Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect a 5 and 8 year old to be able to pack their own overnight bag?

491 replies

CrumpledCrumpet · 02/01/2022 11:25

I’ve asked 8 and 5yo DS’s to pack PJs and a change of clothes in a bag about half an hour ago. Despite increasingly stroppy reminders from me to stay on task, no progress is being made. AIBU to expect children of their age to be able to do this? I’m exasperated!

OP posts:
Barksmum12 · 02/01/2022 13:16

I'm surprised by some if these replies.

My 6-year-old can do this independently. My 4 year old would have a pretty good go. They'd know to ask how many nights to pack for for example.

LBOCS2 · 02/01/2022 13:14

@userisi2

Why this reply? Sounds like a pretty reasonable thing to do with kids

Because the thought of having to sit down children and have a discussion around what they need to pack for ONE night away is hilarious to me.

You're missing the point. This isn't about following a list, or even knowing what to pack for one night away because they've been taught. That doesn't help children in the long run.

This is equipping them with the ability to plan a task and see it through to the end. Hence the conversation about it - I want them to be able to look at something which needs doing and be able to problem solve until the task is complete. And it starts off small, with having a chat about what they might need for a night away and lots of supervision, and it ends up with them being independent adults.

DelphiniumBlue · 02/01/2022 13:13

8 year old, certainly, and 5 year old with help.
They would need to already know , or have broken down for them, exactly what " a change of clothes" means in terms of activity and warmth. Also if they pack, you have to accept their choices and colour co-ordination skills.
DS3 used to camp with beavers/Cubs from about 6, and they were expected to be heavily involved with the packing.
If you have time, talk them through it..ask them what they think they will need.

nomoneytreehere · 02/01/2022 13:12

My 6 and 8 year old would be able to do this no problem. I probably wouldn't even check what they had packed if it was just an overnight trip. I would write out for them what they need to pack though (eg 2 x pants 1 x pj 1 x toothbrush 1 x coat 1 x wellies 1 x reading book etc). Or use it as an opportunity for writing practise (so dictate the list and they write it down).

I have 5 children. The younger ones have grown up watching the older ones and my 6 year old is super organised for school now, he packs his bag every morning and checks he has everything he needs the night before. Without me telling him he knows which club he has the next day. I think this is good parenting to be honest but I also work full time in a pretty intensive job, - I want to spend my free time playing with them and doing stuff with them, not emptying their lunch box. My 18 month old empties his nursery bag when we get home and knows where to put his shoes and he can't actually speak yet!

My 8 year old plays a lot of sport both after school and at the weekend. He gets his own kit ready and only asks me if he can't find something. He also does this the night before (so last night told me he couldn't find his gum-shield, so I helped him find it.). I wash his kit obviously. On top of that he knows where he is playing and at what time (it can vary) and knows how to check the various apps on my phone so he knows what he's doing. I have to check them too.

My most haphazard child is my teenage daughter. I mostly did everything for her when she was young and now she needs a lot of prompting still. She's very good company though!

OP I would just ask them once. Don't keep going on about it but give them a deadline for when it needs to be done. Children don't respond to being nagged at in my experience.

Doubledenimrock · 02/01/2022 13:07

I find my 14 and 17 year old struggle with this. Not because they cant do it but because they get distracted ( one has ADHD plus Dyspraxia though)

EurghCobwebs · 02/01/2022 13:05

@bluechilli47

I can't expect my husband to do that! My 12 year old I would check. 5y pack for them, 8y pack with them
You would check a 12 year old's?? Jesus, I used to pack my bag for sleepovers when I was in primary school. It's not rocket science.
liveforsummer · 02/01/2022 13:03

[quote userisi2]@liveforsummer it is to me when my kids are quite capable of being given and bag and cracking on, no "discussion" necessary.[/quote]
Fair enough, mine are too but for many 5 year olds there's nothing wrong with saying. Pack some pyjamas, leggings and a t shirt. Put something in with long sleeves and don't forget pants and socks. Not sure why that's funny. What's funny is all the posters insinuating OP is an awful lazy parent and that no child under the age of about 15 should be capable.

Georgeskitchen · 02/01/2022 13:02

YABU My son aged about 9/10 packed to go staying at granny's. Luckily I checked the 10 T shirts. One pair of undies one pair of socks and no trousers he had packed 😳

EurghCobwebs · 02/01/2022 13:02

@OGenkiDesuKa

Not in mumsnet Land no, where kids have their asses wiped till their 18.

In the real world yes. Mine has been packing her own over ungut bag since 5. Unless there’s learning difficulties involved a 5 year old is perfectly capable of putting some clothes in a bag.

Hahaha, exactly this!
ElephantOfRisk · 02/01/2022 13:01

it obviously depends if they clearly know what they need to take and that it is all in a place they know and is accessible.

If not then they will find it easier to learn if given clear instructions in small parts.

e.g. Go and get your blue backpack and put in your PJs, toothpaste and brush and come and show me when you've done that.

Next I want you to get pants and socks and whatever outfit you want to wear tomorrow and then come and show me.

Lastly, if you want a stuffed toy and/or a book or small toy to take then get those and pack them.

Then the next time you can ask if they remember what they need to pack and take it from there.

Even as an adult i'm much more likely to do a task when i know what it is I'm doing.

DropYourSword · 02/01/2022 13:00

@userisi2

Why this reply? Sounds like a pretty reasonable thing to do with kids

Because the thought of having to sit down children and have a discussion around what they need to pack for ONE night away is hilarious to me.

