Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Covid. Permanent suppression or truly learning to live with it?

238 replies

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 11:55

Interested to see where people are at, as we go into our third year of the suppression approach.

Its taken a while, but most have accepted that coronavirus is here to stay, and that restrictions serve only to suppress (they cant/wont eradicate). We hear the theory (and the phrase) 'learning to live' with it, but in practice we're nowhere near to learning to live with it. Indeed, we're still behaving as though we can eradicate it via repeated 'short term' suppression. Current thinking is as it was in March 2020 ie that if we suppress it for 'just a bit longer' it'll go away. It wont. Clearly we cant continue swinging between 'living with it' and 'suppressing it' - the uncertainty of a continued stop/start for business, education (planning life in general!) etc isnt feasible as a long term strategy; we need to decide one way or another.

So... are you in favour of accepting that our current way of living must become permanent and (obviously this list is not exhaustive) masks, distancing, limits on mixing, one way systems etc are how we must live now. Funding to support business/furlough is made permanent and we all pay extra to support same (because I suppose the alternative is hospitality businesses just close? Become part of the bygone era). Remote learning in schools is a fixture (and that will be based, not on illness, but on isolation rules) every time there is a peak (and funding will need to be, I dont know, redirected from schools to parents in order to allow this). WFH is made permanent and, again, funding redirected to allow same.
Or... are you in favour of truly 'learning to live' with it, relying on vaccine to do the heavy lifting (thus not counting cases and accepting, as with flu, hospitalisations and deaths), scrapping track and trace, scrapping isolation (thus allowing asymptomatic people - including teachers and NHS staff to live/go to work normally) and essentially returning to life as it was in 2019.

YABU - in favour of permanent suppression.
YANBU - in favour of truly learning to live with it.

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 02/01/2022 23:32

You definitely aren't a bore @Natty13
Quite the opposite.

Also, thank you for what you do. I'm sorry things are so tough for you and your colleagues. I hope you know that many of us do very much appreciate your work.

BootsScootsAndToots · 02/01/2022 23:31

@DoleWhipFloat

I’m in favour of living with it and relying on my own immune system to do so.
@Natty13

What do you think of these sorts of replies? I've got a few on my FB feed who think they just need to rely on their immune system and they'll be fine 🙄

Natty13 · 02/01/2022 23:22

Yes I'm so boring that wherever I go and whatever I do peiple are asking me for my opinion and current experiences.

I have provided an alternative to the many, many posts declaring it "just a cold". It's not. Yes, severe and critical illness in healthy young people is rare but in 14 years of intensive care I have NEVER come across a young healthy person dying of the cold (or flu). It's not a cold and as long as people keep dismissing it as such in order to justify their views I will correct them with my anecdotes. The ease of transmission and severity of illness to the vulnerable and non vulnerable is why we need to have some restrictions. One avoidable death is one too many imo.

I have hand on heart met a lot of people who share(d) your views. It absolutely sickens me how every single one of them ONLY start to care about it all when it is them or someone they love being stuck on a ventilator and dialysis machine as their organs fail one by one. Suddenly the whole world needs to turn on its axis in order to save them.

DoleWhipFloat · 02/01/2022 23:21

I’m in favour of living with it and relying on my own immune system to do so.

TheScenicWay · 02/01/2022 23:21

@Dozer where is that info from? According to news articles I’ve seen, hospitals don’t seem to be overwhelmed at the moment. I know staff absences due to illness and self isolation is causing issues but not actual hospitalisations.
There has been a rise but it seems to be mainly ‘incidental covid’ and there isn’t a rise in patients needing critical care because of covid.

ittakes2 · 02/01/2022 23:14

I am sorry I could not be bothered to vote.
The Spanish flu eventually assimilated into our society - and covid will too.
Nothing will be permanent - they are all temporary measures until covid becomes like a common cold. A few years of restrictive living seems like a long time to those living it - but in the history of the world its really not.

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 23:12

@Dozer

Oh come on OP, you made some silly points and Natty - a health care professional - challenged you and shared her anecdotal experience. Her posts seem anything but boring!
What points were 'silly'?
OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 02/01/2022 23:06

unless another severe variant arises (unlikely, fingers crossed)

We can't know how likely. Hopefully it won't happen, but we cannot predict with confidence because this is still a new disease.

But it's not all bad news. We have the good luck of ability to take mitigations. Sensible basic infection control measures. Masks, vaccines and vaccine passes, and good ventilation including HEPA filters.

We also have new treatments. Antivirals, and monoclonal antibodies like sotrovimab. High global demand and currently limited supply, but it's a positive step forwards for a better future. Eventually there will be wider availability.

We will also hopefully have more of the world vaccinated (morally right, but also vital if we are to reduce the likelihood of new variants).

Tealightsandd · 02/01/2022 23:05

Omicron doesn’t seem to be killing and disabling.

Well except for the nearly 1000 patients killed by SARS-CoV-2 in just the last week alone.

And Long Covid is disabling a significant minority.

Dozer · 02/01/2022 22:55

TheScenicWay Omicon is causing serious illness requiring hospital treatment to the extent that there is risk hospitals won’t have capacity to provide care - after cancelling other healthcare for other conditions.

Dozer · 02/01/2022 22:54

Oh come on OP, you made some silly points and Natty - a health care professional - challenged you and shared her anecdotal experience. Her posts seem anything but boring!

