Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a 5 and 8 year old to be able to pack their own overnight bag?

491 replies

CrumpledCrumpet · 02/01/2022 11:25

I’ve asked 8 and 5yo DS’s to pack PJs and a change of clothes in a bag about half an hour ago. Despite increasingly stroppy reminders from me to stay on task, no progress is being made. AIBU to expect children of their age to be able to do this? I’m exasperated!

OP posts:
Topseyt · 02/01/2022 15:41

Many years ago when I was in hospital to have DD3 (who is now 19), DH was looking after DD1 and DD2, who were 7 and 3 at the time.

He had to take them to his mother's (60 miles away) for an overnight stay as DD3 needed delivery by emcs.

He sent them to pack for themselves, but he didn't check that they had done it properly. They went in a witch's costume and a fairy princess costume. They packed no other clothes, no pyjamas and no toothbrushes. Just some teddies and DD2's large Scooby Doo!

MIL had to take them clothes shopping that afternoon after DH had left to drive over to the hospital to be with me for DD3's birth.

We laugh about it now, though I think MIL was a bit perplexed with him at the time. 🤣

thewhatsit · 02/01/2022 15:38

5 year old loves packing his own bag but it’s mostly just toys and maybe 5 tops for 2 days and not any pants.
Personally I wouldn’t stress about it. It’s the kind of job that takes a few minutes only if the parent helps.

KatharinaRosalie · 02/01/2022 15:34

But why bother? He won't learn anything from this. All for a job you could have done in 5 minutes..

Of course they learn, they will remember next time that for overnight bag, they need PJs and what an outfit for next day includes. It would also be faster if I would tie my DC's shoelaces until they are 20, but I still think it makes sense to take the time to teach them and wait there until they manage.
Or how else would it work? They don't wake up one morning magically knowing how packing works.

liveforsummer · 02/01/2022 15:32

@Sarahplane

My ten year old can't do this so yabu
Outside of ASN a 10 year old absolutely should be able to put a handful of specified items in a provided bag. I expect they very much could though and that you've just never tried
PinkSyCo · 02/01/2022 15:32

I’d maybe expect the 8 year old to be ABLE to do it but I don’t see why you wouldn’t help her. Can’t believe you expect a 5 year old to just get on with it alone. Confused

WutheringHeights66 · 02/01/2022 15:31

At five you are asking too much.

BoredZelda · 02/01/2022 15:30

How can you not know that this is ridiculous and unreasonable.

Despite several people confirming their kids could do it at those ages?

Barbie222 · 02/01/2022 15:30

@liveforsummer

For context yesterday my 8 year old went and caught her share point from the field alone, brought it down and tied it with a quick release knot. Removed rugs brushed it and remembered to pick out all 4 feet. Put on bridle and saddle, fitted cross nose and correctly, remembered to check reins weren't under before doing up breastplate straps, remembered to check the flap under the girth buckles wasn't caught in saddle pad. Afterwards she was able to put on rugs checking all buckles , fill hay net put down bed, hose legs. The only thing I had to do was get saddle down and put up on rack as it's too high and check the girth tightness before she got on.To imagine she couldn't manage to put 2 basic outfits in a bag when directed is absurd.
She's doing well to do all that with a share point lol
cruelladepoppins · 02/01/2022 15:25

I used to do the packing with them at that age. I would sit in the middle of the floor with a bag."Bring me one pair of pyjamas." "Now bring me 3 pairs of pants." "Now ... 3 pairs of socks." and so on. Seemed to work.

When they were a bit older, I got them to take over the actual packing bit, I would just tell them how many of everything I thought they needed. (I remember being quite strong on trousers and tops all needing to go with each other.) But I would still supervise.

See if you can make it happen without a falling out. I know it's hard sometimes Wink.

Sarahplane · 02/01/2022 15:22

My ten year old can't do this so yabu

Underparmummy · 02/01/2022 15:20

8 year old might manage. My nine year old could. My nearly 12 year old kind of can but always picks stupid clothes for planned activities. My 7 year old NO WAY. So a five year old for me is impossible.

AshLane · 02/01/2022 15:20

I did with mine. We used to lay the stuff out ( on the landing ??? - tho not sure why the landing) and I'd check it before helping them to put it in the bag. This developed into the same system for holiday packing.

As 20 somethings, I noticed they still do this...😂

liveforsummer · 02/01/2022 15:19

For context yesterday my 8 year old went and caught her share point from the field alone, brought it down and tied it with a quick release knot. Removed rugs brushed it and remembered to pick out all 4 feet. Put on bridle and saddle, fitted cross nose and correctly, remembered to check reins weren't under before doing up breastplate straps, remembered to check the flap under the girth buckles wasn't caught in saddle pad. Afterwards she was able to put on rugs checking all buckles , fill hay net put down bed, hose legs. The only thing I had to do was get saddle down and put up on rack as it's too high and check the girth tightness before she got on.To imagine she couldn't manage to put 2 basic outfits in a bag when directed is absurd.

ViceLikeBlip · 02/01/2022 15:18

For ONCE my 5yo can do something that no one else would expect of them!! Even my 3yo can pack an overnight bag with pjs, pants, socks, Teddy and toothbrush. But then again they only ever pack a bag for something fun, so they love doing it.

5yo can't wipe his own arse though #winsomelosesome

EmmaWoodhousestreehouse · 02/01/2022 15:16

How can you not know that this is ridiculous and unreasonable.

MajorCarolDanvers · 02/01/2022 15:15

We teach kids this age to do this at beavers.

The 5 year old will need advice and guidance. The 8 year old should be able to manage but I'd check the bag when finished.

Never to early to teach life skills.

brokenkettle · 02/01/2022 15:13

I don't think you are being totally unreasonable. My son has been packing his own overnight bag, with guidance at first, from about age 5. He wanted to though, so maybe that's the difference.

Figgygal · 02/01/2022 15:12

Why not just help them? Especially the 5 year old

DysmalRadius · 02/01/2022 15:08

@GoodPrincessWenceslas

5yo when I prompted him on the individual items that needed to go in.

But why bother? He won't learn anything from this. All that's happened is that the whole thing has taken at least an hour longer than it needed to, you've got stressed out, and your 5 year old probably feels confused and unhappy. All for a job you could have done in 5 minutes.

But isn't that true of almost everything a child learns to do? Mine couldn't put their own shoes on the first time they tried, but they learn by doing it when the opportunity arises, and repetition cements the skill so they can do it by themselves eventually. It takes longer, of course, but it helps them to develop independence and they are really pleased with themselves when they master something they remember not being able to do before.
Babamamananarama · 02/01/2022 15:06

I've got a 5 and and 8 year old and they can and do pack their own overnight bags. I'd always give them a quick check to make sure they haven't forgotten their pants or packed wildly inappropriate clothes for the weather but I'm honestly surprised at all the people saying they wouldn't trust their children to do this.

BoredZelda · 02/01/2022 15:04

You are creating stress and drama for yourself. Just pack them yourself.

For how long? Til they are 12? 15? 20?

Doing it yourself is taking the short term easy way out for the long term hassle of always having to do it?

When your kids started learning to walk and kept falling over, did you say “ach it’s easier just to pick them up and carry them?” Or did you appreciate that the frustration in having them try and try was for their own good in the long term. Stepping in and always doing for them does them no favours.

Maybe because my daughter is disabled we realised that teaching her independence was so important in so many ways, we had more patience for the little things like packing cases, but I can’t imagine just not teaching them life skills because it was easier in the short term.

stingofthebutterfly · 02/01/2022 15:04

Honestly, you'd have saved yourself a lot of hassle to just do it yourself. It'd have taken 5 minutes. I'd no way expect a 5 year old to be able to do this without assistance. Surely you'd check their bags yourself anyway?

liveforsummer · 02/01/2022 15:04

I suppose a lot of people are guessing whether their dc could do this and assuming they couldn't (and indeed imagining a harder task with the examples of winter 2 week holidays and scout camps although fwiw brownies has always advised heavy involvement in packing as they need to be able to pack their own stuff to come home). As a lone parent with a very busy life and lots of trips our lifestyle simply wouldn't have been possible if my dc could not manage the basics themselves. I remember being proud when an impressed airport worker commented when my 2 dc independently whipped out all the correct things from their hand luggage at security and put them in the trays and removed their coats. Dd then got the bags off the belt at the end while keeping her sister next to he rI was being frisked 😆. I think they were 4 and 7 at the time. I promise at 5 and 8 they absolutely can learn to follow basic instructions and put 2 simple outfits in a bag

GoodPrincessWenceslas · 02/01/2022 14:58

5yo when I prompted him on the individual items that needed to go in.

But why bother? He won't learn anything from this. All that's happened is that the whole thing has taken at least an hour longer than it needed to, you've got stressed out, and your 5 year old probably feels confused and unhappy. All for a job you could have done in 5 minutes.

saraclara · 02/01/2022 14:57

Mine loved doing their own packing at that age. We gave them as much independence and responsibility as we could from an early age. The youngest's efforts were amusing though!
Once their dad and I each thought that the other had checked the bags, and arrived at my in-laws for four days to find that youngest had packed soft toys, my little ponies, her favourite jumper and one pair of knickers!