Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Covid. Permanent suppression or truly learning to live with it?

238 replies

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 11:55

Interested to see where people are at, as we go into our third year of the suppression approach.

Its taken a while, but most have accepted that coronavirus is here to stay, and that restrictions serve only to suppress (they cant/wont eradicate). We hear the theory (and the phrase) 'learning to live' with it, but in practice we're nowhere near to learning to live with it. Indeed, we're still behaving as though we can eradicate it via repeated 'short term' suppression. Current thinking is as it was in March 2020 ie that if we suppress it for 'just a bit longer' it'll go away. It wont. Clearly we cant continue swinging between 'living with it' and 'suppressing it' - the uncertainty of a continued stop/start for business, education (planning life in general!) etc isnt feasible as a long term strategy; we need to decide one way or another.

So... are you in favour of accepting that our current way of living must become permanent and (obviously this list is not exhaustive) masks, distancing, limits on mixing, one way systems etc are how we must live now. Funding to support business/furlough is made permanent and we all pay extra to support same (because I suppose the alternative is hospitality businesses just close? Become part of the bygone era). Remote learning in schools is a fixture (and that will be based, not on illness, but on isolation rules) every time there is a peak (and funding will need to be, I dont know, redirected from schools to parents in order to allow this). WFH is made permanent and, again, funding redirected to allow same.
Or... are you in favour of truly 'learning to live' with it, relying on vaccine to do the heavy lifting (thus not counting cases and accepting, as with flu, hospitalisations and deaths), scrapping track and trace, scrapping isolation (thus allowing asymptomatic people - including teachers and NHS staff to live/go to work normally) and essentially returning to life as it was in 2019.

YABU - in favour of permanent suppression.
YANBU - in favour of truly learning to live with it.

OP posts:
mynamesnotMa · 02/01/2022 14:13

Are the NHS staff off with covid 19 or due to isolating.

We are still need to understand how much vaccines work and are effective
Learning to safely as possible learn to live with it I presume.
I have worked through out in a role that requires extensive people contact. I am fed up off masks as I know they are rather pointless but wear them anyway

MarshmallowFondant · 02/01/2022 14:11

@Footnote

Mostly people are using the term ‘learning to live with it’ to mean doing whatever they want and ignoring the inevitable consequences of the health system collapsing. I don’t get the feeling they mean that they’ve accepted that people will die of easily preventable non-Covid causes and they are fine with it, and willing to take the risk of their family and friends being among them.
The NHS is not fit for purpose and has not been for decades. We need to get over this attitude that the NHS is some sort of sacred cow which can never ever be reformed and must not be criticised. Chucking more and more good money after bad to prop it up.
MarshmallowFondant · 02/01/2022 14:09

We currently have minimal mitigations in place that in practice impact very little on day to day life in terms of actions we are obliged to take as individuals.

I am assuming you are in England.

In Scotland they have shut nightclubs, maximum numbers of 100 at standing indoor events, 200 at seated indoor events, 500 outside. So at the moment no theatre, no pantomimes, no concerts, no trade shows/exhibitions etc. No standing at a bar, table service only , you must make a reservation and can only stay 2 hours. Masks in shops/public spaces never went away and have been in place since summer 2020. Masks in classrooms since August 2020. People being asked not to mix. Capacity caps in shops/supermarkets, one way systems.

And despite Queen Covid's attempts to do it oh so differently in Scotland, we're in no better/worse position than anywhere else in the UK.

It all needs to stop now. Stay at home if you feel ill, just as you would with the flu, Ebola or any other infectious disease. And that's it.

Footnote · 02/01/2022 14:07

Mostly people are using the term ‘learning to live with it’ to mean doing whatever they want and ignoring the inevitable consequences of the health system collapsing. I don’t get the feeling they mean that they’ve accepted that people will die of easily preventable non-Covid causes and they are fine with it, and willing to take the risk of their family and friends being among them.

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 14:06

@LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood

I am not here to argue for a blended approach. Merely stating my view that in opening your discussion, it diminishes the argument if some options are off the table even for debate.
Its my impression that, when people refer to a 'blended approach', theyre talking about PRN restrictions ('as required'); and that serves only to prolong the issues business, education, staffing (all the things I mentioned) currently face. How can it be considered a long term solution when its already proving unfeasible?

Its easy for unaffected people to say its 'only' been two years. Not so easy when you're hanging by a thread to your livelihood.

OP posts:
Peas252 · 02/01/2022 14:02

What restrictions does England have at the moment?

Masks are optional (anyone can claim a medical exemption and not give details), pcr/lft testing is optional (if I don't have to give medical info to not wear a mask, then I don't have to give medical info to anyone about any potential symptoms), isolation is optional as its based on an optional positive pcr test, and vaccines are optional.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 02/01/2022 14:02

I think pandemics risk becoming more common. There were deadly flu outbreaks in the 1950’s and 1960’s but most people didn’t travel much, population density was lower etc. so there was generally less capacity for global spread.

The WHO describes HIV/AIDS as an epidemic others consider it a pandemic.

More recently we’ve seen Swine Flu and SARS plus other localised issues such as MERS, Ebola, Zika and Nipah. 60 years ago the risk of these localised viruses spreading globally would have been pretty low. With modern travel the risk is higher.

I wonder if we will have to rethink our perception of pandemics post Covid that we live with the risk and have a suite of measures that can be brought in quickly if needed.

BusBusBus · 02/01/2022 14:01

We need to really overhaul our social care and healthcare services, with a proper long term plan focusing on expanding the numbers of qualified staff and keeping conditions good enough they want to stay working. At the very least we need to know that its not just 'manage it like flu' as flu still exists so its manage it like covid and flu together. We had a system which ran at very high capacity as standard and regularly struggled in winter.

FluffyBooBoo · 02/01/2022 14:01

[quote Lifeisnteasy]@SilverDragonfly1 it’s not a good analogy at all Confused

Everyone was at risk of death during the blitz - nobody is immune to a bomb landing on them.

Whereas covid is only a risk to a small number of the population, it’s just the rest of the country is expected to shut their lives down for it as well.[/quote]
I disagree with you.

Covid is a risk for everyone - but it's a bigger risk for some than others. (The elderly, people with co-morbidities)

Bombs were a risk for everyone - but it was a bigger risk for some than others (people that live in cities or near other places of high interest to the people bombing)

GoldenOmber · 02/01/2022 13:59

Surely a bigger issue with the Covid/Blitz analogy is that wars actually end, so there is a defined period in which to act, not an indefinite way of life? We didn’t keep blackout curtains up forever. What’s the Covid equivalent to Hitler shooting himself and the German army surrendering?

worriedandannoyed · 02/01/2022 13:59

I think you are quite mistaken in your thinking. The aim initially was to surpress in order to save the NHS from being overwhelmed. It was never thought that it could or would be eradicated. Any restrictions have been in place to keep numbers to a level where the NHS can cope. As it seems to be becoming more deadly I'm sure we will have less and less restrictions as time goes on

Julieandthejets · 02/01/2022 13:55

@RandomLondoner

‘ @Whichjab my previous post was in reply to your claim about covid killing more brits than WW2 eye 🙄
She didn't say what you claim she said. She was talking about civilian deaths. Your statistics prove her correct.’

This was the exact quote I replied to covid has killed more Brits than the Nazis

The Nazis killed hundreds of thousands of Brits. More accurate would be for the OP to say ‘covid has killed more Brits than were killed in bombings on British soil during WW2’. But that doesn’t sound quite so alarmist does it.

Chasingaftermidnight · 02/01/2022 13:54

It’s not until your last sentence that ‘NHS’ gets a mention and then only in the context of staff’s way of life. Until we can get the medical system on a safe and stable footing there is no alternative but to accept that we must have a management plan.

Exactly. And I do wonder what people mean when they say ‘we need to learn to live with it’ while it’s apparent that the health service is struggling to cope with it. What does ‘living with it’ mean against that background? Does it mean that people who become very ill with Covid shouldn’t receive hospital treatment and should die at home? Or does it mean that we should just allow hospitals to be overwhelmed and it’ll become a matter of luck whether we receive medical care if we need it - just cross your fingers it’s someone else’s child who gets meningitis?

Lifeisnteasy · 02/01/2022 13:54

@SilverDragonfly1 it’s not a good analogy at all Confused

Everyone was at risk of death during the blitz - nobody is immune to a bomb landing on them.

Whereas covid is only a risk to a small number of the population, it’s just the rest of the country is expected to shut their lives down for it as well.

BiniorellaSun · 02/01/2022 13:52

Short term we need some mitigation to stop the health service being overwhelmed.
Long term we need to invest in a better health service that isn’t as easily overwhelmed!

SilverDragonfly1 · 02/01/2022 13:52

@Lavender24

can you imagine in the second world war people refusing to black out because they are bored of it?

A bombing isn't really comparable to what is now essentially a common cold though is it?

In the sense that your own carelessness could potentially injure or kill the people around you, it's pretty similar. Saying it's essentially a common cold is like saying a bomb will probably only blow your windows out. Sure it's a much more common outcome but you won't know until the bomb drops/ you or a loved one end up in ICU.
GoldenOmber · 02/01/2022 13:51

We need to live with it.

That said, many people are still absolutely committed to the idea there is some set of halfway house Sensible Measures which would being covid rates down to almost 0 without causing much damage to anything else. Which would be lovely! But hasn’t worked for anybody anywhere on the planet, which is a bit of a hitch…

Emilyontmoor · 02/01/2022 13:50

Pandemics usually happen roughly every 80 years, we have been lucky in that this one was overdue. I don't see anyone still taking precautions because of any of the previous ones See my comment above. We did have a pandemic in 2003 and the countries with that experience did take precautions this time because of that experience. The lessons were there to be learnt from them. Taiwan actually shouting was ignored in WHO meetings. We were too arrogant and entitled to take notice

Almostwelsh · 02/01/2022 13:47

Well Im not a healthcare professional or a policy maker so I might know nothing, but measures I would like to see include-

An ending of presenteeism culture. If you have any ailment that might be transmissible and can work from home, you should do so. Similarly children should not be encouraged to come to school when ill under the treat of sanctions.

A concerted effort to increase the number of healthcare professionals trained. Possibly a scheme where they get free funding and maintenance grants provided they work in the NHS following qualification for a set period of time. This won't help us instantly, but will bear fruit 5-10 years later.

Money given now to social care by increased taxation. A reorganisation such that the service works on weekends and holidays the same as it does Monday-Friday. This will ease pressure on hospitals in the shorter term by stopping people who don't medically need a hospital bed from using one.

If we did these things, in conjunction with vaccines then living with Covid without restrictions I think would be possible.

Emilyontmoor · 02/01/2022 13:46

How does the blended approach work in practice? Ive not seen any proposition to a 'blended' approach that doesnt bring the same issues associated with the permanent suppression approach? Taiwan, South Korea, Japan even all had a more effective response and saw less economic damage because they bought in the public health strategies they developed as a result of SARS. Taiwan’s economy has actually grown.

llantwitminor · 02/01/2022 13:46

It is not a black and white situation as others have mentioned. What I most of all want to see is competent government in the approach taken, which we do not have now.

For example, one minister saying more restrictions will be a last resort, then the next day another one announces a new restriction of sorts.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 02/01/2022 13:43

For what it’s worth, I think we now have to learn to live with it (and provide proper support to people who are so vulnerable that the vaccine programme alone cannot properly protect them). I just waited to see the discussion more nuanced than I think AIBU is able to supply really.

Chasingaftermidnight · 02/01/2022 13:42

I think the answer depends entirely on whether the health service can cope with it or not. If it can, then we can live with Covid in the same way we live with other viruses. If it can’t, we need measures to curb it. It’s in no one’s interests for the NHS to collapse.

It seems to me that the problem is that our health service has been run at 99% capacity for years and years. It’s been creaking at the seams every winter for a decade and a half. No one thought about what would happen if a new novel health threat appeared in addition to existing winter pressures. In order to learn to live with the virus we need to increase the capacity of our health service but that takes money and, more importantly, time.

LadyMacbethWasMisunderstood · 02/01/2022 13:40

I am not here to argue for a blended approach. Merely stating my view that in opening your discussion, it diminishes the argument if some options are off the table even for debate.

FluffyBooBoo · 02/01/2022 13:39

Of course we are going to learn to live with it, just like the Spanish flu. We just need to do it in the right way at the right time, and rushing into it would be incredibly foolish.

Pandemics usually happen roughly every 80 years, we have been lucky in that this one was overdue. I don't see anyone still taking precautions because of any of the previous ones.