Yep, clearly “hilarious” to communicate with children, isn’t it. I’ve already said upthread I don’t think my 5 year old would be capable of packing his own bag. But talking through what you might need etc is just giving them life skills. It’s just parenting. And apparently parenting is now hilarious. Sorry, just not getting the joke.
userisi2 · 02/01/2022 13:00

@liveforsummer it is to me when my kids are quite capable of being given and bag and cracking on, no "discussion" necessary.

Jl2014 · 02/01/2022 12:58

My 5 year old can do this no problem. Packed her mini suitcase for going away at Christmas. I did double check it but she did a pretty good job. They should be learning to help out with small activities like this.

liveforsummer · 02/01/2022 12:58

Because the thought of having to sit down children and have a discussion around what they need to pack for ONE night away is hilarious to me.

Well it's not a discussion that's going to take long - less than a minute. Hardly 'hilarious'

SportsMother · 02/01/2022 12:57

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

userisi2 · 02/01/2022 12:55

Why this reply? Sounds like a pretty reasonable thing to do with kids

Because the thought of having to sit down children and have a discussion around what they need to pack for ONE night away is hilarious to me.

liveforsummer · 02/01/2022 12:55

Don't be daft - what kid needs to be able to independently pack an overnight bag for primary 1?

You're conflating two completely different issues. Yes, some parents don't prep their children well for school but that's not the same thing at all as expecting a 5 year old to know what to pack for a overnight stay.

Would think a teacher would be able to comprehend the difference

Obviously they don't have to pack an over night bag for primary 1 but they need to pack their bag at the end of the day, lunch box, water bottle, items from tray. They need to check they've got their cardigan and coat, sometimes hat, gloves and scarf. Not dissimilar at all. Fwiw I'm not a teacher, I'm generally far more patient than the teachers many of whom don't have kids or have grown up ones and who 10 years ago did not have the same trouble getting kids doing these things as they do now. Especially post pandemic we are huge drop in basic independence skills and ability to follow simple instructions. Threads like this often indicate why. Just because they don't actually need an over night bag for p1 doesn't mean teaching them to pack one isn't a skill that will over all help them in other areas of independence. Skills are transferable and it suggest OP encourages independence in other areas too.

StationaryMagpie · 02/01/2022 12:54

As someone said, its about Executive Functioning ability.

After 4 years of doing this EVERY other weekend, without fail, this is evidenced by the fact my ASD/ADHD/Dyspraxic 15yo still can't without an itemised list, and my doing the actual packing so he can find stuff the other end(or it just all gets shoved in the bag in a screwed up ball and he gets stressed he can't find stuff), nor can my ADHD 12yo, although she's a bit better at the actual packing.. she still needs a list/instructions.

lollipoprainbow · 02/01/2022 12:54

So joyless let kids be kids without packing a bag being a military operation !! There's plenty of time for them to pack their own bags in the future.

mimi0708 · 02/01/2022 12:52

Yanbu. 8 yo definitely can. My 4 yo will pack her stuff when we go but we've always been involving her so she's used to it, and she does need reminding of what she needs to pack. Of course, I check in the end that she's got everything

BlwyddynNewydd2022 · 02/01/2022 12:52

@cultkid

🤣🤣🤣 mine would bring some Lego, a teddy one nappy and biscuits. Maybe a night light!!

Deffo not 🤣🤣🤣

🤣🤣 same 7DS wanted to pack his suitcase recently, it had one pair of jogging bottoms and toys in it 🤣

I said to him "planning to wear Lego pants are we?" I then helped him pack showing him what he would need.

Busybee5000 · 02/01/2022 12:51

Mine were probably around 12 and 10 before they could be even started to relied upon. Even then we've had some moments! However yes they should be able to choose a pair of PJ's and an outfit maybe at that age but need help putting it in a bag etc.

DropYourSword · 02/01/2022 12:51

@userisi2

My 5 and 9yo are capable of it, but I don't just shove a bag at them and tell them to crack on - we have a chat about what we might need, how many days we'll be away for, what we use at bedtime etc. And then I'll either supervise or double check what they've put in.

Do you do a debrief? Assess what went well, what could have gone better, lessons learned for next time? With pie charts.

Why this reply? Sounds like a pretty reasonable thing to do with kids
RantyAunty · 02/01/2022 12:48

Yes, they can but you need to supervise it.

It's a process and teaching them to follow instructions sequence step by step.

Start with asking what makes up an outfit. Lay the things out on the floor. Have some funny things around too like an umbrella, cups, blocks.

Then pick up each item and ask if it is part of an outfit. When they get it right they go put it in the bag. Have the silly things like putting a cup on your head and they'll laugh and tell you Nooooo.

Do that a few times and they'll know how to pack an outfit, pjs.

My grandkids ended up loving this game even when we weren't going anywhere. We take pretend boat rides, plane trips, car rides. They always included the dog too. Grin

Kinko · 02/01/2022 12:47

This is a learning opportunity but they need more hands on guidance. Try:

  • you put two bags on the landing and you say to your kids right go find the pjs you want and bring them back - I'm going to time you. Lots of laughter and cheers when they race back
  • then you say - right ok now put them in your bag
  • then you repeat for socks, pants, jeans, t-shirt

Then you say - right now what else could we put in here, what might you need tonight before bed - wait for them to guess toothbrush, then you say - excellent I think you're right! Quick quick go get it.

You have to teach them independence through play and reward (reward being laughter, praise and fun).

Make it a game. Keep repeating the game until they get it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread