022 13:18

That’s a diet? What on earth do you eat normally? Chips, toast, Jaffa Cakes all need to go.

No they don't! All you need to lose weight is a calorie deficit and 400-500 calories a day definitely is enough for a 1-2lb loss a week (obviously depends on your own personal metabolism but you learn as you go where your 'right' level is). You could eat 1600 calories worth of McDonald's every day and so long as it didn't put you over your calorie allowance you would lose weight. As my GP once put it when I was on 1000 calories a day but only eating junk - "1000 calories of crap is still only 1000 calories".

Cutting out all the foods you enjoy or foods you consider nice and swapping for things you don't think are nice is a recipe for disaster, no one is going to stick to that for long. It is much more sensible to still include the foods you like and just eat smaller portions of them.

Are you drinking enough, OP? I sometimes feel hungry and I'm actually just thirsty so I make a deal with myself that I'll have a glass of water and wait twenty minutes, if I'm still hungry after then I eat because being hungry is miserable.

BendingSpoons · 02/01/2022 13:16

Yes it will take your body a while to adjust. I used to snack lots in the evening. I now mostly don't eat from 6.30pm until breakfast and don't really notice it. I've also been eating terribly the last few years and need to get it under control. Munching on raw veg helps me feel I am eating something and limits my reaching for the biscuits again!

SallyWD · 02/01/2022 13:12

I do 16/8 and am very rarely hungry - only a little hungry just before I break my fast and a black coffee kills the hunger. Apart from that, I'm always satisfied. This is why I've stuck at 16/8 for 6 years. The weight falls off without hunger. 16/8 great is also great for maintaining.

Scottishnewbie2022 · 02/01/2022 13:11

I agree! If you’re used to snacking all day (I am) then you WILL need to be hungry to lose weight but you’ll probably eventually get used to it as you were eating too much in the first place.

All the protein in the world won’t replace grazing on crisps and biscuits all day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread