Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Covid. Permanent suppression or truly learning to live with it?

238 replies

GaolBhoAlba · 02/01/2022 11:55

Interested to see where people are at, as we go into our third year of the suppression approach.

Its taken a while, but most have accepted that coronavirus is here to stay, and that restrictions serve only to suppress (they cant/wont eradicate). We hear the theory (and the phrase) 'learning to live' with it, but in practice we're nowhere near to learning to live with it. Indeed, we're still behaving as though we can eradicate it via repeated 'short term' suppression. Current thinking is as it was in March 2020 ie that if we suppress it for 'just a bit longer' it'll go away. It wont. Clearly we cant continue swinging between 'living with it' and 'suppressing it' - the uncertainty of a continued stop/start for business, education (planning life in general!) etc isnt feasible as a long term strategy; we need to decide one way or another.

So... are you in favour of accepting that our current way of living must become permanent and (obviously this list is not exhaustive) masks, distancing, limits on mixing, one way systems etc are how we must live now. Funding to support business/furlough is made permanent and we all pay extra to support same (because I suppose the alternative is hospitality businesses just close? Become part of the bygone era). Remote learning in schools is a fixture (and that will be based, not on illness, but on isolation rules) every time there is a peak (and funding will need to be, I dont know, redirected from schools to parents in order to allow this). WFH is made permanent and, again, funding redirected to allow same.
Or... are you in favour of truly 'learning to live' with it, relying on vaccine to do the heavy lifting (thus not counting cases and accepting, as with flu, hospitalisations and deaths), scrapping track and trace, scrapping isolation (thus allowing asymptomatic people - including teachers and NHS staff to live/go to work normally) and essentially returning to life as it was in 2019.

YABU - in favour of permanent suppression.
YANBU - in favour of truly learning to live with it.

OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 03/01/2022 18:48

Still it's very positive to see so much concern for mental health issues. It bodes well for the future. It's clearly a popular cause with the public - which should encourage improved funding from the government. On the underlying causes as much as the support.

For decades it's been a neglected and underfunded area. Both the causes and the help.

Far more long-term and devastating on mental health than temporary lockdowns is the ongoing public health housing and homelessness emergency.

The housing emergency lies behind so much of the issues. Poor physical as well as mental health. Poverty. Damaging children's access to stable educational opportunities and life chances.

Relevant too (given the major focus during the pandemic on the economy) is that the housing emergency costs the taxpayer many billions every year.

BoopTheFloof · 03/01/2022 18:48

@DoleWhipFloat Lots if things are restricted for people with more capacity out of safety/fairness/duty.

Speed limits on roads for example. Or there being laws against things like murder and physical assault.

DoleWhipFloat · 03/01/2022 18:46

“ So what about those with weakened immune systems?”

What have they done in the past, when flu was circulating?

My aunty has lupus and my brother has rheumatoid. They don’t go out much.

They’ve always shielded to a certain extent and their lives have always sadly been more limited than mine. For instance, they can’t go abroad on nice holidays without serious planning, huge insurance premiums and acknowledgment of last minute cancellations.

I’ve only ever visited them when well…we don’t ever go there with the slightest hint of sickness. And still, they spend far more time than the average person in hospital.

Their lives have always been like this and they’ve never ever felt other peoples lives should be restricted to protect them.

Covid is here forever. F.O.R.E.V.E.R.
Do you think that everyone, young and old should now be restricted in ways, out of fairness perhaps? Duty?

newtothisdad · 03/01/2022 18:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Tealightsandd · 03/01/2022 18:40

@MarshaBradyo

True and this

Poor mental health

Hugely exacerbated by lockdowns

We used measures which made it harder to lower weight and risk and should be aware of that

Yes. And equally the huge mental health impact on the millions of Others (and their loved ones).

Bereavement too is a key trigger or mental health struggles.

Mitigations are always the preferable first choice. Masks, vaccine passes, good ventilation including HEPA filters.

But of course prevention is better than cure.

Perhaps a miracle will happen and lessons really have been learnt.

Maybe just maybe next time the whole world will act to stop a would be pandemic from ever becoming one in the first place. Couple of months worldwide border control (with real quarantine where necessary for genuinely essential travel)...and abracadabra, no pandemic.

hugr · 03/01/2022 18:36

@MarshaBradyo

True and this

Poor mental health

Hugely exacerbated by lockdowns

We used measures which made it harder to lower weight and risk and should be aware of that

Lockdown or the pandemic itself? How can you prove either way?
MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2022 18:30

True and this

Poor mental health

Hugely exacerbated by lockdowns

We used measures which made it harder to lower weight and risk and should be aware of that

Tealightsandd · 03/01/2022 18:29

We know what brings extra risk.

Yes. Poor mental health, undiagnosed and late diagnosed physical health conditions, poverty - and particularly the public health housing and homelessness emergency.

It would be fantastic if the socioeconomic underlying causes were addressed.

Tealightsandd · 03/01/2022 18:25

Plenty of family members and Covid victims have gone public, to show the brutal reality. It must be very painful for them - and I have great respect for their brave act of compassion. Make no bones about it, enabling denial of reality, is the very opposite of compassion.

hugr · 03/01/2022 18:24

@DoleWhipFloat

I’m in favour of living with it and relying on my own immune system to do so.
So what about those with weakened immune systems?
MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2022 18:24

I agree re overall health but also that people make changes without government help too.

We know what brings extra risk.

Lifeisnteasy · 03/01/2022 18:23

@TheScenicWay

If anything, then this whole pandemic should have taught us that biggest difference in outcome is underlying health. I look forward to our government focusing on this as the next step and improving the outcomes for everyone.
I hope so too. Prevention is better than a cure.
MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2022 18:22

@TimBoothseyes

There's nothing any of us can do to fight that and having to watch it over and over/respect their choice affects you

And posting about it knowing that there may be people reading it who are still grieving and now have that image in their head (again, thanks for that), made you feel what? Because it sure as Hell wasn't compassion.

I agree and hope that posters respect your request.
TheScenicWay · 03/01/2022 18:20

If anything, then this whole pandemic should have taught us that biggest difference in outcome is underlying health. I look forward to our government focusing on this as the next step and improving the outcomes for everyone.

Tealightsandd · 03/01/2022 17:34

It absolutely is compassion. When nothing else is getting through, Natty's blunt truth might just manage to spare one family from going through unnecessary premature Covid bereavement.

It's certainly not compassion to give false hope and enable potentially deadly denial.

It's a relatively common phenomenon. Families who've lost a loved one in a terrible and/or unnecessary manner, don't shy away from the brutal truth. See the mothers who've lost children to knife crime. Their campaigns do not pussyfoot around. Photos and and graphic descriptions of the bloody reality.

Spelling it out in contrast to dangerous denial comes from a place of immense compassion.

Tealightsandd · 03/01/2022 17:26

Aside from the fact that elderly and disabled lives do matter, as the scientific and medical experts say, everybody is indeed at risk. Long Covid is a real thing. Denial won't change that fact.

As for the "oh they're old, ready to die anyway" eugenics ageist shit. Ok then, if there's no need to take any mitigations whatsoever once over, what do you want to say, 60? 65? 70?, anyway whatever age you pick, let's legalise all risky activities for the elderly. Including currently illegal drugs. Oh - and we really must think of a different message for the anti smoking crew. Because "it shortens your life" no longer works when , if you live longer, you're told it's well past time for you to pop off... albeit in a much more unpleasant manner than the compassionate option denied in the UK of assisted suicide.

Btw there's a difference between low risk versus no risk.

The vast majority of approx 600-1000 UK HCP dead from Covid were under 75.

TimBoothseyes · 03/01/2022 13:18

There's nothing any of us can do to fight that and having to watch it over and over/respect their choice affects you

And posting about it knowing that there may be people reading it who are still grieving and now have that image in their head (again, thanks for that), made you feel what? Because it sure as Hell wasn't compassion.

Echobelly · 03/01/2022 13:16

Well I don't think anyone's going to advocate for a continual surpression - obviously we were well beyond 'Zero covid' by April 2020 in the UK and I think the intial responses of the last few years were totally justified if usually several weeks too late. The limitations of surpression seem to be showing in NZ and Australia now perhaps.

I was just thinking this morning that the government is desperately angling for no more lockdowns of any kind during this wave so they can claim a 'lockdown-free year' (and contrast this with places that didn't) in 2022.

I think masks will stick around and even if not mandated I can see some people sticking with them in crowded, enclosed situations, especially in winter.

I also expect we'll calm down a bit about the vaccinations as in we'll get down to maybe one a year for most people and perhaps two for the more vulnerable. I really hope this year we'll vaccinate the rest of the world as that's super important now.

Bro and I were just talking about travel restrictions and wondering if more countries (at least well-vaccinated ones) might ease up on it - because it seems now that unless you have managed to totally surpress any form of COVID in your country, is it really worth losing so much tourism when any new variants will have probably got in before you are aware of them?

Natty13 · 03/01/2022 13:04

Tell me have you ever said to a bereaved person due to a car accident, "well their heart was ripped away and the amount of blood they lost was enormous"?

Well for one I've never spoken to a bereaved relative of one of my patients woth anything but genuine compassion so comparing what I write online about my personal opinions to how I treat actual people in my care is a bit pointless.

FYI If we were discussing car accidents on a thread I would in fact write something like that if someone had killed a person they love by drink/drug/dangerous driving. The attitude of "why should I change my life in any way whstsoever because of a cold, I will be fine if I catch it" and "why should I get everyone to wear a seatbelt/I'm fine to drive mum home after 6 pints" are comparable to me. We all know there's a chance these things could end in something terrible, however small and of you choose to take that risk rather than, say, get a vaccine or wear a mask then thsts on you. Sorry. This post asked for opinions and that's mine.

I am very sorry about your mum. All I can say it that me andy colleagues will do whatever it takes and prioritise as much as we can to make sure people are comfortable and peaceful at the end. There are unfortunately people who refuse all medications/oxygen/comfort measures because they and their family think its all nonsense right to the end and die in distress but this is at their choice and (thank God) the minority. There's nothing any of us can do to fight that and having to watch it over and over/respect their choice affects you. We are human too, you know?

llansannan22 · 03/01/2022 11:59

OP you present two very contrasting alternatives. I'm not in favour of either. Adapting long term with things such as face coverings on public transport, testing in hospitals/care homes, for example, I'd be happy with. Working from home part or even most of the time where it is possible should be long term I think, not just for Covid reasons but to reduce traffic levels and carbon footprints.

I'd like a competent government most of all, regardless of the party.

MarshaBradyo · 03/01/2022 11:33

The initial pressure was high so the most immediate measure was to keep people apart

This meant using messages around being ‘safe’ backed up by idea of high risk

I agree this should change pretty quickly when not needed for compliance.

I look forward to lower media focus and better view on risk

Ponoka7 · 03/01/2022 11:30

I totally agree that the message should be that we were never equally at risk. There should have been more transparency about who was dying. I've had hospital appointments three times since it started and although I was considered at risk, my consultant (one whose been on the BBC) has said that they've only lost two very elderly patients linked to Covid which is what they would every winter. Which reassured me and spurred me on to take more care of health. However there should also have been more time spent explaining about stopping varients.

Ponoka7 · 03/01/2022 11:17

@GoldenOmber, I agree with visitors, but there's ways to manage that so other residents are protected. Outdoor rooms could be made, for whole extended family visiting with school children, rather than just everyone in the lounge. If we could do it for pubs, we can do for residential care. There's a difference in residents, not all will have the same vulnerability. LFTs can be used. We've always asked people not to visit if they are unwell, we are now dealing with an asymptomatic serious (for them) flu.

GaolBhoAlba · 03/01/2022 11:13

@Ponoka7

There's always going to be some restrictions, or conditions, or do we want the care homes etc opened up for everyone to enter again? I like that two weeks ago dentists have been threatened with fines. I believe that GP's and walk ins shouldn't be demanding PCRs. I'm CEV, I couldn't shield. I've been sent a PCR to use if I have symptoms, which many vulnerable people have. We will get instant access to the latest medication, sent to us if we test positive. Things like that should continue. So there needs to be some measures in place for another year. We need to plan for each winter and have services better funded because our issues are partly because of a lack of funding, as said by Chris Whitty, but ignored in the press.
We're still living the legacy of the government message back in 2020 that "we're all at risk" (as though equally) when, in reality, some were (and remain) at far more risk than others. They still dont have a plan to adequately protect the more vulnerable. Theyre referring to restrictions as 'protections' now whilst still applying the same approach to everyone. Far more could (and still should) be invested in genuine protections for the most vulnerable.
OP posts:
GoldenOmber · 03/01/2022 11:03

or do we want the care homes etc opened up for everyone to enter again?

Yes, because residents in care homes need to have visitors and see their families. Those are their homes, they should have as much right to being part of a family and a community as the rest of us.

Visiting restrictions justified for short emergency situations (and this was the case pre-covid too because of what other infectious diseases can do in care homes), but have been massively damaging to happiness and health and shouldn’t be kept in place forever as if covid is the only thing that matters to people.