TheScenicWay · 02/01/2022 22:49

“It's not possible to 'live with' something that kills and disables”

Isn’t omicron displacing delta now? Omicron doesn’t seem to be killing and disabling. It also seems to be giving us immunity against delta according to research from South Africa. If this is the case, then we should be coming out of this pandemic, unless another severe variant arises (unlikely, fingers crossed)

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 22:48

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Dozer · 02/01/2022 22:47

God, hate the scenario of dangerous variants causing lots of serious illness and death in five years time! Really hope that doesn’t happen.

Tealightsandd · 02/01/2022 22:42

There's plenty of research that supports masks as a mitigation against airborne diseases. It's why for years before this pandemic HCP have used them. It was known about 100 years ago during the Spanish flu pandemic, and they even had some understanding back in the times of the Great Plague.

But yes agreed that good ventilation and air equality is also important.

An arsenal of tools works best.

SantaClawsServiette · 02/01/2022 22:36

Living with it is going to be the end state. The real difficulty that needs to be overcome, and this is not just the UK, is what to do if and when hospitals actually become overwhelmed. In five years time if there is a particularly virulent mutation where the hospital beds are being filled up, I think we will certainly see attempts to suppress for the short term.

The other question is which mitigation techniques really work well in such a case, and could be justified. The relatively easy ones like masks have limited research to support them as having much effect at this point. Air quality measures may end up being the more important methods.

Tealightsandd · 02/01/2022 22:17

Kuwait has a good idea on how to live with it. They've recently very sensibly advised Kuwaitis to leave plague island the UK due to us being such a high risk country.

Tealightsandd · 02/01/2022 22:15

It's not possible to 'live with' something that kills and disables.

But - generally with other life and health threatening things in our everyday world, 'living with' means mitigations.

Like seat belts and child seats for cars. They don't stop all road traffic deaths and disabilities but they reduce the risks.

For the time being, wth this still new likely lab escaped (and possibly not wholly natural) disease, mitigations for 'living with' it include masks, vaccines and vaccine passes, and good ventilation (eg. HEPA filters).

Going forwards it would be no bad thing to adopt a more East Asian civic mindedness - and embrace a culture of wearing masks when sick (whether SARS-COV-2, flu, cold, or whatever) out of courtesy and decency to others, particularly but not only the vulnerable.

In the future we'll also have wider availability of the new antivirals, and the monoclonal antibodies like sotrovimab (and any other treatments that come along). Plus better knowledge and understanding of both initial Covid infection and Long Covid.

PineappleMojito · 02/01/2022 22:09

@PlanetNormal

The ‘suppression’ ship has sailed. It is not possible to suppress a virus as transmissible as Omicron and to attempt to do so would destroy our economy and our society. It would almost certainly fail anyway.

Our only option is to learn to live with it. I have been very critical of the government over the last two years, but with every piece of evidence we get about Omicron’s reduced severity over Delta their strategy of getting as many doses of vaccines into arms as possible then letting the vaccines do their job without locking down society appears to have been the right call. Well done, Professors Whitty, Vallance, Van Tam & co.

Whitty and the rest wanted restrictions!
TheHamburgler · 02/01/2022 22:03

It just feels like you’re at least 18 months behind in the discussion.

It was the prevailing view amongst scientists, at least by the middle of 2020 that eradicating Covid was not a likely outcome, and it would very likely become endemic. For example:

www.cnbc.com/2020/10/20/covid-19-likely-to-become-as-endemic-as-flu.html

As time has passed, I think that’s gone from widely-accepted to near-universally accepted.

Ongoing restrictions have been implemented for the purpose of preventing a massive spike in infections and deaths, thus protecting essential services so far as possible. It’s not a case of stopping people getting the virus, but trying to restrict simultaneous cases to a manageable number. I thought this was understood by now...

Between vaccines (which significantly reduce the risk of severe illness), increasing natural immunity and new medical treatments, we are likely on the return path to normality, it’s just a gradual process (assuming you don’t want healthcare and other services to collapse, and lots of deaths that could have been avoided with a little more patience).

ChequerBoard · 02/01/2022 22:01

At least OP has accurately assessed that she looks a clown 🤡 for trying to use Dr Google 'facts' to argue with a healthcare professional...

Thanks @Natty13 for your insights and for the care you provide for all your patients, whatever their views.

Natty13 · 02/01/2022 21:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Dozer · 02/01/2022 21:27

Sorry, at present, the number of people with covid needing care is more than the NHS has capacity to deal with, whilst maintaining care for everything else.

So with no interventions, more people with covid will die or have worse health outcomes, and more people with other illnesses or emergencies will die.

Countries with better resourced healthcare have more capacity, but similar trade offs.

Dozer · 02/01/2022 21:21

‘Living with it’ is the wrong phrase when a key factor is death numbers.

It’s about how many people need hospital care and die vs the capacity of health services in specific times and places. Also how many covid deaths that voters will tolerate relative to other costs, eg detriment to DCs and the economy, worse health services, increased deaths due to other health conditions not being treated well or in time.

At present that and is

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 21:11

@TheHamburgler

I actually regret replying to you now (and thus quoting your comments). Its taken the chat on what feels like quite an intrusive tangent. Oh no! And it was such an informed discussion Grin
🤡
OP posts: