Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Covid. Permanent suppression or truly learning to live with it?

238 replies

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 11:55

Interested to see where people are at, as we go into our third year of the suppression approach.

Its taken a while, but most have accepted that coronavirus is here to stay, and that restrictions serve only to suppress (they cant/wont eradicate). We hear the theory (and the phrase) 'learning to live' with it, but in practice we're nowhere near to learning to live with it. Indeed, we're still behaving as though we can eradicate it via repeated 'short term' suppression. Current thinking is as it was in March 2020 ie that if we suppress it for 'just a bit longer' it'll go away. It wont. Clearly we cant continue swinging between 'living with it' and 'suppressing it' - the uncertainty of a continued stop/start for business, education (planning life in general!) etc isnt feasible as a long term strategy; we need to decide one way or another.

So... are you in favour of accepting that our current way of living must become permanent and (obviously this list is not exhaustive) masks, distancing, limits on mixing, one way systems etc are how we must live now. Funding to support business/furlough is made permanent and we all pay extra to support same (because I suppose the alternative is hospitality businesses just close? Become part of the bygone era). Remote learning in schools is a fixture (and that will be based, not on illness, but on isolation rules) every time there is a peak (and funding will need to be, I dont know, redirected from schools to parents in order to allow this). WFH is made permanent and, again, funding redirected to allow same.
Or... are you in favour of truly 'learning to live' with it, relying on vaccine to do the heavy lifting (thus not counting cases and accepting, as with flu, hospitalisations and deaths), scrapping track and trace, scrapping isolation (thus allowing asymptomatic people - including teachers and NHS staff to live/go to work normally) and essentially returning to life as it was in 2019.

YABU - in favour of permanent suppression.
YANBU - in favour of truly learning to live with it.

OP posts:
MatildaTheCat · 02/01/2022 13:38

@GaolBhoAlba

Interested to see where people are at, as we go into our third year of the suppression approach.

Its taken a while, but most have accepted that coronavirus is here to stay, and that restrictions serve only to suppress (they cant/wont eradicate). We hear the theory (and the phrase) 'learning to live' with it, but in practice we're nowhere near to learning to live with it. Indeed, we're still behaving as though we can eradicate it via repeated 'short term' suppression. Current thinking is as it was in March 2020 ie that if we suppress it for 'just a bit longer' it'll go away. It wont. Clearly we cant continue swinging between 'living with it' and 'suppressing it' - the uncertainty of a continued stop/start for business, education (planning life in general!) etc isnt feasible as a long term strategy; we need to decide one way or another.

So... are you in favour of accepting that our current way of living must become permanent and (obviously this list is not exhaustive) masks, distancing, limits on mixing, one way systems etc are how we must live now. Funding to support business/furlough is made permanent and we all pay extra to support same (because I suppose the alternative is hospitality businesses just close? Become part of the bygone era). Remote learning in schools is a fixture (and that will be based, not on illness, but on isolation rules) every time there is a peak (and funding will need to be, I dont know, redirected from schools to parents in order to allow this). WFH is made permanent and, again, funding redirected to allow same.
Or... are you in favour of truly 'learning to live' with it, relying on vaccine to do the heavy lifting (thus not counting cases and accepting, as with flu, hospitalisations and deaths), scrapping track and trace, scrapping isolation (thus allowing asymptomatic people - including teachers and NHS staff to live/go to work normally) and essentially returning to life as it was in 2019.

YABU - in favour of permanent suppression.
YANBU - in favour of truly learning to live with it.

It’s not until your last sentence that ‘NHS’ gets a mention and then only in the context of staff’s way of life. Until we can get the medical system on a safe and stable footing there is no alternative but to accept that we must have a management plan.
GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 13:35

@LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood

OP your question is not properly put as it rules out the option, well articulated by your first respondent, for a blended approach. It is plain you do not agree with that approach (and your reasons are perfectly valid and possibly even cogent). But in raising the legitimate questions you do, you have ruled out that others, for decent reasons, may espouse a blended approach.

It is perfectly value for you to reject a blended approach. But it is not really making your discussion susceptible to intelligent debate for you to decide that such a plan is off the table even for discussion.

The trouble with AIBU, for important subjects of public policy, is the binary nature of the choices. It is much more nuanced than one option is unreasonable and the other not.

A blended approach sounds very appealing. I think the majority of us would go for that IF it was possible. How does the blended approach work in practice? Ive not seen any proposition to a 'blended' approach that doesnt bring the same issues associated with the permanent suppression approach?
OP posts:
RandomLondoner · 02/01/2022 13:35

[quote Julieandthejets]@Whichjab my previous post was in reply to your claim about covid killing more brits than WW2 eye 🙄[/quote]
She didn't say what you claim she said. She was talking about civilian deaths. Your statistics prove her correct.

Emilyontmoor · 02/01/2022 13:35

Not even Starmer

GrendelsGrandma · 02/01/2022 13:34

There are plenty of things they could be doing that would be beneficial for a post covid world while also reducing numbers. Air filtration in schools, better active transport infrastructure to encourage walking and cycling, an effective anti obesity campaign that targets the real causes like poverty, lack of cooking skills, supermarket promotions.

They're finding better ways to treat covid all the time, I'd far rather live a slightly restricted life and get it in a few years when the hospitals are not stuffed and they know more about things like preventing long covid.

Emilyontmoor · 02/01/2022 13:34

As to just funding the NHS to deal with it, the fact is that our local hospital is in a state of emergency for two reasons. Firstly the level of Covid admissions, yes they are less ill or have been admitted for other reasons and turn out to have Covid but they are still taking up beds that have to be isolated from the rest, cared for by staff in PPE and infecting staff who are then absent. You can’t compare this to normal winter pressure because flu is not as transmissible. The second problem is that social care is in crisis, not just in terms of staff shortages due to sickness but also long term issues of funding exacerbated by Brexit. NHS Wards are jammed by elderly dementia patients with issues that would be better cared for with the specialist care available in fully staffed and funded care homes. I believe that should be via taxation including of the wealthy elderly (which will be me). The nettle no government has been prepared to grasp.

LakieLady · 02/01/2022 13:31

I think a mixture of both will be needed, tbh. We can live with it until it gets to the point that hospitals are at risk of becoming overwhelmed and essential services start to buckle because of the number of people off sick and then take measures to mitigate transmission.

That requires careful management though, because of the time lag between infection and symptoms/hospitalisation. Because of the mutable nature of viruses, we can't rely on vaccination being effective on new variants.

Eventually, I think it will be like flu, where there will be an updated vaccine every year and the only people who get ill will be the unvaccinated and those unlucky enough to get a new variant. And I have no objection to wearing a mask in shops and other buildings to protect people.

We certainly can't afford to have almost 2,000 people a day being admitted to hospital, like there were the other day.

And imo Long Covid may turn out to be the elephant in the room. That's potentially a very big unknown.

Lifeisnteasy · 02/01/2022 13:28

But yes I can’t imagine a virus with a 99% survival rate, which most of the country has been inoculated against, would bring the country to a house arrest standstill even 30 or 40 years ago.

Lifeisnteasy · 02/01/2022 13:27

@Lavender24

can you imagine in the second world war people refusing to black out because they are bored of it?

A bombing isn't really comparable to what is now essentially a common cold though is it?

Let’s not forget how much Spanish flu was underplayed in order to keep the war effort going…
LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 02/01/2022 13:24

OP your question is not properly put as it rules out the option, well articulated by your first respondent, for a blended approach. It is plain you do not agree with that approach (and your reasons are perfectly valid and possibly even cogent). But in raising the legitimate questions you do, you have ruled out that others, for decent reasons, may espouse a blended approach.

It is perfectly value for you to reject a blended approach. But it is not really making your discussion susceptible to intelligent debate for you to decide that such a plan is off the table even for discussion.

The trouble with AIBU, for important subjects of public policy, is the binary nature of the choices. It is much more nuanced than one option is unreasonable and the other not.

Emilyontmoor · 02/01/2022 13:22

It isn’t a black and white decision, suppresssion v no suppression.

The Scientists are saying that hopefully Covid will become an illness that we live with like flu but even with flu, if a new strain was as transmissible as Covid and had the impact Omichron is having on hospitals and essential services,, then we would be taking measures to suppress it. The existing pandemic plan was for exactly that scenario. High case numbers come with an economic cost too, businesses in London have been hit badly by this wave without enough corresponding support and I know we will now lose several local independent businesses.

However much people want to go back to “normal” as a society we have to respond to the level of threat we face. It may be that this milder version has peaked and the current NHS crisis, especially in our local hospital , will not worsen as a result of people socialising at New Year and getting back to school etc. That the level of threat will recede to the point where we manage it like normal flu. Or it might not, and the whole country could face the problems London already is. We can’t know for certain what is coming in two weeks, let alone two months or two years.

Clearly with vaccines (and new and better ones in development) we are not where we were a year ago and that is a hopeful sign that we will never have to go back to the sort of full and disastrous lockdowns we have seen (and which could have been avoided if earlier and more effective suppression had kept case numbers down) . Though our local care homes are suffering staffing problems they are not getting outbreaks amongst residents which is a very hopeful sign.

However we do need to keep monitoring the situation, and especially learn the lessons and develop public health strategies to more successfully minimise the future threat of either more transmissible / deadly variants of Covid or entirely new viruses, just as Asian countries did after SARS and therefore have had a more effective response with less economic damage.

I would like to see that strategy guided by Science not ideology. At the moment we are being guided by a bunch of science denying right wing libertarians who hold too much power over their leader (whoever that leader might be since all the candidates are dancing to their tune) and ideology is guiding strategy.

ChequerBoard · 02/01/2022 13:21

@TeeBee

I'm in favour of removing restrictions, removing isolation and instead funding the NHS properly to deal with the percentage of people who will end up hospitalised.

How does that work then?

You can throw money about all you like, it still won't instantly create more healthcare professionals to actually care for people.

Cornettoninja · 02/01/2022 13:20

@Squirrelblanket tbf covid is the straw that broke the camels back re: comparisons to previous years flu/winter demands. I’ve never known it to be so common to be advised that ambulance wait times can be hours. In October my elderly father had a heart attack and fall and we were advised that an ambulance would be up to two hours. My story isn’t uncommon and I dread to think what things are like now with much higher levels of staff absences.

We’ve (the collective UK we - I’ve personally not voted Tory) pretty much consistently voted for this, I’m in my forties and labour were only in power for thirteen years of my lifetime, the tories have had a damning hand in a lot of what we’re experiencing today.

Julieandthejets · 02/01/2022 13:16

@Whichjab my previous post was in reply to your claim about covid killing more brits than WW2 eye 🙄

maddening · 02/01/2022 13:16

Based on previous examples, eg Spanish flu, I reckon we are currently in process of moving to learning to live with it, 3 years is a normal time frame for something like this and the suppression while the vaccine was drafted has mitigated deaths as much as it could and it was necessary to do so, I reckon this year will be the transition, that monitoring is required for now until we are sure we have as much a handle on it as flu.
So I have voted yanbu but I don't think current caution is unnecessary or a sign that people are under the impression that we will continue to live like that, and I don't think anyone wants to either.

Julieandthejets · 02/01/2022 13:14

That’s factually incorrect. ‘In WWII there were 384,000 soldiers killed in combat, but a higher civilian death toll (70,000, as opposed to 2,000 in WWI), largely due to German bombing raids during the Blitz’
There’s no need to blatantly misrepresent facts

Squirrelblanket · 02/01/2022 13:12

Living with it, 100%. We do need to see some changes in order to do this effectively, such as massive investment in healthcare. What I do find frustrating though, is that most years in winter the health service has been overstretched by normal winter illnesses. It's with covid this time, but this happened each year before covid too.

Also I'm happy to admit being 'bored' with it.🤷🏻‍♀️

TeeBee · 02/01/2022 13:10

I'm in favour of removing restrictions, removing isolation and instead funding the NHS properly to deal with the percentage of people who will end up hospitalised.

Cornettoninja · 02/01/2022 13:09

if not allowing it, we need to (quickly) establish permanency (for all the reasons ive mentioned)

But your desire for speed just isn’t possible without a period of stability from the virus itself. There have been a lot of variations in a short space of time (for example, vaccines have been available for just about a year and not universally).

The emphasis is on the ‘learning’ bit of your original statement. You can’t learn information that doesn’t exist yet. We’re not even through our first winter with a largely vaccinated population.

This doesn’t bode particularly well for anyone or anything struggling with any aspect currently because I suspect we’re at a point, particularly economically, where less and less can be supported because of the effects of something that isn’t going anywhere and going forward finances will have to take it into accounts In that respect I agree with you, but that needs to come as a clear message from those in leadership.

Adelino · 02/01/2022 13:06

I think it's still about flattening the curve to some extent.

If dropping isolation/ restrictions means hospitals being overwhelmed and not having enough ICU beds to recieve non-covid patients or to perform life saving operations then I don't think that can be an acceptable way forward.

SmithofSilver · 02/01/2022 13:06

Honestly, I think talking 'permanent' anything at this point is ridiculous. Do you have a crystal ball that we are all missing and know what covid is going to look like this time next year? If the answer to this is no then I don't know how you can make 'permanent' plans to tackle or not. What if by some freak chance it mutated to having a 10% death rate? Would you want to sally along with your plan to do nothing? What if it mutated to have a death rate of 0% would you continue with your plan for suppression? Or would you do the sensible thing and realise that it is an evolving situation and 'permanent plans' for evolving situations are never going to work and just make people pissed off if the 'permanent plans' have to change?

Baystard · 02/01/2022 13:06

Often I see "live with it" meaning little or no mitigation and taking the consequences (which aren't life threatening for most) in terms of hospitalisations etc. The problem is that our health care system is not prepared for that, we have underfunded it for many years and it arguably couldn't cope with the demand for services pre-pandemic nevermind now when there's a large backlog and higher levels of demand overall.

If we had unlimited healthcare capacity then I could support just living with it and dealing with the consequences. However we don't have unlimited healthcare capacity.

We now understand very well that not having healthcare capacity to deal with covid doesn't simply mean that everything else works as normal and covid patients aren't seen. It means that all services are impacted - we all suffer.

It's a failure of our government that we're in this situation re the fragility of the NHS, but we are where we are and we can't improve it overnight so for the time being we need to suppress the virus.

Sowhatifiam · 02/01/2022 13:04

A bombing isn't really comparable to what is now essentially a common cold though is it?

We don’t have hundreds of hospital admissions daily with a common cold. Nor do we have a death tally.

I think we are at the point of understanding that there will be an annual covid death toll, just like there is with flu, which is sad and frustrating but just the way it is. What we can’t have with the state of the NHS, is any illness that puts major pressure on the way covid is doing. So I think we need to accept that living with it means upping health care capacity wnd paying for that. I also think that whether we like it or not, restrictions are always going to be a possibility. We do have to accept that normal is a new normal and we may never get back what we had.

Whichjab · 02/01/2022 13:02

@Lavender24

can you imagine in the second world war people refusing to black out because they are bored of it?

A bombing isn't really comparable to what is now essentially a common cold though is it?

Covid has killed more than the Nazis.

www.google.com/amp/s/www.businessinsider.com/coronavirus-kills-more-british-civilians-than-nazis-2021-1%3famp

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 13:00

@CastleCrasher

"there can't be an in between" Of course there can. For example there is an annual vax drive for flu, combined with h&s advice re reducing spread. That's not full supression as you describe but it's also not just living with it.

Long term/permanent furlough is a nonsense. If there are jobs or industries that are no longer viable in their current form (or at all) then they will need to adapt or close, it's simply not feasible to suggest long term support

Very fair points. In these chats, there's much down to interpretation (and nuance), mine is that how we manage flu WOULD be living with it (thus I deliberately mentioned flu in that option). Living with it isnt ignoring it; I didnt mean to give that impression.
OP posts: