Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Covid. Permanent suppression or truly learning to live with it?

238 replies

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 11:55

Interested to see where people are at, as we go into our third year of the suppression approach.

Its taken a while, but most have accepted that coronavirus is here to stay, and that restrictions serve only to suppress (they cant/wont eradicate). We hear the theory (and the phrase) 'learning to live' with it, but in practice we're nowhere near to learning to live with it. Indeed, we're still behaving as though we can eradicate it via repeated 'short term' suppression. Current thinking is as it was in March 2020 ie that if we suppress it for 'just a bit longer' it'll go away. It wont. Clearly we cant continue swinging between 'living with it' and 'suppressing it' - the uncertainty of a continued stop/start for business, education (planning life in general!) etc isnt feasible as a long term strategy; we need to decide one way or another.

So... are you in favour of accepting that our current way of living must become permanent and (obviously this list is not exhaustive) masks, distancing, limits on mixing, one way systems etc are how we must live now. Funding to support business/furlough is made permanent and we all pay extra to support same (because I suppose the alternative is hospitality businesses just close? Become part of the bygone era). Remote learning in schools is a fixture (and that will be based, not on illness, but on isolation rules) every time there is a peak (and funding will need to be, I dont know, redirected from schools to parents in order to allow this). WFH is made permanent and, again, funding redirected to allow same.
Or... are you in favour of truly 'learning to live' with it, relying on vaccine to do the heavy lifting (thus not counting cases and accepting, as with flu, hospitalisations and deaths), scrapping track and trace, scrapping isolation (thus allowing asymptomatic people - including teachers and NHS staff to live/go to work normally) and essentially returning to life as it was in 2019.

YABU - in favour of permanent suppression.
YANBU - in favour of truly learning to live with it.

OP posts:
TheScenicWay · 02/01/2022 20:51

We need to just learn to live with it now. The fact that omicron is mild and everyone is getting it, is surely setting us well for living with it after this wave. What happens next will guide us but it’s looking hopefully to be endemic and similar to regular flu.
If that’s the case then, yes, back to how we were.

TheHamburgler · 02/01/2022 20:45

I actually regret replying to you now (and thus quoting your comments). Its taken the chat on what feels like quite an intrusive tangent.
Oh no! And it was such an informed discussion Grin

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 19:34

@Natty13

GaolBhoAlba

Well done for Googling but you will note that I didn't say having covid means a lung transplant isn't possible. There have heen zero in the UK because we are not doing transplants for covid patients.

Secobdly, there are definitely more than single figures for lung necrosis from covid. I cover multiple specialist centres and can tell you in 1 hospital alone I've looked after enough to count on 2 hands.

But thanks for proving my point that folk with absolutely zero experience of this think they know better!

Yes, I did take that impression from your post (ie that a transplant simply wasnt possible).

I actually regret replying to you now (and thus quoting your comments). Its taken the chat on what feels like quite an intrusive tangent. If it were my loved one, I wouldnt want a person nursing them to post intricate details on MN.

OP posts:
Emilyontmoor · 02/01/2022 19:00

Ie it won’t be eradicated but through vaccines, mandatory isolation and treatment for those who have it, it will eventually not figure in daily lives of all of us. One benefit of the pandemic hitting when it did was that there was vaccine technology in place that could be developed, only held back by funding issues. In the last two years the funding issues have evaporated and there is a lot of exciting developments in the pipeline. Imperial for instance have a vaccine in development that can be administered in very small doses (because it replicates in the body but I’m no scientist so this may not be the scientific term Grin so much easier to manufacture and deliver in the third world. Most of the funding has come from individual benefactors and it has been developed on the basis it will be freely available to the rest of the world with no license. Not just that but they are looking at targeted versions for Ebola and other viruses and even on the distant horizon, Cancer.

The only issue is will so many people be infected online with the it’s only a cold / anti vaxx / conspiracy misinformation that it can’t be truly effective.

Natty13 · 02/01/2022 18:37

GaolBhoAlba

Well done for Googling but you will note that I didn't say having covid means a lung transplant isn't possible. There have heen zero in the UK because we are not doing transplants for covid patients.

Secobdly, there are definitely more than single figures for lung necrosis from covid. I cover multiple specialist centres and can tell you in 1 hospital alone I've looked after enough to count on 2 hands.

But thanks for proving my point that folk with absolutely zero experience of this think they know better!

TheHamburgler · 02/01/2022 18:35

The premise of this thread is stupid.

It has been widely accepted, for a long time now, that the virus will almost certainly become endemic and we will learn to live with it.

However, until then, the aim is to stop so many getting it at once that essential services fail.

So, no, ‘suppression’ and ‘learning to live with it’ are not mutually exclusive.

Littlecaf · 02/01/2022 18:28

I think we’ll eventually, probably Over the next 18m-5years where we’ll get to a place where is not problem anymore. Ie it won’t be eradicated but through vaccines, mandatory isolation and treatment for those who have it, it will eventually not figure in daily lives of all of us.

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 18:14

@Sowhatifiam

I did a bit of searching, and apparently there has been dozens of successful lung transplants in covid patients? In addition, lung necrosis secondary to COVID-19 has been reported literally only a handful of times (single figures)

Are you serious? I mean questioning the experience of a clearly qualified professional aside, what kind of quality of life do you think exists for people who need lung transplants both before and after the transplant? What do you think the cost of that is, not at the individual level, but to society as a while from both a social and economic perspective? How vulnerable to covid and other illness will that person be in the future? What will be the long term cost of their medication vs.potential economic/working/productive life lost?

There is a clear balance that needs to be struck between ‘living with covid’ and the cost of lockdowns, furloughs, large venues running at half capacity etc etc. but we are not quite there yet. You only need to look at the state of the healthcare system to see that,

What a bizarre comment.

I clearly was not being blasé about the subject matter. My reply was directed uniquely at correcting something that was factually incorrect, and i'll do that wherever I see fit, thank you; clinician or otherwise.

OP posts:
Sowhatifiam · 02/01/2022 17:23

I did a bit of searching, and apparently there has been dozens of successful lung transplants in covid patients? In addition, lung necrosis secondary to COVID-19 has been reported literally only a handful of times (single figures)

Are you serious? I mean questioning the experience of a clearly qualified professional aside, what kind of quality of life do you think exists for people who need lung transplants both before and after the transplant? What do you think the cost of that is, not at the individual level, but to society as a while from both a social and economic perspective? How vulnerable to covid and other illness will that person be in the future? What will be the long term cost of their medication vs.potential economic/working/productive life lost?

There is a clear balance that needs to be struck between ‘living with covid’ and the cost of lockdowns, furloughs, large venues running at half capacity etc etc. but we are not quite there yet. You only need to look at the state of the healthcare system to see that,

Emilyontmoor · 02/01/2022 17:15

OP You do understand that in England vaccinated contacts do not need to isolate, just test. The reason that our hospitals in London are declaring major incidents and not carrying out any non essential work and whole rail lines are not running at all is because people are absent because they are testing positive for the virus via PCR tests. The Scientists have just released data that shows that reducing the isolation period further from 7 days will lead to more cases and more staff absence not less.

Emilyontmoor · 02/01/2022 17:09

Natty I was just coming on to highlight exactly this. The majority of nurses and doctors I know who qualified between 40 and 5 years ago had left the country even before the pandemic hit as a result of the increasing pressure on them in the NHS. Examples include qualifying as a neonatal nurse 15 years ago when given responsibility for the care of 5 critically ill babies, left the country when that rose to 10 and they felt it inevitable they would be responsible for a baby’s death. In Australia they were only allowed to care for 1 because of the cross infection risk. Plus more free time and a better quality of life. Many are now citizens and will make their lives there. For all the weakness in the Australian Covid strategy they are certainly not jealous of their U.K. colleagues, many of whom are talking of leaving the profession.

A strategy of throwing hospital beds at uncontrolled cases of Covid is going to have diminishing returns as staff burn out or become frustrated at not being able to gain more experience and make a difference in their specialism. An orthopaedic surgeon I know is frustrated at all the patients building up on his lists whilst he spent last winter and the winter before twiddling his thumbs because the only operating theatre not given over to Covid was for emergencies only.

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 16:45

@Natty13

A bombing isn't really comparable to what is now essentially a common cold though is it?

I looked after someone born in the 1990s who has had a necrotic lung because of covid. Young, fit and healthy. Absolutely zero health problems before this.

If this person survives that lung will need cut out and covid patients are not candidates for lung transplants. They'll be in hospital for the best part of this year. There's no way they'll be able to go back to their job again. They have young kids and a mortgage.

Like you, they and their family thought "it was just a cold" and decided they knew better than those of us who have been bloody experiencing totally unavoidable deaths for the best part of 2 years.

Its a specialist cancer centre I work in BTW. I can't remember the last post op cancer patient I looked after because we are full of unvaccinated covid patients. We are all sick of this, we are sick of resuscitating people younger and fitter than us. Sick of suppirting yet ANOTHER family shocked that it's taking out someone they love when the partners, kids, parents etc who caught it with them were all OK. We want to go back to our specialities and start treating patients for other diseases again.

We can't and won't do that until we stop being full of covid patients.

I have family and friends abroad and the healthcare workers there are nowhere near as burnt out as us. My sibling in particular lives in a European country with very very strict mask mandate and vaccine passports (you can't even go to an outdoor market or swimming pool with a negative test) and guess what - hospitals are pretty empty of covid, economy is doing ok because people are all living pretty normally again and spending money in bars and shops. Nothing is shut down. THAT is the "new normal" we mean.

I did a bit of searching, and apparently there has been dozens of successful lung transplants in covid patients? In addition, lung necrosis secondary to COVID-19 has been reported literally only a handful of times (single figures).

What European country is your sibling in?

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 02/01/2022 16:35

@Natty13 - well said.

I think some form of restrictions for the unvaccinated by choice is going to be part of the future in this country as it is in others.

Natty13 · 02/01/2022 16:24

A bombing isn't really comparable to what is now essentially a common cold though is it?

I looked after someone born in the 1990s who has had a necrotic lung because of covid. Young, fit and healthy. Absolutely zero health problems before this.

If this person survives that lung will need cut out and covid patients are not candidates for lung transplants. They'll be in hospital for the best part of this year. There's no way they'll be able to go back to their job again. They have young kids and a mortgage.

Like you, they and their family thought "it was just a cold" and decided they knew better than those of us who have been bloody experiencing totally unavoidable deaths for the best part of 2 years.

Its a specialist cancer centre I work in BTW. I can't remember the last post op cancer patient I looked after because we are full of unvaccinated covid patients. We are all sick of this, we are sick of resuscitating people younger and fitter than us. Sick of suppirting yet ANOTHER family shocked that it's taking out someone they love when the partners, kids, parents etc who caught it with them were all OK. We want to go back to our specialities and start treating patients for other diseases again.

We can't and won't do that until we stop being full of covid patients.

I have family and friends abroad and the healthcare workers there are nowhere near as burnt out as us. My sibling in particular lives in a European country with very very strict mask mandate and vaccine passports (you can't even go to an outdoor market or swimming pool with a negative test) and guess what - hospitals are pretty empty of covid, economy is doing ok because people are all living pretty normally again and spending money in bars and shops. Nothing is shut down. THAT is the "new normal" we mean.

BusBusBus · 02/01/2022 15:19

The thing is believing there needs to be an overhaul and in particular increasing staffing and beds doesnt mean someone feels it has to be reformed to a us style healthcare. Its always painted as our system or the US with no reference to many other good systems. However with the trend for selling off public things for private profit or having private companies make profits for public services, i think lots of us worry that is what reform would mean.

Sloth169 · 02/01/2022 15:11

But by the same token I do agree we cant just keep grinding to a halt constantly, the only solution is to increase funding, efficiency & capacity of the NHS

But in reality that takes years as HCPs take years to train

Sloth169 · 02/01/2022 15:09

@GaolBhoAlba

I think, given where we are NOW (note I said now! ie in the advent of vaccine, anti virals, knowledge), that isolation rules have WAY more potential to overwhelm the NHS than coronavirus.

Its also noteworthy that the NHS has not actually become overwhelmed at any point of the pandemic.

You say that theyve not become overwhelmed but thats because the majority of routine outpatients/routine surgery etc was cancelled, even a lot of urgent stuff was cancelled!

So this still had a knock on effect on the care people received for none covid conditions/waiting times

The health board I work for sent out an email just before christmas saying that yet again routine outpatients & surgery was being cancelled

ChequerBoard · 02/01/2022 15:09

You know, it's embarrassing that so many people are falling for the same old privatisation tricks and tactics. You'd think having seen them all before and experiencing the huge price hikes in the cost of their basic utilities post-privatisation that people would be a bit wiser. Not to mention Brexit.

Be really, very careful what you wish for when you decry and bemoan the NHS. No, it's not perfect and improvements are needed, especially to the funding model and the postcode lottery of service provision but throwing the baby out with the bath water is not the way forward.

Always remember that medical debt is the biggest reason for personal bankruptcy in the USA. And that's not due to plastic surgery that due to the cost of looking after a chronically sick family member.

There are some key issues we need to resolve including;

We not have enough healthcare professionals in this country, we aren't training enough and we aren't treating the ones we have well enough.

We don't have enough hospital beds. This has been a deliberate cost saving drive taking us down to an unmanageable levels of beds and this is why we have struggle for beds every winter.

There are too many different organisations operating so care isn't patient centric in the community. This needs a total reorganisation and transformation in care delivery.

Etc etc.

But throwing huge contracts for cherry picked bits of healthcare than can make money to private organisations is not the answer.

Chasingaftermidnight · 02/01/2022 14:51

The NHS is not fit for purpose and has not been for decades. We need to get over this attitude that the NHS is some sort of sacred cow which can never ever be reformed and must not be criticised. Chucking more and more good money after bad to prop it up.

I agree that it is hugely problematic and overly-sanctified and requires reform.

That doesn’t mean we should allow it to collapse overnight.

This isn’t about protecting the NHS as a sacred cow. It’s important to realise what the sudden collapse of the NHS would actually mean. It would be a catastrophe. It wouldn’t just affect ‘the elderly’ and ‘people with underlying health conditions’. All of us, no matter how healthy, would just have to hope to avoid getting sick or being involved in an accident.

Admittedly, there are some Tory nutters out there who think the collapse of the NHS - and the death and suffering that would come with it - is a price we have to pay in order to reform it.

Esspee · 02/01/2022 14:49

Suppression was with the hope that vaccines, and drugs to treat COVID would be found which thankfully came to pass, and to allow the NHS to cope. Unfortunately the NHS is still under strain and worldwide vaccination is a long way off.

Cornettoninja · 02/01/2022 14:42

Okay @GaolBhoAlba. Thanks for clarifying Smile

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 14:26

@Cornettoninja

You would assume correctly *@MarshmallowFondant*, but I can only assume that the OP is also talking about England (happy to be corrected) and I have no political voice when it comes to scotland, wales or NI and their covid strategies.
Im Scots living in Scotland, though yes referring to the UK as a whole (the most impactful mitigations, such as isolation, apply to the UK as a whole).
OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 02/01/2022 14:17

You would assume correctly @MarshmallowFondant, but I can only assume that the OP is also talking about England (happy to be corrected) and I have no political voice when it comes to scotland, wales or NI and their covid strategies.

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 14:15

I think, given where we are NOW (note I said now! ie in the advent of vaccine, anti virals, knowledge), that isolation rules have WAY more potential to overwhelm the NHS than coronavirus.

Its also noteworthy that the NHS has not actually become overwhelmed at any point of the pandemic.

OP posts:
Footnote · 02/01/2022 14:14

You have to put something else in place if you want to get rid of the NHS. If you just let it implode, people will die of trivial things. Private healthcare won’t step in seamlessly.