Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that, Italy, hands down, wins the international battle of the Christmas cake.

114 replies

KenDodd · 02/01/2022 11:48

British, heavy fruit cake, just horrible.
Germany, stollen, not much better.
France, chocolate log, very nice but not very christmassy.
Italy, panettone, just delicious!

OP posts:
Loveinacoldishclimate · 02/01/2022 17:03

@BIWI I had a tier of Caribbean Christmas cake for my wedding. Unbelievably delicious and reminds me of misspent summers of my youth.

FinalNameChange · 02/01/2022 16:50

I always wonder why people don't like Pannetone.

It's just struck me, reading this thread.
Perhaps many are trying to eat it as if it's cake?
But it's not, it's a sweet fruited and spiced bread.

It's delicious very very lightly toasted with butter.

TimBoothseyes · 02/01/2022 16:40

Anything with marzipan is only fit for the bin.

Bwix · 02/01/2022 16:35

Pannetone is always too dry for my taste. I do have a soft spot for a good buche de Noel though.

PartyPrawnRingGames · 02/01/2022 16:34

That cake looks very interesting @BIWI and there are some other delicious looking cakes on that site too.

Snoken · 02/01/2022 16:31

I like stollen cake and Yule log, find panettone too dry and tasteless, British fruitcake is hideous. I hate mince pies and British gingerbread too. I like Dutch gingerbread and the Swedish ones you can find at IKEA.

BIWI · 02/01/2022 16:07

I'm not really a fan of the classic Christmas cake, but this year I made a Caribbean Rum Cake (I believe this is sometime called Black Cake?)

Dried fruits are soaked in spiced rum for as long as you like, then processed into a chunky purée, before being stirred into the batter. You then stir through a 'browning', which is made from heated molasses syrup and spiced rum before baking the cake.

Once baked, you feed it with (yet more) spiced rum.

It was absolutely delicious.

Luredbyapomegranate · 02/01/2022 16:04

God no - you are completely mad and deluded, I’d seek help urgently.

The RIGHT order is the reverse:

British Christmas cake - delicious and rich, hefty enough to power you through days with relies. 🎂🔋

Stollen - pretty nice, but it’s like comparing vegemite to marmite, it’s a pale imitation, the true British Christmas cake will always win the war. 🔫

Yule Log - nice enough, but it’s Christmas - where are the currents, where is the booze?!?! You can have chocolate cake any time - it does not say Christmas!!! The French are such cheese 🧀 eaters they aren’t focusing.

Panettone - completely rubbish by any cake standards, dry and dull like chewing slightly sweetened cotton wool. It’s drier than the excellent Uk teatime staples of teacakes and hot cross buns, which given they need slathering in butter says it all. The only thing it’s good for is bread and butter pudding (🇬🇧✌️). It would be better for everyone Italy played to its main course strengths - those stupid zeppole things also need deporting.

whitewashing · 02/01/2022 16:02

Toasted panettone…delicious!

2TurtleDovesInARow · 02/01/2022 16:00

The only thing panettone is good for is regifting to people you forgot to buy for. I didn't realise anyone actually ate the damned stuff apart from post 26th when you lose the pass the panettone game and end up lumbered with one you reluctantly slather with better ingredients to make a bread and butter pudding.

Yule log on the other hand...yum.

ThettaReddast · 02/01/2022 15:51

Best Christmas cake hands down is Tunis Cake. Seems to be really underrated but it’s delicious

rifling · 02/01/2022 15:19

Noooo! I'm a big fan of Italy (in fact recently became Italian Grin). Luckily, you do not have to be a fan of panettone for citizenship! My British-style Christmas cake with added apricots, on the other hand, was delicious!

ouch321 · 02/01/2022 15:15

I tried both of Morrisons strollers this year. The regular version was rubbish but the The Best version for £5 was quite nice.

There was a thread a week before Xmas and several posters named Wilkos as doing ace pannetones but they were clean out of all types when I went there.

PartyPrawnRingGames · 02/01/2022 14:53

Christmas cake is the winner for me and feels more traditional as it's what we had growing up, my Granny was a good cook and made a lovely one iced with a nice royal icing snow scene. I also like all the others but sometimes Yule log can be too sweet for me, I like the icing that is made with a dark chocolate and cream ganache, not the sickly buttercream.
But the Italians do win when it comes to dessert, tiramisu is my favourite and I love it much more than Xmas pud or trifle.

OchonAgusOchonOh · 02/01/2022 14:37

[quote AfterEightMintyCedric]@ochonAgusOchonOh

Haven't got a recipe as such as originally made it years ago, but basically roll out puff pastry to a long thinnish rectangle.

Sprinkle with dried fruit (I use cranberries, raisins and dried apricots pre soaked in brandy) and pistachios.

Roll out a log of marzipan to match the length of pastry, place it in the middle and roll the pastry round, sealing it with a little water or beaten egg.

Shape into a circle and make slashes all the way round to form a wreath, brush with egg and bake according to the pastry instructions.

Once out and still a bit warm, glaze with apricot jam, drizzle with water icing and sprinkle with toasted flaked almonds.[/quote]
Sounds amazing. Thank you. I have some homemade (not by me) puff pastry in the freezer. I'll give it a go. I'll make the marzipan though as it's much nicer. I add lemon juice and whiskey which gives it a depth you don't get in the bought stuff or a lot of recipes.

Glitterblue · 02/01/2022 14:37

People who find panettone dry etc probably haven't had the right one yet. We had one from Costco that was sooooo good and one from tesco that was dry and awful. If the tesco one had been my first taste of panettone, I'd think I didn't like it.

DontKnowWhatToThink7 · 02/01/2022 14:32

YABU Panettone is vile.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 02/01/2022 14:16

I love them all

Notjustanymum · 02/01/2022 14:14

Nope! Murrumbidgee cake all the way - delicious😋😋😋

IncyWincyGrownUp · 02/01/2022 14:14

A decent fresh yule log is a thing of beauty.

I don’t like dried fruit, but do bake Christmas cake for friends each year.

Tal45 · 02/01/2022 14:11

YABU Panettone is only any good if you slice it up, toast it and slather it in butter. Dry, dry, dry else.

AfterEightMintyCedric · 02/01/2022 14:11

Have to admit that this year's favourite has been mincemeat shortbread.

AIBU to think that, Italy,  hands down, wins the international battle of the Christmas cake.
AfterEightMintyCedric · 02/01/2022 14:08

@ochonAgusOchonOh

Haven't got a recipe as such as originally made it years ago, but basically roll out puff pastry to a long thinnish rectangle.

Sprinkle with dried fruit (I use cranberries, raisins and dried apricots pre soaked in brandy) and pistachios.

Roll out a log of marzipan to match the length of pastry, place it in the middle and roll the pastry round, sealing it with a little water or beaten egg.

Shape into a circle and make slashes all the way round to form a wreath, brush with egg and bake according to the pastry instructions.

Once out and still a bit warm, glaze with apricot jam, drizzle with water icing and sprinkle with toasted flaked almonds.

AIBU to think that, Italy,  hands down, wins the international battle of the Christmas cake.
ISeeTheLight · 02/01/2022 14:05

YABVU. French or Belgian yule log is by far the best. And proper one, not the poor copies you get in supermarkets here.

LadyLolaRuben · 02/01/2022 14:00

Yes you're right OP but the evry best if the one from Cost Co